Spatial and temporal patterns of plant diversity in the Italian forest monitoring network (CONECOFOR)

Since 1996, the Italian network CONECOFOR included Ground Vegetation (GV) within the forest monitoring actions, in the frame of ICP Forests. Plant diversity variables have been assessed yearly on 11 of the 31 sites of the intensive network (LII), while a unique survey was realized for the extensive network (LI) in 2007, within the Biosoil-Biodiversity project. CONECOFOR is presently undergoing a revision process aimed to assure the financial sustainability of reliable information on forest status and trends (SMART4Action, LIFE+ ENV project). We contribute to the project by analysing spatial and temporal patterns options for GV assessment. (i) Aims: suggest an affordable number of sites and the best sampling strategy to provide an overview of forest plant diversity within both LII and LI network. (ii) Objectives: estimate the effect of reduced sampling frequency and size, as well as different sampling designs on GV assessment. (iii) Methods: previous datasets are examined to test the conformity of LII vs. LI sites, to compare time-trend descriptors, and to estimate the critical number of sites and sampling units (SU). Field cross-surveys in next summer will compare different methods on selected sites. (iv) Considering LII sites (1999-2102), the reduction from annual to multiple-year surveys provides incomparable regression functions. The effect of reducing SUs numbers within LII sites is variable, due to different understory heterogeneity, and arousing misleading plant diversity description. LII hardly represents the spatial distribution achieved by LI reference (in 2007), due to the “preferential” selection used in the former network. A relevant reduction of LI sites can be achieved (almost 50%) maintaining the representativeness of plant species richness; relevant thresholds have been provided considering the stratification by Biogeographic Regions and the most relevant Forest types (Alpine conifers, Mountinous Beech, and Thermophilous deciduous forests). The experimental design of the comparative field test will be presented

Unimodal relationships of understory alpha and beta diversity along chronosequence in coppiced and unmanaged beech forests

Patterns of diversity across spatial scales in forest successions are being overlooked, despite their importance for developing sustainable management practices. Here, we tested the recently proposed U-shaped biodiversity model of forest succession. A chronosequence of 11 stands spanning from 5 to 400 years since the last disturbance was used. Understory species presence was recorded along 200 m long transects of 20 X 20 cm quadrates. Alpha diversity (species richness, Shannon and Simpson diversity indices) and three types of beta diversity indices were assessed at multiple scales. Beta diversity was expressed by a) spatial compositional variability (number and diversity of species combinations), b) pairwise spatial turnover (between plots Sorensen, Jaccard, and Bray-Curtis dissimilarity), and c) spatial variability coefficients (CV% of alpha diversity measures). Our results supported the U-shaped model for both alpha and beta diversity. The strongest differences appeared between active and abandoned coppices. The maximum beta diversity emerged at characteristic scales of 2 m in young coppices and 10 m in later successional stages. We conclude that traditional coppice management maintains high structural diversity and heterogeneity in the understory. The similarly high beta diversities in active coppices and old-growth forests suggest the presence of microhabitats for specialist species of high conservation value

The Italian endemic forest plants: an annotated inventory and synthesis of knowledge

Background and aims – Forests are among the most threatened ecosystems worldwide, and endemic plants are often a vulnerable component of the flora of a given territory. So far, however, understory forest endemics of southern Europe have received little attention and are poorly known for several aspects. Material and methods – We developed the first list of native vascular plants that are restricted to Italian forests. Available information on taxonomy, regional distribution, ecology, biology, functional traits, and conservation status was collected for each taxon, allowing to identify major knowledge gaps and calculate baseline statistics. Key results – The list includes 134 taxa, most of which are linked to closed-canopy forest habitats, while the others are also found in margins and gaps. The forest and non-forest Italian endemic flora differed in terms of taxonomic and life-form distribution. The rate and density of forest endemism increased with decreasing latitude and were highest in Sicily, Calabria, and Basilicata, where paleoendemic mono- or oligotypic genera also occur. Endemic phanerophytes were especially numerous on islands. Beech and deciduous oak forests were the most important habitats, but hygrophilous woodlands also host numerous endemics. Overall, the ecology, biology, and functional traits of the forest endemic taxa are still poorly known. The ratio diploids/polyploids was highest in the south and on the islands. Almost 24% of the taxa were assessed as “Critically Endangered”, “Endangered”, or “Vulnerable”, and 24% were categorized as “Data Deficient”, based on the IUCN system. Increasing frequency and intensity of fires was the most frequent threat. Conclusions – This work can contribute to implement the European forest plant species list and serve as a basis for further research on a unique biological heritage of the continent. However, more knowledge about these globally rare taxa is needed, to support their conservation in changing forest landscapes

Context-dependent plant traits drive fine-scale species persistence in old-growth forests

Questions: we studied old growth beech forest vegetation in Permanent Monitoring Plots (PMPs) located in Italy, with the following questions: is species turnover the main component of the observed changes or the present species assemblages is an impoverished sub-sets of the former ones?; 2) how compositional changes are reflected by specific plant functional traits? Location: we selected 4 PMPs (50 x 50 m) of the CONECOFOR network, placed along a latitudinal and climatic gradient in Italy, from south to north: CALABRIA03, CAMPANIA04, ABRUZZO01 and VENETO20. Methods: presence/absence of herb layer species were recorded in 100 permanent micro-plots of 50 x 50 cm over 12 years (1999-2011). For all sampled species we chose a set of 8 easy-to-measure functional traits. We compared the persistence, nestedness and turnover components of compositional changes. The role of plant traits explaining species persistence were analyzed by classification and regression tree. Results: Analysis in species diversity reveal antithetical ecological phenomena due to the diversity and complexity of the 4 different forest stands. ABRUZZO01 and CALABRIA03 show a clear nestedness trends over time with persistent species in ABR01 having higher seed mass and persistent species in CALABRIA03 having scleromorphic leaves and mesoporphic leaves, with large below-ground budbank. On the other hand, VENETO20 and CAMPANIA04 exibit a significant turnover trends over the 12 years characterized by persistent species in VENETO20 having helomorphic leaves, while in CAMPANIA04 large below-ground budbank and smaller SLA were the most important traits for species survival. Conclusion: Fine-scale approach highlight different mechanisms for the maintenance of species diversity in different complex forest systems driven significantly by specific traits, influenced by context-dependent factors

Exploring patterns of beta-diversity to test the consistency of biogeographical boundaries: A case study across forest plant communities of Italy

Aim: To date, despite their great potential biogeographical regionalization models have been mostly developed on descriptive and empirical bases. This paper aims at applying the beta-diversity framework on a statistically representative data set to analytically test the consistency of the biogeographical regionalization of Italian forests. Location: Italy. Taxon: Vascular plants. Methods: Forest plant communities were surveyed in 804 plots made in a statistically representative sample of forest communities made by 201 sites of Italian forests across the three biogeographical regions of the country: Alpine, Continental, and Mediterranean. We conducted an ordination analysis and an analysis of beta-diversity, decomposing it into its turnover and nestedness components. Results: Our results provide only partial support to the consistency of the biogeographical regionalization of Italy. While the differences in forest plant communities support the distinction between the Alpine and the other two regions, differences between Continental and Mediterranean regions had lower statistical support. Pairwise beta-diversity and its turnover component are higher between- than within-biogeographical regions. This suggests that different regional species pools contribute to assembly of local communities and that spatial distance between-regions has a stronger effect than that within-regions. Main conclusions: Our findings confirm a biogeographical structure of the species pools that is captured by the biogeographical regionalization. However, nonsignificant differences between the Mediterranean and Continental biogeographical regions suggest that this biogeographical regionalization is not consistent for forest plant communities. Our results demonstrate that an analytical evaluation of species composition differences among regions using beta-diversity analysis is a promising approach for testing the consistency of biogeographical regionalization models. This approach is recommended to provide support to the biogeographical regionalization used in some environmental conservation polices adopted by EU

Plant functional traits are correlated with species persistence in the herb layer of old-growth beech forests

This paper explores which traits are correlated with fine-scale (0.25 m2) species persistence patterns in the herb layer of old-growth forests. Four old-growth beech forests representing different climatic contexts (presence or absence of summer drought period) were selected along a north–south gradient in Italy. Eight surveys were conducted in each of the sites during the period spanning 1999–2011. We found that fine-scale species persistence was correlated with different sets of plant functional traits, depending on local ecological context. Seed mass was found to be as important for the fine-scale species persistence in the northern sites, while clonal and bud-bank traits were markedly correlated with the southern sites characterised by summer drought. Leaf traits appeared to correlate with species persistence in the drier and wetter sites. However, we found that different attributes, i.e. helomorphic vs scleromorphic leaves, were correlated to species persistence in the northernmost and southernmost sites, respectively. These differences appear to be dependent on local trait adaptation rather than plant phylogenetic history. Our findings suggest that the persistent species in the old-growth forests might adopt an acquisitive resource-use strategy (i.e. helomorphic leaves with high SLA) with higher seed mass in sites without summer drought, while under water-stressed conditions persistent species have a conservative resource-use strategy (i.e. scleromorphic leaves with low SLA) with an increased importance of clonal and resprouting ability

Plant functional traits are correlated with species persistence in the herb layer of old-growth beech forests

This paper explores which traits are correlated with fine-scale (0.25 m2) species persistence patterns in the herb layer of old-growth forests. Four old-growth beech forests representing different climatic contexts (presence or absence of summer drought period) were selected along a north–south gradient in Italy. Eight surveys were conducted in each of the sites during the period spanning 1999–2011. We found that fine-scale species persistence was correlated with different sets of plant functional traits, depending on local ecological context. Seed mass was found to be as important for the fine-scale species persistence in the northern sites, while clonal and bud-bank traits were markedly correlated with the southern sites characterised by summer drought. Leaf traits appeared to correlate with species persistence in the drier and wetter sites. However, we found that different attributes, i.e. helomorphic vs scleromorphic leaves, were correlated to species persistence in the northernmost and southernmost sites, respectively. These differences appear to be dependent on local trait adaptation rather than plant phylogenetic history. Our findings suggest that the persistent species in the old-growth forests might adopt an acquisitive resource-use strategy (i.e. helomorphic leaves with high SLA) with higher seed mass in sites without summer drought, while under water-stressed conditions persistent species have a conservative resource-use strategy (i.e. scleromorphic leaves with low SLA) with an increased importance of clonal and resprouting ability

Effects of climate, soil, structure and management on functional traits in forest understory

Many studies explored how the observed pattern of plant functional traits (PFTs) may be influenced by environmental variables. However, studies on forest ecosystems including also stand structure and management are lacking. A first attempt to test the relative effect of variables related to the latter groups, together with climate and soil gradients, on the community weighted mean (CWM) values of PFTs was performed on forest understory in Italy. The Level I biodiversity dataset (extensive CONECOFOR network) has been used, based on a probabilistic sampling design, by 201 sites on a representative 16 x 16 km systematic grid. Following a harmonized protocol (ICP Forests, BioSoil-Biodiversity project) 29 explanatory variables were recorded and four plots 10x10 m have been surveyed for vascular specific cover, on each site. Variance partitioning was used to identify the relative role of climatic, soil, structural and management variables on the CWM values of specific leaf area (SLA), plant height (H) and seed mass (SM). Redundancy analysis was used to assess the relation between traits and variables. The combination of the selected variables explained the variation of H (34.3%) better than SLA (14.9%) and SM (11.1%). Climate alone, and in combination with other variables, demonstrated to explain the largest proportion of the variation for H (29.5%) and SM (9.3%); however, also structure and soil showed a relevant role. Forest management (9.9%) and structure (5.4%) were the main drivers for SLA. Considering a gradient of increasing temperature, aridity and nutrient availability, we detected plant understory communities with higher mean values of H and SM. High-SLA communities appeared in forests characterized by a larger amount of deadwood.In forest understory vegetation, the PFTs pattern is linked to a complex combination of variables. Not only climate and soil, but also forest structure and management played a role, suggesting the importance of taking into account such parameters in future research, at larger spatial scale including different Country-level policies. The variation of SLA, H and SM is controlled by different variables, making no obvious any attempt to predict the effects of climate and land-use changes on understory functional signature

Can management intensity be more important than environmental factors? A case study along an extreme elevation gradient from central Italian cereal fields

This paper aims to assess the importance of environmental and management factors determining the weed species composition along a strong elevation gradient. A total of 76 cereal fields (39 low input and 37 intensively managed) were sampled along an elevation gradient in central Italy. Explanatory variables were recorded for each field to elucidate the role of large-scale spatial trends, of site-specific abiotic environmental conditions and of field management characters. Redundancy analysis was used to assess the relative importance of each environmental variable in explaining the variation in species composition. Our results indicate that variation in weed species composition is strongly determined by altitude, mean annual precipitation, mean annual temperature and also by soil characteristics. However, the level of intensification proved to be the most influential variable. There was a significant difference in species richness and composition between low-input and intensively managed fields. Intensification leads to considerable species loss at both lower and higher elevations. Low-input fields had 296 species in total, while intensively managed fields had only 196