Integration of returns and decomposition of customer orders in e-commerce warehouses

In picker-to-parts warehouses, order picking is a cost- and labor-intensive operation that must be designed efficiently. It comprises the construction of order batches and the associated order picker routes, and the assignment and sequencing of those batches to multiple order pickers. The ever-increasing competitiveness among e-commerce companies has made the joint optimization of this order picking process inevitable. Inspired by the large number of product returns and the many but small-sized customer orders, we address a new integrated order picking process problem. We integrate the restocking of returned products into regular order picking routes and we allow for the decomposition of customer orders so that multiple batches may contain products from the same customer order. We thereby generalize the existing models on order picking processing. We provide Mixed Integer Programming (MIP) formulations and a tailored adaptive large neighborhood search heuristic that, amongst others, exploits these MIPs. We propose a new set of practically-sized benchmark instances, consisting of up to 5547 to be picked products and 2491 to be restocked products. On those large-scale instances, we show that integrating the restocking of returned products into regular order picker routes results in cost-savings of 10 to 15%. Allowing for the decomposition of the customer orders' products results in cost savings of up to 44% compared to not allowing this. Finally, we show that on average cost-savings of 17.4% can be obtained by using our ALNS instead of heuristics typically used in practice.Comment: Authors' preprin

Data-driven warehouse optimization

Batching orders and routing order pickers is a commonly studied problem in many picker-to-parts warehouses. The impact of individual differences in picking skills on performance has received little attention. In this paper, we show that taking into account differences in the skills of individual pickers when assigning work has a substantial effect on total batch execution time and picker productivity. We demonstrate this for the case of a Finnish retailer. First, using time-stamped picking data, multilevel modeling is used to forecast batch execution times for individual pickers by modeling individual skills of pickers. Next, these forecasts are used to minimize total batch execution time, by assigning the right picker to the right order batch. We formulate the problem as a joint order batching and generalized assignment model, and solve it with an Adaptive Large Neighborhood Search algorithm. For the sample company, we are able to improve state-of-the-art batching and routing methods by almost 10% taking skill differences among pickers into account and minimizing the sum of total order processing time. Compared to assigning order batches to pickers only based on individual picker productivity, savings of 6% in total time are achieved

Material handling optimization in warehousing operations

Tableau d’honneur de la Faculté des études supérieures et postdoctorales, 2018-2019.Les activités de distribution et d’entreposage sont des piliers importants de la chaîne d’approvisionnement. Ils assurent la stabilité du flux de matières et la synchronisation de toutes les parties prenantes du réseau. Un centre de distribution (CD) agit comme un point de découplage entre l’approvisionnement, la production et les ventes. La distribution comprend un large éventail d’activités visant à assurer la satisfaction de la demande. Ces activités passent de la réception au stockage des produits finis ou semi-finis, à la préparation des commandes et à la livraison. Les opérations d’un CD sont maintenant perçues comme des facteurs critiques d’amélioration. Elles sont responsables de la satisfaction d’un marché en évolution, exigeant des délais de livraison toujours plus rapides et plus fiables, des commandes exactes et des produits hautement personnalisés. C’est pourquoi la recherche en gestion des opérations met beaucoup d’efforts sur le problème de gestion des CDs. Depuis plusieurs années, nous avons connu de fortes avancées en matière d’entreposage et de préparation de commandes. L’activité de préparation de commandes est le processus consistant à récupérer les articles à leur emplacement de stockage afin d’assembler des commandes. Ce problème a souvent été résolu comme une variante du problème du voyageur de commerce, où l’opérateur se déplace à travers les allées de l’entrepôt. Cependant, les entrepôts modernes comportent de plus en plus de familles de produits ayant des caractéristiques très particulières rendant les méthodes conventionnelles moins adéquates. Le premier volet de cette thèse par articles présente deux importants et complexes problèmes de manutention des produits lors de la préparation des commandes. Le problème de préparation des commandes a été largement étudié dans la littérature au cours des dernières décennies. Notre recherche élargit le spectre de ce problème en incluant un ensemble de caractéristiques associées aux installations physiques de la zone de prélèvement, comme les allées étroites, et aux caractéristiques des produits (poids, volume, catégorie, fragilité, etc.). Une perspective plus appliquée à la réalité des opérations est utilisée dans notre développement d’algorithmes. Les déplacements liés à la préparation des commandes sont fortement influencés par le positionnement des produits. La position des produits dans la zone de prélèvement est déterminée par une stratégie d’affectation de stockage (storage assignment strategy). Beaucoup de ces stratégies utilisent de l’information sur les ventes des produits afin de faciliter l’accès aux plus populaires. Dans l’environnement concurrentiel d’aujourd’hui, la durée de vie rentable d’un produit peut être relativement courte. Des promotions peuvent également être faites pour pousser différents produits sur le marché. Le positionnement fourni par la stratégie d’hier ne sera probablement plus optimal aujourd’hui. Il existe plusieurs études mesurant l’impact d’une bonne réaffectation de produits sur les opérations de prélèvement. Cependant, ils étudient la différence des performances avec les positionnements passés et actuels. La littérature démontre clairement que cela apporte des avantages en termes d’efficacité. Toutefois, les déplacements nécessaires pour passer d’une position à une autre peuvent constituer une activité très exigeante. Ceci constitue le second volet de cette thèse qui présente des avancées intéressantes sur le problème de repositionnement des produits dans la zone de prélèvement. Nous présentons le problème de repositionnement des produits sous une forme encore peu étudiée aux meilleurs de nos connaissances : le problème de repositionnement. Plus précisément, nous étudions la charge de travail requise pour passer d’une configuration à l’autre. Cette thèse est structuré comme suit. L’introduction présente les caractéristiques et les missions d’un système de distribution. Le chapitre 1 fournit un survol de la littérature sur les principales fonctions d’un centre de distribution et met l’accent sur la préparation des commandes et les décisions qui affectent cette opération. Le chapitre 2 est consacré à l’étude d’un problème de préparation de commandes en allées étroites avec des équipements de manutention contraignants. Dans le chapitre 3, nous étudions un problème de préparation des commandes où les caractéristiques des produits limitent fortement les routes de prélèvement. Le chapitre 4 présente une variante du problème de repositionnement (reassignment) avec une formulation originale pour le résoudre. La conclusion suit et résume les principales contributions de cette thèse. Mots clés : Préparation des commandes, entreposage, problèmes de routage, algorithmes exacts et heuristiques, réaffectation des produits, manutention.Distribution and warehousing activities are important pillars to an effective supply chain. They ensure the regulation of the operational flow and the synchronization of all actors in the network. Hence, distribution centers (DCs) act as crossover points between the supply, the production and the demand. The distribution includes a wide range of activities to ensure the integrity of the demand satisfaction. These activities range from the reception and storage of finished or semi-finished products to the preparation of orders and delivery. Distribution has been long seen as an operation with no or low added value; this has changed, and nowadays it is perceived as one of the critical areas for improvement. These activities are responsible for the satisfaction of an evolving market, requiring ever faster and more reliable delivery times, exact orders and highly customized products. This leads to an increased research interest on operations management focused on warehousing. For several years, we have witnessed strong advances in warehousing and order picking operations. The order picking activity is the process of retrieving items within the storage locations for the purpose of fulfilling orders. This problem has long been solved as a variant of the travelling salesman problem, where the order picker moves through aisles. However, modern warehouses with more and more product families may have special characteristics that make conventional methods irrelevant or inefficient. The first part of this thesis presents two practical and challenging material handling problems for the order picking within DCs. Since there are many research axes in the field of warehousing operations, we concentrated our efforts on the order picking problem and the repositioning of the products within the picking area. The order picking problem has been intensively studied in the literature. Our research widens the spectrum of this problem by including a set of characteristics associated with the physical facilities of the picking area and characteristics of the product, such as its weight, volume, category, fragility, etc. This means that a more applied perspective on the reality of operations is used in our algorithms development. The order picking workload is strongly influenced by the positioning of the products. The position of products within the picking area is determined by a storage assignment strategy. Many of these strategies use product sales information in order to facilitate access to the most popular items. In today’s competitive environment, the profitable lifetime of a product can be relatively short. The positioning provided by yesterday’s assignment is likely not the optimal one in the near future. There are several studies measuring the impact of a good reassignment of products on the picking operations. However, they study the difference between the two states of systems on the picking time. It is clear that this brings benefits. However, moving from one position to another is a very workload demanding activity. This constitutes the second part of this thesis which presents interesting advances on the repositioning of products within the picking area. We introduce the repositioning problem as an innovative way of improving performance, in what we call the reassignment problem. More specifically, we study the workload required to move from one setup to the next. This thesis is structured as follows. The introduction presents the characteristics and missions of a distribution system. Chapter 1 presents an overview of the literature on the main functions of a DC and emphasizes on order picking and decisions affecting this operation. Chapter 2 is devoted to the study of a picking problem with narrow aisles facilities and binding material handling equipment. In Chapter 3, we study the picking problem with a set of product features that strongly constrain the picking sequence. Chapter 4 presents a variant of the reassignment problem with a strong and new formulation to solve it. The conclusion follows and summarizes the main contributions of this thesis. Key words: Order-picking, warehousing, routing problems, exact and heuristic algorithms, products reassignment, material handling

Order Picking Optimization in a Distribution Center

This study focuses on the order picking process of a distribution center (DC) supplying locomotive and railroad car parts. The DC employs a manual picker-to-parts system where pickers move on foot or by vehicular means. Efficiency of an order picking process in such a DC mainly depends on three problems when the layout of the DC is given: the storage location assignment problem (SLAP), the order batching problem and the order picker routing problem. This study focuses on the aggregate effect three major decisions have on order picking performance in a manual picker-to-parts warehouse. To study the effects of these three sub-problems, we create a framework that allows us to run simulated scenarios with different approaches to these problems. To solve the SLAP, we employ a hybrid of class-based and family grouping methods by enhancing a class-based SKU location assignment with modern clustering techniques. To further improve the order picking process, we experiment with various order batching methods. We use picker routing heuristics to evaluate combinations of the storage location assignments and batching procedures. Over a set of order lines to be fulfilled, the objective function is be the aggregate distance covered over the warehouse floor. We show that distance savings of more than 55% can be achieved by rearranging the DC. Moreover, we show that stock keeping unit (SKU) clustering can improve the performance of class-based storage location assignments and that even simple order batching algorithms are likely to improve order picking performance significantly. Based on the framework, we develop a tool set that encompasses the aspects concerning the DC’s order picking process. The solution will be implemented into a cloud-computing environment, allowing for real-time tracking of the DC’s order picking efficiency and the generation of visual tools that help move SKUs to desirable shelf locations and batch orders