Ad libitum intake of a high-carbohydrate or high-fat diet in young men: effects on nutrient balances.

The effect of diet composition [high-carbohydrate, low-fat (HC) and high-fat, low-carbohydrate (HF) diets] on macronutrient intakes and nutrient balances was investigated in young men of normal body weight. Eleven subjects were studied on two occasions for 48 h in a whole-body indirect calorimeter in a crossover design. Subjects selected their meals from a list containing a large variety of common food, which had a food quotient > 0.85 for the HC diet and < 0.85 for the HF diet. The average ad libitum intake was 14.41 +/- 0.85 MJ/d (67%, 18%, and 15% of energy as carbohydrate, fat, and protein, respectively) with the HC diet and 18.25 +/- 0.90 MJ/d (26%, 61%, and 13% of energy as carbohydrate, fat, and protein, respectively) with the HF diet. Total energy expenditure was not significantly influenced by diet composition: 10.46 +/- 0.27 and 10.97 +/- 0.22 MJ/d for the HC and HF diets, respectively. During the 2 test days, cumulative carbohydrate storage was 418 +/- 72 and 205 +/- 47 g, and fat balance was 29 +/- 17 and 291 +/- 29 g with the HC and HF diets, respectively. Only the HF diet induced a significantly positive fat balance. These results emphasize the important role of the dietary fat content in body fat storage

Obesidade e a substituição de macronutrientes da dieta Obesity and diet macronutrients substitution

Os fatores envolvidos na gênese da obesidade não são conclusivos, incluindo o papel dos macronutrientes da dieta na suscetibilidade ao ganho de peso. O carboidrato pode ser considerado um componente importante na saciedade. Sua substituição pelo adoçante, reduz o valor energético da dieta, reduzindo a massa corporal. Os efeitos dos adoçantes sobre o apetite dependem da natureza e da densidade dos nutrientes consumidos simultaneamente. Não existem evidencias suficientes que mostrem que os adoçantes causam ganho de peso, mas seu uso pode resultar em compensação energética com alimentos ricos em lipídios. Os lipídios tendem a aumentar a densidade energética da dieta promovendo o superconsumo passivo de energia, além de apresentar baixa prioridade oxidativa, estando associado à baixa saciedade. Sua substituição tem sido relacionada à compensação da ingestão energética, principalmente por carboidratos. Um plano alimentar disciplinado deve incluir alimentos que reduzam a densidade energética da dieta, sem promoção do consumo alimentar.<br>The factors involved in obesity genesis are not conclusive, including the function of diet macronutrients concerning susceptibility of weight gain. Carbohydrate can be considered an important component in satiety. Its substitution for sweeteners decreases the diet caloric value, consequently decreasing body mass. The effects of sweeteners on appetite rely on nature and density of the nutrients that are consumed simultaneously with sweeteners. There are no sufficient evidences showing that sweeteners cause weight gain, but the use of sweeteners may result on energetic compensation with lipid-rich foods. Lipids tend to increase diet energetic density promoting high passive consumption of energy, besides its low oxidative priority, which is associated with low satiety. Lipid substitution has been related to caloric ingestion compensation, mainly for carbohydrates. A disciplined dietetic plan should include foods that decrease diet energetic density without increasing food consumptio