Direct and indirect mechanisms behind successful biomanipulation

Lake Vesijärvi is a relatively large (length 25 km; total area 110 km2), shallow (mean depth 6 m), but stratified lake in southern Finland. The Enonselkä basin (26 km2), surrounded by the city of Lahti, received its sewage effluent, and changed from a clear water basin with flourishing fisheries from the 1940–50s to one of the most eutrophic lake systems in Finland thereafter. In 1976, the sewage effluent was diverted, resulting in a temporary recovery of water quality. However, in the 1980s, massive surface scums of cyanobacteria degraded the water quality and arrested the recovery of the lake. A restoration strategy providing an ecologically sound basis for the management of the lake was initiated in 1987. This strategy involved biomanipulation (mass removal of coarse fish) together with conventional pollution control measures on discharges to the lake. Biomanipulation was chosen instead of much more expensive chemical and/or technical methods, such as chemical treatment or dredging of the profundal sediment. The large-scale biomanipulation trial was carried out in the Enonselkä basin during 1989–93. Following the mass removal of coarse fish (1000 metric tons of fish; mainly roach and smelt), the biomass of cyanobacteria collapsed concomitantly with a decline of total phosphorus concentration from 45 to 35 mg P m3, and with an increase of Secchi depth from 1 m to 3.5 m. These observed improvements in the water quality were matched with a large decline in roach-mediated phosphorus movement from littoral to pelagial, from 100 mg P m2 in 1989 t

Epiphytic metazoans on emergent macrophytes in oxbow lakes of the Krapina River, Croatia: differences related to plant species and limnological conditions

This study investigated the structure of the epiphytic metazoans on emerged macrophytes in the littoral zone of two oxbow lakes with different trophic levels. Differences in the diversity and density of the epiphytic metazoans were analyzed in relation to plant architecture (simple or complex stems), food resources (algae and detritus) and water characteristics (transparency and derived trophic state index). Asignificant negative correlation was found between detritus on plants as food resource, and diversity and density of epiphytic metazoans, indicating grazing of microphagous species. Rotifers dominated in diversity and density in the epiphyton on all habitats. Total density of metazoans, rotifers and copepods in epiphyton were significantly higher on Mentha in mesotrophic lake than on Iris in a eutrophic lake.We presume that macrophyte belt width and trophic state governed biotic interactions and consequently epiphytic assemblages more strongly than macrophyte architecture. However, a Mentha habitat showed a slightly higher density and diversity of epiphytic metazoans in relation to Iris at the same site, but these differences were not significant

The influence of macrophytes on sediment resuspension and the effect of associated nutrients in a shallow and large lake (Lake Taihu, China)

A yearlong campaign to examine sediment resuspension was conducted in large, shallow and eutrophic Lake Taihu, China, to investigate the influence of vegetation on sediment resuspension and its nutrient effects. The study was conducted at 6 sites located in both phytoplankton-dominated zone and macrophyte-dominated zone of the lake, lasting for a total of 13 months, with collections made at two-week intervals. Sediment resuspension in Taihu, with a two-week high average rate of 1771 g.m(-2).d(-1) and a yearly average rate of 377 g.m(-2).d(-1), is much stronger than in many other lakes worldwide, as Taihu is quite shallow and contains a long fetch. The occurrence of macrophytes, however, provided quite strong abatement of sediment resuspension, which may reduce the sediment resuspension rate up to 29-fold. The contribution of nitrogen and phosphorus to the water column from sediment resuspension was estimated as 0.34 mg.L-1 and 0.051 mg.L-1 in the phytoplankton-dominated zone. Sediment resuspension also largely reduced transparency and then stimulated phytoplankton growth. Therefore, sediment resuspension may be one of the most important factors delaying the recovery of eutrophic Lake Taihu, and the influence of sediment resuspension on water quality must also be taken into account by the lake managers when they determine the restoration target.Peer reviewe

Lake catchment characteristics and external P load — cultivated area/lake area ratio as a tool for evaluating the risk of eutrophication from land use information

The effects of land use on external P load (LP), critical P load (LC) and on LP/LC of 27 lakes in Finland were examined with regression analyses. Catchment area to lake area ratio (AC/AL), cultivated catchment area to lake area ratio (AF/AL) and the percentage of cultivated land in the catchment (F%) were used as independent variables. We studied whether these parameters can be used to estimate the risk of exceeding the critical P load (LP/LC > 1). All three parameters had a positive effect on LP and LP/LC. Compared with AC/AL and F%, AF/AL had a higher coefficient of determination in predicting LP and LP/LC. This was because AC/AL does not include land use variations in catchments and F% does not include information on catchment size, while AF/AL includes information on both. Critical P load was exceeded when AF/AL > 1.63. AF/AL can be a useful and simple tool for evaluating the risk of lake eutrophication

Physiological and visual refuges in a metalimnion: an experimental study of effects of clay turbidity and an oxygen minimum on fish predation

1. The effectivity of elevated clay turbidity and low-oxygen concentration in the metalimnion as refuges for chaoborid larvae against fish predation was studied in experimental water columns. 2. When 70–80 nephelometric turbidity unit clay turbidity was combined with 3–4 mg L)1 oxygen concentration, prey capture rate by fish (golden orfe Leuciscus idus) was reduced by 74% compared with the control treatment with no refuges. Oxygen and turbidity refuges alone did not significantly reduce the feeding rate. 3. All fish in the control treatment dwelled in the metalimnion, but 36% of the fish in the low-oxygen treatment and 23% of the fish in the turbidity treatment stayed in the epilimnion. In the combined treatment, 54% of the fish were in the epilimnion. 4. The results demonstrated that a combination of moderately elevated turbidity and lowered oxygen concentration in the metalimnion is an effective protection against fish predation, while turbidity or oxygen refuge alone are much less effective. 5. In the treatment with the combined refuge, oxygen concentration limited the time fish could spend in the metalimnion and turbidity affected the detection of prey through changes in reactive distance. 6. Because of the combined effects of turbidity and oxygen refuges, planktivorous fish and phantom midge larvae may co-occur in clay-turbid lakes in high densities. Such situation is problematic for biomanipulation, which aims to enhance the grazing rate of zooplankton through reduction of planktivorous fish

Differences in parasite community composition support ecological differentiation in a freshwater gadoid fish

Several northern freshwater fishes have gone through rapid adaptive radiation after the last glacial period, resulting in new species or intraspecific morphs with distinct life histories. Parasite infections can promote adaptive radiations and spatiotemporal differences in patterns of infections can potentially reveal incipient or ongoing speciation processes. We investigated intraspecific differentiation in a freshwater gadoid fish, burbot (Lota lota), by exploring differences in parasite infections between two potential life-history morphs in Lake Konnevesi, Central-Finland, one reproducing species characteristically in shallow littoral waters in February and the other possibly in deep profundal zone roughly a month later. By conducting a sampling campaign on reproducing fish over two consecutive years, we found significant differences in infections between the fish captured from littoral and profundal sites. More specifically, larval trematode and cestode infections were consistently less abundant in profundal fish, tracking long-term exposure differences in shallow waters. In contrast, trophically transmitted metazoan infections in the fish gut, reflecting shorter-term differences in feeding, showed higher variation between sampling years rather than depths. We also found suggestive evidence of higher trematode-inflicted tissue damage per parasite in the profundal fish, implying lower tolerance to the infection. These results offer further evidence that burbot captured from littoral and profundal sites represent differentiated life-history morphs. We propose that ecological and evolutionary differentiation within burbot populations across its circumpolar distribution may be more widespread than previously acknowledged.peerReviewe