On Pattern Selection for Laparoscope Calibration

Camera calibration is a key requirement for augmented reality in surgery. Calibration of laparoscopes provides two challenges that are not sufficiently addressed in the literature. In the case of stereo laparoscopes the small distance (less than 5mm) between the channels means that the calibration pattern is an order of magnitude more distant than the stereo separation. For laparoscopes in general, if an external tracking system is used, hand-eye calibration is difficult due to the long length of the laparoscope. Laparoscope intrinsic, stereo and hand-eye calibration all rely on accurate feature point selection and accurate estimation of the camera pose with respect to a calibration pattern. We compare 3 calibration patterns, chessboard, rings, and AprilTags. We measure the error in estimating the camera intrinsic parameters and the camera poses. Accuracy of camera pose estimation will determine the accuracy with which subsequent stereo or hand-eye calibration can be done. We compare the results of repeated real calibrations and simulations using idealised noise, to determine the expected accuracy of different methods and the sources of error. The results do indicate that feature detection based on rings is more accurate than a chessboard, however this doesn’t necessarily lead to a better calibration. Using a grid with identifiable tags enables detection of features nearer the image boundary, which may improve calibration

Hand-eye calibration for rigid laparoscopes using an invariant point

PURPOSE: Laparoscopic liver resection has significant advantages over open surgery due to less patient trauma and faster recovery times, yet it can be difficult due to the restricted field of view and lack of haptic feedback. Image guidance provides a potential solution but one current challenge is in accurate "hand-eye" calibration, which determines the position and orientation of the laparoscope camera relative to the tracking markers. METHODS: In this paper, we propose a simple and clinically feasible calibration method based on a single invariant point. The method requires no additional hardware, can be constructed by theatre staff during surgical setup, requires minimal image processing and can be visualised in real time. Real-time visualisation allows the surgical team to assess the calibration accuracy before use in surgery. In addition, in the laboratory, we have developed a laparoscope with an electromagnetic tracking sensor attached to the camera end and an optical tracking marker attached to the distal end. This enables a comparison of tracking performance. RESULTS: We have evaluated our method in the laboratory and compared it to two widely used methods, "Tsai's method" and "direct" calibration. The new method is of comparable accuracy to existing methods, and we show RMS projected error due to calibration of 1.95 mm for optical tracking and 0.85 mm for EM tracking, versus 4.13 and 1.00 mm respectively, using existing methods. The new method has also been shown to be workable under sterile conditions in the operating room. CONCLUSION: We have proposed a new method of hand-eye calibration, based on a single invariant point. Initial experience has shown that the method provides visual feedback, satisfactory accuracy and can be performed during surgery. We also show that an EM sensor placed near the camera would provide significantly improved image overlay accuracy

Evaluation of a calibration rig for stereo laparoscopes

BACKGROUND: Accurate camera and hand-eye calibration are essential to ensure high quality results in image guided surgery applications. The process must also be able to be undertaken by a non-expert user in a surgical setting. PURPOSE: This work seeks to identify a suitable method for tracked stereo laparoscope calibration within theatre. METHODS: A custom calibration rig, to enable rapid calibration in a surgical setting, was designed. The rig was compared against freehand calibration. Stereo reprojection, stereo reconstruction, tracked stereo reprojection and tracked stereo reconstruction error metrics were used to evaluate calibration quality. RESULTS: Use of the calibration rig reduced mean errors: reprojection (1.47mm [SD 0.13] vs 3.14mm [SD 2.11], p-value 1e-8), reconstruction (1.37px [SD 0.10] vs 10.10px [SD 4.54], p-value 6e-7) and tracked reconstruction (1.38mm [SD 0.10] vs 12.64mm [SD 4.34], p-value 1e-6) compared with freehand calibration. The use of a ChArUco pattern yielded slightly lower reprojection errors, while a dot grid produced lower reconstruction errors and was more robust under strong global illumination. CONCLUSION: The use of the calibration rig results in a statistically significant decrease in calibration error metrics, versus freehand calibration, and represents the preferred approach for use in the operating theatre. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved

In vivo estimation of target registration errors during augmented reality laparoscopic surgery

PURPOSE: Successful use of augmented reality for laparoscopic surgery requires that the surgeon has a thorough understanding of the likely accuracy of any overlay. Whilst the accuracy of such systems can be estimated in the laboratory, it is difficult to extend such methods to the in vivo clinical setting. Herein we describe a novel method that enables the surgeon to estimate in vivo errors during use. We show that the method enables quantitative evaluation of in vivo data gathered with the SmartLiver image guidance system. METHODS: The SmartLiver system utilises an intuitive display to enable the surgeon to compare the positions of landmarks visible in both a projected model and in the live video stream. From this the surgeon can estimate the system accuracy when using the system to locate subsurface targets not visible in the live video. Visible landmarks may be either point or line features. We test the validity of the algorithm using an anatomically representative liver phantom, applying simulated perturbations to achieve clinically realistic overlay errors. We then apply the algorithm to in vivo data. RESULTS: The phantom results show that using projected errors of surface features provides a reliable predictor of subsurface target registration error for a representative human liver shape. Applying the algorithm to in vivo data gathered with the SmartLiver image-guided surgery system shows that the system is capable of accuracies around 12 mm; however, achieving this reliably remains a significant challenge. CONCLUSION: We present an in vivo quantitative evaluation of the SmartLiver image-guided surgery system, together with a validation of the evaluation algorithm. This is the first quantitative in vivo analysis of an augmented reality system for laparoscopic surgery

Multispectral image analysis in laparoscopy – A machine learning approach to live perfusion monitoring

Modern visceral surgery is often performed through small incisions. Compared to open surgery, these minimally invasive interventions result in smaller scars, fewer complications and a quicker recovery. While to the patients benefit, it has the drawback of limiting the physician’s perception largely to that of visual feedback through a camera mounted on a rod lens: the laparoscope. Conventional laparoscopes are limited by “imitating” the human eye. Multispectral cameras remove this arbitrary restriction of recording only red, green and blue colors. Instead, they capture many specific bands of light. Although these could help characterize important indications such as ischemia and early stage adenoma, the lack of powerful digital image processing prevents realizing the technique’s full potential. The primary objective of this thesis was to pioneer fluent functional multispectral imaging (MSI) in laparoscopy. The main technical obstacles were: (1) The lack of image analysis concepts that provide both high accuracy and speed. (2) Multispectral image recording is slow, typically ranging from seconds to minutes. (3) Obtaining a quantitative ground truth for the measurements is hard or even impossible. To overcome these hurdles and enable functional laparoscopy, for the first time in this field physical models are combined with powerful machine learning techniques. The physical model is employed to create highly accurate simulations, which in turn teach the algorithm to rapidly relate multispectral pixels to underlying functional changes. To reduce the domain shift introduced by learning from simulations, a novel transfer learning approach automatically adapts generic simulations to match almost arbitrary recordings of visceral tissue. In combination with the only available video-rate capable multispectral sensor, the method pioneers fluent perfusion monitoring with MSI. This system was carefully tested in a multistage process, involving in silico quantitative evaluations, tissue phantoms and a porcine study. Clinical applicability was ensured through in-patient recordings in the context of partial nephrectomy; in these, the novel system characterized ischemia live during the intervention. Verified against a fluorescence reference, the results indicate that fluent, non-invasive ischemia detection and monitoring is now possible. In conclusion, this thesis presents the first multispectral laparoscope capable of videorate functional analysis. The system was successfully evaluated in in-patient trials, and future work should be directed towards evaluation of the system in a larger study. Due to the broad applicability and the large potential clinical benefit of the presented functional estimation approach, I am confident the descendants of this system are an integral part of the next generation OR

Uncertainty-Aware Organ Classification for Surgical Data Science Applications in Laparoscopy

Objective: Surgical data science is evolving into a research field that aims to observe everything occurring within and around the treatment process to provide situation-aware data-driven assistance. In the context of endoscopic video analysis, the accurate classification of organs in the field of view of the camera proffers a technical challenge. Herein, we propose a new approach to anatomical structure classification and image tagging that features an intrinsic measure of confidence to estimate its own performance with high reliability and which can be applied to both RGB and multispectral imaging (MI) data. Methods: Organ recognition is performed using a superpixel classification strategy based on textural and reflectance information. Classification confidence is estimated by analyzing the dispersion of class probabilities. Assessment of the proposed technology is performed through a comprehensive in vivo study with seven pigs. Results: When applied to image tagging, mean accuracy in our experiments increased from 65% (RGB) and 80% (MI) to 90% (RGB) and 96% (MI) with the confidence measure. Conclusion: Results showed that the confidence measure had a significant influence on the classification accuracy, and MI data are better suited for anatomical structure labeling than RGB data. Significance: This work significantly enhances the state of art in automatic labeling of endoscopic videos by introducing the use of the confidence metric, and by being the first study to use MI data for in vivo laparoscopic tissue classification. The data of our experiments will be released as the first in vivo MI dataset upon publication of this paper.Comment: 7 pages, 6 images, 2 table

Visual SLAM for Measurement and Augmented Reality in Laparoscopic Surgery

In spite of the great advances in laparoscopic surgery, this type of surgery still shows some difficulties during its realization, mainly caused by its complex maneuvers and, above all, by the loss of the depth perception. Unlike classical open surgery --laparotomy-- where surgeons have direct contact with organs and a complete 3D perception, laparoscopy is carried out by means of specialized instruments, and a monocular camera (laparoscope) in which the 3D scene is projected into a 2D plane --image. The main goal of this thesis is to face with this loss of depth perception by making use of Simultaneous Localization and Mapping (SLAM) algorithms developed in the fields of robotics and computer vision during the last years. These algorithms allow to localize, in real time (25 $\thicksim$ 30 frames per second), a camera that moves freely inside an unknown rigid environment while, at the same time, they build a map of this environment by exploiting images gathered by that camera. These algorithms have been extensively validated both in man-made environments (buildings, rooms, ...) and in outdoor environments, showing robustness to occlusions, sudden camera motions, or clutter. This thesis tries to extend the use of these algorithms to laparoscopic surgery. Due to the intrinsic nature of internal body images (they suffer from deformations, specularities, variable illumination conditions, limited movements, ...), applying this type of algorithms to laparoscopy supposes a real challenge. Knowing the camera (laparoscope) location with respect to the scene (abdominal cavity) and the 3D map of that scene opens new interesting possibilities inside the surgical field. This knowledge enables to do augmented reality annotations directly on the laparoscopic images (e.g. alignment of preoperative 3D CT models); intracavity 3D distance measurements; or photorealistic 3D reconstructions of the abdominal cavity recovering synthetically the lost depth. These new facilities provide security and rapidity to surgical procedures without disturbing the classical procedure workflow. Hence, these tools are available inside the surgeon's armory, being the surgeon who decides to use them or not. Additionally, knowledge of the camera location with respect to the patient's abdominal cavity is fundamental for future development of robots that can operate automatically since, knowing this location, the robot will be able to localize other tools controlled by itself with respect to the patient. In detail, the contributions of this thesis are: - To demonstrate the feasibility of applying SLAM algorithms to laparoscopy showing experimentally that using robust data association is a must. - To robustify one of these algorithms, in particular the monocular EKF-SLAM algorithm, by adapting a relocalization system and improving data association with a robust matching algorithm. - To develop of a robust matching method (1-Point RANSAC algorithm). - To develop a new surgical procedure to ease the use of visual SLAM in laparoscopy. - To make an extensive validation of the robust EKF-SLAM (EKF + relocalization + 1-Point RANSAC) obtaining millimetric errors and working in real time both on simulation and real human surgeries. The selected surgery has been the ventral hernia repair. - To demonstrate the potential of these algorithms in laparoscopy: they recover synthetically the depth of the operative field which is lost by using monocular laparoscopes, enable the insertion of augmented reality annotations, and allow to perform distance measurements using only a laparoscopic tool (to define the real scale) and laparoscopic images. - To make a clinical validation showing that these algorithms allow to shorten surgical times of operations and provide more security to the surgical procedures

The value of Augmented Reality in surgery — A usability study on laparoscopic liver surgery

Augmented Reality (AR) is considered to be a promising technology for the guidance of laparoscopic liver surgery. By overlaying pre-operative 3D information of the liver and internal blood vessels on the laparoscopic view, surgeons can better understand the location of critical structures. In an effort to enable AR, several authors have focused on the development of methods to obtain an accurate alignment between the laparoscopic video image and the pre-operative 3D data of the liver, without assessing the benefit that the resulting overlay can provide during surgery. In this paper, we present a study that aims to assess quantitatively and qualitatively the value of an AR overlay in laparoscopic surgery during a simulated surgical task on a phantom setup. We design a study where participants are asked to physically localise pre-operative tumours in a liver phantom using three image guidance conditions — a baseline condition without any image guidance, a condition where the 3D surfaces of the liver are aligned to the video and displayed on a black background, and a condition where video see-through AR is displayed on the laparoscopic video. Using data collected from a cohort of 24 participants which include 12 surgeons, we observe that compared to the baseline, AR decreases the median localisation error of surgeons on non-peripheral targets from 25.8 mm to 9.2 mm. Using subjective feedback, we also identify that AR introduces usability improvements in the surgical task and increases the perceived confidence of the users. Between the two tested displays, the majority of participants preferred to use the AR overlay instead of navigated view of the 3D surfaces on a separate screen. We conclude that AR has the potential to improve performance and decision making in laparoscopic surgery, and that improvements in overlay alignment accuracy and depth perception should be pursued in the future