Calibrating Generative Models: The Probabilistic Chomsky-Schützenberger Hierarchy

A probabilistic Chomsky–Schützenberger hierarchy of grammars is introduced and studied, with the aim of understanding the expressive power of generative models. We offer characterizations of the distributions definable at each level of the hierarchy, including probabilistic regular, context-free, (linear) indexed, context-sensitive, and unrestricted grammars, each corresponding to familiar probabilistic machine classes. Special attention is given to distributions on (unary notations for) positive integers. Unlike in the classical case where the "semi-linear" languages all collapse into the regular languages, using analytic tools adapted from the classical setting we show there is no collapse in the probabilistic hierarchy: more distributions become definable at each level. We also address related issues such as closure under probabilistic conditioning

Exploring the N-th Dimension of Language

This paper is aimed at exploring the hidden fundamental\ud computational property of natural language that has been so elusive that it has made all attempts to characterize its real computational property ultimately fail. Earlier natural language was thought to be context-free. However, it was gradually realized that this does not hold much water given that a range of natural language phenomena have been found as being of non-context-free character that they have almost scuttled plans to brand natural language contextfree. So it has been suggested that natural language is mildly context-sensitive and to some extent context-free. In all, it seems that the issue over the exact computational property has not yet been solved. Against this background it will be proposed that this exact computational property of natural language is perhaps the N-th dimension of language, if what we mean by dimension is\ud nothing but universal (computational) property of natural language

Feasible Learnability of Formal Grammars and the Theory of Natural Language Acquisition

We propose to apply a complexity theoretic notion of feasible learnability called polynomial learnability to the evaluation of grammatical formalisms for linguistic description. Polynomial learnability was originally defined by Valiant in the context of boolean concept learning and subsequently generalized by Blumer et al. to infinitary domains. We give a clear, intuitive exposition of this notion of learnability and what characteristics of a collection of languages may or may not help feasible learnability under this paradigm. In particular, we present a novel, nontrivial constraint on the degree of locality of grammars which allows a rich class of mildly context sensitive languages to be feasibly learnable. We discuss possible implications of this observation to the theory of natural language acquisition

Ensemble-Based Unsupervised Discontinuous Constituency Parsing by Tree Averaging

We address unsupervised discontinuous constituency parsing, where we observe a high variance in the performance of the only previous model. We propose to build an ensemble of different runs of the existing discontinuous parser by averaging the predicted trees, to stabilize and boost performance. To begin with, we provide comprehensive computational complexity analysis (in terms of P and NP-complete) for tree averaging under different setups of binarity and continuity. We then develop an efficient exact algorithm to tackle the task, which runs in a reasonable time for all samples in our experiments. Results on three datasets show our method outperforms all baselines in all metrics; we also provide in-depth analyses of our approach

Unsupervised Learning of Probabilistic Context-Free Grammar using Iterative Biclustering (Extended Version)

This paper presents PCFG-BCL, an unsupervised algorithm that learns a probabilistic context-free grammar (PCFG) from positive samples. The algorithm acquires rules of an unknown PCFG through iterative biclustering of bigrams in the training corpus. Our analysis shows that this procedure uses a greedy approach to adding rules such that each set of rules that is added to the grammar results in the largest increase in the posterior of the grammar given the training corpus. Results of our experiments on several benchmark datasets show that PCFG-BCL is competitive with existing methods for unsupervised CFG learning