An Experimental Study of Reduced-Voltage Operation in Modern FPGAs for Neural Network Acceleration

We empirically evaluate an undervolting technique, i.e., underscaling the circuit supply voltage below the nominal level, to improve the power-efficiency of Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) accelerators mapped to Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs). Undervolting below a safe voltage level can lead to timing faults due to excessive circuit latency increase. We evaluate the reliability-power trade-off for such accelerators. Specifically, we experimentally study the reduced-voltage operation of multiple components of real FPGAs, characterize the corresponding reliability behavior of CNN accelerators, propose techniques to minimize the drawbacks of reduced-voltage operation, and combine undervolting with architectural CNN optimization techniques, i.e., quantization and pruning. We investigate the effect of environmental temperature on the reliability-power trade-off of such accelerators. We perform experiments on three identical samples of modern Xilinx ZCU102 FPGA platforms with five state-of-the-art image classification CNN benchmarks. This approach allows us to study the effects of our undervolting technique for both software and hardware variability. We achieve more than 3X power-efficiency (GOPs/W) gain via undervolting. 2.6X of this gain is the result of eliminating the voltage guardband region, i.e., the safe voltage region below the nominal level that is set by FPGA vendor to ensure correct functionality in worst-case environmental and circuit conditions. 43% of the power-efficiency gain is due to further undervolting below the guardband, which comes at the cost of accuracy loss in the CNN accelerator. We evaluate an effective frequency underscaling technique that prevents this accuracy loss, and find that it reduces the power-efficiency gain from 43% to 25%.Comment: To appear at the DSN 2020 conferenc

An experimental study of reduced-voltage operation in modern FPGAs for neural network acceleration

We empirically evaluate an undervolting technique, i.e., underscaling the circuit supply voltage below the nominal level, to improve the power-efficiency of Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) accelerators mapped to Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs). Undervolting below a safe voltage level can lead to timing faults due to excessive circuit latency increase. We evaluate the reliability-power trade-off for such accelerators. Specifically, we experimentally study the reduced-voltage operation of multiple components of real FPGAs, characterize the corresponding reliability behavior of CNN accelerators, propose techniques to minimize the drawbacks of reduced-voltage operation, and combine undervolting with architectural CNN optimization techniques, i.e., quantization and pruning. We investigate the effect ofenvironmental temperature on the reliability-power trade-off of such accelerators. We perform experiments on three identical samples of modern Xilinx ZCU102 FPGA platforms with five state-of-the-art image classification CNN benchmarks. This approach allows us to study the effects of our undervolting technique for both software and hardware variability. We achieve more than 3X power-efficiency (GOPs/W ) gain via undervolting. 2.6X of this gain is the result of eliminating the voltage guardband region, i.e., the safe voltage region below the nominal level that is set by FPGA vendor to ensure correct functionality in worst-case environmental and circuit conditions. 43% of the power-efficiency gain is due to further undervolting below the guardband, which comes at the cost of accuracy loss in the CNN accelerator. We evaluate an effective frequency underscaling technique that prevents this accuracy loss, and find that it reduces the power-efficiency gain from 43% to 25%.The work done for this paper was partially supported by a HiPEAC Collaboration Grant funded by the H2020 HiPEAC Project under grant agreement No. 779656. The research leading to these results has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Programme under the LEGaTO Project (www.legato-project.eu), grant agreement No. 780681.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

Aggressive undervolting of FPGAs : power & reliability trade-offs

In this work, we evaluate aggressive undervolting, i.e., voltage underscaling below the nominal level to reduce the energy consumption of Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs). Usually, voltage guardbands are added by chip vendors to ensure the worst-case process and environmental scenarios. Through experimenting on several FPGA architectures, we con¿rm a large voltage guardband for several FPGA components, which in turn, delivers signi¿cant power savings. However, further undervolting below the voltage guardband may cause reliability issues as the result of the circuit delay increase, and faults might start to appear. We extensively characterize the behavior of these faults in terms of the rate, location, type, as well as sensitivity to environmental temperature, primarily focusing on FPGA on-chip memories, or Block RAMs (BRAMs). Understanding this behavior can allow to deploy ef¿cient mitigation techniques, and in turn, FPGA-based designs can be improved for better energy, reliability, and performance trade-offs. Finally, as a case study, we evaluate a typical FPGA-based Neural Network (NN) accelerator when the FPGA voltage is underscaled. In consequence, the substantial NN energy savings come with the cost of NN accuracy loss. To attain power savings without NN accuracy loss below the voltage guardband gap, we proposed an application-aware technique and we also, evaluated the built-in Error-Correcting Code (ECC) mechanism. Hence, First, we developed an application-dependent BRAMs placement technique that relies on the deterministic behavior of undervolting faults, and mitigates these faults by mapping the most reliability sensitive NN parameters to BRAM blocks that are relatively more resistant to undervolting faults. Second, as a more general technique, we applied the built-in ECC of BRAMs and observed a signi¿cant fault coverage capability thanks to the behavior of undervolting faults, with a negligible power consumption overhead.En este trabajo, evaluamos el reducir el voltaje en forma agresiva, es decir, bajar la tensión por debajo del nivel nominal para reducir el consumo de energía en Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGA). Por lo general, los vendedores de chips establecen margen de seguridad al voltaje para garantizar el funcionamiento de los mismos en el peor de los casos y en los peores escenarios ambientales. Mediante la experimentación en varias arquitecturas FPGA, confirmamos que hay un margen de seguridad de voltaje grande en varios de los componentes de la FPGA, que a su vez, nos ofrece ahorros de energía significativos. Sin embargo, un trabajar a un voltaje por debajo del margen de seguridad del voltaje puede causar problemas de confiabilidad a medida ya que aumenta el retardo del circuito y pueden comenzar a aparecer fallos. Caracterizamos ampliamente el comportamiento de estos fallos en términos de velocidad, ubicación, tipo, así como la sensibilidad a la temperatura ambiental, centrándonos principalmente en memorias internas de la FPGA, o Block RAM (BRAM). Comprender este comportamiento puede permitir el desarrollo de técnicas eficientes de mitigación y, a su vez, mejorar los diseños basados en FPGA para obtener ahorros en energía, una mayor confiabilidad y un mayor rendimiento. Finalmente, como caso de estudio, evaluamos un acelerador típico de Redes Neuronales basado en FPGA cuando el voltaje de la FPGA esta por debajo del nivel mínimo de seguridad. En consecuencia, los considerables ahorros de energía de la red neuronal vienen asociados con la pérdida de precisión de la red neuronal. Para obtener ahorros de energía sin una pérdida de precisión en la red neuronal por debajo del margen de seguridad del voltaje, proponemos una técnica que tiene en cuenta la aplicación, asi mismo, evaluamos el mecanismo integrado en las BRAMs de Error Correction Code (ECC). Por lo tanto, en primer lugar, desarrollamos una técnica de colocación de BRAM dependiente de la aplicación que se basa en el comportamiento determinista de las fallos cuando la FPGA funciona por debajo del margen de seguridad, y se mitigan estos fallos asignando los parámetros de la red neuronal más sensibles a producir fallos a los bloques BRAM que son relativamente más resistentes a los fallos. En segundo lugar, como técnica más general, aplicamos el ECC incorporado de los BRAM y observamos una capacidad de cobertura de fallos significativo gracias a las características de comportamiento de fallos, con una sobrecoste de consumo de energía insignificantePostprint (published version