Evaluation of PNCC and extended spectral subtraction methods for robust speech recognition

International audienceThis paper evaluates the robustness of different approaches for speech recognition with respect to signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), to signal level and to presence of non-speech data before and after utterances to be recognized. Three types of noise robust features are considered: Power Normalized Cepstral Coefficients (PNCC), Mel-Frequency Cepstral Coefficients (MFCC) after applying an extended spectral subtraction method, and Sphinx embedded denoising features from recent sphinx versions. Although removing C0 in MFCC-based features leads to a slight decrease in speech recognition performance, it makes the speech recognition system independent on the speech signal level. With multi-condition training, the three sets of noise-robust features lead to a rather similar behavior of performance with respect to SNR and presence of non-speech data. Overall, best performance is achieved with the extended spectral subtraction approach. Also, the performance of the PNCC features appears to be dependent on the initialization of the normalization factor

Bio-motivated features and deep learning for robust speech recognition

Mención Internacional en el título de doctorIn spite of the enormous leap forward that the Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) technologies has experienced over the last five years their performance under hard environmental condition is still far from that of humans preventing their adoption in several real applications. In this thesis the challenge of robustness of modern automatic speech recognition systems is addressed following two main research lines. The first one focuses on modeling the human auditory system to improve the robustness of the feature extraction stage yielding to novel auditory motivated features. Two main contributions are produced. On the one hand, a model of the masking behaviour of the Human Auditory System (HAS) is introduced, based on the non-linear filtering of a speech spectro-temporal representation applied simultaneously to both frequency and time domains. This filtering is accomplished by using image processing techniques, in particular mathematical morphology operations with an specifically designed Structuring Element (SE) that closely resembles the masking phenomena that take place in the cochlea. On the other hand, the temporal patterns of auditory-nerve firings are modeled. Most conventional acoustic features are based on short-time energy per frequency band discarding the information contained in the temporal patterns. Our contribution is the design of several types of feature extraction schemes based on the synchrony effect of auditory-nerve activity, showing that the modeling of this effect can indeed improve speech recognition accuracy in the presence of additive noise. Both models are further integrated into the well known Power Normalized Cepstral Coefficients (PNCC). The second research line addresses the problem of robustness in noisy environments by means of the use of Deep Neural Networks (DNNs)-based acoustic modeling and, in particular, of Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) architectures. A deep residual network scheme is proposed and adapted for our purposes, allowing Residual Networks (ResNets), originally intended for image processing tasks, to be used in speech recognition where the network input is small in comparison with usual image dimensions. We have observed that ResNets on their own already enhance the robustness of the whole system against noisy conditions. Moreover, our experiments demonstrate that their combination with the auditory motivated features devised in this thesis provide significant improvements in recognition accuracy in comparison to other state-of-the-art CNN-based ASR systems under mismatched conditions, while maintaining the performance in matched scenarios. The proposed methods have been thoroughly tested and compared with other state-of-the-art proposals for a variety of datasets and conditions. The obtained results prove that our methods outperform other state-of-the-art approaches and reveal that they are suitable for practical applications, specially where the operating conditions are unknown.El objetivo de esta tesis se centra en proponer soluciones al problema del reconocimiento de habla robusto; por ello, se han llevado a cabo dos líneas de investigación. En la primera líınea se han propuesto esquemas de extracción de características novedosos, basados en el modelado del comportamiento del sistema auditivo humano, modelando especialmente los fenómenos de enmascaramiento y sincronía. En la segunda, se propone mejorar las tasas de reconocimiento mediante el uso de técnicas de aprendizaje profundo, en conjunto con las características propuestas. Los métodos propuestos tienen como principal objetivo, mejorar la precisión del sistema de reconocimiento cuando las condiciones de operación no son conocidas, aunque el caso contrario también ha sido abordado. En concreto, nuestras principales propuestas son los siguientes: Simular el sistema auditivo humano con el objetivo de mejorar la tasa de reconocimiento en condiciones difíciles, principalmente en situaciones de alto ruido, proponiendo esquemas de extracción de características novedosos. Siguiendo esta dirección, nuestras principales propuestas se detallan a continuación: • Modelar el comportamiento de enmascaramiento del sistema auditivo humano, usando técnicas del procesado de imagen sobre el espectro, en concreto, llevando a cabo el diseño de un filtro morfológico que captura este efecto. • Modelar el efecto de la sincroní que tiene lugar en el nervio auditivo. • La integración de ambos modelos en los conocidos Power Normalized Cepstral Coefficients (PNCC). La aplicación de técnicas de aprendizaje profundo con el objetivo de hacer el sistema más robusto frente al ruido, en particular con el uso de redes neuronales convolucionales profundas, como pueden ser las redes residuales. Por último, la aplicación de las características propuestas en combinación con las redes neuronales profundas, con el objetivo principal de obtener mejoras significativas, cuando las condiciones de entrenamiento y test no coinciden.Programa Oficial de Doctorado en Multimedia y ComunicacionesPresidente: Javier Ferreiros López.- Secretario: Fernando Díaz de María.- Vocal: Rubén Solera Ureñ

Robust text independent closed set speaker identification systems and their evaluation

PhD ThesisThis thesis focuses upon text independent closed set speaker identi cation. The contributions relate to evaluation studies in the presence of various types of noise and handset e ects. Extensive evaluations are performed on four databases. The rst contribution is in the context of the use of the Gaussian Mixture Model-Universal Background Model (GMM-UBM) with original speech recordings from only the TIMIT database. Four main simulations for Speaker Identi cation Accuracy (SIA) are presented including di erent fusion strategies: Late fusion (score based), early fusion (feature based) and early-late fusion (combination of feature and score based), late fusion using concatenated static and dynamic features (features with temporal derivatives such as rst order derivative delta and second order derivative delta-delta features, namely acceleration features), and nally fusion of statistically independent normalized scores. The second contribution is again based on the GMM-UBM approach. Comprehensive evaluations of the e ect of Additive White Gaussian Noise (AWGN), and Non-Stationary Noise (NSN) (with and without a G.712 type handset) upon identi cation performance are undertaken. In particular, three NSN types with varying Signal to Noise Ratios (SNRs) were tested corresponding to: street tra c, a bus interior and a crowded talking environment. The performance evaluation also considered the e ect of late fusion techniques based on score fusion, namely mean, maximum, and linear weighted sum fusion. The databases employed were: TIMIT, SITW, and NIST 2008; and 120 speakers were selected from each database to yield 3,600 speech utterances. The third contribution is based on the use of the I-vector, four combinations of I-vectors with 100 and 200 dimensions were employed. Then, various fusion techniques using maximum, mean, weighted sum and cumulative fusion with the same I-vector dimension were used to improve the SIA. Similarly, both interleaving and concatenated I-vector fusion were exploited to produce 200 and 400 I-vector dimensions. The system was evaluated with four di erent databases using 120 speakers from each database. TIMIT, SITW and NIST 2008 databases were evaluated for various types of NSN namely, street-tra c NSN, bus-interior NSN and crowd talking NSN; and the G.712 type handset at 16 kHz was also applied. As recommendations from the study in terms of the GMM-UBM approach, mean fusion is found to yield overall best performance in terms of the SIA with noisy speech, whereas linear weighted sum fusion is overall best for original database recordings. However, in the I-vector approach the best SIA was obtained from the weighted sum and the concatenated fusion.Ministry of Higher Education and Scienti c Research (MoHESR), and the Iraqi Cultural Attach e, Al-Mustansiriya University, Al-Mustansiriya University College of Engineering in Iraq for supporting my PhD scholarship

Environmentally robust ASR front-end for deep neural network acoustic models

This paper examines the individual and combined impacts of various front-end approaches on the performance of deep neural network (DNN) based speech recognition systems in distant talking situations, where acoustic environmental distortion degrades the recognition performance. Training of a DNN-based acoustic model consists of generation of state alignments followed by learning the network parameters. This paper first shows that the network parameters are more sensitive to the speech quality than the alignments and thus this stage requires improvement. Then, various front-end robustness approaches to addressing this problem are categorised based on functionality. The degree to which each class of approaches impacts the performance of DNN-based acoustic models is examined experimentally. Based on the results, a front-end processing pipeline is proposed for efficiently combining different classes of approaches. Using this front-end, the combined effects of different classes of approaches are further evaluated in a single distant microphone-based meeting transcription task with both speaker independent (SI) and speaker adaptive training (SAT) set-ups. By combining multiple speech enhancement results, multiple types of features, and feature transformation, the front-end shows relative performance gains of 7.24% and 9.83% in the SI and SAT scenarios, respectively, over competitive DNN-based systems using log mel-filter bank features.This is the final version of the article. It first appeared from Elsevier via http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.csl.2014.11.00

DNN-Assisted Speech Enhancement Approaches Incorporating Phase Information

Speech enhancement is a widely adopted technique that removes the interferences in a corrupted speech to improve the speech quality and intelligibility. Speech enhancement methods can be implemented in either time domain or time-frequency (T-F) domain. Among various proposed methods, the time-frequency domain methods, which synthesize the enhanced speech with the estimated magnitude spectrogram and the noisy phase spectrogram, gain the most popularity in the past few decades. However, this kind of techniques tend to ignore the importance of phase processing. To overcome this problem, the thesis aims to jointly enhance the magnitude and phase spectra by means of the most recent deep neural networks (DNNs). More specifically, three major contributions are presented in this thesis. First, we present new schemes based on the basic Kalman filter (KF) to remove the background noise in the noisy speech in time domain, where the KF acts as joint estimator for both the magnitude and phase spectra of speech. A DNN-augmented basic KF is first proposed, where DNN is applied for estimating key parameters in the KF, namely the linear prediction coefficients (LPCs). By training the DNN with a large database and making use of the powerful learning ability of DNN, the proposed algorithm is able to estimate LPCs from noisy speech more accurately and robustly, leading to an improved performance as compared to traditional KF based approaches in speech enhancement. We further present a high-frequency (HF) component restoration algorithm to extenuate the degradation in the HF regions of the Kalman-filtered speech, in which the DNN-based bandwidth extension is applied to estimate the magnitude of HF component from the low-frequency (LF) counterpart. By incorporating the restoration algorithm, the enhanced speech suffers less distortion in the HF component. Moreover, we propose a hybrid speech enhancement system that exploits DNN for speech reconstruction and Kalman filtering for further denoising. Two separate networks are adopted in the estimation of magnitude spectrogram and LPCs of the clean speech, respectively. The estimated clean magnitude spectrogram is combined with the phase of the noisy speech to reconstruct the estimated clean speech. A KF with the estimated parameters is then utilized to remove the residual noise in the reconstructed speech. The proposed hybrid system takes advantages of both the DNN-based reconstruction and traditional Kalman filtering, and can work reliably in either matched or unmatched acoustic environments. Next, we incorporate the DNN-based parameter estimation scheme in two advanced KFs: subband KF and colored-noise KF. The DNN-augmented subband KF method decomposes the noisy speech into several subbands, and performs Kalman filtering to each subband speech, where the parameters of the KF are estimated by the trained DNN. The final enhanced speech is then obtained by synthesizing the enhanced subband speeches. In the DNN-augmented colored-noise KF system, both clean speech and noise are modelled as autoregressive (AR) processes, whose parameters comprise the LPCs and the driving noise variances. The LPCs are obtained through training a multi-objective DNN, while the driving noise variances are obtained by solving an optimization problem aiming to minimize the difference between the modelled and observed AR spectra of the noisy speech. The colored-noise Kalman filter with DNN-estimated parameters is then applied to the noisy speech for denoising. A post-subtraction technique is adopted to further remove the residual noise in the Kalman-filtered speech. Extensive computer simulations show that the two proposed advanced KF systems achieve significant performance gains when compared to conventional Kalman filter based algorithms as well as recent DNN-based methods under both seen and unseen noise conditions. Finally, we focus on the T-F domain speech enhancement with masking technique, which aims to retain the speech dominant components and suppress the noise dominant parts of the noisy speech. We first derive a new type of mask, namely constrained ratio mask (CRM), to better control the trade-off between speech distortion and residual noise in the enhanced speech. The CRM is estimated with a trained DNN based on the input noisy feature set and is applied to the noisy magnitude spectrogram for denoising. We further extend the CRM to the complex spectrogram estimation, where the enhanced magnitude spectrogram is obtained with the CRM, while the estimated phase spectrogram is reconstructed with the noisy phase spectrogram and the phase derivatives. Performance evaluation reveals our proposed CRM outperforms several traditional masks in terms of objective metrics. Moreover, the enhanced speech resulting from the CRM based complex spectrogram estimation has a better speech quality than that obtained without using phase reconstruction

Learnable Nonlinear Compression for Robust Speaker Verification

International audienceIn this study, we focus on nonlinear compression methods in spectral features for speaker verification based on deep neural network. We consider different kinds of channel-dependent (CD) nonlinear compression methods optimized in a data-driven manner. Our methods are based on power nonlinearities and dynamic range compression (DRC). We also propose multi-regime (MR) design on the nonlinearities, at improving robustness. Results on VoxCeleb1 and Vox-Movies data demonstrate improvements brought by proposed compression methods over both the commonly-used logarithm and their static counterparts, especially for ones based on power function. While CD generalization improves performance on VoxCeleb1, MR provides more robustness on VoxMovies, with a maximum relative equal error rate reduction of 21.6%