New Comparative Data on the Long Bone Microstructure of Large Extant and Extinct Flightless Birds

Here, we investigate whether bone microanatomy can be used to infer the locomotion mode (cursorial vs. graviportal) of large terrestrial birds. We also reexamine, or describe for the first time, the bone histology of several large extant and extinct flightless birds to (i) document the histovariability between skeletal elements of the hindlimb; (ii) improve our knowledge of the histological diversity of large flightless birds; (iii) and reassess previous hypotheses pertaining to the growth strategies of modern palaeognaths. Our results show that large extinct terrestrial birds, inferred as graviportal based on hindlimb proportions, also have thicker diaphyseal cortices and/or more bony trabeculae in the medullary region than cursorial birds. We also report for the first time the occurrence of growth marks (not associated with an outer circumferential layer-OCL) in the cortices of several extant ratites. These observations support earlier hypotheses that flexible growth patterns can be present in birds when selection pressures for rapid growth within a single year are absent. We also document the occurrence of an OCL in several skeletally mature ratites. Here, the high incidence of pathologies among the modern species is attributed to the fact that these individuals were probably long-lived zoo specimens

-

Les Gastornithidae sont des oiseaux géants terrestres présents dans le Tertiaire (Paléocène- Eocène) d'Europe, d'Amérique du Nord et d'Asie. Bien que ces oiseaux soient connus depuis le 19ème siècle, leur écologie et les environnements dans lesquels ils vivaient sont encore très mal connus. Cette thèse propose donc d'apporter des réponses sur ces deux points afin de mieux comprendre ces oiseaux grâce à une approche pluridisciplinaire, combinant des études de morphologie-fonctionnelle, de géochimie isotopique, et de paléontologie. Nous avons pu déterminer que cet oiseau de deux mètres de haut devait peser entre 110 et 260 kg, et avait un déplacement relativement lent ne lui permettant pas de courir rapidement et longtemps. Le régime alimentaire des Gastornithidae, en débat depuis plus de vingt ans, a été ré-étudié grâce à une étude de géochimie isotopique combinée à une étude de morphologie fonctionnelle, permettant de conclure à une alimentation herbivore. Parallèlement, les paléo-environnements dans lesquels évoluaient cet oiseau ont également pu être étudiés grâce une étude de géochimie isotopique appliquée à des coquilles d'oeufs fossiles du Sud de la France attribuées à Gastornis dans cette thèse. Ces grands oiseaux vivaient donc dans un environnement relativement sec et chaud avec probablement une alternance de saison sèche et humide pour le Sud de la France, ce qui est différent de ce qu'on connait pour des environnements du centre de l'Allemagne où d'autres fossiles de Gastornis ont été trouvés, et où la végétation montre un environnement plus humide. Cela montre donc que cet oiseau avait une bonne capacité d'adaptation à différents environnements, ce qui lui a probablement permis de franchir le PETM sans être particulièrement affecté, comme le montre le registre fossile dans lequel aucune extinction, aucune variation géographique ou anatomique ne sont observées dans cette famille contrairement au cas de nombreux mammifèresGastornithidae are a familly of large ground fossils birds present in the Tertiary (Paleocene- Eocene) from Europe, North America and Asia. Although these birds are known since the beginning of the 19th century, their ecology and the environment where they lived are still poorly known. Therefore, this PhD propose to bring some answers about this two points in order to better understand these birds using a multidisciplinary approach, including functional morphology, isotope geochemistry and paleontological studies. We have determined that this two meter high bird should weigh around 110 to 260 kg, and had a relatively slow locomotion not allowing him to run quickly and for a long time. The diet of the Gastornithidae, discussed since more twenty years, has been studied using an isotopic geochemical approach combine with a morphofunctional study, which permits to conclude to an herbivore diet. In parallel, paleo-environments where lived this bird have also been studied using isotopical analysis applied on fossils bird’s eggshells from the southern France, attributed to Gastornis in this thesis. Thus these large birds lived in an environment relatively dry and hot, with probably an alternance of dry and wet saison in the southern France, which is different than which is known in middle Germany environments where other Gastornis fossils were found, and where vegetation shows an environment wetter. Therefore, that shows that this bird had a good adaptability to different environments, which allowed him to cross the PETM without being particularly affected as shown in the fossil record, on the contrary to numerous mammal

An Introduction to Evolution and Palaeobiology of Flightless Birds

Although flight is often considered as one of the most salient characteristics of birds, in the course of their evolution various avian lineages have lost the ability to fly [...

Gargantuavis is an insular basal ornithurine: a comment on Mayr et al., 2020, ‘A well-preserved pelvis from the Maastrichtian of Romania suggests that the enigmatic Gargantuavis is neither an ornithurine bird nor an insular endemic’

International audienc

Stratigraphic distribution of large flightless birds in the Palaeogene of Europe and its palaeobiological and palaeogeographical implications

The stratigraphic distribution of the three main groups of large flightless birds known from the Palaeogene of Europe, Gastornithidae, Phorusrhacidae and Ratitae, is reviewed. The huge, herbivorous gastornithids, represented by the single genus Gastornis, are known from the Selandian (Middle Palaeocene) to the late Lutetian (Middle Eocene), being recorded from reference levels MP5 to MP13. The carnivorous phorusrhacids are represented by a single species, Eleutherornis cotei, from the late Lutetian (MP14, late Middle Eocene). The ratites have a patchy distribution, being represented by two species of moderate size, Remiornis heberti from the Thanetian (MP6, Late Palaeocene) and Palaeotis weigelti from the Lutetian (MP11 to MP13, Middle Eocene). The stratigraphic distributions of large eggs referred to gastornithids in the Late Palaeocene and Early Eocene of southern Europe and the occurrence of enigmatic large avian footprints in the Late Eocene of France are discussed. Whereas gastornithids and ratites co-existed in both the Palaeocene and the Middle Eocene, phorusrhacids seem to have been the only large ground birds in Europe at the end of the Middle Eocene. The palaeobiogeographical and evolutionary implications of the stratigraphic distributions of those groups of large birds in Europe are discussed. As Gastornis first appears in North America and in Asia in the Early Eocene, it is likely that gastornithids originated in Europe and later spread to other land masses during a dispersal event close to the PalaeoceneEocene boundary. Prior to that, gastornithids evolved on the European "island continent", where they were the largest terrestrial tetrapods during the Palaeocene. Gastornithids do not seem to have been significantly affected by the PETM. Ratitae have a more patchy record and relationships between Remiornis and Palaeotis remain unclear. Nevertheless, those European forms are among the earliest known ratites and this should not be overlooked in discussions of ratite evolution and palaeobiogeography. Phorusrhacids appear to have been present in Europe for only a short time and are interpreted as the result of dispersal from Africa followed by local extinction