SMART IMAGE-GUIDED NEEDLE INSERTION FOR TISSUE BIOPSY

M.S

Planning for steerable needles in neurosurgery

The increasing adoption of robotic-assisted surgery has opened up the possibility to control innovative dexterous tools to improve patient outcomes in a minimally invasive way. Steerable needles belong to this category, and their potential has been recognised in various surgical fields, including neurosurgery. However, planning for steerable catheters' insertions might appear counterintuitive even for expert clinicians. Strategies and tools to aid the surgeon in selecting a feasible trajectory to follow and methods to assist them intra-operatively during the insertion process are currently of great interest as they could accelerate steerable needles' translation from research to practical use. However, existing computer-assisted planning (CAP) algorithms are often limited in their ability to meet both operational and kinematic constraints in the context of precise neurosurgery, due to its demanding surgical conditions and highly complex environment. The research contributions in this thesis relate to understanding the existing gap in planning curved insertions for steerable needles and implementing intelligent CAP techniques to use in the context of neurosurgery. Among this thesis contributions showcase (i) the development of a pre-operative CAP for precise neurosurgery applications able to generate optimised paths at a safe distance from brain sensitive structures while meeting steerable needles kinematic constraints; (ii) the development of an intra-operative CAP able to adjust the current insertion path with high stability while compensating for online tissue deformation; (iii) the integration of both methods into a commercial user front-end interface (NeuroInspire, Renishaw plc.) tested during a series of user-controlled needle steering animal trials, demonstrating successful targeting performances. (iv) investigating the use of steerable needles in the context of laser interstitial thermal therapy (LiTT) for maesial temporal lobe epilepsy patients and proposing the first LiTT CAP for steerable needles within this context. The thesis concludes with a discussion of these contributions and suggestions for future work.Open Acces

Respiratory Compensated Robot for Liver Cancer Treatment: Design, Fabrication, and Benchtop Characterization

Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is one of the leading causes of cancer-related death in the world. Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) is an effective method for treating tumors less than 5 cm. However, manually placing the RFA needle at the site of the tumor is challenging due to the complicated respiratory induced motion of the liver. This paper presents the design, fabrication, and benchtop characterization of a patient mounted, respiratory compensated robotic needle insertion platform to perform percutaneous needle interventions. The robotic platform consists of a 4-DoF dual-stage cartesian platform used to control the pose of a 1-DoF needle insertion module. The active needle insertion module consists of a 3D printed flexible fluidic actuator capable of providing a step-like, grasp-insert-release actuation that mimics the manual insertion procedure. Force characterization of the needle insertion module indicates that the device is capable of producing 22.6 ± 0.40 N before the needle slips between the grippers. Static phantom targeting experiments indicate a positional error of 1.14 ± 0.30 mm and orientational error of 0.99° ± 0.36°. Static ex-vivo porcine liver targeting experiments indicate a positional error of 1.22 ± 0.31 mm and orientational error of 1.16° ± 0.44°. Dynamic targeting experiments with the proposed active motion compensation in dynamic phantom and ex-vivo porcine liver show 66.3% and 69.6% positional accuracy improvement, respectively. Future work will continue to develop this platform with the long-term goal of applying the system to RFA for HCC

DESIGN, DEVELOPMENT, AND EVALUATION OF A DISCRETELY ACTUATED STEERABLE CANNULA

Needle-based procedures require the guidance of the needle to a target region to deliver therapy or to remove tissue samples for diagnosis. During needle insertion, needle deflection occurs due to needle-tissue interaction which deviates the needle from its insertion direction. Manipulating the needle at the base provides limited control over the needle trajectory after the insertion. Furthermore, some sites are inaccessible using straight-line trajectories due to delicate structures that need to be avoided. The goal of this research is to develop a discretely actuated steerable cannula to enable active trajectory corrections and achieve accurate targeting in needle-based procedures. The cannula is composed of straight segments connected by shape memory alloy (SMA) actuators and has multiple degrees-of-freedom. To control the motion of the cannula two approaches have been explored. One approach is to measure the cannula configuration directly from the imaging modality and to use this information as a feedback to control the joint motion. The second approach is a model-based controller where the strain of the SMA actuator is controlled by controlling the temperature of the SMA actuator. The constitutive model relates the stress, strain and the temperature of the SMA actuator. The uniaxial constitutive model of the SMA that describes the tensile behavior was extended to one-dimensional pure- bending case to model the phase transformation of the arc-shaped SMA wire. An experimental characterization procedure was devised to obtain the parameters of the SMA that are used in the constitutive model. Experimental results demonstrate that temperature feedback can be effectively used to control the strain of the SMA actuator and image feedback can be reliably used to control the joint motion. Using tools from differential geometry and the configuration control approach, motion planning algorithms were developed to create pre-operative plans that steer the cannula to a desired surgical site (nodule or suspicious tissue). Ultrasound-based tracking algorithms were developed to automate the needle insertion procedure using 2D ultrasound guidance. The effectiveness of the proposed in-plane and out-of-plane tracking methods were demonstrated through experiments inside tissue phantom made of gelatin and ex-vivo experiments. An optical coherence tomography probe was integrated into the cannula and in-situ microscale imaging was performed. The results demonstrate the use of the cannula as a delivery mechanism for diagnostic applications. The tools that were developed in this dissertation form the foundations of developing a complete steerable-cannula system. It is anticipated that the cannula could be used as a delivery mechanism in image-guided needle-based interventions to introduce therapeutic and diagnostic tools to a target region

Sensorisation of a novel biologically inspired flexible needle

Percutaneous interventions are commonly performed during minimally invasive brain surgery, where a straight rigid instrument is inserted through a small incision to access a deep lesion in the brain. Puncturing a vessel during this procedure can be a life-threatening complication. Embedding a forward-looking sensor in a rigid needle has been proposed to tackle this problem; however, using a rigid needle, the procedure needs to be interrupted if a vessel is detected. Steerable needle technology could be used to avoid obstacles, such as blood vessels, due to its ability to follow curvilinear paths, but research to date was lacking in this respect. This thesis aims to investigate the deployment of forward-looking sensors for vessel detection in a steerable needle. The needle itself is based on a bioinspired programmable bevel-tip needle (PBN), a multi-segment design featuring four hollow working channels. In this thesis, laser Doppler flowmetry (LDF) is initially characterised to ensure that the sensor fulfils the minimum requirements for it to be used in conjunction with the needle. Subsequently, vessel reconstruction algorithms are proposed. To determine the axial and off-axis position of the vessel with respect to the probe, successive measurements of the LDF sensor are used. Ideally, full knowledge of the vessel orientation is required to execute an avoidance strategy. Using two LDF probes and a novel signal processing method described in this thesis, the predicted possible vessel orientations can be reduced to four, a setup which is explored here to demonstrate viable obstacle detection with only partial sensor information. Relative measurements from four LDF sensors are also explored to classify possible vessel orientations in full and without ambiguity, but under the assumption that the vessel is perpendicular to the needle insertion axis. Experimental results on a synthetic grey matter phantom are presented, which confirm these findings. To release the perpendicularity assumption, the thesis concludes with the description of a machine learning technique based on a Long Short-term memory network, which enables a vessel's spatial position, cross-sectional diameter and full pose to be predicted with sub-millimetre accuracy. Simulated and in-vitro examinations of vessel detection with this approach are used to demonstrate effective predictive ability. Collectively, these results demonstrate that the proposed steerable needle sensorisation is viable and could lead to improved safety during robotic assisted needle steering interventions.Open Acces

SHAPE MEMORY ALLOY ACTUATOR CONTROL FOR 3D STEERING OF ACTIVE SURGICAL NEEDLE IN MINIMAL INVASIVE SURGERIES

Ph.D

Cable-driven parallel robot for transoral laser phonosurgery

Transoral laser phonosurgery (TLP) is a common surgical procedure in otolaryngology. Currently, two techniques are commonly used: free beam and fibre delivery. For free beam delivery, in combination with laser scanning techniques, accurate laser pattern scanning can be achieved. However, a line-of-sight to the target is required. A suspension laryngoscope is adopted to create a straight working channel for the scanning laser beam, which could introduce lesions to the patient, and the manipulability and ergonomics are poor. For the fibre delivery approach, a flexible fibre is used to transmit the laser beam, and the distal tip of the laser fibre can be manipulated by a flexible robotic tool. The issues related to the limitation of the line-of-sight can be avoided. However, the laser scanning function is currently lost in this approach, and the performance is inferior to that of the laser scanning technique in the free beam approach. A novel cable-driven parallel robot (CDPR), LaryngoTORS, has been developed for TLP. By using a curved laryngeal blade, a straight suspension laryngoscope will not be necessary to use, which is expected to be less traumatic to the patient. Semi-autonomous free path scanning can be executed, and high precision and high repeatability of the free path can be achieved. The performance has been verified in various bench and ex vivo tests. The technical feasibility of the LaryngoTORS robot for TLP was considered and evaluated in this thesis. The LaryngoTORS robot has demonstrated the potential to offer an acceptable and feasible solution to be used in real-world clinical applications of TLP. Furthermore, the LaryngoTORS robot can combine with fibre-based optical biopsy techniques. Experiments of probe-based confocal laser endomicroscopy (pCLE) and hyperspectral fibre-optic sensing were performed. The LaryngoTORS robot demonstrates the potential to be utilised to apply the fibre-based optical biopsy of the larynx.Open Acces

Design, Modeling and Control of Micro-scale and Meso-scale Tendon-Driven Surgical Robots

Manual manipulation of passive surgical tools is time consuming with uncertain results in cases of navigating tortuous anatomy, avoiding critical anatomical landmarks, and reaching targets not located in the linear range of these tools. For example, in many cardiovascular procedures, manual navigation of a micro-scale passive guidewire results in increased procedure times and radiation exposure. This thesis introduces the design of two steerable guidewires: 1) A two degree-of-freedom (2-DoF) robotic guidewire with orthogonally oriented joints to access points in a three dimensional workspace, and 2) a micro-scale coaxially aligned steerable (COAST) guidewire robot that demonstrates variable and independently controlled bending length and curvature of the distal end. The 2-DoF guidewire features two micromachined joints from a tube of superelastic nitinol of outer diameter 0.78 mm. Each joint is actuated with two nitinol tendons. The joints that are used in this robot are called bidirectional asymmetric notch (BAN) joints, and the advantages of these joints are explored and analyzed. The design of the COAST robotic guidewire involves three coaxially aligned tubes with a single tendon running centrally through the length of the robot. The outer tubes are made from micromachined nitinol allowing for tendon-driven bending of the robot at variable bending curvatures, while an inner stainless steel tube controls the bending length of the robot. By varying the lengths of the tubes as well as the tendon, and by insertion and retraction of the entire assembly, various joint lengths and curvatures may be achieved. Kinematic and static models, a compact actuation system, and a controller for this robot are presented. The capability of the robot to accurately navigate through phantom anatomical bifurcations and tortuous angles is also demonstrated in three dimensional phantom vasculature. At the meso-scale, manual navigation of passive pediatric neuroendoscopes for endoscopic third ventriculostomy may not reach target locations in the patient's ventricle. This work introduces the design, analysis and control of a meso-scale two degree-of-freedom robotic bipolar electrocautery tool that increases the workspace of the neurosurgeon. A static model is proposed for the robot joints that avoids problems arising from pure kinematic control. Using this model, a control system is developed that comprises of a disturbance observer to provide precise force control and compensate for joint hysteresis. A handheld controller is developed and demonstrated in this thesis. To allow the clinician to estimate the shape of the steerable tools within the anatomy for both micro-scale and meso-scale tools, a miniature tendon force sensor and a high deflection shape sensor are proposed and demonstrated. The force sensor features a compact design consisting of a single LED, dual-phototransistor, and a dual-screen arrangement to increase the linear range of sensor output and compensate for external disturbances, thereby allowing force measurement of up to 21 N with 99.58 % accuracy. The shape sensor uses fiber Bragg grating based optical cable mounted on a micromachined tube and is capable of measuring curvatures as high as 145 /m. These sensors were incorporated and tested in the guidewire and the neuroendoscope tool robots and can provide robust feedback for closed-loop control of these devices in the future.Ph.D

Intracorporeal anchoring and guiding system with permanent magnet force modulation

Magnetic manipulation of objects within the body is a growing field of research since the second half of the last century. Therapeutic and diagnostic capabilities offered by such technology are extended with the clinical need to make procedures less invasive and traumatic for the patients. Ophthalmologists were among the first to explore magnetic manipulation for removing iron fragments from the interior of the eye. Subsequently, the intubation devices were developed for extracting foreign objects from the body. The first case of magnetic guidance is an intravascular catheter magnetically guided by large external magnets in the 1950s. Half a century later, magnetic actuation of medical devices has led to many developments growing in complexity, such as wireless endoscopic capsule for exploring the gastrointestinal tract; intraocular microrobots of sub-millimitric size per- forming delicate tasks; internal magnetic laparoscopic instruments magnetically coupled through the abdominal wall without the need of additional incisions; or enormous systems for remote magnetic steering of catheters in cardiovascular or neurological procedures. Technically, magnetic guidance requires variable, reshapable or steerable magnetic fields and therefore is generally associated with large magnetic arrangements of coils or perma- nent magnets surrounding the patient; while magnetic anchoring is achievable by external permanent magnets of adequate size placed or dragged manually on the surface of the body. In this thesis work, we propose a novel type of magnetic guidance. Instead of having the guiding part external to the body, we propose to perform the guidance locally, on- site, by having the guiding part within the body in close vicinity of the element to be guided. Although the separation distance between the guiding and guided member is decreased, the required magnetic field to be generated is still significant with regards to the size of the system. Moreover, the magnetic attractions force should be adjusted in order to provide a robust guidance over variable and dynamic anatomical conditions. Electromagnets are an ideal solution by their ability to control the strength, polarity and shape of the generated magnetic field. However, obtaining a substantial magnetic field strength becomes challenging in the millimetric scale. Rare-earth magnets produce strong magnetic fields and become interesting when size is limited. But, they produce a constant field and the resulting attractive forces are strongly depending on the distance, which can be a safety issue. To overcome these hurdles, we present a proof-of-concept of intracorporeal force mod- ulation with steerable permanent magnets. We demonstrate through several examples that the magnetic forces applied to the guided element can be modulated by combining permanent magnets together or with other ferromagnetic materials. A first prototype of force modulator is produced, characterized and tested in vitro. We analyze the behavior of this “magnetotractive” system of guidance through two operating modes, namely passive and active guidance modes. While the passive guidance mode uses static magnetic fields, the active guidance mode allows the variation of the magnetic field during the guidance. Operating at static magnetic field implies that the coupling force within the system depends on the tissue thickness and irregularities. As the coupling force decreases approximately as the square of the distance, levels of coupling force could rapidly change during the guidance. Therefore, having the capability of adjusting the coupling force provides flexibility of the method. We demonstrate that active control can be achieved by a combination of several movable permanent magnets. This provides smoother guidance and superior robustness in comparison with the passive mode. On the guided element, we empirically identify the parameters representing the most significant effect on friction during the guidance. These findings could be very helpful in the design of magnetic guidance systems. Finally, we show that magnetic attractive forces applied on the guided element could be adjusted with permanent magnet arrangements. This solution not only offers larger amplitude of force with regards to its size, but the range of modulation is significant in comparison with electromagnets. In addition, we demonstrate in vitro that intracorporeal magnetic guidance with steerable permanent magnets is feasible over variable and irregular tissue thickness. Therefore, this novel type of guidance has the potential to facilitate for example the treatment of cardiac arrhythmias

Image-guided robots for dot-matrix tumor ablation

Thesis (Ph. D.)--Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, 2010.Cataloged from PDF version of thesis.Includes bibliographical references (p. 203-208).Advances in medical imaging now provides detailed images of solid tumors inside the body and miniaturized energy delivery systems enable tumor destruction through local heating powered by a thin electrode. However, the use of thermal ablation as a first line of treatment is limited due to the difficulty in accurately matching a desired treatment and a limited region of active heating around an electrode. The purpose of this research is to identify and quantify the current limitations of image-guided interventional procedures and subsequently develop a procedure and devices to enable accurate and efficient execution of image-based interventional plans and thus ablation of a tumor of any shape with minimal damage to surrounding tissue. Current limitations of probe placement for ablation therapy were determined by a detailed retrospective study of 50 representative CT-guided procedures. On average, 21 CT scans were performed for a given procedure (range 11-38), with the majority devoted to needle orientation and insertion (mean number of scans was 54%) and trajectory planning (mean number of scans was 19%). A regression analysis yielded that smaller and deeper lesions were associated with a higher number of CT scans for needle orientation and insertion; highlighting the difficulty in targeting. Another challenge identified was repositioning the instrument distal tip within tissue. The first robot is a patient-mounted device that aligns an instrument along a desired trajectory via two motor-actuated concentric, crossed, and partially nested hoops. A carriage rides in the hoops and grips and inserts an instrument via a two degree-of-freedom friction drive. An imagebased point-and-click user interface relates appropriate clicks on the medical images to robot commands. Mounting directly on the patient provides a sufficiently stable and safe platform for actuation and eliminates the need to compensate for chest motion; thereby reducing the cost and complexity compared to other devices. Phantom experiments in a realistic clinical setting demonstrated a mean targeting accuracy of 3.5 mm with an average of five CT scans. The second robot is for repositioning the distal tip of a medical instrument to adjacent points within tissue. The steering mechanism is based on the concept of substantially straightening a pre-curved Nitinol stylet by retracting it into a concentric outer cannula, and re-deploying it at different axial and rotational cannula positions. The proximal end of the cannula is attached to the distal end of a screw-spline that enables it to be translated and rotated with respect to the casing. Translation of the stylet relative to the cannula is achieved with a second concentric, nested smaller diameter screw that is constrained to rotate with the cannula. The robot mechanism is compatible with the CT images, light enough to be supported on a patient's chest or attached to standard stereotactic frames. Targeting experiments in a gelatin phantom demonstrated a mean targeting error of 1.8 mm between the stylet tip and that predicted with a kinematic model. Ultimately, these types of systems are envisioned being used together as part of a highly dexterous patient-mounted positioning platform that can accurately perform ablation of large and irregularly shaped tumors inside medical imaging machines - offering the potential to replace expensive and traumatic surgeries with minimally invasive out-patient procedures.by Conor James Walsh.Ph.D