Interactions between latent fingermarks, deposition surfaces and development agents

This thesis was submitted for the degree of Master of Philosophy and awarded by Brunel University.Fingerprints have provided a crucial source of forensic evidence for well over a century. Their power lies in an inherent ability for human identification and individualisation, which is based on two fundamental properties: uniqueness and lifelong permanence. Latent fingermarks represent by far the most evidentially common and challenging form of deposition, whereby an invisible copy of the unique friction ridge fingertip pattern is left as an amalgamated secretory residue on any surface that is touched. Dry powder dusting, the first and most iconic method for visualising or developing these deposits, was developed in the latter part of the 19th Century. In the period since, a great number of additional techniques, utilising physical, chemical and optical interactions in isolation or combined, have been devised for the same purpose. By selecting the correct technique in the correct order, it is now possible to extract significant print details from an unprecedented variety of surfaces. In the UK, such operational choices are recommended via Home Office issued protocol tables, which offer an optimum guide based on substrate type, substrate properties and fingermark conditions. Development technique specificity has improved in the last half-century alongside increased biochemical understanding of residue composition, however, the shear variety of potential deposition substrates that exist within a heavily industrialised world inevitably causes disparities in efficiency, even within single protocol classifications. These effects are compounded by the enormous potential for pre- and post-deposition residue composition variation, relating to donor factors (age, sex, diet, lifestyle, etc.) and time dependant changes (environmental, biological, etc.) respectively. As a result, routine technique application can cause sub-optimal development. This research utilises high resolution imaging and analysis techniques to demonstrate how subtle surface chemistry and topography features can selectively influence routine technique efficiency within a single protocol classification (smooth, nonporous plastics). Titanium dioxide, a widely used white pigment, has been shown as prevalent in a range of polymers following SEM and EDX analysis, either in a patchy or ubiquitous distribution. SEM analysis demonstrates a strong interaction between the pigment and carbon powder suspension, which causes detrimental overdevelopment effects in off-ridge areas. ToF-SIMS mapping of a Formica substrate places a significant amount of patchy distributed titanium dioxide in the top 30nm of the surface. Mapping also indicated the presence of an aluminosilicate pigment coating; however, it’s involvement in the possible surface potential or surface energy interaction mechanism is unknown The effects of linear surface features, which have previously been implicated in off-ridge cyanoacrylate overdevelopment on two operationally relevant polymers, were also analysed by creating a silicon wafer model for micro-FTIR analysis. Fingermark residues, including hydroxyl groups, have been shown to migrate significant distances along induced scratches in the model substrate over a 48hr period. It is likely that observed overdevelopment along large valley-like features (uPVC) and scratches (polyethylene) in the operationally relevant polymers is caused by a similar migration of residues.This work is funded by the UK Home Office project 7121939

A literature analysis examining the potential suitability of terahertz imaging to detect friction ridge detail preserved in the imprimatura layer of oil-based, painted artwork

This literature analysis examines terahertz (THz) imaging as a non-invasive tool for the imaging of friction ridge detail from the first painted layer (imprimatura) in multilayered painted works of art. The paintings of interest are those created utilizing techniques developed during the Renaissance and still in use today. The goal of analysis serves to answer two questions. First, can THz radiation penetrate paint layers covering the imprimatura to reveal friction ridge information? Secondly, can the this technology recover friction ridge detail such that the fine details are sufficiently resolved to provide images suitable for comparison and identification purposes. If a comparison standard exists, recovered friction ridge detail from this layer can be used to establish linkages to an artist or between works of art. Further, it can be added to other scientific methods currently employed to assist with the authentication efforts of unattributed paintings. Flanked by the microwave and far-infrared edges, THz straddles the electronic and optic perspectives of the electromagnetic spectrum. As a consequence, this range is imparted with unique and useful properties. Able to penetrate and image through many opaque materials, its non-ionizing radiation is an ideal non-destructive technique that provides visual information from a painting’s sub-strata. Imaging is possible where refractive index differences exist between different paint layers. Though it is impossible, at present, to determine when a fingerprint was deposited, one can infer approximately when a print was created if it is recovered from the imprimatura layer of a painting, and can be subsequently attributed to a known source. Fingerprints are unique, a person is only able to deposit prints while their physical body is intact and thus, in some cases, the multiple layer process some artists use in their work may be used to the examiner’s advantage. Impressions of friction ridge detail have been recorded on receiving surfaces from human hands throughout time (and have also been discovered in works of art). Yet, the potential to associate those recorded impressions to a specific individual was only realized just over one hundred years ago. Much like the use of friction ridge skin, the relatively recently discovered THz range is now better understood; its tremendous potential unlocked by growing research and technology designed to exploit its unique properties

Microscopy in forensic science

This chapter examines the use of electron microscopy, atomic force microscopy and other analytical techniques in forensic investigation and research. These tools can be used to enhance examination of human remains and trace evidence to improve understanding of cause of death, victim identification or post mortem interval.A police-designed scenario is used to highlight trace evidence such as glass, gun shot residue and paint. The validity of forensic techniques is discussed, with reference to international standards, repeatability, and false convictions. Ballistic evidence is used to highlight the complexities in evidence interpretation, including manufacturing variability, environmental effects and likelihood ratios.The use of scanning electron microscopy (SEM), atomic force microscopy (AFM) and other techniques in the development of forensic research is showcased, with particular examples from the field of fingerprints. Examples include improvements in the development of fingermarks from difficult surfaces, interaction of evidence types, and added intelligence from the crime scene, such as forensic timeline or gender of perpetrator

Accelerated Fingerprint Enhancement: A GPU-Optimized Mixed Architecture Approach

This document presents a preliminary approach to latent fingerprint enhancement, fundamentally designed around a mixed Unet architecture. It combines the capabilities of the Resnet-101 network and Unet encoder, aiming to form a potentially powerful composite. This combination, enhanced with attention mechanisms and forward skip connections, is intended to optimize the enhancement of ridge and minutiae features in fingerprints. One innovative element of this approach includes a novel Fingerprint Enhancement Gabor layer, specifically designed for GPU computations. This illustrates how modern computational resources might be harnessed to expedite enhancement. Given its potential functionality as either a CNN or Transformer layer, this Gabor layer could offer improved agility and processing speed to the system. However, it is important to note that this approach is still in the early stages of development and has not yet been fully validated through rigorous experiments. As such, it may require additional time and testing to establish its robustness and usability in the field of latent fingerprint enhancement. This includes improvements in processing speed, enhancement adaptability with distinct latent fingerprint types, and full validation in experimental approaches such as open-set (identification 1:N) and open-set validation, fingerprint quality evaluation, among others

A review of fingerprint recovery within an arson crime scene

Fingerprints have been used in criminal investigations in the United Kingdom since 1902. Many advances in research and technology have improved current opportunities for fingerprint recovery at crime scenes. Possibly due to the lack of training and research, the recoverability of fingerprints in a fire scene are undervalued and misunderstood. There is a widespread misconception that fire will destroy all fingerprint evidence. Evaluation of current literature available has shown that fingerprints can indeed be recovered with excellent results. Fire scenes, in particular deliberate or arson, can be examined with reference to the elevated temperature conditions at each stage and the understanding of the soot removal techniques is paramount to the investigation process. Further research is required to make advancement in fire scene fingerprint recovery

Virtual Frame Technique: Ultrafast Imaging with Any Camera

Many phenomena of interest in nature and industry occur rapidly and are difficult and cost-prohibitive to visualize properly without specialized cameras. Here we describe in detail the Virtual Frame Technique (VFT), a simple, useful, and accessible form of compressed sensing that increases the frame acquisition rate of any camera by several orders of magnitude by leveraging its dynamic range. VFT is a powerful tool for capturing rapid phenomenon where the dynamics facilitate a transition between two states, and are thus binary. The advantages of VFT are demonstrated by examining such dynamics in five physical processes at unprecedented rates and spatial resolution: fracture of an elastic solid, wetting of a solid surface, rapid fingerprint reading, peeling of adhesive tape, and impact of an elastic hemisphere on a hard surface. We show that the performance of the VFT exceeds that of any commercial high speed camera not only in rate of imaging but also in field of view, achieving a 65MHz frame rate at 4MPx resolution. Finally, we discuss the performance of the VFT with several commercially available conventional and high-speed cameras. In principle, modern cell phones can achieve imaging rates of over a million frames per second using the VFT.Comment: 7 Pages, 4 Figures, 1 Supplementary Vide

Interpol review of fingermarks and other body impressions 2016–2019

This review paper covers the forensic-relevant literature in fingerprint and bodily impression sciences from 2016 to 2019 as a part of the 19th Interpol International Forensic Science Managers Symposium. The review papers are also available at the Interpol website at: https://www.interpol.int/content/download/ 14458/file/Interpol%20 Review%20 Papers%202019. pdf

Polarization- and Specular-Reflection-Based, Non-contact Latent Fingerprint Imaging and Lifting

In forensic science the finger marks left unintentionally by people at a crime scene are referred to as latent fingerprints . Most existing techniques to detect and lift latent fingerprints require application of certain material directly onto the exhibit. The chemical and physical processing applied onto the fingerprint potentially degrades or prevents further forensic testing on the same evidence sample. Many existing methods also come with deleterious side effects. We introduce a method to detect and extract latent fingerprint images without applying any powder or chemicals on the object. Our method is based on the optical phenomena of polarization and specular reflection together with the physiology of fingerprint formation. The recovered image quality is comparable to existing methods. In some cases like the sticky side of a tape our method shows unique advantages