Phase separation and stripe formation in the 2D t-J model: a comparison of numerical results

We make a critical analysis of numerical results for and against phase separation and stripe formation in the t-J model. We argue that the frustrated phase separation mechanism for stripe formation requires phase separation at too high a doping for it to be consistent with existing numerical studies of the t-J model. We compare variational energies for various methods, and conclude that the most accurate calculations for large systems appear to be from the density matrix renormalization group. These calculations imply that the ground state of the doped t-J model is striped, not phase separated.Comment: This version includes a revised, more careful comparison of numerical results between DMRG and Green's function Monte Carlo. In particular, for the original posted version we were accidentally sent obsolete data by Hellberg and Manousakis; their new results, which are what were used in their Physical Review Letter, are more accurate because a better trial wavefunction was use