Phosphoric acid - a potentially elusive participant in atmospheric new particle formation

We investigate the molecular interactions between phosphoric acid and common atmospheric nucleation precursors using computational methods. The equilibrium geometries and vibrational frequencies are obtained using the three DFT functionals M06-2X, PW91 and B97X-D. The single-point energy is corrected using a high-level CCSD(T)-F12a/VDZ-F12 calculation. The molecular interaction between phosphoric acid and sulphuric acid is found to be strong with reaction free energy of similar magnitude as the interaction between dimethylamine and sulphuric acid. The strong hydrogen bonding of phosphoric acid to sulphuric acid indicates that concentrations of as low as 10(2)-10(4) molecules/cm(3) will offer equivalent or higher stability as the sulphuric acid dimer for the formation of atmospheric molecular clusters. We assess and utilise the DLPNO-CCSD(T) method for studying larger clusters involving phosphoric acid and sulphuric acid and find that having a phosphoric acid molecule present in the cluster enhances the further addition of sulphuric acid molecules. [GRAPHICS] .Peer reviewe

Diamines Can Initiate New Particle Formation in the Atmosphere

Recent experimental evidence suggests that diamines can enhance atmospheric new particle formation more efficiently compared to monoamines such as dimethylamine Here we investigate the molecular interactions between sulfuric acid (sa) and the diamine putrescine (put) using computational methods. The molecular structure of up to four sulfuric acid molecules and up to four putrescine molecules were obtained, at the omega B97X-D/6-31++G(d,p) level of theory. We utilized a domain local pair natural orbital coupled cluster method (DLPNO-CCSD(T)/aug-cc-pVTZ) to obtain highly accurate binding energies of the clusters. We find that the (sa)(1-4)(put)(1-4) clusters show more ionic character than clusters consisting of sulfuric acid and dimethylamine (dma) by readily forming several sulfate ions in the cluster. To estimate the stability of the clusters, we calculate the evaporation rates and compare them to ESI-APi-TOF measurements. Using the atmospheric cluster dynamics code (ACDC), we simulate and compare the new particle formation rates between the (sa)(1-4)(put)(1-4) and (sa),(1-4)(dma)(1-4) cluster systems. We find that putrescine significantly enhances the formation of new particles compared to dimethylamine. Our findings suggest that a large range of amines with different basicity is capable of explaining various regions of the observed new particle formation events. These results indicate that diamines, or related compounds with high basicity, might be important species in forming the initial cluster with sulfuric acid and subsequently more abundant amines with lower basicity can assist in the new particle formation process by attaching to the sulfuric acid-diamine nucleus.Peer reviewe

What Is Required for Highly Oxidized Molecules To Form Clusters with Sulfuric Acid?

Peer reviewe

Piperazine Enhancing Sulfuric Acid-Based New Particle Formation : Implications for the Atmospheric Fate of Piperazine

Piperazine (PZ), a cyclic diamine, is one of 160 detected atmospheric amines and an alternative solvent to the widely used monoethanolamine in post-combustion CO2 capture. Participating in H2SO4 (sulfuric acid, SA)-based new particle formation (NPF) could be an important removal pathway for PZ. Here, we employed quantum chemical calculations and kinetics modeling to evaluate the enhancing potential of PZ on SA-based NPF by examining the formation of PZ-SA clusters. The results indicate that PZ behaves more like a monoamine in stabilizing SA and can enhance SA-based NPF at the parts per trillion (ppt) level. The enhancing potential of PZ is less than that of the chainlike diamine putrescine and greater than that of dimethylamine, which is one of the strongest enhancing agents confirmed by ambient observations and experiments. After the initial formation of the (PZ)1(SA)1 cluster, the cluster mainly grows by gradual addition of SA or PZ monomer, followed by addition of (PZ)1(SA)1 cluster. We find that the ratio of PZ removal by NPF to that by the combination of NPF and oxidations is 0.5–0.97 at 278.15 K. As a result, we conclude that participation in the NPF pathway could significantly alter the environmental impact of PZ compared to only considering oxidation pathways.Peer reviewe

Technical note : Estimating aqueous solubilities and activity coefficients of mono- and alpha,omega-dicarboxylic acids using COSMOtherm

We have used the COSMOtherm program to estimate activity coefficients and solubilities of mono- and alpha, omega-dicarboxylic acids and water in binary acid-water systems. The deviation from ideality was found to be larger in the systems containing larger acids than in the systems containing smaller acids. COnductor-like Screening MOdel for Real Solvents (COSMO-RS) underestimates experimental monocarboxylic acid activity coefficients by less than a factor of 2, but experimental water activity coefficients are underestimated more especially at high acid mole fractions. We found a better agreement between COSMOtherm-estimated and experimental activity coefficients of monocarboxylic acids when the water clustering with a carboxylic acid and itself was taken into account using the dimerization, aggregation, and reaction extension (COSMO-RS-DARE) of COSMOtherm. COSMO-RS-DARE is not fully predictive, but fit parameters found here for water-water and acid-water clustering interactions can be used to estimate thermodynamic properties of monocarboxylic acids in other aqueous solvents, such as salt solutions. For the dicarboxylic acids, COSMO-RS is sufficient for predicting aqueous solubility and activity coefficients, and no fitting to experimental values is needed. This is highly beneficial for applications to atmospheric systems, as these data are typically not available for a wide range of mixing states realized in the atmosphere, due to a lack of either feasibility of the experiments or sample availability. Based on effective equilibrium constants of different clustering reactions in the binary solutions, acid dimer formation is more dominant in systems containing larger dicarboxylic acids (C-5-C-8), while for monocarboxylic acids (C-1-C-6) and smaller dicarboxylic acids (C-2-C-4), hydrate formation is more favorable, especially in dilute solutions.Peer reviewe

Guanidine : A Highly Efficient Stabilizer in Atmospheric New-Particle Formation

The role of a strong organobase, guanidine, in sulfuric acid-driven new-particle formation is studied using state-of-the-art quantum chemical methods and molecular cluster formation simulations. Cluster formation mechanisms at the molecular level are resolved, and theoretical results on cluster stability are confirmed with mass spectrometer measurements. New-particle formation from guanidine and sulfuric acid molecules occurs without thermodynamic barriers under studied conditions, and clusters are growing close to a 1:1 composition of acid and base. Evaporation rates of the most stable clusters are extremely low, which can be explained by the proton transfers and symmetrical cluster structures. We compare the ability of guanidine and dimethylamine to enhance sulfuric acid-driven particle formation and show that more than 2000-fold concentration of dimethylamine is needed to yield as efficient particle formation as in the case of guanidine. At similar conditions, guanidine yields 8 orders of magnitude higher particle formation rates compared to dimethylamine. Highly basic compounds such as guanidine may explain experimentally observed particle formation events at low precursor vapor concentrations, whereas less basic and more abundant bases such as ammonia and amines are likely to explain measurements at high concentrations.Peer reviewe

Modeling the formation and growth of atmospheric molecular clusters : A review

Molecular clusters are ubiquitous constituents of the ambient atmosphere, that can grow into larger sizes forming new aerosol particles. The formation and growth of small clusters into aerosol particles remain one of the largest uncertainties in global climate predictions. This has made the modeling of atmospheric molecular clustering into an active field of research, yielding direct molecular level information about the formation mechanism. We review the present state of-the-art quantum chemical methods and cluster distribution dynamics models that are applied to study the formation and growth of atmospheric molecular clusters. We outline the current challenges in applying theoretical methods and the future directions to move the field forward.Peer reviewe

Atmospheric Fate of Monoethanolamine : Enhancing New Particle Formation of Sulfuric Acid as an Important Removal Process

Monoethanolamine (MEA), a potential atmospheric pollutant from the capture unit of a leading CO2 capture technology, could be removed by participating H2SO4-based new particle formation (NPF) as simple amines. Here we evaluated the enhancing potential of MEA on H2SO4-based NPF by examining the formation of molecular clusters of MEA and H2SO4 using combined quantum chemistry calculations and kinetics modeling. The results indicate that MEA at the parts per trillion (ppt) level can enhance H2SO4-based NPF. The enhancing potential of MEA is less than that of dimethylamine (DMA), one of the strongest enhancing agents, and much greater than methylamine (MA), in contrast to the order suggested solely by their basicity (MEA <MA <DMA). The unexpectedly high enhancing potential is attributed to the role of -OH of MEA in increasing cluster binding free energies by acting as both a hydrogen bond donor and acceptor. After the initial formation of one H2SO4 and one MEA cluster, the cluster growth mainly proceeds by first adding one H2SO4, and then one MEA, which differs from growth pathways in H2SO4-DMA and H2SO4-MA systems. Importantly, the effective removal rate of MEA due to participation in NPF is comparable to that of oxidation by hydroxyl radicals at 278.15 K, indicating NPF as an important sink for MEA.Peer reviewe

Hydration of Atmospheric Molecular Clusters III : Procedure for Efficient Free Energy Surface Exploration of Large Hydrated Clusters

Sampling the shallow free energy surface of hydrated atmospheric molecular clusters is a significant challenge. Using computational methods, we present an efficient approach to obtain minimum free energy structures for large hydrated clusters of atmospheric relevance. We study clusters consisting of two to four sulfuric acid (sa) molecules and hydrate them with up to five water (w) molecules. The structures of the "dry" clusters are obtained using the ABCluster program to yield a large pool of low-lying conformer minima with respect to free energy. The conformers (up to ten) lowest in free energy are then hydrated using our recently developed systematic hydrate sampling technique. Using this approach, we identify a total of 1145 unique (sa)(2-4)(w)(1-5) cluster structures. The cluster geometries and thermochemical parameters are calculated at the omega B97X-D/6-31++G(d,p) level of theory, at 298.15 K and 1 atm. The single-point energy of the most stable clusters is calculated using a high-level DLPNO-CCSD(T-0)/aug-cc-pVTZ method. Using the thermochemical data, we calculate the equilibrium hydrate distribution of the clusters under atmospheric conditions and find that the larger (sa)(3) and (sa)(4) clusters are significantly more hydrated than the smaller (sa)(2) cluster or the sulfuric acid (sa)(1) molecule. These findings indicate that more than five water molecules might be required to fully saturate the sulfuric acid clusters with water under atmospheric conditions. The presented methodology gives modelers a tool to take the effect of water explicitly into account in atmospheric particle formation models based on quantum chemistry.Peer reviewe

Hydration of Atmospheric Molecular Clusters II: Organic Acid-Water Clusters

Using computational methods, we study the gas phase hydration of three different atmospherically relevant organic acids with up to 10 water molecules. We study a dicarboxylic acid (pinic acid) and a tricarboxylic acid (3-methyl-1,2,3-butanetricarboxylic acid (mbtca)) that are both identified as products from α-pinene oxidation reactions. We also study a 2-oxohexanediperoxy acid (ohdpa) that has been identified as a product from cyclohexene autoxidation. To sample the cluster structures, we employ our recently developed systematic hydrate sampling technique and identify a total of 551 hydrate clusters. The cluster structures and thermochemical parameters (at 298.15 K and 1 atm) are obtained at the ωB97X-D/6-31++G­(d,p) level of theory, and the single point energy of the clusters have been refined using a high level DLPNO–CCSD­(T)/aug-cc-pVTZ calculation. We find that all three tested organic acids interact significantly more weakly with water compared to the primary nucleation precursor sulfuric acid. Even at 100% relative humidity (298.15 K and 1 atm), we find that ohdpa remains unhydrated and only the monohydrate of pinic acid and mbtca are slightly populated (4% and 2%, respectively). From the obtained molecular structures, potential implications for the ice nucleating ability of aerosol particles is discussed