51,760 research outputs found
Non-Parametric Estimation of ROC Curves in the Absence of a Gold Standard
In evaluation of diagnostic accuracy of tests, a gold standard on the disease status is required. However, in many complex diseases, it is impossible or unethical to obtain such the gold standard. If an imperfect standard is used as if it were a gold standard, the estimated accuracy of the tests would be biased. This type of bias is called imperfect gold standard bias. In this paper we develop a maximum likelihood (ML) method for estimating ROC curves and their areas of ordinal-scale tests in the absence of a gold standard. Our simulation study shows the proposed estimates for the ROC curve areas have good finite-sample properties in terms of bias and mean squared error (MSE). Further simulation studies show that our non-parametric approach is comparable to a parametric method without specific model assumptions, and is easier to implement. Finally, we illustrate the application of the proposed method in a real clinical study on assessing the accuracy of seven specific pathologists in detecting carcinoma in situ of the uterine cervix
Recommended from our members
Estimating Diagnostic Accuracy of Raters Without a Gold Standard by Exploiting a Group of Experts
In diagnostic medicine, estimating the diagnostic accuracy of a group of raters or medical tests relative to the gold standard is often the primary goal. When a gold standard is absent, latent class models where the unknown gold standard test is treated as a latent variable are often used. However, these models have been criticized in the literature from both a conceptual and a robustness perspective. As an alternative, we propose an approach where we exploit an imperfect reference standard with unknown diagnostic accuracy and conduct sensitivity analysis by varying this accuracy over scientifically reasonable ranges. In this article, a latent class model with crossed random effects is proposed for estimating the diagnostic accuracy of regional obstetrics and gynaecological (OB/GYN) physicians in diagnosing endometriosis. To avoid the pitfalls of models without a gold standard, we exploit the diagnostic results of a group of OB/GYN physicians with an international reputation for the diagnosis of endometriosis. We construct an ordinal reference standard based on the discordance among these international experts and propose a mechanism for conducting sensitivity analysis relative to the unknown diagnostic accuracy among them. A Monte Carlo EM algorithm is proposed for parameter estimation and a BIC-type model selection procedure is presented. Through simulations and data analysis we show that this new approach provides a useful alternative to traditional latent class modeling approaches used in this setting.Keywords: Sensitivity, Imperfect tests, Model selection, Diagnostic error, Prevalence, SpecificityKeywords: Sensitivity, Imperfect tests, Model selection, Diagnostic error, Prevalence, Specificit
Partially-Latent Class Models (pLCM) for Case-Control Studies of Childhood Pneumonia Etiology
In population studies on the etiology of disease, one goal is the estimation
of the fraction of cases attributable to each of several causes. For example,
pneumonia is a clinical diagnosis of lung infection that may be caused by
viral, bacterial, fungal, or other pathogens. The study of pneumonia etiology
is challenging because directly sampling from the lung to identify the
etiologic pathogen is not standard clinical practice in most settings. Instead,
measurements from multiple peripheral specimens are made. This paper introduces
the statistical methodology designed for estimating the population etiology
distribution and the individual etiology probabilities in the Pneumonia
Etiology Research for Child Health (PERCH) study of 9; 500 children for 7 sites
around the world. We formulate the scientific problem in statistical terms as
estimating the mixing weights and latent class indicators under a
partially-latent class model (pLCM) that combines heterogeneous measurements
with different error rates obtained from a case-control study. We introduce the
pLCM as an extension of the latent class model. We also introduce graphical
displays of the population data and inferred latent-class frequencies. The
methods are tested with simulated data, and then applied to PERCH data. The
paper closes with a brief description of extensions of the pLCM to the
regression setting and to the case where conditional independence among the
measures is relaxed.Comment: 25 pages, 4 figures, 1 supplementary materia
nonbinROC: Software for Evaluating Diagnostic Accuracies with Non-Binary Gold Standards
ROC analysis is a standard method for estimating and comparing diagnostic tests' accuracies when the gold standard is binary. However, there are many situations when the gold standard is not binary. In these situations, traditional ROC methods applied have lead to biased and uninformative outcomes. This article introduces nonbinROC, software for R that implements nonparametric estimators proposed by Obuchowski (2005) for estimating and comparing diagnostic tests' accuracies when the gold standard is measured on a continuous, ordinal or nominal scale. The results produced from these estimators are interpreted in the same manner as in ROC analysis but are not associated with any ROC curve.
Partially Identified Prevalence Estimation under Misclassification using the Kappa Coefficient
We discuss a new strategy for prevalence estimation in the presence of misclassification. Our method is applicable when misclassification probabilities are unknown but independent replicate measurements are available. This yields the kappa coefficient, which indicates the agreement between the two measurements. From this information, a direct correction for misclassification is not feasible due to non-identifiability. However, it is possible to derive estimation intervals relying on the concept of partial identification. These intervals give interesting insights into possible bias due to misclassification. Furthermore, confidence intervals can be constructed. Our method is illustrated in several theoretical scenarios and in an example from oral health, where prevalence estimation of caries in children is the issue
- …