Evaluation of remote sensing methods for continuous cover forestry

The overall aim of the project was to investigate the potential and challenges in the application of high spatial and spectral resolution remote sensing to forest stands in the UK for Continuous Cover Forestry (CCF) purposes. Within the context of CCF, a relatively new forest management strategy that has been implemented in several European countries, the usefulness of digital remote sensing techniques lie in their potential ability to retrieve parameters at sub-stand level and, in particular, in the assessment of natural regeneration and light regimes. The idea behind CCF is the support of a sustainable forest management system reducing disturbance of the forest ecosystem and encouraging the use of more natural methods, e.g. natural regeneration, for which the light environment beneath the forest canopy plays a fundamental role.The study was carried out at a test area in central Scotland, situated within the Queen Elizabeth II Forest Park (lat. 56°10' N, long. 4° 23' W). Six plots containing three different species (Norway spruce, European larch and Sessile oak), characterized by their different light regimes, were established within the area for the measurement of forest variables using a forest inventory approach and hemispherical photography. The remote sensing data available for the study consisted of Landsat ETM+ imagery, a small footprint multi-return lidar dataset over the study area, Airborne Thematic Mapper (ATM) data, and aerial photography with same acquisition date as the lidar data.Landsat ETM+ imagery was used for the spectral characterisation of the species under study and the evaluation of phenological change as a factor to consider for future acquisitions of remotely sensed imagery. Three approaches were used for the discrimination between species: raw data, NDVI, and Principal Component Analysis (PCA). It can be concluded that no single date is ideal for discriminating the species studied (early summer was best) and that a combination of two or three datasets covering their phenological cycles is optimal for the differentiation. Although the approaches used helped to characterize the forest species, especially to the discrimination between spruces, larch and the deciduous oak species, further work is needed in order to define an optimum approach to discriminate between spruce species (e.g. Sitka spruce and Norway spruce) for which spectral responses are very similar. In general, the useful ranges of the indices were small, so a careful and accurate preprocessing of the imagery is highly recommended.Lidar, ATM, and aerial photographic datasets were analysed for the characterisation of vertical and horizontal forest structure. A slope-based algorithm was developed for the extraction of ground elevation and tree heights from multiple return lidar data, the production of a Digital Terrain Model (DTM) and Digital Surface Model (DSM) of the area under study, and for the comparison of the predicted lidar tree heights with the true tree heights, followed by the building of a Digital Canopy Model (DCM) for the determination of percentage canopy cover and tree crown delineation. Mean height and individual tree heights were estimated for all sample plots. The results showed that lidar underestimated tree heights by an average of 1.49 m. The standard deviation of the lidar estimates was 3.58 m and the mean standard error was 0.38 m.This study assessed the utility of an object-oriented approach for deciduous and coniferous crown delineation, based on small-footprint, multiple return lidar data, high resolution ATM imagery, and aerial photography. Special emphasis in the analysis was made in the fusion of aerial photography and lidar data for tree crown detection and classification, as it was expected that the high vertical accuracy of lidar, combined with the high spatial resolution aerial photography would render the best results and would provide the forestry sector with an affordable and accurate means for forest management and planning. Most of the field surveyed trees could be automatically and correctly detected, especially for the spruce and larch plots, but the complexity of the deciduous plots hindered the tree recognition approach, leading to poor crown extent and gap estimations. Indicators of light availability were calculated from the lidar data by calculation of laser hit penetration rates and percentage canopy cover. These results were compared to estimates of canopy openness obtained from hemispherical pictures for the same locations.Finally, the synergistic benefits of all datasets were evaluated and the forest structural variables determined from remote sensing and hemispherical photography were examined as indicators of light availability for regenerating seedlings

VEGETATION FIRE FUELS MAPPING IN THE SAN DIEGO CITY CANYONS – A METHOD COMPARISON

Fire risk is a major threat to life, property and natural resources in southern California. Recent fire disasters occurred in autumn 2003 and 2007. Fire risk management deals with these hazards, input data are collected, analyzed and evaluated. One of the most important input data is the vegetation density in the endangered areas. Here we describe methods to map vegetation density forming five hazard classes. The main objective of this study is to explore the benefits of using remote sensed data for the accurate classification of vegetation in San Diego city canyons. Three very high resolution remote sensing data sets (< 1 m) were used in comparison: scanned color infrared film (CIR) airborne, digital multi-spectral airborne (ADS40) and digital multi-spectral satellite imagery (QuickBird). Different classification approaches (e.g. pixel-based, segment-based and knowledge-based) were tested and analyzed to separate the vegetation into five hazard classes. Accuracy assessment indicated low overall accuracies of 58 % on average. With regard to an optimized classification result in particular unsupervised and segment-based classification can be recommended. The overall accuracy for these two methods reached around 62 %. The use of specially selected reference areas for validation helped to increase the accuracies up to 81 %. Also a separating between three instead of five different hazard classes resulted in accuracies around 80 %. Furthermore it could be shown that all three data sets can be used for successful classification procedures. The resulting fire risk maps can help to reduce or prevent fire hazards. The maps are a basis for the brush management of the Fir

Land Cover Change Image Analysis for Assateague Island National Seashore Following Hurricane Sandy

The assessment of storm damages is critically important if resource managers are to understand the impacts of weather pattern changes and sea level rise on their lands and develop management strategies to mitigate its effects. This study was performed to detect land cover change on Assateague Island as a result of Hurricane Sandy. Several single-date classifications were performed on the pre and post hurricane imagery utilized using both a pixel-based and object-based approach with the Random Forest classifier. Univariate image differencing and a post classification comparison were used to conduct the change detection. This study found that the addition of the coastal blue band to the Landsat 8 sensor did not improve classification accuracy and there was also no statistically significant improvement in classification accuracy using Landsat 8 compared to Landsat 5. Furthermore, there was no significant difference found between object-based and pixel-based classification. Change totals were estimated on Assateague Island following Hurricane Sandy and were found to be minimal, occurring predominately in the most active sections of the island in terms of land cover change, however, the post classification detected significantly more change, mainly due to classification errors in the single-date maps used

Object-based image analysis for forest-type mapping in New Hampshire

The use of satellite imagery to classify New England forests is inherently complicated due to high species diversity and complex spatial distributions across a landscape. The use of imagery with high spatial resolutions to classify forests has become more commonplace as new satellite technology become available. Pixel-based methods of classification have been traditionally used to identify forest cover types. However, object-based image analysis (OBIA) has been shown to provide more accurate results. This study explored the ability of OBIA to classify forest stands in New Hampshire using two methods: by identifying stands within an IKONOS satellite image, and by identifying individual trees and building them into forest stands. Forest stands were classified in the IKONOS image using OBIA. However, the spatial resolution was not high enough to distinguish individual tree crowns and therefore, individual trees could not be accurately identified to create forest stands. In addition, the accuracy of labeling forest stands using the OBIA approach was low. In the future, these results could be improved by using a modified classification approach and appropriate sampling scheme more reflective of object-based analysis

Remote Sensing Applications to Support Sustainable Natural Resource Management

The original design of this dissertation project was relatively simple and straightforward. It was intended to produce one single, dynamic, classification and mapping system for existing vegetation that could rely on commonly available inventory and remote sensing data. This classification and mapping system was intended to provide the analytical basis for resource planning and management. The problems encountered during the first phase of the original design transformed this project into an extensive analysis of the nature of these problems and a decade-long remote sensing applications development endeavor. What evolved from this applications development process is a portion of what has become a system of systems to inform and support natural resource management. This dissertation presents the progression of work that sequentially developed a suite of remote sensing applications designed to address different aspects of the problems encountered with the original project. These remote sensing applications feature different resource issues, and resource components and are presented in separate chapters. Chapter one provides an introduction and description of the project evolution and chapter six provides a summary of the work and concluding discussion. Chapters two through five describe remote sensing applications that represent related, yet independent studies that are presented essentially as previously published. Chapter two evaluates different approaches to classifying and mapping fire severity using multi-temporal Landsat TM data. The recommended method currently represents the analytical basis for fire severity data produced by the USDA Forest Service and the US Geological Survey. Chapter three also uses multi-temporal Landsat data and compares quantitative, remote-sensing-based change detection methods for forest management related canopy change. The recommended method has been widely applied for a variety of forest health and disaster response applications. Chapter four presents a method for multi-source and multi-classifier regional land cover mapping that is currently incorporated in the USDA Forest Service Existing Vegetation Classification and Mapping Technical Guide. Chapter five presents a study using nearest neighbor imputation methods to generate geospatial data surfaces for simulation modeling of vegetation through time and space. While these results have not yet been successful enough to support widespread adoption and implementation, it is possible that these general methods can be adapted to perform adequately for simulation modeling data needs

Cartografía de severidad de incendios forestales a partir de la combinación del modelo de mezclas espectrales y la clasificación basada en objetos

This study shows an accurate and fast methodology in order to evaluate fire severity classes of large forest fires. A single Landsat Enhanced Thematic Mapper multispectral image was utilized in this study with the aim of mapping fire severity classes (high, moderate and low) using a combined-approach based in an spectral mixing model and object-based image analysis. A large wildfire in the Northwest of Spain is used to test the model. Fraction images obtained by Landsat unmixing were used as input data in the object-based image analysis. A multilevel segmentation and a classification were carried out by using membership functions. This method was compared with other simplest ones in order to evaluate the suitability to distinguish between the three fire severity classes above mentioned. McNemar’s test was used to evaluate the statistical significance of the difference between approaches tested in this study. The combined approach achieved the highest accuracy reaching 97.32% and kappa index of agreement of 95.96% and improving accuracy of individual classes.Este estudio presenta una metodología rápida y precisa para la evaluación de los niveles de severidad que afectan a grandes incendios forestales. El trabajo combina un modelo de mezclas espectrales y un análisis de imágenes basado en objetos con el objetivo de cartografiar distintos niveles de severidad (alto, moderado y bajo) empleando una imagen multiespectral Landsat Enhanced Thematic Mapper. Este modelo es testado en un gran incendio forestal ocurrido en el noroeste de España. Las imágenes fracción obtenidas tras aplicar el modelo de mezclas a la imagen Landsat fueron utilizadas como datos de entrada en el análisis basado en objetos. En este se llevó a cabo una segmentación multinivel y una posterior clasificación usando funciones de pertenencia. Esta metodología fue comparada con otras más simples con el fin de evaluar su conveniencia a al hora de distinguir entre los tres niveles de severidad anteriormente mencionados. El test de McNemar fue empleado para evaluar la significancia estadística de la diferencia entre los métodos testados en el estudio. El método combinado alcanzó la más alta precisión con un 97,32% y un índice Kappa del 95,96%, además de mejorar la precisión de los niveles individualmente

A methodology to produce geographical information for land planning using very-high resolution images

Actualmente, os municípios são obrigados a produzir, no âmbito da elaboração dos instrumentos de gestão territorial, cartografia homologada pela autoridade nacional. O Plano Director Municipal (PDM) tem um período de vigência de 10 anos. Porém, no que diz respeito à cartografia para estes planos, principalmente em municípios onde a pressão urbanística é elevada, esta periodicidade não é compatível com a dinâmica de alteração de uso do solo. Emerge assim, a necessidade de um processo de produção mais eficaz, que permita a obtenção de uma nova cartografia de base e temática mais frequentemente. Em Portugal recorre-se à fotografia aérea como informação de base para a produção de cartografia de grande escala. Por um lado, embora este suporte de informação resulte em mapas bastante rigorosos e detalhados, a sua produção têm custos muito elevados e consomem muito tempo. As imagens de satélite de muito alta-resolução espacial podem constituir uma alternativa, mas sem substituir as fotografias aéreas na produção de cartografia temática, a grande escala. O tema da tese trata assim da satisfação das necessidades municipais em informação geográfica actualizada. Para melhor conhecer o valor e utilidade desta informação, realizou-se um inquérito aos municípios Portugueses. Este passo foi essencial para avaliar a pertinência e a utilidade da introdução de imagens de satélite de muito alta-resolução espacial na cadeia de procedimentos de actualização de alguns temas, quer na cartografia de base quer na cartografia temática. A abordagem proposta para solução do problema identificado baseia-se no uso de imagens de satélite e outros dados digitais em ambiente de Sistemas de Informação Geográfica. A experimentação teve como objectivo a extracção automática de elementos de interesse municipal a partir de imagens de muito alta-resolução espacial (fotografias aéreas ortorectificadas, imagem QuickBird, e imagem IKONOS), bem como de dados altimétricos (dados LiDAR). Avaliaram-se as potencialidades da informação geográfica extraídas das imagens para fins cartográficos e analíticos. Desenvolveram-se quatro casos de estudo que reflectem diferentes usos para os dados geográficos a nível municipal, e que traduzem aplicações com exigências diferentes. No primeiro caso de estudo, propõe-se uma metodologia para actualização periódica de cartografia a grande escala, que faz uso de fotografias aéreas vi ortorectificadas na área da Alta de Lisboa. Esta é uma aplicação quantitativa onde as qualidades posicionais e geométricas dos elementos extraídos são mais exigentes. No segundo caso de estudo, criou-se um sistema de alarme para áreas potencialmente alteradas, com recurso a uma imagem QuickBird e dados LiDAR, no Bairro da Madre de Deus, com objectivo de auxiliar a actualização de cartografia de grande escala. No terceiro caso de estudo avaliou-se o potencial solar de topos de edifícios nas Avenidas Novas, com recurso a dados LiDAR. No quarto caso de estudo, propõe-se uma série de indicadores municipais de monitorização territorial, obtidos pelo processamento de uma imagem IKONOS que cobre toda a área do concelho de Lisboa. Esta é uma aplicação com fins analíticos onde a qualidade temática da extracção é mais relevante.Currently, the Portuguese municipalities are required to produce homologated cartography, under the Territorial Management Instruments framework. The Municipal Master Plan (PDM) has to be revised every 10 years, as well as the topographic and thematic maps that describe the municipal territory. However, this period is inadequate for representing counties where urban pressure is high, and where the changes in the land use are very dynamic. Consequently, emerges the need for a more efficient mapping process, allowing obtaining recent geographic information more often. Several countries, including Portugal, continue to use aerial photography for large-scale mapping. Although this data enables highly accurate maps, its acquisition and visual interpretation are very costly and time consuming. Very-High Resolution (VHR) satellite imagery can be an alternative data source, without replacing the aerial images, for producing large-scale thematic cartography. The focus of the thesis is the demand for updated geographic information in the land planning process. To better understand the value and usefulness of this information, a survey of all Portuguese municipalities was carried out. This step was essential for assessing the relevance and usefulness of the introduction of VHR satellite imagery in the chain of procedures for updating land information. The proposed methodology is based on the use of VHR satellite imagery, and other digital data, in a Geographic Information Systems (GIS) environment. Different algorithms for feature extraction that take into account the variation in texture, color and shape of objects in the image, were tested. The trials aimed for automatic extraction of features of municipal interest, based on aerial and satellite high-resolution (orthophotos, QuickBird and IKONOS imagery) as well as elevation data (altimetric information and LiDAR data). To evaluate the potential of geographic information extracted from VHR images, two areas of application were identified: mapping and analytical purposes. Four case studies that reflect different uses of geographic data at the municipal level, with different accuracy requirements, were considered. The first case study presents a methodology for periodic updating of large-scale maps based on orthophotos, in the area of Alta de Lisboa. This is a situation where the positional and geometric accuracy of the extracted information are more demanding, since technical mapping standards must be complied. In the second case study, an alarm system that indicates the location of potential changes in building areas, using a QuickBird image and LiDAR data, was developed for the area of Bairro da Madre de Deus. The goal of the system is to assist the updating of large scale mapping, providing a layer that can be used by the municipal technicians as the basis for manual editing. In the third case study, the analysis of the most suitable roof-tops for installing solar systems, using LiDAR data, was performed in the area of Avenidas Novas. A set of urban environment indicators obtained from VHR imagery is presented. The concept is demonstrated for the entire city of Lisbon, through IKONOS imagery processing. In this analytical application, the positional quality issue of extraction is less relevant.GEOSAT – Methodologies to extract large scale GEOgraphical information from very high resolution SATellite images (PTDC/GEO/64826/2006), e-GEO – Centro de Estudos de Geografia e Planeamento Regional, da Faculdade de Ciências Sociais e Humanas, no quadro do Grupo de Investigação Modelação Geográfica, Cidades e Ordenamento do Territóri