6 research outputs found
Algebras for Agent Norm-Regulation
An abstract architecture for idealized multi-agent systems whose behaviour is
regulated by normative systems is developed and discussed. Agent choices are
determined partially by the preference ordering of possible states and
partially by normative considerations: The agent chooses that act which leads
to the best outcome of all permissible actions. If an action is non-permissible
depends on if the result of performing that action leads to a state satisfying
a condition which is forbidden, according to the norms regulating the
multi-agent system. This idea is formalized by defining set-theoretic
predicates characterizing multi-agent systems. The definition of the predicate
uses decision theory, the Kanger-Lindahl theory of normative positions, and an
algebraic representation of normative systems.Comment: 25 page
Towards automatisation of the Swedish property formation process:A structural and logical analysis of property subdivision
The ongoing digitalization of public administration and increased automation of legal decision-making bears promise to benefit citizens, businesses and other stakeholders through simpler and more efficient civil processes, and thus has great impact on the urban planning and building process. However, automation of decision-making that is directed or constrained by normative systems such as laws, regulations and policies, requires a detailed and accurate representation of these concepts and their constituent parts, and the domain to which they are applied. In this paper, we combine two perspectives on formalisation and classification of legal relations within the urban planning and building domain. In a cross-disciplinary fashion, we analyse and describe a small part of this domain at a higher level of abstraction and formalization using two different analysis instruments. Using these tools, we perform structural and conceptual as well as logical analyses of two specific snapshots of a fictitious property subdivision case in Sweden, focusing on the legal relations between different entities and parties involved in the specific situations. The structural analysis uses the Land Administration Domain Model ISO 19152:2012 standard formalism, and the logical analysis is based on the notion of atomic types of legal relations. We discuss some of the strengths and weaknesses of the two tools regarding the formal representation of rights, restrictions and responsibilities of different parties in the land administration domain, as well as how the tools relate to each other and how they can be aligned. We thus take one step towards a deeper understanding of the domain, and identify areas for future research that may provide better conditions for efficient and transparent use of geospatial information, and automation of the property subdivision process and other related civil processes
Social Order and Adaptability in Animal and Human Cultures as Analogues for Agent Communities: Toward a Policy-Based Approach
Abstract. In this paper we discuss some of the ways social order is maintained in animal and human realms, with the goal of enriching our thinking about mechanisms that might be employed in developing similar means of ordering communities of agents. We present examples from our current work in human-agent teamwork, and we speculate about some new directions this kind of research might take. Since communities also need to change over time to cope with changing circumstances, we also speculate on means that regulatory bodies can use to adapt. 1
Trusted computing or trust in computing? Legislating for trust networks
This thesis aims to address several issues emerging in the new digital world. Using Trusted Computing as the paradigmatic example of regulation though code that tries to address the cyber security problem that occurs, where the freedom of the user to reconfigure her machine is restricted in exchange for greater, yet not perfect, security. Trusted Computing is a technology that while it aims to protect the user, and the integrity of her machine and her privacy against third party users, it discloses more of her information to trusted third parties, exposing her to security risks in case of compromising occurring to that third party. It also intends to create a decentralized, bottom up solution to security where security follows along the arcs of an emergent ânetwork of trustâ, and if that was viable, to achieve a form of code based regulation. Through the analysis attempted in this thesis, we laid the groundwork for a refined assessment, considering the problems that Trusted Computing Initiative (TCI) faces and that are based in the intentional, systematic but sometimes misunderstood and miscommunicated difference (which as we reveal results directly in certain design choices for TC) between the conception of trust in informatics (âtechno-trustâ) and the common sociological concept of it. To reap the benefits of TCI and create the dynamic ânetwork of trustâ, we need the sociological concept of trust sharing the fundamental characteristics of transitivity and holism which are absent from techno-trust.
This gives rise to our next visited problems which are: if TC shifts the power from the customer to the TC provider, who takes on roles previously reserved for the nation state, then how in a democratic state can users trust those that make the rules? The answer lies partly in constitutional and human rights law and we drill into those functions of TC that makes the TCI provider comparable to state-like and ask what minimal legal guarantees need to be in place to accept, trustingly, this shift of power. Secondly, traditional liberal contract law reduces complex social relations to binary exchange relations, which are not transitive and disrupt rather than create networks. Contract law, as we argue, plays a central role for the way in which the TC provider interacts with his customers and this thesis contributes in speculating of a contract law that does not result in atomism, rather âbrings inâ potentially affected third parties and results in holistic networks. In the same vein, this thesis looks mainly at specific ways in which law can correct or redefine the implicit and democratically not validated shift of power from customer to TC providers while enhancing the social environment and its social trust within which TC must operate
Mobile, intelligent and autonomous policing tools and the law
This thesis resolves
around problems arising for the existing
legal framework from the use of
novel software-Ââbased
policing tools during criminal
investigations. The
increasing dependence on information and
communication technologies and the Internet means
that more aspects of peopleâs lives move online, and
crime follows them. This has triggered the development
of innovative, autonomous investigative technologies that
are increasingly replacing human officers for the policing
of the online sphere. While only recently discussions of
the legal status of embodied and unembodied robotical
devices have gained more widespread attention, discussions
of the legal status of autonomous agent technology are not
new. They have focussed however in the past on applications
in the private domain, enabling contract formation online. No
systematic study has so far been carried out that looks at the
use of autonomous agent technology when deployed by state
actors, to fulfil core state functions. This thesis starts with the
hypothesis that the use of automated, intelligent devices to
replicate core police functions in the online world will increase
in the future. Looking at first emerging technologies, but with an
eye
towards
future
deployment
of
much
more
capable
software
tools
that
fulfil
policing
functions
on
the
Internet,
this
thesis
looks
at
the
challenges
this
poses
for
regulators
and
software
developers.
Based
on
extensive
qualitative
research
interviews
with
stakeholders
from
two
different
jurisdictions
(Germany
&
UK)
this
thesis
finds
that
these
novel
policing
technologies
challenge
existing
legal
frameworks,
which
are
still
premised
on
the
parameters
of
the
offline
world.
It
therefore
develops
an
alternative
governance
model
for
these
policing
tools,
which
enables
their
law-Ââcompliant
use
and
prevents
rights
violations
of
suspects.
In
doing
so
it
draws
upon
both
worlds,
the
technical
and
the
legal,
while
also
incorporating
the
empirical
research
results
from
the
interviews
with
experts.
The
first
part
of
this
thesis
analyses
the
technical
foundations
of
these
software-Ââbased
policing
tools.
Here,
one
of
the
key
findings
is
that
the
current
governance
system
focuses
on
ex-Ââante
authorisation
of
very
specific,
individual
software
tools
without
developing
a
systematic
classification.
This contradicts the principle of sustainable law making. To overcome this piecemeal approach,
as a first contribution to existing research this work defines a new class of investigative technologies
â mobile, intelligent and autonomous (MIA) policing tools â based on the findings of the technical
analysis. Identifying such a natural class of present and future technologies that pose the same type
of legal issues should facilitate the sustainable governance of these new policing tools. The second
part of this thesis analyses two specific legal issues: cross-Âjurisdictional investigations and the
evidentiary value of the seized data. These issues were identified as most pressing by the
experts interviewed for this work. This analysis reveals that investigative activities of MIA tools
are potentially in conflict with international law principles and criminal procedure law.
In order to gain legitimacy, these new policing tools need to operate within the parameters
of the existing legal framework. This thesis argues that given the unique technical capabilities
of MIA tools, the primary approach to achieving this is to assign legal responsibility to these
tools. The third part of this thesis develops
a novel governance approach to ensure that MIA tools operate within the parameters of the legal framework,
and therefore obtain legitimacy and relevance, also with regard
to the investigative results. This approach builds on existing research identifying
code as a regulatory modality and contributes to the field of legal
theory. It constitutes a solution for the governance problems of
MIA tools, however, it requires currently
lacking collaboration among stakeholders
and cross-Âdisciplinary research
Allgemeine GeschÀftsbedingungen in Peer-to-Peer-MÀrkten
Die Arbeit behandelt elektronische MarktplĂ€tze, die ohne eine zentrale Instanz auskommen und allein durch die Marktteilnehmer entstehen. Sie bietet technische AnsĂ€tze und deren rechtliche Beurteilung, um den Zugangsnachweis fĂŒr ErklĂ€rungen fĂŒhren zu können und behandelt wie Rechner zur Rechtsfolgenermittlung eingesetzt werden können, um den Nutzer fĂŒr den Vertragsentwurf und -abschluss einzelfallbezogenes rechtliches Expertenwissen zur VerfĂŒgung stellen zu können