Grid-Connected Energy Storage Systems: State-of-the-Art and Emerging Technologies

High penetration of renewable energy resources in the power system results in various new challenges for power system operators. One of the promising solutions to sustain the quality and reliability of the power system is the integration of energy storage systems (ESSs). This article investigates the current and emerging trends and technologies for grid-connected ESSs. Different technologies of ESSs categorized as mechanical, electrical, electrochemical, chemical, and thermal are briefly explained. Especially, a detailed review of battery ESSs (BESSs) is provided as they are attracting much attention owing, in part, to the ongoing electrification of transportation. Then, the services that grid-connected ESSs provide to the grid are discussed. Grid connection of the BESSs requires power electronic converters. Therefore, a survey of popular power converter topologies, including transformer-based, transformerless with distributed or common dc-link, and hybrid systems, along with some discussions for implementing advanced grid support functionalities in the BESS control, is presented. Furthermore, the requirements of new standards and grid codes for grid-connected BESSs are reviewed for several countries around the globe. Finally, emerging technologies, including flexible power control of photovoltaic systems, hydrogen, and second-life batteries from electric vehicles, are discussed in this article.This work was supported in part by the Office of Naval Research Global under Grant N62909-19-1-2081, in part by the National Research Foundation of Singapore Investigatorship under Award NRFI2017-08, and in part by the I2001E0069 Industrial Alignment Funding. (Corresponding author: Josep Pou.

Delta STATCOM with partially rated energy storage for intended provision of ancillary services

This thesis presents research on two distinct areas, where the work carried out in the first half highlights the challenges posed by the declining system inertia in the future power systems and the potential capability of the energy storage systems in bridging the gap, supporting a safe and reliable operation. A comparison of various energy storage technologies based on their specific energy, specific power, response time, life-cycle, efficiency, cost and further correlating these characteristics to the timescale requirements of frequency and RoCoF services showed that supercapacitors (SC) and Li-ion batteries present the most suitable candidates. Results of a network stability study showed that for a power system rated at 2940 MVA with a high RES contribution of 1688 MVA, equating to 57% of the energy mix, during a power imbalance of 200 MW, an ESS designed to provide emulated inertia response (EIR) in isolation required a power and energy rating of 39.54 MW and 0.0365 MWh respectively. Similarly, providing primary frequency response (PFR) on its own required a power and energy rating of 114.52 MW and 2.14 MWh respectively. ESS providing these services in isolation was not able to maintain all the frequency operating limits and similar results were also seen in the case of the recently introduced Dynamic Containment service. However, with the introduction of a combined response capability, a significantly improved performance, comparable to that of the synchronous generators was observed. In order to maintain the RoCoF and the statutory frequency limit of 0.5 Hz/s and ±0.5 Hz respectively, an ESS must be able to respond with a delay time of no more than 0.2 seconds and be able to ramp up to full response within 0.3 seconds (0.5 seconds from the start of contingency) for a frequency deviation of ±0.5 Hz. The second half of the thesis focused on investigating the current state-of-the-art power conversion system topologies, with the objective of identifying a suitable topology for interfacing ESSs to the grid at MV level. A delta-connected Modular Multilevel STATCOM with partially rated storage (PRS-STATCOM) is proposed, capable of providing both reactive and active power support. The purpose is to provide short-term energy storage enabled grid support services such as inertial and frequency response, either alongside or temporarily instead of standard STATCOM voltage support. The topology proposed here contains two types of sub-modules (SM) in each phase-leg: standard sub-modules (STD-SMs) and energy storage element sub-modules (ESE-SMs) with a DC-DC interface converter between the SM capacitor and the ESE. A control structure has been developed that allows energy transfer between the SM capacitor and the ESE, resulting in an active power exchange between the converter and the grid. A 3rd harmonic current injection into the converter waveforms was used to increase the amount of power that can be extracted from the ESE-SMs and so reduce the required ESE-SMs fraction in each phase-leg. Simulation results demonstrate that for three selected active power ratings, 1 pu, 2/3 pu, & 1/3 pu, the fraction of SMs that need to be converted to ESE-SMs are only 69%, 59% & 38%. Thus, the proposed topology is effective in adding real power capability to a STATCOM without a large increase in equipment cost. Furthermore, modifying the initially proposed topology with the use of Silicon Carbide (SiC) switching devices and interleaved DC-DC interface converter with inverse coupled inductors resulted in similar efficiencies when operated in STATCOM mode.Open Acces

STATCOM based on modular multilevel converter : dynamic performance and transient response during AC network disturbances

This paper presents detailed assessment of the behaviour of STATCOM based on modular multilevel converter during steady-state and transient operation. The steady-state performance of the presented STATCOM is examined when it provides autonomous voltage regulation across number of switch loads. Its transient response is examined by subjecting the test system where STATCOM is connected to symmetrical and asymmetrical ac network faults. In this work, STATCOM power circuit is modelled using detailed switch model of modular converter with 16 cells per arm, including capacitor voltage balancing strategy, and control systems are represented detail (dc and ac voltage regulars, and current controller). Simulations conducted in Matlab-Simulink enlivenment are used to assess the STATCOM performance

Grid-forming wind power plants

With growing concerns over climate change, the power system is witnessing an unprecedented growth in electricity generation from intermittent renewable energy sources (RES) such as wind and solar, which are commonly interfaced to the grid by power-electronic converters. However, increasing the penetration level of converter-interfaced generation units reduces the number of synchronous generators (SGs) in the grid that provide system services to support voltage and frequency, either inherently or through mandatory requirements and market products. This brings several challenges for the grid operators, which include increasing risk of harmonic interactions, decreasing system inertia and reduction in the short-circuit power of the grid, which all together might jeopardize the security and availability of the power systems. As a countermeasure, it is necessary that the power-electronic-based generation units not only provide grid support services that are originally provided by the SGs, but also operate in harmony with other generation units in all kinds of grid conditions. As a result, the concept of grid-forming (GFM) control, which mimics the beneficial properties of the SGs in converter systems, has emerged as a viable solution to allow effective and secured operation of power systems with increased penetration of converter-based resources.\ua0\ua0 This thesis investigates the application of GFM control strategies in wind power plants (WPPs). In particular, the focus of the work will be on developing an effective GFM control strategy for the energy storage systems (ESS) in WPPs that not only supports the operation of the WPP in various grid conditions, but also offers a certain degree of GFM properties to the overall WPP. To start with, the selection of the most suitable GFM control strategy for wind power applications is made by evaluating and comparing various control strategies available in the literature. The comparison is based on their influence on the frequency characteristics of the converter and robustness of the controller in varying grid strength. To address the transient stability problem of GFM converters during current limitation, a novel strategy based on the limitation of converter\u27s internal voltage vector is developed, which effectively limits the converter current to a desired value and retains the GFM properties of the converter at all times. An experimental setup is used to validate the effectiveness of the proposed limitation strategy in case of various grid disturbances. By implementing the proposed GFM control strategy for the ESS in a test WPP model, it is shown using detailed time-domain simulation results that the GFM behaviour can be offered to the overall WPP. The Network Frequency Perturbation (NFP) plots are used to verify the GFM behaviour of the considered WPP. Furthermore, an overview of various energy storage technologies (ESTs) suitable for providing ancillary services from WPPs is presented. With a focus on the two most suitable ESTs, i.e., batteries and supercapacitors, recommendations are given for design and sizing of the ESS for a given application. Finally, a coordinated control strategy between the WPP and SGs is developed, which facilitates the provision of frequency support from the WPP and at the same time reduces the energy storage requirements for the converter system

Providing Virtual Inertia Through Power Electronics

VSC-HVDC (voltage source converter based HVDC) system with its inherent merits for renewable energy integration has captured increasing research attentions. However, compared with AC systems dominated by synchronous generators (SGs), VSC-HVDC systems with general vector control cannot provide inertia for the grid due to lack of kinetic energy. This tends to degrade the safety and stability of the grid with the increasing penetration of renewable energy sources. To cope with this issue, virtual synchronous generator (VSG) has been proposed. In this thesis, firstly, a comprehensive introduction of various typologies of VSG schemes is made to illustrate their deficiencies and merits. The simulation results established in Simulink/Plecs show that VSG can not only participate into the regulation of frequency and voltage in case of power disturbances but guarantee the inertia provision for the grid. Although the integration of VSG control enhances the inertia and damping response of inverts, researches show that plenty of issues relative with VSG should be ameliorated. The fluctuation performances of SGs are introduced into the output active power and current of inverters when incorporates VSG control. This threatens the stability and safety of VSG operation, for power electronic based inverters are more vulnerable during the oscillations of current and frequency. Hence, to solve these issues, various enhanced VSG strategies have been constructed to improve its robustness and output performance. In this thesis, the structures and properties of enhanced VSG schemes are fully discussed. The results show that the dynamic properties of VSG during transient periods are enhanced in comparison of that of normal VSG. Modular multilevel converters (MMC) and alternate arm converters (AAC), as the representatives for enhanced topologies of VSC-HVDC system, have more complicated inner structures in comparison with 2/3 level converters. In this thesis, VSG control is applied into MMC/AAC models to strengthen their power and frequency regulation ability. In addition, a four-terminal multi terminal direct current (MTDC) system is incorporated with VSG control to provide primary frequency and voltage response for the grid. The results show that the integration of VSG improves the stability operation and inertia response of MMC/AAC/MTDC systems

Control and Protection of MMC-Based HVDC Systems: A Review

The voltage source converter (VSC) based HVDC (high voltage direct current system) offers the possibility to integrate other renewable energy sources (RES) into the electrical grid, and allows power flow reversal capability. These appealing features of VSC technology led to the further development of multi-terminal direct current (MTDC) systems. MTDC grids provide the possibility of interconnection between conventional power systems and other large-scale offshore sources like wind and solar systems. The modular multilevel converter (MMC) has become a popular technology in the development of the VSC-MTDC system due to its salient features such as modularity and scalability. Although, the employment of MMC converter in the MTDC system improves the overall system performance. However, there are some technical challenges related to its operation, control, modeling and protection that need to be addressed. This paper mainly provides a comprehensive review and investigation of the control and protection of the MMC-based MTDC system. In addition, the issues and challenges associated with the development of the MMC-MTDC system have been discussed in this paper. It majorly covers the control schemes that provide the AC system support and state-of-the-art relaying algorithm/ dc fault detection and location algorithms. Different types of dc fault detection and location algorithms presented in the literature have been reviewed, such as local measurement-based, communication-based, traveling wave-based and artificial intelligence-based. Characteristics of the protection techniques are compared and analyzed in terms of various scenarios such as implementation in CBs, system configuration, selectivity, and robustness. Finally, future challenges and issues regarding the development of the MTDC system have been discussed in detail

External inertia emulation controller for grid-following power converter

The advent of renewable energy has posed difficulties in the operation of power systems whose net inertia is becoming critically low. To face such challenges, grid-forming power has been one of the potential solutions pursued by the industry and research community. Although promising, grid-forming power converters are still immature for mass deployment in power systems. In the meanwhile, an enormous amount of grid-following power converters has been underexploited when it comes to grid-supporting functionalities. Therefore, this article proposes an external inertia emulation controller (eIEC) for grid-following power converter to provide frequency support to the grid. For the purpose of minimizing installation efforts and resources, the controller is designed in such a way that it can be implemented in an external controller communicating with the grid-following power converter via an industrial communication link. This article also investigates the effect of communication delay on the stability performance of the proposed controller. In addition to the detailed analysis, hardware-in-the-loop experiments are also carried out to validate the proposed eIEC.This work was supported by the European Commission under Project FLEXITRANSTORE-H2020-LCE-2016-2017-SGS-774407Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft