The Emptiness Problem for Tree Automata with at Least One Disequality Constraint is NP-hard

The model of tree automata with equality and disequality constraints was introduced in 2007 by Filiot, Talbot and Tison. In this paper we show that if there is at least one disequality constraint, the emptiness problem is NP-hard

Global Numerical Constraints on Trees

We introduce a logical foundation to reason on tree structures with constraints on the number of node occurrences. Related formalisms are limited to express occurrence constraints on particular tree regions, as for instance the children of a given node. By contrast, the logic introduced in the present work can concisely express numerical bounds on any region, descendants or ancestors for instance. We prove that the logic is decidable in single exponential time even if the numerical constraints are in binary form. We also illustrate the usage of the logic in the description of numerical constraints on multi-directional path queries on XML documents. Furthermore, numerical restrictions on regular languages (XML schemas) can also be concisely described by the logic. This implies a characterization of decidable counting extensions of XPath queries and XML schemas. Moreover, as the logic is closed under negation, it can thus be used as an optimal reasoning framework for testing emptiness, containment and equivalence

Decidable Classes of Tree Automata Mixing Local and Global Constraints Modulo Flat Theories

We define a class of ranked tree automata TABG generalizing both the tree automata with local tests between brothers of Bogaert and Tison (1992) and with global equality and disequality constraints (TAGED) of Filiot et al. (2007). TABG can test for equality and disequality modulo a given flat equational theory between brother subterms and between subterms whose positions are defined by the states reached during a computation. In particular, TABG can check that all the subterms reaching a given state are distinct. This constraint is related to monadic key constraints for XML documents, meaning that every two distinct positions of a given type have different values. We prove decidability of the emptiness problem for TABG. This solves, in particular, the open question of the decidability of emptiness for TAGED. We further extend our result by allowing global arithmetic constraints for counting the number of occurrences of some state or the number of different equivalence classes of subterms (modulo a given flat equational theory) reaching some state during a computation. We also adapt the model to unranked ordered terms. As a consequence of our results for TABG, we prove the decidability of a fragment of the monadic second order logic on trees extended with predicates for equality and disequality between subtrees, and cardinality.Comment: 39 pages, to appear in LMCS journa

Random Generation of Positive TAGEDs wrt. the Emptiness Problem

Tree automata are a widely used formalism in Computer Science. Since their creation in the fifties, numerous more expressive extensions have been proposed. Unfortunately, the decision problems associated with these extensions are quite often undecidable or in prohibitive classes of algorithmic complexity (NP-complete or worse), and little work has gone into finding efficient heuristics for them. Beyond the inherent difficulty of those problems, a common hitch in this line of research is the experimental evaluation of new algorithms. As those extensions of tree automata have remained in chiefly theoretical spheres, there are no established testbeds from the "real world" against which to quantify the efficiency (or lack thereof) of new algorithms. Failing that, there is a need to generate suitable testbeds at random. Regrettably, there is little material in the literature regarding random generation of tree automata, and none at all regarding extensions such as Tree Automata with Global Equality and Disequality Constraints (TAGEDs). It should also be noted that what little material there is does not concern itself with the interest of the generated automata wrt. specific decision problems. In this report we present a scheme for random generation of positive TAGEDs, with a focus on making them interesting wrt. the Emptiness problem

The emptiness problem for tree automata with global constraints

Abstract—We define tree automata with global constraints (TAGC), generalizing the class of tree automata with global equality and disequality constraints [1] (TAGED). TAGC can test for equality and disequality between subterms whose positions are defined by the states reached during a computation. In particular, TAGC can check that all the subterms reaching a given state are distinct. This constraint is related to monadic key constraints for XML documents, meaning that every two distinct positions of a given type have different values. We prove decidability of the emptiness problem for TAGC. This solves, in particular, the open question of decidability of emptiness for TAGED. We further extend our result by allowing global arithmetic constraints for counting the number of occurrences of some state or the number of different subterms reaching some state during a computation. We also allow local equality and disequality tests between sibling positions and the extension to unranked ordered trees. As a consequence of our results for TAGC, we prove the decidability of a fragment of the monadic second order logic on trees extended with predicates for equality and disequality between subtrees, and cardinality. I