Keeping an Eye on Your Neighbors: Agents Monitoring and Sanctioning One Another In a Common-Pool Resource Environment

The role of a specific institution in avoiding a "tragedy of the commons" situation in a common pool-resource environment is studied experimentally. The resource users privately decide their own exploitation level and then, once the group outcome is revealed, can choose to select other individuals for inspection. At a cost, the inspector can view the decision of any individual. If the inspected individual has exploited the resource excessively, relative to a publicly known amount, a fine is imposed and paid to the inspector. The rules, called Carte di Regola, were modeled after an historical case of self-governed rural communities. The impact of the rules is a dramatic increase in efficiency over the no rule case but still less than 100%. As part of an attempt to understand the nature of the impact of the rules the paper focuses on models of individual agent’s choices. The patterns of results relative to the classical Nash model are similar to other experiments. The model does well, except for the fact that contributions to the public good are less than Nash equilibrium amount. However, when the environment is changed to allow sanctions, contributions above the Nash equilibrium are observed. This paradoxical “flip” in behavior is explained by a non classical model in which spite plays a role in preferences and in which agents are heterogeneous. The model of asymmetric, other regarding agents also does relatively well in predicting patterns of individual choices such as the choice to inspect and sanction others. Efficiency is improved along with the strength of sanctions and the patterns of individual choices are consistent with the non classical model

Solar geoengineering may lead to excessive cooling and high strategic uncertainty

Climate engineering-the deliberate large-scale manipulation of the Earth's climate system-is a set of technologies for reducing climate-change impacts and risks. It is controversial and raises novel governance challenges [T. C. Schelling, Climatic Change, 33, 303-307 (1996); J. Virgoe, Climatic Change, 95, 103-119 (2008)]. We focus on the strategic implications of solar geoengineering. When countries engineer the climate, conflict can arise because different countries might prefer different temperatures. This would result in too much geoengineering: the country with the highest preference for geoengineering cools the planet beyond what is socially optimal at the expense of the others-a theoretical possibility termed "free-driving" [M. L. Weitzman, Scand. J. Econ., 117, 1049-1068 (2015)]. This study is an empirical test of this hypothesis. We carry out an economic laboratory experiment based on a public "good or bad" game. We find compelling evidence of free-driving: global geoengineering exceeds the socially efficient level and leads to welfare losses. We also evaluate the possibility of counteracting the geoengineering efforts of others. Results show that countergeoengineering generates high payoff inequality as well as heavy welfare losses, resulting from both strategic and behavioral factors. Finally, we compare strategic behavior in bilateral and multilateral settings. We find that welfare deteriorates even more under multilateralism when countergeoengineering is a possibility. These results have general implications for governing global good or bad commons

Preparation and optimization of TiO2 photoanodes fabricated by pulsed laser deposition for photoelectrochemical water splitting

Quasi-1D TiO2 nanostructures prepared by pulsed laser deposition (PLD) are tested as photoanodes for photoelectrochemical water splitting application and compared with TiO2 nanotube arrays prepared by anodic oxidation. PLD TiO2 films with controlled structure and morphology ranging from compact to vertically oriented or hierarchical porous nanostructures are deposited by ablating a TiO2 target with nanosecond UV laser pulses in the presence of an O2 background atmosphere at different pressures. Thermal treatments at different temperatures are used to transform the so-obtained amorphous systems into nanocrystalline structures (mainly anatase). The effect of film density and thickness is also considered by depositing different amounts of material per unit surface. The morphology and the phase composition of the samples are characterized by SEM and Raman spectroscopy, while the photoelectrochemical water splitting performances are investigated by monitoring the photocurrent generated under illumination in a three-electrode cell. Voltammetric scans and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy analysis were also used to correlate the morphology of PLD samples with their electrochemical properties and their working mechanism in the absence and presence of a light radiation. A clear correlation between structural/morphological properties and photoelectrochemical behavior is found and ideal values of the synthesis parameters are identified, which allow the identification of the optimal quasi-1D nanoporous morphology for water splitting applications. The use of sacrificial organic reagents as hole scavengers was also considered to improve the photoelectrochemical performance of the samples

A strategy for the robust forecasting of gas turbine health subjected to fouling

Fouling represents a major problem for Gas Turbines (GTs) in both heavy-duty and aeropropulsion applications. Solid particles entering the engine can stick to the internal surfaces and form deposits. Components' lifetime and performance can dramatically vary as a consequence of this phenomenon. These effects impact the whole engine in terms of residual life, operating stability, and maintenance costs. In the High-Pressure Turbine (HPT), in particular, the high temperatures soft the particles and promote their adhesion, especially in the short term. Unfortunately, predicting the GT response to this detrimental issue is still an open problem for scientists. Furthermore, the stochastic variations of the components operating conditions increase the uncertainty of the forecasting results. In this work, a strategy to predict the effects of turbine fouling on the whole engine is proposed. A stationary Gas Path Analysis (GPA) has been performed for this scope to predict the GT health parameters. Their alteration as a consequence of fouling has been evaluated by scaling the turbine map. The scaling factor has been found by performing Computational Fluid Dynamic (CFD) simulations of a HPT nozzle with particle injection. Being its operating conditions strongly uncertain, a stochastic analysis has been conducted. The uncertainty sources considered are the circumferential hot core location and the turbulence level at the inlet. The study enables to build of confidence intervals on the GT health parameters predictions and represents a step forward towards a robust forecasting tool

Multi-wavelength Raman scattering of nanostructured Al-doped zinc oxide

In this work we present a detailed Raman scattering investigation of zinc oxide and aluminum-doped zinc oxide (AZO) films characterized by a variety of nanoscale structure and morphology and synthesized by pulsed laser deposition (PLD) under different oxygen pressure conditions. The comparison of Raman data for pure ZnO and AZO films with similar morphology at the nano/mesoscale allows to investigate the relation between Raman features (peak or band positions, width, relative intensity) and material properties such as local structural order, stoichiometry and doping. Moreover Raman measurements with three different excitation lines (532, 457 and 325 nm) point out a strong correlation between vibrational and electronic properties. This observation confirms the relevance of a multi-wavelength Raman investigation to obtain a complete structural characterization of advanced doped oxide materials.Comment: 27 pages, 7 figures, submitted to the Journal of Applied Physic

Off-line washing effectiveness on a multistage axial compressor

The interaction between gas turbines and airborne particles determines detrimental effects on the performance, efficiency, and reliability of the power unit. When it is possible, the interaction is reduced by the use of inlet separators and filtration systems. In an aero engine, these barriers are difficult to implement, and only bigger particles (usually greater than 10 µm) are separated from the airflow. Small units, especially those equips helicopters, are usually affected by fouling issues, especially when the aircraft is employed in harsh environments such as firefighting and rescue activities. To recover this contamination, the unit is washed after the mission by ground operations to restore the unit performance by removing the deposits. This operation occurs during a sub-idle unit operation, and the washing process has to be effective when the engine operates in this off-design condition. In this paper, the evaluation of the washing performance during a sub-idle unit operation is carried out. The compressor unit is a multistage axial compressor that equips the Allison 250-C18 engine. The washing operation was performed by water, and a sensitivity analysis is carried out to discover the capability of water droplets to remove the contaminants. The experimental analysis involves the contamination of the unit by micro-sized soot particles and a washing operation by micro-sized water droplets. These experimental results are compared to numerical simulations to discover the effects of the washing operation on a small power unit during sub-idle operating conditions. The off-design regime imposes a specific evaluation of the proper setup of the washing strategy: flow separations involve wider regions in the compressor unit, and the removal capability is strongly related to the droplet path through the stages. The results show how in the off-design washing operation, the droplet diameter has greater importance than the water flow rate for reducing the deposits over the compressor stages. © The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/