Replicability of data collected for empirical estimation of relative pollen productivity

The effects of repeated survey and fieldwork timing on data derived from a recently proposed standard field methodology for empirical estimation of relative pollen productivity (RPP) have been tested. Seasonal variations in vegetation and associated pollen assemblages were studied in three contrasting cultural habitat types; semi-natural ancient woodlands, lowland heaths, and unimproved, traditionally managed hay meadows. Results show that in woodlands and heathlands the standard method generates vegetation data with a reasonable degree of similarity throughout the field season, though in some instances additional recording of woodland canopy cover should be undertaken, and differences were greater for woodland understorey taxa than for arboreal taxa. Large differences in vegetation cover were observed over the field season in the grassland community, and matching the phenological timing of surveys within and between studies is clearly important if RPP estimates from these sites are to be comparable. Pollen assemblages from closely co-located moss polsters collected on different visits are shown to be variable in all communities, to a greater degree than can be explained by the sampling error associated with pollen counting, and further study of moss polsters as pollen traps is recommended

Seeing the wood for the trees:Recent advances in the reconstruction of woodland in archaeological landscapes using pollen data

Pollen sequences record the vegetation cover of past landscapes, but translating a pollen diagram into a landscape reconstruction is not straightforward. This paper reviews recent advances in the reconstruction of woodland cover from palynological data and shows how they have been used to address three archaeologically relevant problems: • The detection of woodland presence and extent in a largely open landscape • The reconstruction of the habitat context of a specific archaeological site • The detection of woodland management Pollen surface samples which can be directly related to contemporary vegetation cover are shown to be useful both in their own right and as the basis for calibration of models of pollen dispersal and deposition. These models can be used as a foundation for quantitative reconstruction of past landscapes, for example using the Multiple Scenario Approach, or as a tool for construction and testing of hypotheses and to inform selection of coring sites. We argue that surface sample studies and simulation approaches are improving the scientific basis of reconstruction of past landscapes, and that these approaches offer new opportunities for communication and collaboration between archaeologists and environmental specialists

Do local habitat conditions affect estimates of relative pollen productivity and source area in heathlands?

Relative Pollen Productivity is an essential parameter for quantitative reconstruction of past land cover from pollen records, but published studies have produced a range of different values for the same taxa. Heathland habitats have limited plant diversity and strong spatial patterning, therefore are useful case studies to investigate aspects of pollen dispersal and deposition, but the estimated spatial area “sensed” by pollen records in these habitats also varies widely between studies. In this study, we estimate pollen productivity from two different microhabitats in a heathland ecosystem in order to investigate the role of local environmental conditions in any observed differences.Vegetation survey was carried out using the Crackles Bequest Project method, pollen assemblages from moss samples counted using standard methods, and relative pollen productivity and estimated source area derived using Extended R-Value analysis. Analysis of the data suggests that at least two pollen source areas exist at the sites studied, reflecting scales of landscape organisation. Microhabitat does not appear to have a marked effect on estimates of Relative Pollen Productivity in this heathland system. This study confirms earlier findings that the estimates obtained for some taxafrom heathlands are substantially different than those from gricultural landscapes,especially Poaceae. The findings suggest that the factors controlling Relative Pollen Productivity are still not fully understood, and that differences between locations may reflect real, habitat-led differences. Further investigation of this parameter, whichis central to reconstruction of past land cover from pollen records whether overtly incorporated via an algebraic model or less explicitly present via ecological narrative, biomisation or modern analog approaches, is clearly necessary

Family-Owned Newspapers: Filling Niches in Local U.S. Communities

Citation: Powers, A., Sohn, A. B., Briggs-Bunting, J. (2016) Family-Owned Newspapers: Filling Niches in Local U.S. Communities. Journal of Media Business Studies. 2(11)Since small town newspapers are facing increased competition and technological changes that are threatening their survival, the purpose of this paper was to analyze the strategy-making activities of these organizations from an ecological perspective. Findings indicate that family-owned newspapers were finding stability in retaining their core print businesses while migrating content to the web. Too many variations from the norm appeared to weaken financial footholds and were often eventually abandoned. Such behaviors indicate a rationale for upholding a “tried-and-true” approach in newspapers. While profits may fluctuate, the uncertainty that occurred with variation seemed to play a role in increasing the threat of failure for these small, family-owned newspapers

Maps from Mud - using the Multiple Scenario Approach to reconstruct land cover dynamics from pollen records:A case study of two Neolithic landscapes

Pollen records contain a wide range of information about past land cover, but translation from the pollen diagram to other formats remains a challenge. In this paper, we present LandPolFlow, a software package enabling Multiple Scenario Approach (MSA) based land cover reconstruction from pollen records for specific landscapes. It has two components: a basic Geographic Information System which takes grids of landscape constraints (e.g. topography, geology) and generates possible 'scenarios' of past land cover using a combination of probabilistic and deterministic placement rules to distribute defined plant communities within the landscape, and a pollen dispersal and deposition model which simulates pollen loading at specified points within each scenario and compares that statistically with actual pollen assemblages from the same location. Goodness of fit statistics from multiple pollen site locations are used to identify which scenarios are likely reconstructions of past land cover. We apply this approach to two case studies of Neolithisation in Britain, the first from the Somerset Levels and the second from Mainland, Orkney. Both landscapes contain significant evidence of Neolithic activity, but present contrasting contexts. In Somerset, wet-preserved Neolithic remains such as trackways are abundant, but little dry land settlement archaeology is known, and the pre-Neolithic landscape was extensively wooded. In Orkney, the Neolithic archaeology includes domestic and monumental stone-built structures forming a UNESCO World Heritage Site, and the pre-Neolithic landscape was largely treeless. Existing pollen records were collated from both landscapes and correlated within a new age model framework (presented elsewhere). This allowed pollen data to be grouped into 200 year periods, or “timeslices”, for reconstruction of land cover through time using the MSA. Reconstruction suggests that subtle but clear and persistent impacts of Neolithisation on land cover occurred in both landscapes, with no reduction in impact during periods when archaeological records suggest lower activity levels.By applying the methodology to specific landscapes, we critically evaluate the strengths and weaknesses and identify potential remedies, which we then expand into consideration of how simulation can be incorporated into palynological research practice. We argue that the MSA deserves a place within the palynologist’s standard tool kit

Editorial: Teaching palaeosciences to future generations

Sec. Paleoecology This article is part of the Research Topic: Teaching Palaeosciences to Future Generation

Novel methods of estimating relative pollen productivity; a key parameter for reconstruction of past land cover from pollen records

Reconstructing land cover from pollen data using mathematical models of the relationship between them has the potential to translate the many thousand pollen records produced over the last 100 years (over 2300 radiocarbon-dated pollen records exist for the UK alone) into formats relevant to ecologists, archaeologists and climate scientists. However, the reliability of these reconstructions depends on model parameters. A key parameter is Relative Pollen Productivity (RPP), usually estimated from empirical data using ‘Extended R Value analysis’ (ERV analysis). Lack of RPP estimates for many regions is currently a major limitation on reconstructing global land cover. We present two alternatives to ERV analysis, the Modified Davis Method and an iteration method, which use the same underlying model of the relationship between pollen and vegetation to estimate RPP from empirical data, but with different assumptions. We test them in simulation against ERV analysis, and use a case study of a problematic empirical dataset to determine whether they have the potential to increase the speed and geographic range of RPP estimation. The two alternative methods are shown to perform at least as well as ERV analysis in simulation. We also present new RPP estimates from southeastern sub-tropical China for nine taxa estimated using the Modified Davis Method. Adding these two methods to the ‘toolkit’ for land cover reconstruction from pollen records opens up the possibility to estimate a key parameter from existing datasets with less field time than using current methods. This can both speed up the inclusion of more of the globe in past land cover mapping exercises such as the PAGES Landcover6k working group and improve our understanding of how this parameter varies within a single taxon and the factors control that variation

Relative pollen productivity estimates for alpine meadow vegetation, northeastern Tibetan Plateau

A promising method of reconstructing past vegetation from pollen records uses mathematical models of the relationship between pollen and vegetation. These can be calibrated using the extended R-value (ERV) approach on datasets of modern pollen assemblages and related vegetation surveys. This study presents the results of calibrating the pollen-vegetation models for non-arboreal pollen types in alpine meadow habitats on the Tibetan Plateau. Surface soil samples were analysed for pollen and the surrounding vegetation was recorded at 30 randomly located sites in the Zoige basin, northeastern Tibetan Plateau. ERV analysis found that the most reliable results were obtained when using ERV sub-models 1 and 2, and distance-weighting the vegetation data by applying the taxon-specific Prentice–Sutton method. The relevant source area of pollen for these soil samples was found to be ca. 200m. Relative pollen productivities (RPP) of 15 non-arboreal taxa were estimated relative to Cyperaceae (RPPCyp). The taxa can be divided into three groups according to their RPPs, those with high RPPCyp values > 1.68 (Thalictrum, Artemisia, Caryophyllaceae, Chenopodiaceae and Plantago), those with moderate values (0.42–0.62) (Taraxacum-type, Apiaceae, Polygonum and Aster-type), and those with low values < 0.4 (Gentianaceae, Potentilla, Brassicaceae, Saussurea-type and Poaceae). The RPP values obtained from our study differ from those of previous studies in other parts of China, and form the basis for future reconstruction of palaeovegetation on the Tibetan Plateau through model-based methods, such as the Landscape Reconstruction Algorithm, or Multiple Scenario Approach

Landscapes for Neolithic People in Mainland, Orkney

Neolithic occupation of the Orkney Islands, in the north of Scotland, probably began in the mid fourth millennium cal BC, culminating in a range of settlements, including stone-built houses, varied stone-built tombs and two noteworthy stone circles. The environmental and landscape context of the spectacular archaeology, however, remains poorly understood. We applied the Multiple Scenario Approach (MSA) to Neolithic pollen records from Mainland, Orkney, in order to understand land cover and landscape openness across the timespan 4200–2200cal BC. Interpreted within a framework provided by Bayesian chronological modelling, 406 radiocarbon dates from archaeological contexts and a further 103 from palaeoenvironmental samples provide the basis for the first detailed reconstruction of the spatio-temporal patterns of Neolithic people and their environment. Major alterations to the land cover of Mainland took place from 3400cal BC (reduction in woodland from 20% to 10%) and from 3200cal BC (increase in disturbed land from 3% to 30%). The dramatic increase in disturbed land coincided with the Grooved Ware phenomenon and the establishment of settlements at Skara Brae and Ness of Brodgar. The upturn in the signal for disturbance communities in the pollen record may indicate an increase in the amount of land used as pasture. This accords with the archaeological record, since the Neolithic Orcadian economy probably relied heavily on cattle for subsistence. By 2800cal BC in the core of the Orkney Mainland, most settlements appear to have been ending, with people dispersing into the wider landscape, as the MSA modelling indicates a maintenance of disturbed land, and indeed a subsequent slight increase, implying persistence of human activity elsewhere in Mainland. People exhausted themselves rather than their land; that and its varied resources endured, while the intensive social relationships and practices of the peak of late Neolithic Orkney could not be maintained