Energy-efficient and high-performance lock speculation hardware for embedded multicore systems

Embedded systems are becoming increasingly common in everyday life and like their general-purpose counterparts, they have shifted towards shared memory multicore architectures. However, they are much more resource constrained, and as they often run on batteries, energy efficiency becomes critically important. In such systems, achieving high concurrency is a key demand for delivering satisfactory performance at low energy cost. In order to achieve this high concurrency, consistency across the shared memory hierarchy must be accomplished in a cost-effective manner in terms of performance, energy, and implementation complexity. In this article, we propose Embedded-Spec, a hardware solution for supporting transparent lock speculation, without the requirement for special supporting instructions. Using this approach, we evaluate the energy consumption and performance of a suite of benchmarks, exploring a range of contention management and retry policies. We conclude that for resource-constrained platforms, lock speculation can provide real benefits in terms of improved concurrency and energy efficiency, as long as the underlying hardware support is carefully configured.This work is supported in part by NSF under Grants CCF-0903384, CCF-0903295, CNS-1319495, and CNS-1319095 as well the Semiconductor Research Corporation under grant number 1983.001. (CCF-0903384 - NSF; CCF-0903295 - NSF; CNS-1319495 - NSF; CNS-1319095 - NSF; 1983.001 - Semiconductor Research Corporation

Efficient concurrent data structure access parallelism techniques for increasing scalability

Multi-core processors have revolutionised the way data structures are designed by bringing parallelism to mainstream computing. Key to exploiting hardware parallelism available in multi-core processors are concurrent data structures. However, some concurrent data structure abstractions are inherently sequential and incapable of harnessing the parallelism performance of multi-core processors. Designing and implementing concurrent data structures to harness hardware parallelism is challenging due to the requirement of correctness, efficiency and practicability under various application constraints. In this thesis, our research contribution is towards improving concurrent data structure access parallelism to increase data structure performance. We propose new design frameworks that improve access parallelism of already existing concurrent data structure designs. Also, we propose new concurrent data structure designs with significant performance improvements. To give an insight into the interplay between hardware and concurrent data structure access parallelism, we give a detailed analysis and model the performance scalability with varying parallelism.In the first part of the thesis, we focus on data structure semantic relaxation. By relaxing the semantics of a data structure, a bigger design space, that allows weaker synchronization and more useful parallelism, is unveiled. Investigating new data structure designs, capable of trading semantics for achieving better performance in a monotonic way, is a major challenge in the area. We algorithmically address this challenge in this part of the thesis. We present an efficient, lock-free, concurrent data structure design framework for out-of-order semantic relaxation. We introduce a new two-dimensional algorithmic design, that uses multiple instances of a given data structure to improve access parallelism. In the second part of the thesis, we propose an efficient priority queue that improves access parallelism by reducing the number of synchronization points for each operation. Priority queues are fundamental abstract data types, often used to manage limited resources in parallel systems. Typical proposed parallel priority queue implementations are based on heaps or skip lists. In recent literature, skip lists have been shown to be the most efficient design choice for implementing priority queues. Though numerous intricate implementations of skip list based queues have been proposed in the literature, their performance is constrained by the high number of global atomic updates per operation and the high memory consumption, which are proportional to the number of sub-lists in the queue. In this part of the thesis, we propose an alternative approach for designing lock-free linearizable priority queues, that significantly improve memory efficiency and throughput performance, by reducing the number of global atomic updates and memory consumption as compared to skip-list based queues. To achieve this, our new design combines two structures; a search tree and a linked list, forming what we call a Tree Search List Queue (TSLQueue). Subsequently, we analyse and introduce a model for lock-free concurrent data structure access parallelism. The major impediment to scaling concurrent data structures is memory contention when accessing shared data structure access points, leading to thread serialisation, and hindering parallelism. Aiming to address this challenge, a significant amount of work in the literature has proposed multi-access techniques that improve concurrent data structure parallelism. However, there is little work on analysing and modelling the execution behaviour of concurrent multi-access data structures especially in a shared memory setting. In this part of the thesis, we analyse and model the general execution behaviour of concurrent multi-access data structures in the shared memory setting. We study and analyse the behaviour of the two popular random access patterns: shared (Remote) and exclusive (Local) access, and the behaviour of the two most commonly used atomic primitives for designing lock-free data structures: Compare and Swap, and, Fetch and Add

CROSS-LAYER CUSTOMIZATION FOR LOW POWER AND HIGH PERFORMANCE EMBEDDED MULTI-CORE PROCESSORS

Due to physical limitations and design difficulties, computer processor architecture has shifted to multi-core and even many-core based approaches in recent years. Such architectures provide potentials for sustainable performance scaling into future peta-scale/exa-scale computing platforms, at affordable power budget, design complexity, and verification efforts. To date, multi-core processor products have been replacing uni-core processors in almost every market segment, including embedded systems, general-purpose desktops and laptops, and super computers. However, many issues still remain with multi-core processor architectures that need to be addressed before their potentials could be fully realized. People in both academia and industry research community are still seeking proper ways to make efficient and effective use of these processors. The issues involve hardware architecture trade-offs, the system software service, the run-time management, and user application design, which demand more research effort into this field. Due to the architectural specialties with multi-core based computers, a Cross-Layer Customization framework is proposed in this work, which combines application specific information and system platform features, along with necessary operating system service support, to achieve exceptional power and performance efficiency for targeted multi-core platforms. Several topics are covered with specific optimization goals, including snoop cache coherence protocol, inter-core communication for producer-consumer applications, synchronization mechanisms, and off-chip memory bandwidth limitations. Analysis of benchmark program execution with conventional mechanisms is made to reveal the overheads in terms of power and performance. Specific customizations are proposed to eliminate such overheads with support from hardware, system software, compiler, and user applications. Experiments show significant improvement on system performance and power efficiency

Performance Evaluation of Multicore Cache Locking using Multimedia Applications

Supporting real-time multimedia applications on multicore systems is a great challenge due to cache’s dynamic behavior. Studies show that cache locking may improve execution time predictability and power/performance ratio. However, entire locking at level-1 cache (CL1) may not be efficient if smaller amount of instructions/data compared to the cache size is locked. An alternative choice may be way (i.e., partial) locking. For some processors, way locking is possible only at level-2 cache (CL2). Even though both CL1 cache locking and CL2 cache locking improve predictability, it is difficult to justify the performance and power trade-off between these two cache locking mechanisms. In this work, we assess the impact of CL1 and CL2 cache locking on the performance, power consumption, and predictability of a multicore system using ISO standard H.264/AVC, MPEG4, and MPEG3 multimedia applications and FFT and DFT codes. Simulation results show that both the performance and predictability can be increased and the total power consumption can be decreased by using a cache locking mechanism added to a cache memory hierarchy. Results also show that for the applications used, CL1 cache locking outperforms CL2 cache locking

Design of Efficient TLB-based Data Classification Mechanisms in Chip Multiprocessors

Most of the data referenced by sequential and parallel applications running in current chip multiprocessors are referenced by a single thread, i.e., private. Recent proposals leverage this observation to improve many aspects of chip multiprocessors, such as reducing coherence overhead or the access latency to distributed caches. The effectiveness of those proposals depends to a large extent on the amount of detected private data. However, the mechanisms proposed so far either do not consider either thread migration or the private use of data within different application phases, or do entail high overhead. As a result, a considerable amount of private data is not detected. In order to increase the detection of private data, this thesis proposes a TLB-based mechanism that is able to account for both thread migration and private application phases with low overhead. Classification status in the proposed TLB-based classification mechanisms is determined by the presence of the page translation stored in other core's TLBs. The classification schemes are analyzed in multilevel TLB hierarchies, for systems with both private and distributed shared last-level TLBs. This thesis introduces a page classification approach based on inspecting other core's TLBs upon every TLB miss. In particular, the proposed classification approach is based on exchange and count of tokens. Token counting on TLBs is a natural and efficient way for classifying memory pages. It does not require the use of complex and undesirable persistent requests or arbitration, since when two ormore TLBs race for accessing a page, tokens are appropriately distributed classifying the page as shared. However, TLB-based ability to classify private pages is strongly dependent on TLB size, as it relies on the presence of a page translation in the system TLBs. To overcome that, different TLB usage predictors (UP) have been proposed, which allow a page classification unaffected by TLB size. Specifically, this thesis introduces a predictor that obtains system-wide page usage information by either employing a shared last-level TLB structure (SUP) or cooperative TLBs working together (CUP).La mayor parte de los datos referenciados por aplicaciones paralelas y secuenciales que se ejecutan enCMPs actuales son referenciadas por un único hilo, es decir, son privados. Recientemente, algunas propuestas aprovechan esta observación para mejorar muchos aspectos de los CMPs, como por ejemplo reducir el sobrecoste de la coherencia o la latencia de los accesos a cachés distribuidas. La efectividad de estas propuestas depende en gran medida de la cantidad de datos que son considerados privados. Sin embargo, los mecanismos propuestos hasta la fecha no consideran la migración de hilos de ejecución ni las fases de una aplicación. Por tanto, una cantidad considerable de datos privados no se detecta apropiadamente. Con el fin de aumentar la detección de datos privados, proponemos un mecanismo basado en las TLBs, capaz de reclasificar los datos a privado, y que detecta la migración de los hilos de ejecución sin añadir complejidad al sistema. Los mecanismos de clasificación en las TLBs se han analizado en estructuras de varios niveles, incluyendo TLBs privadas y con un último nivel de TLB compartido y distribuido. Esta tesis también presenta un mecanismo de clasificación de páginas basado en la inspección de las TLBs de otros núcleos tras cada fallo de TLB. De forma particular, el mecanismo propuesto se basa en el intercambio y el cuenteo de tokens (testigos). Contar tokens en las TLBs supone una forma natural y eficiente para la clasificación de páginas de memoria. Además, evita el uso de solicitudes persistentes o arbitraje alguno, ya que si dos o más TLBs compiten para acceder a una página, los tokens se distribuyen apropiadamente y la clasifican como compartida. Sin embargo, la habilidad de los mecanismos basados en TLB para clasificar páginas privadas depende del tamaño de las TLBs. La clasificación basada en las TLBs se basa en la presencia de una traducción en las TLBs del sistema. Para evitarlo, se han propuesto diversos predictores de uso en las TLBs (UP), los cuales permiten una clasificación independiente del tamaño de las TLBs. En concreto, esta tesis presenta un sistema mediante el que se obtiene información de uso de página a nivel de sistema con la ayuda de un nivel de TLB compartida (SUP) o mediante TLBs cooperando juntas (CUP).La major part de les dades referenciades per aplicacions paral·leles i seqüencials que s'executen en CMPs actuals són referenciades per un sol fil, és a dir, són privades. Recentment, algunes propostes aprofiten aquesta observació per a millorar molts aspectes dels CMPs, com és reduir el sobrecost de la coherència o la latència d'accés a memòries cau distribuïdes. L'efectivitat d'aquestes propostes depen en gran mesura de la quantitat de dades detectades com a privades. No obstant això, els mecanismes proposats fins a la data no consideren la migració de fils d'execució ni les fases d'una aplicació. Per tant, una quantitat considerable de dades privades no es detecta apropiadament. A fi d'augmentar la detecció de dades privades, aquesta tesi proposa un mecanisme basat en les TLBs, capaç de reclassificar les dades com a privades, i que detecta la migració dels fils d'execució sense afegir complexitat al sistema. Els mecanismes de classificació en les TLBs s'han analitzat en estructures de diversos nivells, incloent-hi sistemes amb TLBs d'últimnivell compartides i distribuïdes. Aquesta tesi presenta un mecanisme de classificació de pàgines basat en inspeccionar les TLBs d'altres nuclis després de cada fallada de TLB. Concretament, el mecanisme proposat es basa en l'intercanvi i el compte de tokens. Comptar tokens en les TLBs suposa una forma natural i eficient per a la classificació de pàgines de memòria. A més, evita l'ús de sol·licituds persistents o arbitratge, ja que si dues o més TLBs competeixen per a accedir a una pàgina, els tokens es distribueixen apropiadament i la classifiquen com a compartida. No obstant això, l'habilitat dels mecanismes basats en TLB per a classificar pàgines privades depenen de la grandària de les TLBs. La classificació basada en les TLBs resta en la presència d'una traducció en les TLBs del sistema. Per a evitar-ho, s'han proposat diversos predictors d'ús en les TLBs (UP), els quals permeten una classificació independent de la grandària de les TLBs. Específicament, aquesta tesi introdueix un predictor que obté informació d'ús de la pàgina a escala de sistema mitjançant un nivell de TLB compartida (SUP) or mitjançant TLBs cooperant juntes (CUP).Esteve García, A. (2017). Design of Efficient TLB-based Data Classification Mechanisms in Chip Multiprocessors [Tesis doctoral no publicada]. Universitat Politècnica de València. https://doi.org/10.4995/Thesis/10251/86136TESI

Transactional memory for high-performance embedded systems

The increasing demand for computational power in embedded systems, which is required for various tasks, such as autonomous driving, can only be achieved by exploiting the resources offered by modern hardware. Due to physical limitations, hardware manufacturers have moved to increase the number of cores per processor instead of further increasing clock rates. Therefore, in our view, the additionally required computing power can only be achieved by exploiting parallelism. Unfortunately writing parallel code is considered a difficult and complex task. Hardware Transactional Memories (HTMs) are a suitable tool to write sophisticated parallel software. However, HTMs were not specifically developed for embedded systems and therefore cannot be used without consideration. The use of conventional HTMs increases complexity and makes it more difficult to foresee implications with other important properties of embedded systems. This thesis therefore describes how an HTM for embedded systems could be implemented. The HTM was designed to allow the parallel execution of software and to offer functionality which is useful for embedded systems. Hereby the focus lay on: elimination of the typical limitations of conventional HTMs, several conflict resolution mechanisms, investigation of real time behavior, and a feature to conserve energy. To enable the desired functionalities, the structure of the HTM described in this work strongly differs from a conventional HTM. In comparison to the baseline HTM, which was also designed and implemented in this thesis, the biggest adaptation concerns the conflict detection. It was modified so that conflicts can be detected and resolved centrally. For this, the cache hierarchy as well as the cache coherence had to be adapted and partially extended. The system was implemented in the cycle-accurate gem5 simulator. The eight benchmarks of the STAMP benchmark suite were used for evaluation. The evaluation of the various functionalities shows that the mechanisms work and add value for the operation in embedded systems.Der immer größer werdende Bedarf an Rechenleistung in eingebetteten Systemen, der für verschiedene Aufgaben wie z. B. dem autonomen Fahren benötigt wird, kann nur durch die effiziente Nutzung der zur Verfügung stehenden Ressourcen erreicht werden. Durch physikalische Grenzen sind Prozessorhersteller dazu übergegangen, Prozessoren mit mehreren Prozessorkernen auszustatten, statt die Taktraten weiter anzuheben. Daher kann die zusätzlich benötigte Rechenleistung aus unserer Sicht nur durch eine Steigerung der Parallelität gelingen. Hardwaretransaktionsspeicher (HTS) erlauben es ihren Nutzern schnell und einfach parallele Programme zu schreiben. Allerdings wurden HTS nicht speziell für eingebettete Systeme entwickelt und sind daher nur eingeschränkt für diese nutzbar. Durch den Einsatz herkömmlicher HTS steigt die Komplexität und es wird somit schwieriger abzusehen, ob andere wichtige Eigenschaften erreicht werden können. Um den Einsatz von HTS in eingebettete Systeme besser zu ermöglichen, beschreibt diese Arbeit einen konkreten Ansatz. Der HTS wurde hierzu so entwickelt, dass er eine parallele Ausführung von Programmen ermöglicht und Eigenschaften besitzt, welche für eingebettete Systeme nützlich sind. Dazu gehören unter anderem: Wegfall der typischen Limitierungen herkömmlicher HTS, Einflussnahme auf den Konfliktauflösungsmechanismus, Unterstützung einer abschätzbaren Ausführung und eine Funktion, um Energie einzusparen. Um die gewünschten Funktionalitäten zu ermöglichen, unterscheidet sich der Aufbau des in dieser Arbeit beschriebenen HTS stark von einem klassischen HTS. Im Vergleich zu dem Referenz HTS, der ebenfalls im Rahmen dieser Arbeit entworfen und implementiert wurde, betrifft die größte Anpassung die Konflikterkennung. Sie wurde derart verändert, dass die Konflikte zentral erkannt und aufgelöst werden können. Hierfür mussten die Cache-Hierarchie und Cache-Kohärenz stark angepasst und teilweise erweitert werden. Das System wurde in einem taktgenauen Simulator, dem gem5-Simulator, umgesetzt. Zur Evaluation wurden die acht Benchmarks der STAMP-Benchmark-Suite eingesetzt. Die Evaluation der verschiedenen Funktionen zeigt, dass die Mechanismen funktionieren und somit einen Mehrwert für eingebettete Systeme bieten

Temporal-Aware Mechanism to Detect Private Data in Chip Multiprocessors

© 2013 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. Permission from IEEE must be obtained for all other uses, in any current or future media, including reprinting/republishing this material for advertising or promotional purposes, creating new collective works, for resale or redistribution to servers or lists, or reuse of any copyrighted component of this work in other works.Most of the data referenced by sequential and parallel applications running in current chip multiprocessors are referenced by only one thread and can be considered as private data. A lot of recent proposals leverage this observation to improve many aspects of chip multiprocessors, such as reducing coherence overhead or the access latency to distributed caches. The effectiveness of those proposals depend to a large extent on the amount of detected private data. However, the mechanisms proposed so far do not consider thread migration and the private use of data within different application phases. As a result, a considerable amount of data is not detected as private. In order to make this detection more accurate and reaching more significant improvements, we propose a mechanism that is able to account for both thread migration and private data within application phases. Simulation results for 16-core systems show that, thanks to our mechanism, the average number of pages detected as private significantly increases from 43% in previous proposals up to 74% in ours. Finally, when our detection mechanism is used to deactivate the coherence for private data in a directory protocol, our proposal improves execution time by 13% with respect to previous proposals.This work was supported by the Spanish MINECO, as well as European Commission FEDER funds, under grant TIN2012-38341-C04-01/03 and by the VIRTICAL project (grant agreement no 288574) which is funded by the European Commission within the Research Programme FP7.Ros Bardisa, A.; Cuesta Sáez, BA.; Gómez Requena, ME.; Robles Martínez, A.; Duato Marín, JF. (2013). Temporal-Aware Mechanism to Detect Private Data in Chip Multiprocessors. En Proceedings of the International Conference on Parallel Processing. IEEE. 562-571. https://doi.org/10.1109/ICPP.2013.70S56257

Proximity coherence for chip-multiprocessors

Many-core architectures provide an efficient way of harnessing the growing numbers of transistors available in modern fabrication processes; however, the parallel programs run on these platforms are increasingly limited by the energy and latency costs of communication. Existing designs provide a functional communication layer but do not necessarily implement the most efficient solution for chip-multiprocessors, placing limits on the performance of these complex systems. In an era of increasingly power limited silicon design, efficiency is now a primary concern that motivates designers to look again at the challenge of cache coherence. The first step in the design process is to analyse the communication behaviour of parallel benchmark suites such as Parsec and SPLASH-2. This thesis presents work detailing the sharing patterns observed when running the full benchmarks on a simulated 32-core x86 machine. The results reveal considerable locality of shared data accesses between threads with consecutive operating system assigned thread IDs. This pattern, although of little consequence in a multi-node system, corresponds to strong physical locality of shared data between adjacent cores on a chip-multiprocessor platform. Traditional cache coherence protocols, although often used in chip-multiprocessor designs, have been developed in the context of older multi-node systems. By redesigning coherence protocols to exploit new patterns such as the physical locality of shared data, improving the efficiency of communication, specifically in chip-multiprocessors, is possible. This thesis explores such a design – Proximity Coherence – a novel scheme in which L1 load misses are optimistically forwarded to nearby caches via new dedicated links rather than always being indirected via a directory structure.EPSRC DTA research scholarshi

An Implementation of a Predictable Cache-coherent Multi-core System

Multi-core platforms have entered the realm of the embedded systems to meet the ever growing performance requirements of the real-time embedded applications. Real-time applications leverage the hardware parallelism from multi-cores while keeping the hardware cost minimum. However, when the real-time tasks are deployed on the multi-core platforms, they experience interference due to sharing of hardware resources such as shared bus, last level cache, and main memory. As a result, it complicates computing the worst-case execution time of the real-time tasks. In this thesis, I present a hardware prototype that implements a predictable cache-coherent real-time multi-core system. The designed hardware follows the design guidelines outlined in the predictable cache coherence protocol. The hardware uses a latency insensitive interfaces to integrate the multi-core components such as the processor, cache controller, and interconnecting bus. The prototyped multi-core hardware is synthesized and implemented in a low-cost and high-performing FPGA board. The hardware is validated and verified on a tethered system that enables the design to run multi-threaded pthread applications