Hepatitis C Virus: Structural Insights into Protease Inhibitor Efficacy and Drug Resistance: A Dissertation

The Hepatitis C Virus (HCV) is a global health problem as it afflicts an estimated 170 million people worldwide and is the major cause of viral hepatitis, cirrhosis and liver cancer. HCV is a rapidly evolving virus, with 6 major genotypes and multiple subtypes. Over the past 20 years, HCV therapeutic efforts have focused on identifying the best-in-class direct acting antiviral (DAA) targeting crucial components of the viral lifecycle, The NS3/4A protease is responsible for processing the viral polyprotein, a crucial step in viral maturation, and for cleaving host factors involved in activating immunity. Thus targeting the NS3/4A constitutes a dual strategy of restoring the immune response and halting viral maturation. This high priority target has 4 FDA approved inhibitors as well as several others in clinical development. Unfortunately, the heterogeneity of the virus causes seriously therapeutic challenges, particularly the NS3/4A protease inhibitors (PIs), which suffer from both the rapid emergence of drug resistant mutants as well as a lack of pan-genotypic activity. My thesis research focused on filling two critical gaps in our structural understanding of inhibitor binding modes. The first gap in knowledge is the molecular basis by which macrocyclization of PIs improves antiviral activity. Macrocycles are hydrophobic chains used to link neighboring chemical moieties within an inhibitor and create a structurally pre-organized ligand. In HCV PIs, macrocycle come in two forms: a P1 - P3 and P2 - P4 strategy. I investigated the structural and thermodynamic basis of the role of macrocyclization in reducing resistance susceptibility. For a rigorous comparison, we designed and synthesized both a P1 - P3 and a linear analog of grazoprevir, a P2 - P4 inhibitor. I found that, while the P2 - P4 strategy is more favorable for achieving potency, it does not allow the inhibitor sufficient flexibility to accommodate resistance mutations. On the other hand, the P1 - P3 strategy strikes a better balance between potency and resistance barrier. The second gap my thesis addresses is elucidating the structural basis by which highly potent protease inhibitors function in genotype 1 but not in genotype 3, despite having an 87% sequence similarity. After mapping the amino acids responsible for this differential efficacy in genotypes 1 and 3, I engineered a 1a3a chimeric protease for crystallographic studies. My structural characterization of three PIs in complex with both the 1a3a and genotype 1 protease revealed that the loss of inhibitor efficacy in the 1a3a and GT-3 proteases is a consequence of disrupted electrostatic interactions between amino acids 168 and 155, which is critical for potent binding of quinoline and isoindoline based PIs. Here, I have revealed details of molecular and structural basis for the lack of PI efficacy against GT-3, which are needed for design of pan-genotypic inhibitors

Mechanisms of Substrate Recognition by HCV NS3/4A Protease Provide Insights Into Drug Resistance: A Dissertation

HCV afflicts many millions of people globally, and antiviral therapies are often ineffective and intolerable. The Food and Drug Administration approved the HCV protease inhibitors telaprevir and boceprevir in May 2011, marking an important milestone in anti-HCV research over the past two decades. Nevertheless, severe drug side effects of combination therapy – flu-like symptoms, depression and anemia – limit patient adherence to treatment regimens. The acquisition of resistance challenges the long-term efficacy of antiviral therapies, including protease inhibitors, as suboptimal dosing allows for the selection of drug resistant viral variants. A better understanding of the molecular basis of drug resistance is therefore central to developing future generation protease inhibitors that retain potency against a broader spectrum of HCV strains. To this end, my research characterizes the molecular basis of drug resistance against HCV protease inhibitors. Chapter II defines the mode of substrate recognition by the common volume shared by NS3/4A substrate products – the substrate envelope. Chapter III then correlates patterns of drug resistance to regions where drugs protrude from the substrate envelope. Lastly, Chapter IV elucidates the molecular underpinnings of resistance against four leading protease inhibitors – telaprevir, danoprevir, vaniprevir and MK-5172 – and provides practical approaches to designing novel drugs that are less susceptible to resistance. I ultimately hope my work appeals to the broader biomedical community of virologists, medicinal chemists and clinicians, who struggle to understand HCV and other human pathogens in the face of rapid disease evolution

Hepatitis C Virus Non-Structural Protein 3/4A: A Tale of Two Domains: A Dissertation

Two decades after the discovery of the Hepatitis C Virus (HCV), Hepatitis C infection still persists to be a global health problem. With the recent approval of the first set of directly acting antivirals (DAAs), the rate of sustained viral response for HCV-infected patients increased significantly. However, a complete cure has not been found yet. Drug development efforts primarily target NS3/4A protease, bifunctional serine protease-RNA helicase of HCV. HCV NS3/4A is critical in viral function; protease domain processes the viral polyprotein and helicase domain aids replication of HCV genome by unwinding double stranded RNA transcripts produced by NS5B, RNA-dependent RNA polymerase of HCV. Protease and helicase domains can be isolated, expressed and purified separately while retaining function. Isolated domains of HCV NS3/4A have been extensively used in biochemical and biophysical studies for scientific and therapeutic purposes to evaluate functional capability and mechanism. However, these domains are highly interdependent and modulate the activities of each other bidirectionally. Interdomain dependence was demonstrated in comparative studies where activities of isolated domains versus the full length protein were evaluated. Nevertheless, specific factors affecting interdependence have not been thoroughly studied. Chapter II investigates the domain-domain interface formed between protease and helicase domains as a determinant in interdependence. Molecular dynamics simulations performed on single chain NS3/4A constructs demonstrated the importance of interface in the coupled dynamics of the two domains. The role of the interface in interdomain communication was experimentally probed by disrupting the domain-domain interface through Ala-scanning mutations in selected residues in the interface with significant buried surface areas. These interface mutants were assayed for both helicase and protease related activities. Instead of downregulating the activities of either domain, interface mutants caused enhancement of protease and helicase activities. In addition, the interface had minimal effect in RNA unwinding activity of the helicase domain, the mere presence of the protease domain was the main protagonist in elevated RNA unwinding activity. In conclusion, I suspect that the interface formed between the domains is transient in nature and plays a regulatory role more than a functional role. In addition, I found results supporting the suggestion that an alternate domain-domain arrangement other than what is observed in crystal structures is the active, biologically relevant conformation for both the helicase and the protease. Chapter III investigates structural features of HCV NS3/4A protease inhibitors in relation to effects on inhibitor potency, susceptibility to drug resistance and modulation of potency by the helicase domain. Nearly all NS3/4A protease inhibitors share common features, with major differences only in bulky P2 extension groups and macrocyclization statuses. Enzymatic inhibition profiles of different drugs were analyzed for wildtype isolated protease domain and single chain NS3/4A helicase-protease construct, their multi drug resistant variants, and additional helicase mutants. Inhibitor potency was mainly influenced by macrocyclization, where macrocyclic drugs were significantly more potent compared to acyclic variants. Potency loss with respect to resistance mutations primarily depended on the P2 extension, while macrocyclization had minimal effect except for P2-P4 macrocyclic compounds which were up to an order of magnitude more susceptible to mutations A156T and, in lesser extent, D168A. Modulation by helicase domain was also dependent on P2 extension, although opposite trends were observed for danoprevir analogs versus others. In conclusion, this study provides a basis for future inhibitor development in both avoiding drug resistance and exploitation of the helicase domain for additional efficacy. In this thesis, I have provided evidence further supporting and revealing the details of domain-domain dependency in HCV NS3/4A. Lessons learned here will aid future research for dissecting the interdependency to gain a better understanding of HCV NS3/4A function, which can possibly be extended to all Flaviviridae NS3 protease-helicase complexes. In addition, interdomain dependence can be exploited in future drug development efforts to create better drugs that will pave the way to an effective cure

Resistance from Afar: Distal Mutation V36M Allosterically Modulates the Active Site to Accentuate Drug Resistance in HCV NS3/4A Protease [preprint]

Hepatitis C virus rapidly evolves, conferring resistance to direct acting antivirals. While resistance via active site mutations in the viral NS3/4A protease has been well characterized, the mechanism for resistance of non-active site mutations is unclear. R155K and V36M often co-evolve and while R155K alters the electrostatic network at the binding site, V36M is more than 13 Angstrom away. In this study the mechanism by which V36M confers resistance, in the context of R155K, is elucidated with drug susceptibility assays, crystal structures, and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations for three protease inhibitors: telaprevir, boceprevir and danoprevir. The R155K and R155K/V36M crystal structures differ in the α-2 helix and E2 strand near the active site, with alternative conformations at M36 and side chains of active site residues D168 and R123, revealing an allosteric coupling, which persists dynamically in MD simulations, between the distal mutation and the active site. This allosteric modulation validates the network hypothesis and elucidates how distal mutations confer resistance through propagation of conformational changes to the active site

Avoiding Drug Resistance by Substrate Envelope-Guided Design: Toward Potent and Robust HCV NS3/4A Protease Inhibitors

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infects millions of people worldwide, causing chronic liver disease that can lead to cirrhosis, hepatocellular carcinoma, and liver transplant. In the last several years, the advent of direct-acting antivirals, including NS3/4A protease inhibitors (PIs), has remarkably improved treatment outcomes of HCV-infected patients. However, selection of resistance-associated substitutions and polymorphisms among genotypes can lead to drug resistance and in some cases treatment failure. A proactive strategy to combat resistance is to constrain PIs within evolutionarily conserved regions in the protease active site. Designing PIs using the substrate envelope is a rational strategy to decrease the susceptibility to resistance by using the constraints of substrate recognition. We successfully designed two series of HCV NS3/4A PIs to leverage unexploited areas in the substrate envelope to improve potency, specifically against resistance-associated substitutions at D168. Our design strategy achieved better resistance profiles over both the FDA-approved NS3/4A PI grazoprevir and the parent compound against the clinically relevant D168A substitution. Crystallographic structural analysis and inhibition assays confirmed that optimally filling the substrate envelope is critical to improve inhibitor potency while avoiding resistance. Specifically, inhibitors that enhanced hydrophobic packing in the S4 pocket and avoided an energetically frustrated pocket performed the best. Thus, the HCV substrate envelope proved to be a powerful tool to design robust PIs, offering a strategy that can be translated to other targets for rational design of inhibitors with improved potency and resistance profiles.IMPORTANCE Despite significant progress, hepatitis C virus (HCV) continues to be a major health problem with millions of people infected worldwide and thousands dying annually due to resulting complications. Recent antiviral combinations can achieve \u3e 95% cure, but late diagnosis, low access to treatment, and treatment failure due to drug resistance continue to be roadblocks against eradication of the virus. We report the rational design of two series of HCV NS3/4A protease inhibitors with improved resistance profiles by exploiting evolutionarily constrained regions of the active site using the substrate envelope model. Optimally filling the S4 pocket is critical to avoid resistance and improve potency. Our results provide drug design strategies to avoid resistance that are applicable to other quickly evolving viral drug targets

Structural characterization of the Hepatitis C Virus NS3 protease from genotype 3a: The basis of the genotype 1b vs. 3a inhibitor potency shift

AbstractThe first structural characterization of the genotype 3a Hepatitis C Virus NS3 protease is reported, providing insight into the differential susceptibility of 1b and 3a proteases to certain inhibitors. Interaction of the 3a NS3 protease with a P2–P4 macrocyclic and a linear phenethylamide inhibitor was investigated. In addition, the effect of the NS4A cofactor binding on the conformation of the protease was analyzed. Complexation of NS3 with the phenethylamide inhibitor significantly stabilizes the protease but binding does not involve residues 168 and 123, two key amino acids underlying the different inhibition of genotype 1b vs. 3a proteases by P2–P4 macrocycles. Therefore, we studied the dynamic behavior of these two residues in the phenethylamide complex, serving as a model of the situation in the apo 3a protein, in order to explore the structural basis of the inhibition potency shift between the proteases of the genotypes 1b and 3a

Structure and Dynamics of Viral Substrate Recognition and Drug Resistance: A Dissertation

Drug resistance is a major problem in quickly evolving diseases, including the human immunodeficiency (HIV) and hepatitis C viral (HCV) infections. The viral proteases (HIV protease and HCV NS3/4A protease) are primary drug targets. At the molecular level, drug resistance reflects a subtle change in the balance of molecular recognition; the drug resistant protease variants are no longer effectively inhibited by the competitive drug molecules but can process the natural substrates with enough efficiency for viral survival. Therefore, the inhibitors that better mimic the natural substrate binding features should result in more robust inhibitors with flat drug resistance profiles. The native substrates adopt a consensus volume when bound to the enzyme, the substrate envelope. The most severe resistance mutations occur at protease residues that are contacted by the inhibitors outside the substrate envelope. To guide the design of robust inhibitors, we investigate the shared and varied properties of substrates with the protein dynamics taken into account to define the dynamic substrate envelope of both viral proteases. The NS3/4A dynamic substrate envelope is compared with inhibitors to detect the structural and dynamic basis of resistance mutation patterns. Comparative analyses of substrates and inhibitors result in a solid list of structural and dynamic features of substrates that are not shared by inhibitors. This study can help guiding the development of novel inhibitors by paying attention to the subtle differences between the binding properties of substrates versus inhibitors

Update on hepatitis C virus resistance to direct-acting antiviral agents

Review[Abstract] Resistance to direct-acting antiviral (DAA) agents against hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection is driven by the selection of mutations at different positions in the NS3 protease, NS5B polymerase and NS5A proteins. With the exception of NS5B nucleos(t)ide inhibitors, most DAAs possess a low genetic barrier to resistance, with significant cross-resistance between compounds belonging to the same family. However, a specific mutation profile is associated with each agent or drug class and varies depending on the genotype/subtype (e.g., genotype 1b showed higher rates of sustained virological response (SVR) and a higher genetic barrier for resistance than genotype 1a). Moreover, some resistance mutations exist as natural polymorphisms in certain genotypes/subtypes at frequencies that require baseline drug resistance testing before recommending certain antivirals. For example, the polymorphism Q80K is frequently found among genotype 1a (19–48%) and is associated with resistance to simeprevir. Similarly, L31M and Y93H, key resistance mutations to NS5A inhibitors, are frequently found (6–12%) among NS5A genotype 1 sequences. In particular, the presence of these polymorphisms may be of relevance in poorly interferon-responsive patients (i.e., null responders and non-CC IL28B) under DAA-based therapies in combination with pegylated interferon-α plus ribavirin. The relevance of pre-existing resistance mutations for responses to interferon-free DAA therapies is unclear for most regimens and requires further study.Instituto de Salud Carlos III; CP08/00214Instituto de Salud Carlos III; PI10/0216

Targeting Drug Resistance In HCV NS3/4A Protease: Mechanisms And Inhibitor Design Strategies

The Hepatitis C virus (HCV) NS3/4A protease inhibitors (PIs) have become a mainstay of newer all-oral combination therapies. Despite improvements in potency of this inhibitor class, drug resistance remains a problem with the rapid emergence of resistance-associated substitutions (RASs). In this thesis I elucidate the molecular mechanisms of drug resistance for PIs against a resistant variant and apply insights toward the design of inhibitors with improved resistance profiles using structural, biochemical and computational techniques. Newer generation PIs retain high potency against most single substitutions in the protease active site by stacking on the catalytic triad. I investigated the molecular mechanisms of resistance against the Y56H/D168A variant. My analysis revealed that the Y56H substitution disrupts these inhibitors’ favorable stacking interactions with the catalytic residue His57. To further address the impact of drug resistance, I designed new inhibitors that minimize contact with known drug resistance residues that are unessential in substrate recognition. The initially designed inhibitors exhibited flatter resistance profiles than the newer generation PIs but lost potency against the D168A variant. Finally, I designed inhibitors to extend into the substrate envelope (SE) and successfully regained potency against RAS variants maintaining a flat profile. These inhibitors both pack well in the enzyme and fit within the SE. Together these studies elucidate the molecular mechanisms of PI resistance and highlight the importance of substrate recognition in inhibitor design. The insights from this thesis provide strategies toward the development of diverse NS3/4A PIs that may one day lead to the eradication of HCV