LiSA: A Lightweight and Secure Authentication Mechanism for Smart Metering Infrastructure

Smart metering infrastructure (SMI) is the core component of the smart grid (SG) which enables two-way communication between consumers and utility companies to control, monitor, and manage the energy consumption data. Despite their salient features, SMIs equipped with information and communication technology are associated with new threats due to their dependency on public communication networks. Therefore, the security of SMI communications raises the need for robust authentication and key agreement primitives that can satisfy the security requirements of the SG. Thus, in order to realize the aforementioned issues, this paper introduces a lightweight and secure authentication protocol, "LiSA", primarily to secure SMIs in SG setups. The protocol employs Elliptic Curve Cryptography at its core to provide various security features such as mutual authentication, anonymity, replay protection, session key security, and resistance against various attacks. Precisely, LiSA exploits the hardness of the Elliptic Curve Qu Vanstone (EVQV) certificate mechanism along with Elliptic Curve Diffie Hellman Problem (ECDHP) and Elliptic Curve Discrete Logarithm Problem (ECDLP). Additionally, LiSA is designed to provide the highest level of security relative to the existing schemes with least computational and communicational overheads. For instance, LiSA incurred barely 11.826 ms and 0.992 ms for executing different passes across the smart meter and the service providers. Further, it required a total of 544 bits for message transmission during each session.Comment: To appear in IEEE Globecom 201

Salsa20 based lightweight security scheme for smart meter communication in smart grid

The traditional power gird is altering dramatically to a smart power grid with the escalating development of information and communication technology (ICT). Among thousands of electronic devices connected to the grid through communication network, smart meter (SM) is the core networking device. The consolidation of ICT to the electronic devices centered on SM open loophole for the adversaries to launch cyber-attack. Therefore, for protecting the network from the adversaries it is required to design lightweight security mechanism for SM, as conventional cryptography schemes poses extensive computational cost, processing delay and overhead which is not suitable to be used in SM. In this paper, we have proposed a security mechanism consolidating elliptic curve cryptography (ECC) and Salsa20 stream cipher algorithm to ensure security of the network as well as addressing the problem of energy efficiency and lightweight security solution. We have numerically analyzed the performance of our proposed scheme in case of energy efficiency and processing time which reveals that the suggested mechanism is suitable to be used in SM as it consumes less power and requires less processing time to encrypt or decrypt

Security Challenges in Smart-Grid Metering and Control Systems

The smart grid is a next-generation power system that is increasingly attracting the attention of government, industry, and academia. It is an upgraded electricity network that depends on two-way digital communications between supplier and consumer that in turn give support to intelligent metering and monitoring systems. Considering that energy utilities play an increasingly important role in our daily life, smart-grid technology introduces new security challenges that must be addressed. Deploying a smart grid without adequate security might result in serious consequences such as grid instability, utility fraud, and loss of user information and energy-consumption data. Due to the heterogeneous communication architecture of smart grids, it is quite a challenge to design sophisticated and robust security mechanisms that can be easily deployed to protect communications among different layers of the smart grid-infrastructure. In this article, we focus on the communication-security aspect of a smart-grid metering and control system from the perspective of cryptographic techniques, and we discuss different mechanisms to enhance cybersecurity of the emerging smart grid. We aim to provide a comprehensive vulnerability analysis as well as novel insights on the cybersecurity of a smart grid

Secure and energy-efficient multicast routing in smart grids

A smart grid is a power system that uses information and communication technology to operate, monitor, and control data flows between the power generating source and the end user. It aims at high efficiency, reliability, and sustainability of the electricity supply process that is provided by the utility centre and is distributed from generation stations to clients. To this end, energy-efficient multicast communication is an important requirement to serve a group of residents in a neighbourhood. However, the multicast routing introduces new challenges in terms of secure operation of the smart grid and user privacy. In this paper, after having analysed the security threats for multicast-enabled smart grids, we propose a novel multicast routing protocol that is both sufficiently secure and energy efficient.We also evaluate the performance of the proposed protocol by means of computer simulations, in terms of its energy-efficient operation

Efficient Key Management Schemes for Smart Grid

With the increasing digitization of different components of Smart Grid by incorporating smart(er) devices, there is an ongoing effort to deploy them for various applications. However, if these devices are compromised, they can reveal sensitive information from such systems. Therefore, securing them against cyber-attacks may represent the first step towards the protection of the critical infrastructure. Nevertheless, realization of the desirable security features such as confidentiality, integrity and authentication relies entirely on cryptographic keys that can be either symmetric or asymmetric. A major need, along with this, is to deal with managing these keys for a large number of devices in Smart Grid. While such key management can be easily addressed by transferring the existing protocols to Smart Grid domain, this is not an easy task, as one needs to deal with the limitations of the current communication infrastructures and resource-constrained devices in Smart Grid. In general, effective mechanisms for Smart Grid security must guarantee the security of the applications by managing (1) key revocation; and (2) key exchange. Moreover, such management should be provided without compromising the general performance of the Smart Grid applications and thus needs to incur minimal overhead to Smart Grid systems. This dissertation aims to fill this gap by proposing specialized key management techniques for resource and communication constrained Smart Grid environments. Specifically, motivated by the need of reducing the revocation management overhead, we first present a distributed public key revocation management scheme for Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) by utilizing distributed hash trees (DHTs). The basic idea is to enable sharing of the burden among smart meters to reduce the overall overhead. Second, we propose another revocation management scheme by utilizing cryptographic accumulators, which reduces the space requirements for revocation information significantly. Finally, we turn our attention to symmetric key exchange problem and propose a 0-Round Trip Time (RTT) message exchange scheme to minimize the message exchanges. This scheme enables a lightweight yet secure symmetric key-exchange between field devices and the control center in Smart Gird by utilizing a dynamic hash chain mechanism. The evaluation of the proposed approaches show that they significantly out-perform existing conventional approaches

Authentication techniques in smart grid: a systematic review

Smart Grid (SG) provides enhancement to existing grids with two-way communication between the utility, sensors, and consumers, by deploying smart sensors to monitor and manage power consumption. However due to the vulnerability of SG, secure component authenticity necessitates robust authentication approaches relative to limited resource availability (i.e. in terms of memory and computational power). SG communication entails optimum efficiency of authentication approaches to avoid any extraneous burden. This systematic review analyses 27 papers on SG authentication techniques and their effectiveness in mitigating certain attacks. This provides a basis for the design and use of optimized SG authentication approaches

Key Management Systems for Smart Grid Advanced Metering Infrastructure: A Survey

Smart Grids are evolving as the next generation power systems that involve changes in the traditional ways of generation, transmission and distribution of power. Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) is one of the key components in smart grids. An AMI comprises of systems and networks, that collects and analyzes data received from smart meters. In addition, AMI also provides intelligent management of various power-related applications and services based on the data collected from smart meters. Thus, AMI plays a significant role in the smooth functioning of smart grids. AMI is a privileged target for security attacks as it is made up of systems that are highly vulnerable to such attacks. Providing security to AMI is necessary as adversaries can cause potential damage against infrastructures and privacy in smart grid. One of the most effective and challenging topic's identified, is the Key Management System (KMS), for sustaining the security concerns in AMI. Therefore, KMS seeks to be a promising research area for future development of AMI. This survey work highlights the key security issues of advanced metering infrastructures and focuses on how key management techniques can be utilized for safeguarding AMI. First of all, we explore the main features of advanced metering infrastructures and identify the relationship between smart grid and AMI. Then, we introduce the security issues and challenges of AMI. We also provide a classification of the existing works in literature that deal with secure key management system in AMI. Finally, we identify possible future research directions of KMS in AMI

Gelişmiş Ölçüm Altyapısı İçin Güvenlik Uygulamaları

Elektrik tüketimi ölçüm araçları, manuel olarak ölçüm yapılan analog sayaçlardan, elektrik tüketimi ile ilgili bilgileri toplayan ve elektrik dağıtım firmalarına ileten yeni akıllı sayaçlara doğru evrilmektedir. Sayaç verisinin okunmasını sağlayan tek yönlü otomatik sayaç okuma sistemlerinin (AMR) çıkışıyla sayaçlar akıllı şebeke yatırımlarının önemli bir kısmını oluşturmuştur. Otomatik sayaç okuma sistemleri ilk uygulamalar için cazip olmasına rağmen, çözülmesi gereken önemli bir husus olan talep tarafı yönetiminin AMR ile sağlanamadığı fark edilmiştir. AMR teknolojisinin kabiliyetlerinin tek yönlü sayaç verisi okuma ile sınırlı olması nedeniyle, sayaçlardan toplanan veriler üzerinden düzeltici önlemler alınmasına ve tüketicinin enerjiyi daha verimli akıllı kullanmasına yönelik özeliklere izin vermemektedir. Gelişmiş Ölçüm Altyapısı (AMI) ise akıllı sayaçlar ve dağıtım şirketleri arasında çift yönlü iletişim kurarak dağıtım şirketlerine sayaçlar üzerindeki parametreleri dinamik olarak değiştirme imkanı tanır. Bu nedenle, bu çalışmada AMI güvenliği üzerine odaklanılacaktır. Akıllı sayaç sistemlerinin yaygınlaşması ile birlikte, güvenlik bu sistemlerin gerekli ve kaçınılmaz bir ihtiyacı haline gelmektedir. Diğer taraftan, AMI sadece akıllı sayaçların fiziksel olarak dağıtımı manasına gelmemekte, ayrıca sayaç verilerinin yönetimi için gerekli olan karmaşık bir iletişim ağı ve bilgi teknolojileri altyapısını da içermektedir. Dolayısıyla güvenlik çözümlerini ele alırken geniş bir perspektifle yaklaşmak gerekmektedir. Bu nedenle de, sistemin kritik varlıkları belirlenmeli, tehditler iyi analiz edilmeli ve daha sonra güvenlik gereksinimleri iyi tanımlanmış olmalıdır. Bu çalışma AMI sisteminin temel güvenlik gereksinimleri, tehditlere karşı sistem kısıtlarını düşünerek olası çözümleri üzerine, şu anki güvenlik çözümlerini de resmederek, genel bir bakış sunmaktadır. Bu çalışmada, AMI sisteminin güvenlik gereksinimleri analiz edilecek, kısıtlar belirlenecek ve olası güvenlik tehditlerine karşı olası karşı önlemler belirlenecektir. Metering utilities have been replacing from analog meters that are read manually with new, smart meters that gather information about electricity consumption and transmit it back to electric companies. The metering has been the important part of the Smart Grid investments so far, with the initial introduction of one-way automated meter reading (AMR) systems to read meter data. Even though AMR technology proved to be initially enticing, utility companies have realized that AMR does not address demand-side management which is the major issue they need to solve. Since AMR’s capability is restricted to reading meter data due to its one-way communication system, it does not let utilities take corrective action based on the information gathered from the meters and does not assist customers in using energy intelligently. Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) creates a two-way communication network between smart meters and utility systems and provides utilities the ability to modify service-level parameters dynamically. Therefore in this work we will also focus on AMI security practices. While smart metering systems are become widespread security is going to be the one of its essential and inevitable needs. On the other hand, AMI does not only mean the physical deployment of smart meters, but it also includes meter data management system which is a complicated communication network and IT infrastructure. Hence a broad perspective has to be adopted when security solutions are considered. Therefore, assets of the system must be identified, threats must be well analyzed and then security requirements must be well defined. This paper presents an overview on the main security requirements of the AMI, on the threats possible solutions considering the system constraints by picturing the current security solutions. In this work, the security requirements for AMI systems will be analyzed, constraints will be determined and possible countermeasures against security threats will be given