System Identification of Bipedal Locomotion in Robots and Humans

The ability to perform a healthy walking gait can be altered in numerous cases due to gait disorder related pathologies. The latter could lead to partial or complete mobility loss, which affects the patients’ quality of life. Wearable exoskeletons and active prosthetics have been considered as a key component to remedy this mobility loss. The control of such devices knows numerous challenges that are yet to be addressed. As opposed to fixed trajectories control, real-time adaptive reference generation control is likely to provide the wearer with more intent control over the powered device. We propose a novel gait pattern generator for the control of such devices, taking advantage of the inter-joint coordination in the human gait. Our proposed method puts the user in the control loop as it maps the motion of healthy limbs to that of the affected one. To design such control strategy, it is critical to understand the dynamics behind bipedal walking. We begin by studying the simple compass gait walker. We examine the well-known Virtual Constraints method of controlling bipedal robots in the image of the compass gait. In addition, we provide both the mechanical and control design of an affordable research platform for bipedal dynamic walking. We then extend the concept of virtual constraints to human locomotion, where we investigate the accuracy of predicting lower limb joints angular position and velocity from the motion of the other limbs. Data from nine healthy subjects performing specific locomotion tasks were collected and are made available online. A successful prediction of the hip, knee, and ankle joints was achieved in different scenarios. It was also found that the motion of the cane alone has sufficient information to help predict good trajectories for the lower limb in stairs ascent. Better estimates were obtained using additional information from arm joints. We also explored the prediction of knee and ankle trajectories from the motion of the hip joints

Adaptive control for wearable robots in human-centered rehabilitation tasks

Robotic rehabilitation therapies have been improving by providing the needed assistance to the patient, in a human-centered environment, and also helping the therapist to choose the necessary procedure. This thesis presents an adaptive "Assistance-as-needed" strategy which adheres to the specific needs of the patient and with the inputs from the therapist, whenever needed. The exertion of assistive and responsive behavior of the lower limb wearable robot is dedicated for the rehabilitation of incomplete spinal cord injury (SCI) patients. The main objective is to propose and evaluate an adaptive control model on a wearable robot, assisting the user and adhering to their needs, with no or less combination of external devices. The adaptation must be more interactive to understand the user needs and their volitional orders. Similarly, by using the existing muscular strength, in incomplete SCI patients, as a motivation to pursue the movement and assist them, only when needed. The adaptive behavior of the wearable robot is proposed by monitoring the interaction and movement of the user. This adaptation is achieved by modulating the stiffness of the exoskeleton in function of joint parameters, such as positions and interaction torques. These joint parameters are measured from the user independently and then used to update the new stiffness value. The adaptive algorithm performs with no need of external sensors, making it simple in terms of usage. In terms of rehabilitation, it is also desirable to be compatible with combination of assistive devices such as muscle stimulation, neural activity (BMI) and body balance (Wii), to deliver a user friendly and effective therapy. Combination of two control approaches has been employed, to improve the efficiency of the adaptive control model and was evaluated using a wearable lower limb exoskeleton device, H1. The control approaches, Hierarchical and Task based approach have been used to assist the patient as needed and simultaneously motivate the patient to pursue the therapy. Hierarchical approach facilitates combination of multiple devices to deliver an effective therapy by categorizing the control architecture in two layers, Low level and High level control. Task-based approaches engage in each task individually and allow the possibility to combine them at any point of time. It is also necessary to provide an interaction based approach to ensure the complete involvement of the user and for an effective therapy. By means of this dissertation, a task based adaptive control is proposed, in function of human-orthosis interaction, which is applied on a hierarchical control scheme. This control scheme is employed in a wearable robot, with the intention to be applied or accommodated to different pathologies, with its adaptive capabilities. The adaptive control model for gait assistance provides a comprehensive solution through a single implementation: Adaptation inside a gait cycle, continuous support through gait training and in real time. The performance of this control model has been evaluated with healthy subjects, as a preliminary study, and with paraplegic patients. Results of the healthy subjects showed a significant change in the pattern of the interaction torques, elucidating a change in the effort and adaptation to the user movement. In case of patients, the adaptation showed a significant improvement in the joint performance (flexion/extension range) and change in interaction torques. The change in interaction torques (positive to negative) reflects the active participation of the patient, which also explained the adaptive performance. The patients also reported that the movement of the exoskeleton is flexible and the walking patterns were similar to their own distinct patterns. The presented work is performed as part of the project HYPER, funded by Ministerio de Ciencia y Innovación, Spain. (CSD2009 - 00067 CONSOLIDER INGENIOLas terapias de rehabilitación robóticas han sido mejoradas gracias a la inclusión de la asistencia bajo demanda, adaptada a las variaciones de las necesidades del paciente, así como a la inclusión de la ayuda al terapeuta en la elección del procedimiento necesario. Esta tesis presenta una estrategia adaptativa de asistencia bajo demanda, la cual se ajusta a las necesidades específicas del paciente junto a las aportaciones del terapeuta siempre que sea necesario. El esfuerzo del comportamiento asistencial y receptivo del robot personal portátil para extremidades inferiores está dedicado a la rehabilitación de pacientes con lesión de la médula espinal (LME) incompleta. El objetivo principal es proponer y evaluar un modelo de control adaptativo en un robot portátil, ayudando al usuario y cumpliendo con sus necesidades, en ausencia o con reducción de dispositivos externos. La adaptación debe ser más interactiva para entender las necesidades del usuario y sus intenciones u órdenes volitivas. De modo similar, usando la fuerza muscular existente (en pacientes con LME incompleta) como motivación para lograr el movimiento y asistirles solo cuando sea necesario. El comportamiento adaptativo del robot portátil se propone mediante la monitorización de la interacción y movimiento del usuario. Esta adaptación conjunta se consigue modulando la rigidez en función de los parámetros de la articulación, tales como posiciones y pares de torsión. Dichos parámetros se miden del usuario de forma independiente y posteriormente se usan para actualizar el nuevo valor de la rigidez. El desempeño del algoritmo adaptativo no requiere de sensores externos, lo que favorece la simplicidad de su uso. Para una adecuada rehabilitación, efectiva y accesible para el usuario, es necesaria la compatibilidad con diversos mecanismos de asistencia tales como estimulación muscular, actividad neuronal y equilibrio corporal. Para mejorar la eficiencia del modelo de control adaptativo se ha empleado una combinación de dos enfoques de control, y para su evaluación se ha utilizado un exoesqueleto robótico H1. Los enfoques de control Jerárquico y de Tarea se han utilizado para ayudar al usuario según sea necesario, y al mismo tiempo motivarle para continuar el tratamiento. Enfoque jerárquico facilita la combinación de múltiples dispositivos para ofrecer un tratamiento eficaz mediante la categorización de la arquitectura de control en dos niveles : el control de bajo nivel y de alto nivel. Los enfoques basados en tareas involucran a la persona en cada tarea individual, y ofrecen la posibilidad de combinarlas en cualquier momento. También es necesario proporcionar un enfoque basado en la interacción con el usuario, para asegurar su participación y lograr así una terapia eficaz. Mediante esta tesis, proponemos un control adaptativo basado en tareas y en función de la interacción persona-ortesis, que se aplica en un esquema de control jerárquico. Este esquema de control se emplea en un robot portátil, con la intención de ser aplicado o acomodado a diferentes patologías, con sus capacidades de adaptación. El modelo de control adaptativo propuesto proporciona una solución integral a través de una única aplicación: adaptación dentro de la marcha y apoyo continúo a través de ejercicios de movilidad en tiempo real. El rendimiento del modelo se ha evaluado en sujetos sanos según un estudio preliminar, y posteriormente también en pacientes parapléjicos. Los resultados en sujetos sanos mostraron un cambio significativo en el patrón de los pares de interacción, elucidando un cambio en la energía y la adaptación al movimiento del usuario. En el caso de los pacientes, la adaptación mostró una mejora significativa en la actuación conjunta (rango de flexión / extensión) y el cambio en pares de interacción. El cambio activo en pares de interacción (positivo a negativo) refleja la participación activa del paciente, lo que también explica el comportamiento adaptativo

Optimizing User Integration for Individualized Rehabilitation

User integration with assistive devices or rehabilitation protocols to improve movement function is a key principle to consider for developers to truly optimize performance gains. Better integration may entail customizing operation of devices and training programs according to several user characteristics during execution of functional tasks. These characteristics may be physical dimensions, residual capabilities, restored sensory feedback, cognitive perception, or stereotypical actions

Otimização muscle-in-the-loop em tempo real para reabilitação física com um exosqueleto ativo: uma mudança de paradigma

Assisting human locomotion with a wearable robotic orthosis is still quite challenging, largely due to the complexity of the neuromusculoskeletal system, the time-varying dynamics that accompany motor adaptation, and the uniqueness of every individual’s response to the assistance given by the robot. To this day, these devices have not met their well-known promise yet, mostly due to the fact that they are not perfectly suitable for the rehabilitation of neuropathologic patients. One of the main challenges hampering this goal still relies on the interface and co-dependency between the human and the machine. Nowadays, most commercial exoskeletons replay pre-defined gait patterns, whereas research exoskeletons are switching to controllers based on optimized torque profiles. In most cases, the dynamics of the human musculoskeletal system are still ignored and do not take into account the optimal conditions for inducing a positive modulation of neuromuscular activity. This is because both rehabilitation strategies are still emphasized on the macro level of the whole joint instead of focusing on the muscles’ dynamics and activity, which are the actual anatomical elements that may need to be rehabilitated. Strategies to keep the human in the loop of the exoskeleton’s control laws in real-time may help to overcome these challenges. The main purpose of the present dissertation is to make a paradigm shift in the approach on how the assistance that is given to a subject by an exoskeleton is modelled and controlled during physical rehabilitation. Therefore, in the scope of the present work, it was intended to design, concede, implement, and validate a real-time muscle-in-the-loop optimization model to find the best assistive support ratio that would induce optimal rehabilitation conditions to a specific group of impaired muscles while having a minimum impact on the other healthy muscles. The developed optimization model was implemented in the form of a plugin and was integrated on a neuromechanical model-based interface for driving a bilateral ankle exoskeleton. Experimental pilot tests evaluated the feasibility and effectiveness of the model. Results of the most significant pilots achieved EMG reductions up to 61 ± 3 % in Soleus and 41 ± 10 % in Gastrocnemius Lateralis. Moreover, results also demonstrated the efficiency of the optimization’s specific reduction on rehabilitation by looking into the muscular fatigue after each experiment. Finally, two parallel preliminary studies emerged from the pilots, which looked at muscle adaptation, after a new assistive condition had been applied, over time and at the effect of the lateral positioning of the exoskeleton’s actuators on the leg muscles.Auxiliar a locomoção humana com uma ortose robótica ainda é bastante desafiante, em grande parte devido à complexidade do sistema neuromusculoesquelético, à dinâmica variável no tempo que acompanha a adaptação motora e à singularidade da resposta de cada indivíduo à assistência dada pelo robô. Até hoje, está por cumprir a promessa inicial destes dispositivos, principalmente devido ao facto de não serem perfeitamente adequados para a reabilitação de pacientes neuropatológicos. Um dos principais desafios que dificultam esse objetivo foca-se ainda na interface e na co-dependência entre o ser humano e a máquina. Hoje em dia, a maioria dos exoesqueletos comerciais reproduz padrões de marcha predefinidos, enquanto que os exoesqueletos em investigação estão só agora a mudar para controladores com base em perfis de binário otimizados. Na maioria dos casos, a dinâmica do sistema musculoesquelético humano ainda é ignorada e não tem em consideração as condições ideais para induzir uma modulação positiva da atividade neuromuscular. Isso ocorre porque ambas as estratégias de reabilitação ainda são enfatizadas no nível macro de toda a articulação, em vez de se concentrar na dinâmica e atividade dos músculos, que são os elementos anatómicos que realmente precisam de ser reabilitados. Estratégias para manter o ser humano em loop nos comandos que controlam o exoesqueleto em tempo real podem ajudar a superar estes desafios. O principal objetivo desta dissertação é fazer uma mudança de paradigma na abordagem em como a assistência que é dada a um sujeito por um exosqueleto é modelada e controlada durante a reabilitação física. Portanto, no contexto do presente trabalho, pretendeu-se projetar, conceder, implementar e validar um modelo de otimização muscle-in-the-loop em tempo real para encontrar a melhor relação de suporte capaz de induzir as condições ideais de reabilitação para um grupo específico de músculos fragilizados, tendo um impacto mínimo nos outros músculos saudáveis. O modelo de otimização desenvolvido foi implementado na forma de um plugin e foi integrado numa interface baseada num modelo neuromecânico para o controlo de um exoesqueleto bilateral de tornozelo. Testes experimentais piloto avaliaram a viabilidade e a eficácia do modelo. Os resultados dos testes mais significativos demonstraram reduções de EMG de até 61 ± 3 % no Soleus e 41 ± 10 % no Gastrocnemius Lateral. Adicionalmente, os resultados demonstraram também a eficiência em reabilitação da redução específica no EMG devido à otimização tendo em conta a fadiga muscular após cada teste. Finalmente, dois estudos preliminares paralelos emergiram dos testes piloto, que analisaram a adaptação muscular após uma nova condição assistiva ter sido definida ao longo do tempo e o efeito do posicionamento lateral dos atuadores do exoesqueleto nos músculos da perna.Mestrado em Engenharia Biomédic

Hand control of bipedal balance in quiet standing: implementations for lower extremity exoskeleton

Maintaining stable posture is important for humans, even though it is challenging because of our bipedal structure. One of the main balance related disorders is paraplegia due to spinal cord injury. People with a complete spinal cord injury have motor and sensory impairment that greatly reduces the ability to move their lower extremities. In recent years, lower extremity exoskeletons that apply torques generated by motors to the joints of the person have helped to them stand and walk. This research is a part of an extended project to build a new exoskeleton for use by individuals with paraplegia due to motor complete spinal cord injury. The goal of the project is to develop a device with an intuitive control mechanism capable of generating real time gait and balance. Commercial exoskeletons have achieved great steps regarding restoring ambulation. On the other hand, most of them do not actively support bipedal balance. In addition, commercially available exoskeletons except the REX need crutches to balance for people with motor complete paraplegia. The NJIT TREKKER, our laboratory’s research exoskeleton, suggests a novel, human-robot interface strategy that allows users to completely control and feel the trajectories of their exoskeleton-assisted feet, and be able to walk with considerably greater independence. The first study to develop TREKKER was performed before where a trekking pole was attached to each foot of a biped robot. Subjects controlled the trajectory of the foot of the biped by applying small forces to the trekking poles. The study proved that hands can produce trajectories similar to human foot trajectories when provided with haptic and visual feedback. If the hands and arms are effective surrogates for expressing ambulation, can they also be surrogates for natural balance in quiet standing? This is the main question that this dissertation answers. Importantly, this dissertation considers the ability of the arms and hands to make rapid adjustments to the center of pressure (COP) that will follow the center of mass (COM) and allow the person to retain balance to achieve this aim a perturbing system was constructed to study human body response to perturbations. Special shoes with small blocks attached to their soles were designed to study the capability of human body to adapt to base of support (BOS) reduction, and two special platforms with shoes on Pivots and two trekking poles attached to them were designed to study the effectiveness of using trekking poles. The pivots were used to eliminate the use of ankle strategy to retain balance by non-disabled subjects. In this study, subjects were asked to stand in front of the perturbing system and within the motion capture system’s field of view, then they were perturbed with at seven different forces with and without visual feedback in three different experiments: using regular shoes, the shoes with small blocks attached to their soles, and the shoes with pivots and trekking poles. Biomechanical parameters were studied to assess balance in A/P plane in each of the three experiments. The results suggest that the use of trekking poles is a viable approach to maintain balance during quiet standing. The main conclusion of this study is that using trekking poles is a good approach to maintain balance in quiet standing and as a response to small perturbations. Statistical analysis of SI, error signal peaks, and correlations comparing Pivots experiment to Regular experiment support this hypothesis. In addition, the high correlation coefficients between COM and COP of quiet standing on Pivots and in Pivots experiment with perturbations, and the high correlation coefficients of the correlation between COP and the trekking poles trajectories indicates that the trekking poles are working as a surrogate to the ankle joint. It is concluded that using the trekking poles, though the response to perturbations does not match the biological response, is good enough to maintain balance in quiet standing and perturbed quiet standing especially for small perturbations

Active robotic training improves locomotor function in a stroke survivor

Abstract Background Clinical outcomes after robotic training are often not superior to conventional therapy. One key factor responsible for this is the use of control strategies that provide substantial guidance. This strategy not only leads to a reduction in volitional physical effort, but also interferes with motor relearning. Methods We tested the feasibility of a novel training approach (active robotic training) using a powered gait orthosis (Lokomat) in mitigating post-stroke gait impairments of a 52-year-old male stroke survivor. This gait training paradigm combined patient-cooperative robot-aided walking with a target-tracking task. The training lasted for 4-weeks (12 visits, 3 × per week). The subject’s neuromotor performance and recovery were evaluated using biomechanical, neuromuscular and clinical measures recorded at various time-points (pre-training, post-training, and 6-weeks after training). Results Active robotic training resulted in considerable increase in target-tracking accuracy and reduction in the kinematic variability of ankle trajectory during robot-aided treadmill walking. These improvements also transferred to overground walking as characterized by larger propulsive forces and more symmetric ground reaction forces (GRFs). Training also resulted in improvements in muscle coordination, which resembled patterns observed in healthy controls. These changes were accompanied by a reduction in motor cortical excitability (MCE) of the vastus medialis, medial hamstrings, and gluteus medius muscles during treadmill walking. Importantly, active robotic training resulted in substantial improvements in several standard clinical and functional parameters. These improvements persisted during the follow-up evaluation at 6 weeks. Conclusions The results indicate that active robotic training appears to be a promising way of facilitating gait and physical function in moderately impaired stroke survivors.http://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/112853/1/12984_2011_Article_375.pd

Inverse Modeling of Human Knee Joint Based on Geometry and Vision Systems for Exoskeleton Applications

Current trends in Robotics aim to close the gap that separates technology and humans, bringing novel robotic devices in order to improve human performance. Although robotic exoskeletons represent a breakthrough in mobility enhancement, there are design challenges related to the forces exerted to the users’ joints that result in severe injuries. This occurs due to the fact that most of the current developments consider the joints as noninvariant rotational axes. This paper proposes the use of commercial vision systems in order to perform biomimetic joint design for robotic exoskeletons. This work proposes a kinematic model based on irregular shaped cams as the joint mechanism that emulates the bone-to-bone joints in the human body. The paper follows a geometric approach for determining the location of the instantaneous center of rotation in order to design the cam contours. Furthermore, the use of a commercial vision system is proposed as the main measurement tool due to its noninvasive feature and for allowing subjects under measurement to move freely. The application of this method resulted in relevant information about the displacements of the instantaneous center of rotation at the human knee joint

Human-robot interaction for assistive robotics

This dissertation presents an in-depth study of human-robot interaction (HRI) withapplication to assistive robotics. In various studies, dexterous in-hand manipulation is included, assistive robots for Sit-To-stand (STS) assistance along with the human intention estimation. In Chapter 1, the background and issues of HRI are explicitly discussed. In Chapter 2, the literature review introduces the recent state-of-the-art research on HRI, such as physical Human-Robot Interaction (HRI), robot STS assistance, dexterous in hand manipulation and human intention estimation. In Chapter 3, various models and control algorithms are described in detail. Chapter 4 introduces the research equipment. Chapter 5 presents innovative theories and implementations of HRI in assistive robotics, including a general methodology of robotic assistance from the human perspective, novel hardware design, robotic sit-to-stand (STS) assistance, human intention estimation, and control

Instrumentation and validation of a robotic cane for transportation and fall prevention in patients with affected mobility

Dissertação de mestrado integrado em Engenharia Física, (especialização em Dispositivos, Microssistemas e Nanotecnologias)O ato de andar é conhecido por ser a forma primitiva de locomoção do ser humano, sendo que este traz muitos benefícios que motivam um estilo de vida saudável e ativo. No entanto, há condições de saúde que dificultam a realização da marcha, o que por consequência pode resultar num agravamento da saúde, e adicionalmente, levar a um maior risco de quedas. Nesse sentido, o desenvolvimento de um sistema de deteção e prevenção de quedas, integrado num dispositivo auxiliar de marcha, seria essencial para reduzir estes eventos de quedas e melhorar a qualidade de vida das pessoas. Para ultrapassar estas necessidades e limitações, esta dissertação tem como objetivo validar e instrumentar uma bengala robótica, denominada Anti-fall Robotic Cane (ARCane), concebida para incorporar um sistema de deteção de quedas e um mecanismo de atuação que possibilite a prevenção de quedas, ao mesmo tempo que assiste a marcha. Para esse fim, foi realizada uma revisão do estado da arte em bengalas robóticas para adquirir um conhecimento amplo e aprofundado dos componentes, mecanismos e estratégias utilizadas, bem como os protocolos experimentais, principais resultados, limitações e desafios em dispositivos existentes. Numa primeira fase, foi estipulado o objetivo de: (i) adaptar a missão do produto; (ii) estudar as necessidades do consumidor; e (iii) atualizar as especificações alvo da ARCane, continuação do trabalho de equipa, para obter um produto com design e engenharia compatível com o mercado. Foi depois estabelecida a arquitetura de hardware e discutidos os componentes a ser instrumentados na ARCane. Em seguida foram realizados testes de interoperabilidade a fim de validar o funcionamento singular e coletivo dos componentes. Relativamente ao controlo de movimento, foi desenvolvido um sistema inovador, de baixo custo e intuitivo, capaz de detetar a intenção do movimento e de reconhecer as fases da marcha do utilizador. Esta implementação foi validada com seis voluntários saudáveis que realizaram testes de marcha com a ARCane para testar sua operabilidade num ambiente de contexto real. Obteve-se uma precisão de 97% e de 90% em relação à deteção da intenção de movimento e ao reconhecimento da fase da marcha do utilizador. Por fim, foi projetado um método de deteção de quedas e mecanismo de prevenção de quedas para futura implementação na ARCane. Foi ainda proposta uma melhoria do método de deteção de quedas, de modo a superar as limitações associadas, bem como a proposta de dispositivos de deteção a serem implementados na ARCane para obter um sistema completo de deteção de quedas.The act of walking is known to be the primitive form of the human being, and it brings many benefits that motivate a healthy and active lifestyle. However, there are health conditions that make walking difficult, which, consequently, can result in worse health and, in addition, lead to a greater risk of falls. Thus, the development of a fall detection and prevention system integrated with a walking aid would be essential to reduce these fall events and improve people quality of life. To overcome these needs and limitations, this dissertation aims to validate and instrument a cane-type robot, called Anti-fall Robotic Cane (ARCane), designed to incorporate a fall detection system and an actuation mechanism that allow the prevention of falls, while assisting the gait. Therefore, a State-of-the-Art review concerning robotic canes was carried out to acquire a broad and in-depth knowledge of the used components, mechanisms and strategies, as well as the experimental protocols, main results, limitations and challenges on existing devices. On a first stage, it was set an objective to (i) enhance the product's mission statement; (ii) study the consumer needs; and (iii) update the target specifications of the ARCane, extending teamwork, to obtain a product with a market-compatible design and engineering that meets the needs and desires of the ARCane users. It was then established the hardware architecture of the ARCane and discussed the electronic components that will instrument the control, sensory, actuator and power units, being afterwards subjected to interoperability tests to validate the singular and collective functioning of cane components altogether. Regarding the motion control of robotic canes, an innovative, cost-effective and intuitive motion control system was developed, providing user movement intention recognition, and identification of the user's gait phases. This implementation was validated with six healthy volunteers who carried out gait trials with the ARCane, in order to test its operability in a real context environment. An accuracy of 97% was achieved for user motion intention recognition and 90% for user gait phase recognition, using the proposed motion control system. Finally, it was idealized a fall detection method and fall prevention mechanism for a future implementation in the ARCane, based on methods applied to robotic canes in the literature. It was also proposed an improvement of the fall detection method in order to overcome its associated limitations, as well as detection devices to be implemented into the ARCane to achieve a complete fall detection system