On sets defining few ordinary lines

Let P be a set of n points in the plane, not all on a line. We show that if n is large then there are at least n/2 ordinary lines, that is to say lines passing through exactly two points of P. This confirms, for large n, a conjecture of Dirac and Motzkin. In fact we describe the exact extremisers for this problem, as well as all sets having fewer than n - C ordinary lines for some absolute constant C. We also solve, for large n, the "orchard-planting problem", which asks for the maximum number of lines through exactly 3 points of P. Underlying these results is a structure theorem which states that if P has at most Kn ordinary lines then all but O(K) points of P lie on a cubic curve, if n is sufficiently large depending on K.Comment: 72 pages, 16 figures. Third version prepared to take account of suggestions made in a detailed referee repor

A finite version of the Kakeya problem

Let $L$ be a set of lines of an affine space over a field and let $S$ be a set of points with the property that every line of $L$ is incident with at least $N$ points of $S$. Let $D$ be the set of directions of the lines of $L$ considered as points of the projective space at infinity. We give a geometric construction of a set of lines $L$, where $D$ contains an $N^{n-1}$ grid and where $S$ has size $2((1/2)N)^n$, given a starting configuration in the plane. We provide examples of such starting configurations for the reals and for finite fields. Following Dvir's proof of the finite field Kakeya conjecture and the idea of using multiplicities of Dvir, Kopparty, Saraf and Sudan, we prove a lower bound on the size of $S$ dependent on the ideal generated by the homogeneous polynomials vanishing on $D$. This bound is maximised as $((1/2)N)^n$ plus smaller order terms, for $n\geqslant 4$, when $D$ contains the points of a $N^{n-1}$ grid.Comment: A few minor changes to previous versio

From Pappus Theorem to parameter spaces of some extremal line point configurations and applications

In the present work we study parameter spaces of two line point configurations introduced by B\"or\"oczky. These configurations are extremal from the point of view of Dirac-Motzkin Conjecture settled recently by Green and Tao. They have appeared also recently in commutative algebra in connection with the containment problem for symbolic and ordinary powers of homogeneous ideals and in algebraic geometry in considerations revolving around the Bounded Negativity Conjecture. Our main results are Theorem A and Theorem B. We show that the parameter space of what we call $B12$ configurations is a three dimensional rational variety. As a consequence we derive the existence of a three dimensional family of rational $B12$ configurations. On the other hand the moduli space of $B15$ configurations is shown to be an elliptic curve with only finitely many rational points, all corresponding to degenerate configurations. Thus, somewhat surprisingly, we conclude that there are no rational $B15$ configurations.Comment: 17 pages, v.2. title modified, material reorganized, introduction new rewritten, discussion more streamline

On the Sylvester-Gallai and the orchard problem for pseudoline arrangements

We study a non-trivial extreme case of the orchard problem for $12$ pseudolines and we provide a complete classification of pseudoline arrangements having $19$ triple points and $9$ double points. We have also classified those that can be realized with straight lines. They include new examples different from the known example of B\"or\"oczky. Since Melchior's inequality also holds for arrangements of pseudolines, we are able to deduce that some combinatorial point-line configurations cannot be realized using pseudolines. In particular, this gives a negative answer to one of Gr\"unbaum's problems. We formulate some open problems which involve our new examples of line arrangements.Comment: 5 figures, 11 pages, to appear in Periodica Mathematica Hungaric