Experiences and Perspectives of Polycystic Kidney Disease Patients following a Diet of Reduced Osmoles, Protein, and Acid Precursors Supplemented with Water:A Qualitative Study

Background Salt, protein, acid precursors, and fluid intake have been identified as factors that influence cyst growth in ADPKD. Unfortunately, the feasibility of following these dietary restrictions/enhancements from a patient's point-of-view has yet to be studied. The purpose of this study is to understand better the experiences of patients following a relatively complex dietary prescription targeting these factors. Methods Twelve adults with ADPKD and kidney function >30ml/min/1.73m(2) were recruited from the University of Kansas Medical Center Polycystic Kidney Disease clinic. In a qualitative design, semi-structured interviews of participants were conducted following a four week dietary intervention (experimental diet lower in sodium, protein, and acid precursors, and supplemented with water) either face-to-face or by telephone. All interviews were recorded, transcribed verbatim, and checked for accuracy. Transcripts were analyzed thematically for emerging themes. Results Participants reported that eating less meat and more fruits and vegetables were the easiest components of the diet, whereas reaching the daily goal amount of fruits and vegetables and tracking the diet constantly were the most difficult components. Participants had little difficulty with fluid intake and reported the prescribed fluid goal as achievable. The tracking system for fruits and vegetables and protein was reported to be both helpful and intuitive, but tracking their intake on paper was tedious. Eating out was the most significant barrier to following the diet with some individuals avoiding restaurants in order to comply with the dietary prescription. Conclusion Participants on the experimental diet heightened their awareness of the consumption of dietary salt, protein, acid precursors, and fluid intake. Additionally, most participants believed adherence to the prescribed diet was feasible. However, participants wanted less cumbersome ways to track and monitor the diet, especially given that the prescribed diet is designed for lifelong adherence. Future studies should focus on targeting these specific dietary factors in larger groups of more ethnically and culturally diverse populations to help inform clinicians and how best to help diverse populations adhere to the dietary intervention

Kidney Response to the Spectrum of Diet-Induced Acid Stress

Chronic ingestion of the acid (H+)-producing diets that are typical of developed societies appears to pose a long-term threat to kidney health. Mechanisms employed by kidneys to excrete this high dietary H+ load appear to cause long-term kidney injury when deployed over many years. In addition, cumulative urine H+ excretion is less than the cumulative increment in dietary H+, consistent with H+ retention. This H+ retention associated with the described high dietary H+ worsens as the glomerular filtration rate (GFR) declines which further exacerbates kidney injury. Modest H+ retention does not measurably change plasma acid–base parameters but, nevertheless, causes kidney injury and might contribute to progressive nephropathy. Current clinical methods do not detect H+ retention in its early stages but the condition manifests as metabolic acidosis as it worsens, with progressive decline of the glomerular filtration rate. We discuss this spectrum of H+ injury, which we characterize as “H+ stress”, and the emerging evidence that high dietary H+ constitutes a threat to long-term kidney health

Pathophysiology of Diet-Induced Acid Stress

Diets can influence the body’s acid–base status because specific food components yield acids, bases, or neither when metabolized. Animal-sourced foods yield acids and plant-sourced food, particularly fruits and vegetables, generally yield bases when metabolized. Modern diets proportionately contain more animal-sourced than plant-sourced foods, are, thereby, generally net acid-producing, and so constitute an ongoing acid challenge. Acid accumulation severe enough to reduce serum bicarbonate concentration, i.e., manifesting as chronic metabolic acidosis, the most extreme end of the continuum of “acid stress”, harms bones and muscles and appears to enhance the progression of chronic kidney disease (CKD). Progressive acid accumulation that does not achieve the threshold amount necessary to cause chronic metabolic acidosis also appears to have deleterious effects. Specifically, identifiable acid retention without reduced serum bicarbonate concentration, which, in this review, we will call “covert acidosis”, appears to cause kidney injury and exacerbate CKD progression. Furthermore, the chronic engagement of mechanisms to mitigate the ongoing acid challenge of modern diets also appears to threaten health, including kidney health. This review describes the full continuum of “acid stress” to which modern diets contribute and the mechanisms by which acid stress challenges health. Ongoing research will develop clinically useful tools to identify stages of acid stress earlier than metabolic acidosis and determine if dietary acid reduction lowers or eliminates the threats to health that these diets appear to cause