Slamming the door on trade policy discretion? : the WTO Appellate Body’s ruling on market distortions and production costs in EU-Biodiesel (Argentina)

This paper presents a legal-economic analysis of the Appellate Body’s decision that the WTO’s Anti-Dumping Agreement (ADA) precludes countries from taking into account government-created price distortions of major inputs when calculating anti-dumping duties, made in EU-Biodiesel (Argentina). In this case, the EU made adjustments to the price of biodiesel’s principal input – soybeans – in determining the cost of production of biodiesel in Argentina. The adjustment was made based on the uncontested finding that the price of soybeans in Argentina was distorted by the existence of an export tax scheme that resulted in artificially low soybean prices. The Appellate Body found that the EU was not permitted to take tax policy-induced price distortions into account in calculating dumping margins. We analyze the economic rationale for Argentina’s export tax system, distortions in biodiesel markets in Argentina and the EU, and the remaining trade policy options for addressing distorted international prices. We also assess whether existing subsidies disciplines would be more effective in addressing this problem and conclude that they would not

Functional <i>IL6R</i> 358Ala Allele Impairs Classical IL-6 Receptor Signaling and Influences Risk of Diverse Inflammatory Diseases

<div><p>Inflammation, which is directly regulated by interleukin-6 (IL-6) signaling, is implicated in the etiology of several chronic diseases. Although a common, non-synonymous variant in the IL-6 receptor gene (<i>IL6R</i> Asp358Ala; rs2228145 A>C) is associated with the risk of several common diseases, with the 358Ala allele conferring protection from coronary heart disease (CHD), rheumatoid arthritis (RA), atrial fibrillation (AF), abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA), and increased susceptibility to asthma, the variant's effect on IL-6 signaling is not known. Here we provide evidence for the association of this non-synonymous variant with the risk of type 1 diabetes (T1D) in two independent populations and confirm that rs2228145 is the major determinant of the concentration of circulating soluble IL-6R (sIL-6R) levels (34.6% increase in sIL-6R per copy of the minor allele 358Ala; rs2228145 [C]). To further investigate the molecular mechanism of this variant, we analyzed expression of IL-6R in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) in 128 volunteers from the Cambridge BioResource. We demonstrate that, although 358Ala increases transcription of the soluble <i>IL6R</i> isoform (<i>P</i> = 8.3×10⁻²²) and not the membrane-bound isoform, 358Ala reduces surface expression of IL-6R on CD4+ T cells and monocytes (up to 28% reduction per allele; <i>P</i>≤5.6×10⁻²²). Importantly, reduced expression of membrane-bound IL-6R resulted in impaired IL-6 responsiveness, as measured by decreased phosphorylation of the transcription factors STAT3 and STAT1 following stimulation with IL-6 (<i>P</i>≤5.2×10⁻⁷). Our findings elucidate the regulation of IL-6 signaling by IL-6R, which is causally relevant to several complex diseases, identify mechanisms for new approaches to target the IL-6/IL-6R axis, and anticipate differences in treatment response to IL-6 therapies based on this common <i>IL6R</i> variant.</p> </div

The 358Ala allele is associated with decreased levels of membrane-bound IL-6R.

<p>Surface expression of IL-6R was quantified by flow cytometry in cryopreserved PBMCs from 128 volunteers from the Cambridge BioResource. Donors were sampled according to rs2228145 genotype. IL-6R surface expression was measured in four distinct immune cell subsets: CD4+ naïve and memory T cells, CD4+ regulatory T cells (Treg) and monocytes. Scatter plots depict the individual normalized IL-6R fluorescence intensity values measured as molecules of equivalent fluorochrome (MEF; see Methods for details). Error bars represent the standard error of the mean as shown by the middle horizontal line. The horizontal grey dotted reference line represents the average background fluorescence signal of the isotype control group. Differences in the mean expression levels, relative to the common homozygote group (Asp/Asp) are indicated above the horizontal black lines. <i>P</i>-values represent test for an association of rs2228145 with surface IL-6R levels, using an additive allelic effects model (see Methods for details).</p

The 358Ala allele is associated with reduced IL-6 signaling potential.

<p>(A) Frequency of pSTAT3 and (B) pSTAT1 positive cells following stimulation of PBMCs with 0, 0.1, 1 or 10 ng/ml of IL-6. Intracellular levels of pSTAT3 and pSTAT1 were measured by flow cytometry in three distinct immune cell subsets: CD4+ naïve T cells, CD4+ memory T cells and monocytes in 14 Asp/Asp and 14 Ala/Ala volunteers from the Cambridge BioResource. Median and interquartile range of the distribution of the frequency of pSTAT3 and pSTAT1 positive events in the two genotype groups for each dose of IL-6 stimulation are plotted. <i>P</i>-values represent tests for differences between rs2228145 genotype groups in pSTAT activation compared to control across doses. (see Methods and <a href="http://www.plosgenetics.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pgen.1003444#pgen.1003444.s006" target="_blank">Figure S6</a> for details).</p

Fetal lung gene array data for <i>AGER</i> expression across Pseudoglandular and Canalicular stages.

<p>Fetal lung gene array data for <i>AGER</i> expression across Pseudoglandular and Canalicular stages.</p

<i>AGER</i> isoform expression in three HBEC donors using RNA Seq.

<p>Structure and abundance of known <i>AGER</i> isoforms in three human bronchial epithelial cell donors illustrating heterogeneity in expression levels. Percentage abundances (% FPKM) were calculated for each donor. Transcripts for full length and soluble <i>AGER</i> were identified at similar low abundancies. FPKM; fragments per kilobase of transcript per million mapped reads.</p

Immunohistochemical analysis of RAGE expression in healthy and COPD lung.

<p>In healthy lung tissue, RAGE was found to be localised to the cytoplasm and membrane. RAGE expression was high in the pneumocytes of alveolar regions (a). The bronchial epithelium showed variable weak to moderate staining (e). In lung tissue of individuals with COPD, RAGE was very strongly immunopositive in the membrane and cytoplasm of the pneumocytes in the alveolar regions (b). The bronchial epithelium from individuals with COPD was weak or immunonegative for the RAGE protein (f). All isotype controls were negative (c, d, g and h). Representative images of one healthy and one COPD lung shown. x10 magnification.</p

<i>AGER</i> mRNA expression levels in total lung and airway cells.

<p>Q-PCR analysis identified <i>AGER</i> mRNA was highly expressed in total lung and at lower levels in human airway smooth muscle cells (HASM) cells, human bronchial epithelial cells (HBEC) and the BEAS-2BR1 bronchial epithelial cell line, (n = 3).</p

Gene expression array data of 38 fetal lungs for the <i>AGER</i> probes.

<p>Expression intensities for the <i>AGER</i> probes 210081_at and 217046_s_at were plotted against the gestational age of each fetal lung sample and showed an increase in expression with fetal lung age. RMA; Robust Multi-array Average. Affymetrix U133 Plus 2 expression array probe 210081_at probes for exon 8 of AGER mRNA whilst 217046_s_at probes AGER exons 7–11’.</p

Baseline characteristics of UK smoker population used for genetic association studies.

<p>Baseline characteristics of UK smoker population used for genetic association studies.</p