Oral Paper SP63. Learner Centred Communication Masterclasses

Background HYMS 3rd and 4th Year MB ChB students frequently encountered communication challenges on clinical placements, despite extensive communication skills teaching in the first two (university based) years of the course. PresentationCompulsory Communication Masterclasses were introduced for 3rd and 4th year students to provide an opportunity for them to address Communication and Professionalism challenges they have encountered on clinical placement. The student-centred Masterclasses are led by Primary /Secondary Care clinicians working with experienced Simulated Patients. They provide an opportunity for students to role play Communication/Professionalism challenges and receive feedback from their peers, Simulated Patient and tutor to help identify strategies for dealing with similar challenges in their future career. Evaluation Students are required to complete an online evaluation which includes descriptive and Likert scale feedback. Students give consistently positive feedback on these sessions, and highlight appreciating the opportunity to reflect and learn from clinician tutors about real-life communication/ professionalism challenges. This student evaluation informs Staff Development Masterclasses for tutors, tutored by faculty and run similarly to the Student Communication Masterclasses. These provide an opportunity to address challenges that tutors have encountered when tutoring Masterclasses and ensure that tutors deliver a consistently high quality student-learning experience

Roundtable RT06. Clinical Reasoning skills: Something that can be taught or just a matter of seeing lots of patients?

There is considerable literature regarding the complex nature of clinical reasoning for clinicians. Norman (2005) stated “there is no such thing as clinical reasoning - there is no best way through a problem. The more one studies the clinical expert, the more one marvels at the complex and multidimensional components of knowledge and skill that he brings to bear on the problem, and the amazing adaptability he must possess to achieve the goals of effective care”.For novices to become experts they need extensive deliberate practice to facilitate the availability of conceptual knowledge and add to their storehouse of already solved problems (Norman 2005).The authors are aware that previously students learnt how to reason clinically by clerking lots of patients and constructing lists of likely differential diagnoses. Students were repeatedly interrogated by doctors to justify their differential diagnoses. Changes in working time directives and increased shift working mean that students are less likely to have to justify their thinking on several occasions to the same doctor who then helps them develop their reasoning skills.Today’s students face further challenges, as modern medical curricula generally focus on delivering clinical experience in system-specific rotations leaving students unable to organise information effectively when patients present with complex, multisystem illnesses. A limitation of systems based curricula is that it does not encourage the development of clinical reasoning skills.There is now extensive literature regarding the need to explicitly teach clinical reasoning skills to students in addition to them having lots of practice in clerking patients and then constructing lists of the most likely differential diagnoses.Delegates at this round table discussion will be encouraged to debate whether they believe that students can be explicitly taught clinical reasoning skills or whether it is just a case of ‘seeing lots of patients’

Oral Paper S26 - What are students frightened of?

Background Despite extensive consistent integrated early clinical experience at HYMS, students have often been noted to struggle in making the transition from the largely University-based Phase I (2 years) to immersion in the clinically-based Phase II. Tutors report student difficulties in adopting an appropriate attitude to learning in this environment; some are noted to respond to this by minimising the time spent on the wards with obvious consequences for their experience and education. Presentation A new “Core Clinical Skills and Professional Expectations” course, lasting 2 weeks was introduced in August 2014 for students making this transition. This block aimed to address many areas which students have been noted to struggle with, including professionalism and development of clinical diagnostic reasoning and skills for independent learning. Evaluation Students were asked to identify their own fears and anxieties about moving into the clinical environment. All students completed a brief survey at both the beginning and the end of this two week period which included identification of their own sources of anxiety in approaching immersion in the clinical environment. Results of this survey are presented and discussed with implications for clinical teaching

Workshop 13. Clinical Diagnostic Reasoning: Equipping students with peer instruction skills to work together in developing their diagnostic reasoning

Workshop Format An introductory presentation covering best evidence in current medical education literature regarding development of diagnostic clinical reasoning skills for undergraduate students Small group work focusing on clinical tutor- identified real case scenarios to enable delegates to identify teaching and learning approaches to help undergraduate students to develop diagnostic reasoning skills. This will include consideration of facilitation of peer-peer approaches for development of clinical reasoning skills A closing plenary will include • DVD demonstrating the authors’ approach to facilitation of skills development in this area • Further discussion about the student-led approach • Reflection on incorporating novel approaches in delegates` own curriculum and teaching sessions • Presentation of the authors student “pocket guide” hand-out • Questions/Answers/Sharing best practice. Workshop Submissions Objectives To consider clinical tutor-identified, specific, student cognitive-processing difficulties in clinical diagnostic reasoning in contemporary systems based curricula. o consider specific challenges for students in developing their own clinical reasoning skills, following a transition from university to clinical teaching environments. To aid development of students` ability to consider their own clinical reasoning skills and facilitate development of these skills in their colleagues To share best practice with colleagues To discuss the authors` example of curricular innovation in this area Intended audience Tutors responsible for delivering clinical skills/ clinical reasoning teaching in undergraduate training

Fear, performance and power: a study of simulation learning in paramedic education.

Simulation or scenario learning is an integral part of student paramedic development and, despite the increasing amount of paramedic research, very little is known about how students and tutors experience it. Current literature regards simulation as invaluable without exploring why this may be the case and this study aims to address this. This is a compressed time mode ethnographic approach study that incorporates data from student paramedics during and immediately after simulation learning events and tutor views of facilitating the simulation experience. This, along with a comprehensive literature review, provides an overview of simulation in the student paramedic development pathway. This thesis exposes how student paramedics find the simulation process anxiety provoking and explores the many reasons for this. The performance aspect of scenarios is echoed in the dramaturgical language used when talking about simulation learning events and the similarities between simulation learning events and simulation assessment events merely adds to this stress. Using the lens of critical pedagogy, issues of power (control and hierarchy) within the educational and organisational structures are examined and offered as another possible explanation for the high levels of anxiety in simulation learning. The thesis ends with the question of whether simulation learning can be changed for the better and if so, how

Workshop 08. Professional Delivery of Clinical Reasoning in Medicine

Objectives To consider the specific challenges for students in developing clinical reasoning skills in contemporary systems-based curricula. To consider case vignettes portraying specific student cognitive-processing difficulties in diagnostic reasoning and design a teaching approach to address these difficulties. To share best practice with colleagues. To watch and discuss one example of teaching and learning practice demonstrated in the authors’ DVD recording of an innovative teaching session .Workshop Summary A brief presentation will explore recent evidence in current literature regarding clinical teaching in this area. The delegates will work in small groups on real case vignettes bringing these specific student cognitive difficulties to life. This will enable delegates, in collaboration, to generate suitable teaching and learning approaches for consideration by the whole group. Watching the authors’ own demonstration DVD depicting an innovative teaching approach will stimulate further discussion and reflection on incorporating novel approaches in delegates` own teaching. There will be time for Questions/Answers and sharing best practice with other delegates

P33. Optimising student experience: an innovative and integrated tutor support and development programme

Background The curriculum of the five year MBBS course at HYMS is integrated and student–centred with regular clinical skills sessions throughout the first two years. The clinical skills tutors are practising clinicians who deliver their teaching role alongside everyday clinical practice. The essential features of our successful support system have evolved during our first eight years, creating a vibrant integrated and innovative Community of Practice. Our support system includes:• Peer observation • Regular online student-tutor feedback • Regular tutor training sessions • Regular Action Learning Sets • New tutor mentoring • Annual Performance Review 65 • Tutor commitment to completing a Postgraduate Certificate in Medical Education • Core staff in key roles facilitating inclusion of tutors in all aspects of the medical school. • Involvement in student assessment.Our tutors benefit and learn from each other’s experiences whilst developing professionally as educators embedded within medical school life. The Community of Practice ensures that tutors deliver consistently high quality student learning experience. The evaluation includes:• Students complete online, anonymous evaluation of tutors • We performed an evaluation of one session by observing all tutors • Informal evaluation that problems are now frequently managed by the tutor group rather than by faculty

P06. Clinical Reasoning in Medicine: Developing Students' metacognitive skills

This poster outlines the introduction of formal Clinical Reasoning Skills sessions - initially a Student Selected Component (SSC) - as compulsory sessions in the core second year curriculum. Observations of 4th and 5th Year students’ performances in live examinations and student feedback indicated that, despite having excellent core communication skills, students struggled with the skills needed for effective analytical thinking when faced with complex diagnostic challenges.A three week SSC was designed around current research introducing students to the concepts underpinning the process of clinical reasoning. This SSC is founded on experiential practice where students analyse their thought processes and hypothetico-deductive reasoning governing the choices and conclusions reached whilst interviewing patients. All sessions are conducted in small interactive groups with experienced simulated patients and academic clinician tutors. Student feedback was extremely positive; all students felt these sessions must become part of the core undergraduate curriculum. The iterative processes required for developing higher order thinking skills in students are described

Theorising simulation in higher education: difficulty for learners as an emergent phenomenon

Despite the widespread interest in using and researching simulation in higher education, little discussion has yet to address a key pedagogical concern: difficulty. A ‘sociomaterial’ view of learning, explained in this paper, goes beyond cognitive considerations to highlight dimensions of material, situational, representational and relational difficulty confronted by students in experiential learning activities such as simulation. In this paper we explore these dimensions of difficulty through three contrasting scenarios of simulation education. The scenarios are drawn from studies conducted in three international contexts: Australia, Sweden and the UK, which illustrate diverse approaches to simulation and associated differences in the forms of difficulty being produced. For educators using simulation, the key implications are the importance of noting and understanding (1) the effects on students of interaction among multiple forms of difficulty; (2) the emergent and unpredictable nature of difficulty; and (3) the need to teach students strategies for managing emergent difficulty