Incremental Timing-Driven Placement with Displacement Constraint

In the modern deep-submicron Very Large Integrated Circuit(VLSI) design flow intercon- nect delays are becoming major limiting factor for timing closure. Traditional placement algorithms such as routability-driven placement (improves routability) and wirelength- driven placement (reduces total wirelength) are no longer sufficient to close timing. To this end, timing-driven placement plays a crucial role in reducing the interconnect delay through timing critical paths (paths with timing violations/negative slacks) of the design and thereby achieving specific performance/clock frequency. In the placement flow, timing information about the design can be incorporated during global placement and/or incremental/detailed placement. Although, over the years, there has been significant advances in the quality of the global placement, there is a growing need for high performance incremental timing-driven placement due to the lack of accurate interconnect information during global placement. Moreover, incremental timing-driven placement is essential to recover timing while preserving the other optimization objectives such as total wirelength, routing congestion, and so forth which are optimized at the early stages of the design flow. This thesis proposes a simple, yet efficient, incremental timing-driven placement algo- rithm that seeks to find optimized locations for standard cells so that the total negative slack of the design can be maximized. Our algorithm consists two stages: (1) Global Move which positions standard cells inside a critical bounding box to eliminate timing violations on timing critical nets; and (2) Local Move which provides further timing improvement by finely adjusting the current locations of the standard cells within a local region. We evaluate our algorithm using ICCAD-2014 timing-driven placement contest bench- marks. The results show that, on average, our technique eliminates 94% and 30% of the late and early total negative slacks, respectively, and, 82% and 27% of the late and early worst negative slacks, respectively, under short and long displacement constraints. The 1st-place team of the contest improves late and early total negative slacks by 90% and 39%, respectively, and improves late and early worst negative slack by 76% and 32%, re- spectively. Taking into account both timing violation improvement and the placement quality (i.e., other objectives), on average, we outperform the 1st-place team by 3% in terms of the ICCAD-2014 contest quality score and our technique is 4.6× faster in terms of runtime

The False Dawn: Reevaluating Google's Reinforcement Learning for Chip Macro Placement

Reinforcement learning (RL) for physical design of silicon chips in a Google 2021 Nature paper stirred controversy due to poorly documented claims that raised eyebrows and attracted critical media coverage. The Nature paper withheld most inputs needed to produce reported results and some critical steps in the methodology. But two separate evaluations filled in the gaps and demonstrated that Google RL lags behind human designers, behind a well-known algorithm (Simulated Annealing), and also behind generally-available commercial software. Crosschecked data indicate that the integrity of the Nature paper is substantially undermined owing to errors in the conduct, analysis and reporting.Comment: 14 pages, 1 figure, 3 table

Timing optimization during the physical synthesis of cell-based VLSI circuits

Tese (doutorado) - Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Centro Tecnológico, Programa de Pós-Graduação em Engenharia de Automação e Sistemas, Florianópolis, 2016.Abstract : The evolution of CMOS technology made possible integrated circuits with billions of transistors assembled into a single silicon chip, giving rise to the jargon Very-Large-Scale Integration (VLSI). The required clock frequency affects the performance of a VLSI circuit and induces timing constraints that must be properly handled by synthesis tools. During the physical synthesis of VLSI circuits, several optimization techniques are used to iteratively reduce the number of timing violations until the target clock frequency is met. The dramatic increase of interconnect delay under technology scaling represents one of the major challenges for the timing closure of modern VLSI circuits. In this scenario, effective interconnect synthesis techniques play a major role. That is why this thesis targets two timing optimization problems for effective interconnect synthesis: Incremental Timing-Driven Placement (ITDP) and Incremental Timing-Driven Layer Assignment (ITLA). For solving the ITDP problem, this thesis proposes a new Lagrangian Relaxation formulation that minimizes timing violations for both setup and hold timing constraints. This work also proposes a netbased technique that uses Lagrange multipliers as net-weights, which are dynamically updated using an accurate timing analyzer. The netbased technique makes use of a novel discrete search to relocate cells by employing the Euclidean distance to define a proper neighborhood. For solving the ITLA problem, this thesis proposes a network flow approach that handles simultaneously critical and non-critical segments, and exploits a few flow conservation conditions to extract timing information for each net segment individually, thereby enabling the use of an external timing engine. The experimental validation using benchmark suites derived from industrial circuits demonstrates the effectiveness of the proposed techniques when compared with state-of-the-art works.A evolução da tecnologia CMOS viabilizou a fabricação de circuitos integrados contendo bilhões de transistores em uma única pastilha de silício, dando origem ao jargão Very-Large-Scale Integration (VLSI). A frequência-alvo de operação de um circuito VLSI afeta o seu desempenho e induz restrições de timing que devem ser manipuladas pelas ferramentas de síntese. Durante a síntese física de circuitos VLSI, diversas técnicas de otimização são usadas para iterativamente reduzir o número de violações de timing até que a frequência-alvo de operação seja atingida. O aumento dramático do atraso das interconexões devido à evolução tecnológica representa um dos maiores desafios para o fluxo de timing closure de circuitos VLSI contemporâneos. Nesse cenário, técnicas de síntese de interconexão eficientes têm um papel fundamental. Por este motivo, esta tese aborda dois problemas de otimização de timing para uma síntese eficiente das interconexões de um circuito VLSI: Incremental Timing-Driven Placement (ITDP) e Incremental Timing-Driven Layer Assignment (ITLA). Para resolver o problema de ITDP, esta tese propõe uma nova formulação utilizando Relaxação Lagrangeana que tem por objetivo a minimização simultânea das violações de timing para restrições do tipo setup e hold. Este trabalho também propõe uma técnica que utiliza multiplicadores de Lagrange como pesos para as interconexões, os quais são atualizados dinamicamente através dos resultados de uma ferramenta de análise de timing. Tal técnica realoca as células do circuito por meio de uma nova busca discreta que adota a distância Euclidiana como vizinhança.Para resolver o problema de ITLA, esta tese propõe uma abordagem em fluxo em redes que otimiza simultaneamente segmentos críticos e não-críticos, e explora algumas condições de fluxo para extrair as informações de timing para cada segmento individualmente, permitindo assim o uso de uma ferramenta de timing externa. A validação experimental, utilizando benchmarks derivados de circuitos industriais, demonstra a eficiência das técnicas propostas quando comparadas com trabalhos estado da arte

RTL-aware dataflow-driven macro placement

© 2019 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. Permission from IEEE must be obtained for all other uses, in any current or future media, including reprinting/republishing this material for advertising or promotional purposes,creating new collective works, for resale or redistribution to servers or lists, or reuse of any copyrighted component of this work in other works.When RTL designers define the hierarchy of a system, they exploit their knowledge about the conceptual abstractions devised during the design and the functional interactions between the logical components. This valuable information is often lost during physical synthesis. This paper proposes a novel multi-level approach for the macro placement problem of complex designs dominated by macro blocks, typically memories. By taking advantage of the hierarchy tree, the netlist is divided into blocks containing macros and standard cells, and their dataflow affinity is inferred considering the latency and flow width of their interaction. The layout is represented using slicing structures and generated with a top-down algorithm capable of handling blocks with both hard and soft components, aimed at wirelength minimization. These techniques have been applied to a set of large industrial circuits and compared against both a commercial floorplanner and handcrafted floorplans by expert back-end engineers. The proposed approach outperforms the commercial tool and produces solutions with similar quality to the best handcrafted floorplans. Therefore, the generated floorplans provide an excellent starting point for the physical design iterations and contribute to reduce turn-around time significantly.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft