A finite version of the Kakeya problem

Abstract

Let $L$ be a set of lines of an affine space over a field and let $S$ be a set of points with the property that every line of $L$ is incident with at least $N$ points of $S$. Let $D$ be the set of directions of the lines of $L$ considered as points of the projective space at infinity. We give a geometric construction of a set of lines $L$, where $D$ contains an $N^{n-1}$ grid and where $S$ has size $2((1/2)N)^n$, given a starting configuration in the plane. We provide examples of such starting configurations for the reals and for finite fields. Following Dvir's proof of the finite field Kakeya conjecture and the idea of using multiplicities of Dvir, Kopparty, Saraf and Sudan, we prove a lower bound on the size of $S$ dependent on the ideal generated by the homogeneous polynomials vanishing on $D$. This bound is maximised as $((1/2)N)^n$ plus smaller order terms, for $n\geqslant 4$, when $D$ contains the points of a $N^{n-1}$ grid.Comment: A few minor changes to previous versio