Android source code vulnerability detection: a systematic literature review

The use of mobile devices is rising daily in this technological era. A continuous and increasing number of mobile applications are constantly offered on mobile marketplaces to fulfil the needs of smartphone users. Many Android applications do not address the security aspects appropriately. This is often due to a lack of automated mechanisms to identify, test, and fix source code vulnerabilities at the early stages of design and development. Therefore, the need to fix such issues at the initial stages rather than providing updates and patches to the published applications is widely recognized. Researchers have proposed several methods to improve the security of applications by detecting source code vulnerabilities and malicious codes. This Systematic Literature Review (SLR) focuses on Android application analysis and source code vulnerability detection methods and tools by critically evaluating 118 carefully selected technical studies published between 2016 and 2022. It highlights the advantages, disadvantages, applicability of the proposed techniques and potential improvements of those studies. Both Machine Learning (ML) based methods and conventional methods related to vulnerability detection are discussed while focusing more on ML-based methods since many recent studies conducted experiments with ML. Therefore, this paper aims to enable researchers to acquire in-depth knowledge in secure mobile application development while minimizing the vulnerabilities by applying ML methods. Furthermore, researchers can use the discussions and findings of this SLR to identify potential future research and development directions

Malware detection techniques for mobile devices

Mobile devices have become very popular nowadays, due to its portability and high performance, a mobile device became a must device for persons using information and communication technologies. In addition to hardware rapid evolution, mobile applications are also increasing in their complexity and performance to cover most needs of their users. Both software and hardware design focused on increasing performance and the working hours of a mobile device. Different mobile operating systems are being used today with different platforms and different market shares. Like all information systems, mobile systems are prone to malware attacks. Due to the personality feature of mobile devices, malware detection is very important and is a must tool in each device to protect private data and mitigate attacks. In this paper, analysis of different malware detection techniques used for mobile operating systems is provides. The focus of the analysis will be on the to two competing mobile operating systems - Android and iOS. Finally, an assessment of each technique and a summary of its advantages and disadvantages is provided. The aim of the work is to establish a basis for developing a mobile malware detection tool based on user profiling.Comment: 11 pages, 6 figure

pDroid

When an end user attempts to download an app on the Google Play Store they receive two related items that can be used to assess the potential threats of an application, the list of permissions used by the application and the textual description of the application. However, this raises several concerns. First, applications tend to use more permissions than they need and end users are not tech-savvy enough to fully understand the security risks. Therefore, it is challenging to assess the threats of an application fully by only seeing the permissions. On the other hand, most textual descriptions do not clearly define why they need a particular permission. These two issues conjoined make it difficult for end users to accurately assess the security threats of an application. This has lead to a demand for a framework that can accurately determine if a textual description adequately describes the actual behavior of an application. In this Master Thesis, we present pDroid (short for privateDroid), a market-independent framework that can compare an Android application’s textual description to its internal behavior. We evaluated pDroid using 1562 benign apps and 243 malware samples, and pDroid correctly classified 91.4% of malware with a false positive rate of 4.9%

Techniques for advanced android malware triage

Mención Internacional en el título de doctorAndroid is the leading operating system in smartphones with a big difference. Statistics show that 88% of all smartphones sold to end users in the second quarter of 2018 were phones with the Android OS. Regardless of the operating systems which are running on smartphones, most of the functionalities of these devices are offered through applications. There are currently over 2 million apps only on the official Google store, known as Google Play. This huge market with billions of users is tempting for attackers to develop and distribute their malicious apps (or malware). Mobile malware has raised explosively since 2009. Symantec reported an increase of 54% in the new mobile malware variants in 2017 as compared to the previous year. Additionally, more incentive has been provided for profit-driven malware by the growth of black markets. This rise has happened for Android malware as well since only 20% of devices are running the newest major version of Android OS based on Symantec report in 2018. Android continued to be the most targeted platform with the biggest number of attacks in 2015. After that year, attacks against the Android platform slowed for the first time as attackers were faced with improved security architectures though Android is still the main appealing target OS for attackers. Moreover, advanced types of Android malware are found which make use of extensive anit-analysis techniques to evade static or dynamic analysis. To address the security and privacy concerns of complex Android malware, this dissertation focuses on three main objectives. First of all, we propose a light-weight yet efficient method to identify risky Android applications. Next, we present a precise approach to characterize Android malware based on their malicious behavior. Finally, we propose an adaptive learning system to address the security concerns of obfuscation in Android malware. Identifying potentially dangerous and risky applications is an important step in Android malware analysis. To this end, we develop a triage system to rank applications based on their potential risk. Our approach, called TriFlow, relies on static features which are quick to obtain. TriFlow combines a probabilistic model to predict the existence of information flows with a metric of how significant a flow is in benign and malicious apps. Based on this, TriFlow provides a score for each application that can be used to prioritize analysis. It also provides the analysts with an explanatory report of the associated risk. Our tool can also be used as a complement with computationally expensive static and dynamic analysis tools. Another important step towards Android malware analysis lies in their accurate characterization. Labeling Android malware is challenging yet crucially important, as it helps to identify upcoming malware samples and threats. A key challenge is that different researchers and anti-virus vendors assign labels using their own criteria, and it is not known to what extent these labels are aligned with the apps’ real behavior. Based on this, we propose a new behavioral characterization method for Android apps based on their extracted information flows. As information flows can be used to track why and how apps use specific pieces of information, a flowbased characterization provides a relatively easy-to-interpret summary of the malware sample’s behavior. Not all Android malware are easy to analyze due to advanced and easyto-apply anti-analysis techniques that are available nowadays. Obfuscation is the most common anti-analysis technique that Android malware use to evade detection. Obfuscation techniques modify an app’s source (or machine) code in order to make it more difficult to analyze. This is typically applied to protect intellectual property in benign apps, or to hinder the process of extracting actionable information in the case of malware. Since malware analysis often requires considerable resource investment, detecting the particular obfuscation technique used may contribute to apply the right analysis tools, thus leading to some savings. Therefore, we propose AndrODet, a mechanism to detect three popular types of obfuscation in Android applications, namely identifier renaming, string encryption, and control flow obfuscation. AndrODet leverages online learning techniques, thus being suitable for resource-limited environments that need to operate in a continuous manner. We compare our results with a batch learning algorithm using a dataset of 34,962 apps from both malware and benign apps. Experimental results show that online learning approaches are not only able to compete with batch learning methods in terms of accuracy, but they also save significant amount of time and computational resources. Finally, we present a number of open research directions based on the outcome of this thesis.Android es el sistema operativo líder en teléfonos inteligentes (también denominados con la palabra inglesa smartphones), con una gran diferencia con respecto al resto de competidores. Las estadísticas muestran que el 88% de todos los smartphones vendidos a usuarios finales en el segundo trimestre de 2018 fueron teléfonos con sistema operativo Android. Independientemente de su sistema operativo, la mayoría de las funcionalidades de estos dispositivos se ofrecen a través de aplicaciones. Actualmente hay más de 2 millones de aplicaciones solo en la tienda oficial de Google, conocida como Google Play. Este enorme mercado con miles de millones de usuarios es tentador para los atacantes, que buscan distribuir sus aplicaciones malintencionadas (o malware). El malware para dispositivos móviles ha aumentado de forma exponencial desde 2009. Symantec ha detectado un aumento del 54% en las nuevas variantes de malware para dispositivos móviles en 2017 en comparación con el año anterior. Además, el crecimiento del mercado negro (es decir, plataformas no oficiales de descargas de aplicaciones) supone un incentivo para los programas maliciosos con fines lucrativos. Este aumento también ha ocurrido en el malware de Android, aprovechando la circunstancia de que solo el 20% de los dispositivos ejecutan la versión mas reciente del sistema operativo Android, de acuerdo con el informe de Symantec en 2018. De hecho, Android ha sido la plataforma que ha centrado los esfuerzos de los atacantes desde 2015, aunque los ataques decayeron ligeramente tras ese año debido a las mejoras de seguridad incorporadas en el sistema operativo. En todo caso, existen formas avanzadas de malware para Android que hacen uso de técnicas sofisticadas para evadir el análisis estático o dinámico. Para abordar los problemas de seguridad y privacidad que causa el malware en Android, esta Tesis se centra en tres objetivos principales. En primer lugar, se propone un método ligero y eficiente para identificar aplicaciones de Android que pueden suponer un riesgo. Por otra parte, se presenta un mecanismo para la caracterización del malware atendiendo a su comportamiento. Finalmente, se propone un mecanismo basado en aprendizaje adaptativo para la detección de algunos tipos de ofuscación que son empleados habitualmente en las aplicaciones maliciosas. Identificar aplicaciones potencialmente peligrosas y riesgosas es un paso importante en el análisis de malware de Android. Con este fin, en esta Tesis se desarrolla un mecanismo de clasificación (llamado TriFlow) que ordena las aplicaciones según su riesgo potencial. La aproximación se basa en características estáticas que se obtienen rápidamente, siendo de especial interés los flujos de información. Un flujo de información existe cuando un cierto dato es recibido o producido mediante una cierta función o llamada al sistema, y atraviesa la lógica de la aplicación hasta que llega a otra función. Así, TriFlow combina un modelo probabilístico para predecir la existencia de un flujo con una métrica de lo habitual que es encontrarlo en aplicaciones benignas y maliciosas. Con ello, TriFlow proporciona una puntuación para cada aplicación que puede utilizarse para priorizar su análisis. Al mismo tiempo, proporciona a los analistas un informe explicativo de las causas que motivan dicha valoración. Así, esta herramienta se puede utilizar como complemento a otras técnicas de análisis estático y dinámico que son mucho más costosas desde el punto de vista computacional. Otro paso importante hacia el análisis de malware de Android radica en caracterizar su comportamiento. Etiquetar el malware de Android es un desafío de crucial importancia, ya que ayuda a identificar las próximas muestras y amenazas de malware. Una cuestión relevante es que los diferentes investigadores y proveedores de antivirus asignan etiquetas utilizando sus propios criterios, de modo no se sabe en qué medida estas etiquetas están en línea con el comportamiento real de las aplicaciones. Sobre esta base, en esta Tesis se propone un nuevo método de caracterización de comportamiento para las aplicaciones de Android en función de sus flujos de información. Como dichos flujos se pueden usar para estudiar el uso de cada dato por parte de una aplicación, permiten proporcionar un resumen relativamente sencillo del comportamiento de una determinada muestra de malware. A pesar de la utilidad de las técnicas de análisis descritas, no todos los programas maliciosos de Android son fáciles de analizar debido al uso de técnicas anti-análisis que están disponibles en la actualidad. Entre ellas, la ofuscación es la técnica más común que se utiliza en el malware de Android para evadir la detección. Dicha técnica modifica el código de una aplicación para que sea más difícil de entender y analizar. Esto se suele aplicar para proteger la propiedad intelectual en aplicaciones benignas o para dificultar la obtención de pistas sobre su funcionamiento en el caso del malware. Dado que el análisis de malware a menudo requiere una inversión considerable de recursos, detectar la técnica de ofuscación que se ha utilizado en un caso particular puede contribuir a utilizar herramientas de análisis adecuadas, contribuyendo así a un cierto ahorro de recursos. Así, en esta Tesis se propone AndrODet, un mecanismo para detectar tres tipos populares de ofuscación, a saber, el renombrado de identificadores, cifrado de cadenas de texto y la modificación del flujo de control de la aplicación. AndrODet se basa en técnicas de aprendizaje automático en línea (online machine learning), por lo que es adecuado para entornos con recursos limitados que necesitan operar de forma continua, sin interrupción. Para medir su eficacia respecto de las técnicas de aprendizaje automático tradicionales, se comparan los resultados con un algoritmo de aprendizaje por lotes (batch learning) utilizando un dataset de 34.962 aplicaciones de malware y benignas. Los resultados experimentales muestran que el enfoque de aprendizaje en línea no solo es capaz de competir con el basado en lotes en términos de precisión, sino que también ahorra una gran cantidad de tiempo y recursos computacionales. Tras la exposición de las contribuciones anteriormente mencionadas, esta Tesis concluye con la identificación de una serie de líneas abiertas de investigación con el fin de alentar el desarrollo de trabajos futuros en esta dirección.Omid Mirzaei is a Ph.D. candidate in the Computer Security Lab (COSEC) at the Department of Computer Science and Engineering of Universidad Carlos III de Madrid (UC3M). His Ph.D. is funded by the Community of Madrid and the European Union through the research project CIBERDINE (Ref. S2013/ICE-3095).Programa Oficial de Doctorado en Ciencia y Tecnología InformáticaPresidente: Gregorio Martínez Pérez.- Secretario: Pedro Peris López.- Vocal: Pablo Picazo Sánche

Demystifying security and compatibility issues in Android Apps

Never before has any OS been so popular as Android. Existing mobile phones are not simply devices for making phone calls and receiving SMS messages, but powerful communication and entertainment platforms for web surfing, social networking, etc. Even though the Android OS offers powerful communication and application execution capabilities, it is riddled with defects (e.g., security risks, and compatibility issues), new vulnerabilities come to light daily, and bugs cost the economy tens of billions of dollars annually. For example, malicious apps (e.g., back-doors, fraud apps, ransomware, spyware, etc.) are reported [Google, 2022] to exhibit malicious behaviours, including privacy stealing, unwanted programs installed, etc. To counteract these threats, many works have been proposed that rely on static analysis techniques to detect such issues. However, static techniques are not sufficient on their own to detect such defects precisely. This will likely yield false positive results as static analysis has to make some trade-offs when handling complicated cases (e.g., object-sensitive vs. object-insensitive). In addition, static analysis techniques will also likely suffer from soundness issues because some complicated features (e.g., reflection, obfuscation, and hardening) are difficult to be handled [Sun et al., 2021b, Samhi et al., 2022].Comment: Thesi

Eight years of rider measurement in the Android malware ecosystem: evolution and lessons learned

Despite the growing threat posed by Android malware, the research community is still lacking a comprehensive view of common behaviors and trends exposed by malware families active on the platform. Without such view, the researchers incur the risk of developing systems that only detect outdated threats, missing the most recent ones. In this paper, we conduct the largest measurement of Android malware behavior to date, analyzing over 1.2 million malware samples that belong to 1.2K families over a period of eight years (from 2010 to 2017). We aim at understanding how the behavior of Android malware has evolved over time, focusing on repackaging malware. In this type of threats different innocuous apps are piggybacked with a malicious payload (rider), allowing inexpensive malware manufacturing. One of the main challenges posed when studying repackaged malware is slicing the app to split benign components apart from the malicious ones. To address this problem, we use differential analysis to isolate software components that are irrelevant to the campaign and study the behavior of malicious riders alone. Our analysis framework relies on collective repositories and recent advances on the systematization of intelligence extracted from multiple anti-virus vendors. We find that since its infancy in 2010, the Android malware ecosystem has changed significantly, both in the type of malicious activity performed by the malicious samples and in the level of obfuscation used by malware to avoid detection. We then show that our framework can aid analysts who attempt to study unknown malware families. Finally, we discuss what our findings mean for Android malware detection research, highlighting areas that need further attention by the research community.Accepted manuscrip