Development of a machine-tooling-process integrated approach for abrasive flow machining (AFM) of difficult-to-machine materials with application to oil and gas exploration componenets

This thesis was submitted for the degree of Doctor of Engineering and awarded by Brunel UniversityAbrasive flow machining (AFM) is a non-traditional manufacturing technology used to expose a substrate to pressurised multiphase slurry, comprised of superabrasive grit suspended in a viscous, typically polymeric carrier. Extended exposure to the slurry causes material removal, where the quantity of removal is subject to complex interactions within over 40 variables. Flow is contained within boundary walls, complex in form, causing physical phenomena to alter the behaviour of the media. In setting factors and levels prior to this research, engineers had two options; embark upon a wasteful, inefficient and poor-capability trial and error process or they could attempt to relate the findings they achieve in simple geometry to complex geometry through a series of transformations, providing information that could be applied over and over. By condensing process variables into appropriate study groups, it becomes possible to quantify output while manipulating only a handful of variables. Those that remain un-manipulated are integral to the factors identified. Through factorial and response surface methodology experiment designs, data is obtained and interrogated, before feeding into a simulated replica of a simple system. Correlation with physical phenomena is sought, to identify flow conditions that drive material removal location and magnitude. This correlation is then applied to complex geometry with relative success. It is found that prediction of viscosity through computational fluid dynamics can be used to estimate as much as 94% of the edge-rounding effect on final complex geometry. Surface finish prediction is lower (~75%), but provides significant relationship to warrant further investigation. Original contributions made in this doctoral thesis include; 1) A method of utilising computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to derive a suitable process model for the productive and reproducible control of the AFM process, including identification of core physical phenomena responsible for driving erosion, 2) Comprehensive understanding of effects of B4C-loaded polydimethylsiloxane variants used to process Ti6Al4V in the AFM process, including prediction equations containing numerically-verified second order interactions (factors for grit size, grain fraction and modifier concentration), 3) Equivalent understanding of machine factors providing energy input, studying velocity, temperature and quantity. Verified predictions are made from data collected in Ti6Al4V substrate material using response surface methodology, 4) Holistic method to translating process data in control-geometry to an arbitrary geometry for industrial gain, extending to a framework for collecting new data and integrating into current knowledge, and 5) Application of methodology using research-derived CFD, applied to complex geometry proven by measured process output. As a result of this project, four publications have been made to-date – two peer-reviewed journal papers and two peer-reviewed international conference papers. Further publications will be made from June 2014 onwards.Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) and the Technology Strategy Board (TSB

Tribological optimisation of the internal combustion engine piston to bore conjunction through surface modification

Internal combustion (IC) engines used in road transport applications employ pistons to convert gas pressure into mechanical work. Frictional losses abound within IC engines, where only 38- 51% of available fuel energy results in useful mechanical work. Piston-bore and ring-bore conjunctions are fairly equally responsible for circa 30% of all engine friction - equivalent to 1.6% of the input fuel each. Therefore, reduction in piston assembly friction would have a direct impact on specific performance and / or fuel consumption. In motorsport, power outputs and duty cycles greatly exceed road applications. Consequently, these engines have a shorter useful life and a high premium is placed on measures which would increase the output power without further reducing engine life. Reduction of friction offers such an opportunity, which may be achieved by improved tribological design in terms of reduced contact area or enhanced lubrication or both. However, the developments in the motorsport sector are typically reactive due to a lack of relative performance or an ad-hoc reliance, based upon a limited number of actual engine tests in order to determine if any improvement can be achieved as the result of some predetermined action. A representative scientific model generally does not exist and as such, investigated parameters are often driven by the supply chain with the promise of improvement. In cylinder investigations are usually limited to bore surface finish, bore and piston geometrical form, piston skirt coatings and the lubricant employed. Of these investigated areas newly emerging surface coatings are arguably seen as predominate. This thesis highlights a scientific approach which has been developed to optimise piston-bore performance. Pre-existing methods of screening and benchmarking alterations have been retained such as engine testing. However, this has been placed in the context of validation of scientifically driven development. A multi-physics numerical model is developed, which combines piston inertial dynamics, as well as thermo-structural strains within a thermoelastohydrodynamic tribological framework. Experimental tests were performed to validate the findings of numerical models. These tests include film thickness measurement and incylinder friction measurement, as well as the numerically-indicated beneficial surface modifications. Experimental testing was performed on an in-house motored engine at Capricorn Automotive, a dynamometer mounted single-cylinder ‘fired’ engine at Loughborough University, as well as on other engines belonging to third party clients of Capricorn. The diversity of tests was to ascertain the generic nature of any findings. The multi-physics multi-scale combined numerical-experimental investigation is the main contribution of this thesis to knowledge. One major finding of the thesis is the significant role that bulk thermo-structural deformation makes on the contact conformity of piston skirt to cylinder liner contact, thus advising piston skirt design. Another key finding is the beneficial role of textured surfaces in the retention of reservoirs of lubricant, thus reducing friction

Impact of superficial surface texture anisotropy in helical slide and plateau honing on ring-pack performance

The improvement of environment efficiency of automotive internal combustion engine becomes a fundamental objective. The cylinder engine surface texture considerably influences the functional performances of the ring-pack tribo-system. These surfaces are obtained by honing process that was pioneered in the last decade. Several innovative honing techniques were developed resulting in new surface textures with different cross-hatch angle obtained after several stages: the rough and finish honing and final stage. The aim of this study is to investigate the effect of variable cross-hatch angle generated at a final stage. These measured obtained surfaces are measured by a 3D white light interferometer and used as input data of the numerical model to estimate the friction. The results show the importance of this ‘residual’ angle

Boundary interactions of rough non-gaussian surfaces

Surface topography is important as it influences contact load-carrying capacity and operational efficiency through generated friction, as well as wear. As a result, a plethora of machining processes and surface finishing techniques have been developed. These processes yield topographies, which are often non-Gaussian, with roughness parameters that alter hierarchically according to their interaction heights. They are also subject to change through processes of rapid initial running-in wear as well as any subsequent gradual wear and embedding. The stochastic nature of the topography makes for complexity of contact mechanics of rough surfaces, which was first addressed by the pioneering work of Greenwood and Williamson, which among other issues is commemorated by this contribution. It is shown that their seminal contribution, based on idealised Gaussian topography and mean representation of asperity geometry should be extended for practical applications where surfaces are often non-Gaussian, requiring the inclusion of surface-specific data which also evolve through process of wear. The paper highlights a process dealing with practical engineering surfaces from laboratory-based testing using a sliding tribometer to accelerated fired engine testing for high performance applications of cross-hatched honed cylinder liners. Such an approach has not hitherto been reported in literature

Plasma texturing for enhanced tribological performance of cast iron

Cathodic plasma electrolysis (CPE) was used to create surface texturing on gray iron samples, which could reduce the friction and increase the wear resistance. During the treating process, cast iron sample served as a cathode where the plasma discharging occurred, increasing the surface hardness and leaving an irregular array of micro craters on the surface. Modified surface morphology was determined from scanning electron microscope (SEM) and surface profiler. Recessed and protruded surface textures were observed when the CPE was applied at low and high voltages, respectively. Pin-on-disk tribotests were conducted on CPE-treated samples and untextured sample. The friction of as-treated samples could be reduced in boundary lubrication regime at low sliding speed due to the ability to store lubricant. Besides that, the surface texture generated extra hydrodynamic pressure that separated two sliding surfaces, increased the oil film thickness and accelerated the transition from boundary to mixed lubrication at high sliding speeds

THE INVESTIGATION INTO THE CONDITION MONITORING OF TRIBOLOGICAL BEHAVIOUR BETWEEN PISTON RING AND CYLINDER LINER USING ACOUSTIC EMISSIONS

To improve engine operational performance and reliability, this study focuses on the investigation into the behaviour of tribological conjunction between the ring - liner based on a comprehensive analysis of non-intrusive acoustic emission (AE) measurement. Particularly, the study will provide more knowledge of using AE for online monitoring and diagnosing the performances of the conjunction. To fulfil this study, it integrates analytical predictions of the theoretical modelling for the AE generation mechanism with extensive experimental evaluations. Moreover, effective signal processing techniques are implemented with a combination of the model based AE predictions to extract the weak and nonstationary AE contents that correlate more with the tribological behaviour. Based on conventional tribological models, tribological AE is modelled to be due to two main dynamic effects: asperity-asperity collision (AAC) and fluid-asperity interaction (FAI), which allows measured AE signals from the tribological conjunction to be explained under different scenarios, especially under abnormal behaviours. FAI induced AE is more correlated with lubricants and velocity. It presents mainly in the middle of engine strokes but is much weaker and severely interfered with AEs from not only valve landings, combustion and fuel injection shocks but also the effect of considerable AACs due to direct contacts and solid particles in oils. To extract weak AEs for accurately diagnosing the tribological behaviours, wavelet transform analysis is applied to AE signals with three novel schemes: 1) hard threshold based wavelet coefficients selection in which the threshold value and wavelet analysis parameters are determined using a modified velocity of piston motion which has high dependence on the AE characteristics predicted by the two models; 2) Adaptive threshold wavelet coefficients selection in which the threshold is gradually updated to minimise the distance between the AE envelopes and the predicted dependence; and 3) wavelet packet transform (WPT) analysis is carried out by an optimised Daubechies wavelet through a novel approach based on minimising the time and frequency overlaps in WPT spectrum. Based on these optimal analyses, the local envelope amplitude (LEA) and the average residual wavelet coefficient (ARWC) are developed from AE signals as novel indicators to reflect the tribological behaviours.\ud Both the hard threshold based LEA and wavelet packet transform LEA values allow two different new lubricants to be diagnosed in accordance with model predictions whereas they produce less consistent results in differentiating the used oil under several operating conditions. Nevertheless, ARWC can separate the used oil successfully in that it can highlight the AAC effects of particle collisions in used oils. Similarly, LEA shows little impacts of two alternative fuels on the tribological behaviours. However, ARWC shows significantly higher amplitudes in several operating conditions when more particles can be produced due to unstable and incomplete combustions of both the biodiesel and FT diesel, compared with pure diesel, indicating they can cause light wear

Measurement and prediction of in-cylinder friction in internal combustion engines

Currently, nearly 75% of worldwide transport is powered by internal combustion engines, with the worldwide transport sector accounting for 14% of the world’s greenhouse gas emissions. With the current trend of downsizing and reducing vehicle cost, expensive solutions such as hybrids are often not viable. One solution is to reduce engine parasitic losses, thereby indirectly improving fuel efficiency, hence emissions. In terms of frictional losses, the piston-cylinder system accounts for 50% of all such losses, which altogether contribute to 20% of all engine losses. The thesis describes an efficient analytical-numerical model in terms of computation times and CPU requirements. The model is a one dimensional analytical solution of Reynolds equation using Elrods cavitation algorithm. The model also includes determination of viscous friction as well as boundary/asperity friction based on the work of Greenwood and Tripp. Lubrication rheology is adjusted for generated hydrodynamic pressures and measured conjunctional temperature based on the cylinder liner. Model predictions are supported by a range of experimental work, from basic science measurements using an instrumented precision slider bearing rig for direct measurement of friction to the development and use of a floating liner on a motored and fired high speed, high performance internal combustion engine at the real situation practical level. The thesis highlights the development of the experimental rigs/engines as well application of state of the art instrumentation and data processing. The combined numerical and experimental analysis show that a significant proportion of friction takes place at the top-dead-center reversal in the transition from the compression to the power stroke. Under motored conditions with low in-cylinder pressures this appears to follow Poiseuille friction, whereas under fired conditions with higher in-cylinder pressures causing increased compression ring sealing a mixed and/or boundary regime of lubrication is observed and predicted. Other than at the TDC reversal in both motored and fired conditions the frictional characteristics follow in direct proportion to the piston sliding velocity, therefore showing the dominance of viscous friction. One outcome of the thesis is a validated analytical model which due to its computational efficiency can now be used in industry to provide timely predictions for the compression ring contact zone. Most significantly, the thesis has established an experimental procedure, infrastructure and data processing methods which enable the determination of the regime of lubrication and the underlying mechanisms of friction generation from basic science sliding surfaces to in situ direct measurements from a fired engine at high loads and sliding speeds

Investigation of wear and scuffing behaviour of ferrous thermal spray coatings for aluminum engines.

The development of lightweight internal combustion engines using materials such as cast aluminum alloys represents one of the most significant technological developments in the automotive industry. These engines reduce weight, which in turn reduce fuel consumption and emission. However, poor wear resistance and low seizure load of unprotected Al-Si alloys are a major drawback for applications involving sliding contact in automotive engine blocks. The wear resistance of cast aluminum parts can be improved by depositing coatings on the sliding surfaces. In this respect, iron based coatings deposited through a thermal spray process may play an important role in improving wear resistances of aluminium parts used in the automotive industry. Paper copy at Leddy Library: Theses & Major Papers - Basement, West Bldg. / Call Number: Thesis2004 .E37. Source: Dissertation Abstracts International, Volume: 65-10, Section: B, page: 5340. Advisers: A. T. Alpas; T. Perry. Thesis (Ph.D.)--University of Windsor (Canada), 2004

Friction Reduction in Powertrain Materials: Role of Tribolayers

This study aims at understanding the micromechanisms responsible for reduction in friction and wear in the engine cylinder bore/liner materials when tested under lubricated and unlubricated conditions. The tribolayers formed in-situ during sliding contact are unique to each tribosystem and a detailed study of these tribolayers will shed light on the friction reduction mechanisms in powertrain materials. Boundary lubricated tribological performance of grey cast iron (CI) tested against non-hydrogenated diamond-like carbon coating (NH-DLC) resulted in 21% lower coefficient of friction (COF) and an order of magnitude lower volumetric wear compared to CI and steel counterfaces. Dilution of the engine oil by ethanol containing E85 biofuel, consisting of 85% ethanol and 15% gasoline, was beneficial as COF and volumetric wear losses were further reduced. TEM/EELS studies of the NH-DLC counterface provided evidence for OH adsorption of the dangling carbon bonds at the coating surface leading to low friction. Advantage of E85/engine oil blend was also evident during boundary lubricated sliding of eutectic Al-12.6% Si alloy against AISI 52100 steel. The oil residue layer (ORL) formed during boundary lubricated sliding incorporated nanocrystalline regions of Al, Si, ZnS, AlPO4 and ZnO surrounded by amorphous carbon regions. Higher proportions of Zn, S, and P antiwear compounds formed in the ORL when tested using the E85/oil (1:1) blend compared to the unmixed engine oil as the hydroxyl groups in ethanol molecules facilitated ZDDP degradation. Mico-Raman spectroscopy indicated two types of tribolayers formed during unlubricated sliding of thermally sprayed low carbon steel 1010 coating deposited on linerless Al 380 cylinder bore: i) Fe2O3 layer transformed from FeO during dry sliding and ii) Fe2O3 layer with a top amorphous carbon transfer layer when run against H-DLC coated TCR with COF of 0.18. The NH- and H-DLC coatings, that provide low friction under room temperature conditions, fail at temperatures \u3e 200 °C. It was shown that W containing DLC (W-DLC) coatings offered low and stable COF of 0.07 at 400 °C while a Ti incorporated multilayer MoS2 (Ti-MoS2) coating maintained COF between 0.11 at 25 °C to 0.13 at 350 °C. The low friction provided by these coatings was attributed to formation of high temperature lubricious oxides: tungsten trioxide (WO3) in case of W-DLC and MoO3 in case of MoS2, as revealed by Raman analyses of the tribolayers formed on counterface surfaces. Tribolayer formation during sliding friction of multuilayered graphene (MLG), a potential lubricant, depended on the material transfer and relative humidity (RH). Sliding friction tests performed on MLG in air (10- 45% RH) and under a dry N2 atmosphere showed that progressively lower friction values were observed when the RH was increased, with maximum COF of 0.52 in dry N2 and lowest COF of about 0.10 at 45% RH. Microstructural studies including cross-sectional FIB/HR-TEM determined that sliding induced defects which comprised of edge fracture, fragmented/bent graphene stacks compared to pristine graphene and disordered regions between them. In summary, this work shows that delineating the micromechanisms responsible for reduction in friction and wear is critical for development of appropriate materials and coatings for powertrain components

Analyse und Modellbildung von Kräften beim Präzisionshonen von Bohrungen

Die vorliegende Arbeit beschäftigt sich mit einem Fertigungsverfahren mit geometrisch unbestimmter Schneide, dem Langhub-Innenrundhonen, das zur Bearbeitung von Bohrungen verwendet wird. Das Honen dient dabei der Erzeugung einer hohen Form-, Maß- und Oberflächengenauigkeit bei vorbearbeiteten Werkstücken und ist in der Regel der letzte Schritt in der Prozesskette. Betrachtet werden zunächst grundlegende Effekte beim Honen sowie Möglichkeiten zur optimierten Prozessführung durch eine Modellierung der Kräfte. Eingegangen wird dabei auf das weggeführte Honen, das in der Industrie derzeit weit verbreitet ist und eine Zustellung der Honleiste in festen Schritten zu festgelegten Zeitpunkten durchführt. Daneben wird auch die alternative Möglichkeit des kraftgeführten Honens vorgestellt. Dieses versucht während der gesamten Prozesszeit eine konstante Kraft zu erreichen und damit eine höhere Präzision und Wiederholgenauigkeit zu gewährleisten. Da die Kraft aber im Moment, insbesondere beim Honen von Präzisionsbohrungen mit einem Durchmesser unter 20mm, nur indirekt gemessen werden kann, ist sie fehlerbehaftet. Eine Modellierung der Kraftverhältnisse am Werkzeug soll hier Abhilfe schaffen. Dazu werden verschiedene Ansätze vorgestellt und auf ihre Eignung hin überprüft. Notwendige Modellparameter werden ermittelt, dann werden berechnete Verläufe mit gemessenen verglichen. Im Anschluss werden Anwendungsmöglichkeiten für die Modelle aufgezeigt.This thesis deals with long-stroke internal honing – a manufacturing process with geometrically undefined cutting edge used for the machining of bores. Honing serves to generate high form-, dimension- and surface accuracy in pre-machined work pieces and constitutes generally the last step in the process chain. At first, basic effects during the honing process as well as possibilities for the optimized process control by modelling the forces are examined. In doing so, the author goes into the stroke-controlled honing which is at the moment widespread in the industry and which conducts a feed of the honing stone in fixed steps and at given points in time. In addition, also the alternative possibility of force-controlled honing is presented which tries to reach a constant force during the entire process time and to ensure with it a higher precision and repeatability. As it is at the moment only possible to indirectly measure the force, especially with regard to the honing of precision bores with a diameter below 20mm, it is subject to errors. A modelling of the force distributions at the tool is to find a remedy. For this purpose, different approaches are presented and their suitability is verified. Necessary model parameters are determined, and then calculated processes are compared with measured ones. Afterwards, possible applications for the models are shown