591 research outputs found
Augmented Conversation and Cognitive Apprenticeship Metamodel Based Intelligent Learning Activity Builder System
This research focused on a formal (theory based) approach to designing Intelligent Tutoring System (ITS) authoring tool involving two specific conventional pedagogical theoriesâConversation Theory (CT) and Cognitive Apprenticeship (CA). The research conceptualised an Augmented Conversation and Cognitive Apprenticeship Metamodel (ACCAM) based on apriori theoretical knowledge and assumptions of its underlying theories. ACCAM was implemented in an Intelligent Learning Activity Builder System (ILABS)âan ITS authoring tool. ACCAMâs implementation aims to facilitate formally designed tutoring systems, hence, ILABSâthe practical implementation of ACCAMâ constructs metamodels for Intelligent Learning Activity Tools (ILATs) in a numerical problem-solving context (focusing on the construction of procedural knowledge in applied numerical disciplines). Also, an Intelligent Learning Activity Management System (ILAMS), although not the focus of this research, was developed as a launchpad for ILATs constructed and to administer learning activities. Hence, ACCAM and ILABS constitute the conceptual and practical contributions that respectively flow from this research.
ACCAMâs implementation was tested through the evaluation of ILABS and ILATs within an applied numerical domainâthe accounting domain. The evaluation focused on the key constructs of ACCAMâcognitive visibility and conversation, implemented through a tutoring strategy employing Process Monitoring (PM). PM augments conversation within a cognitive apprenticeship framework; it aims to improve the visibility of the cognitive process of a learner and infers intelligence in tutoring systems. PM was implemented via an interface that attempts to bring learnerâs thought process to the surface. This approach contrasted with previous studies that adopted standard Artificial Intelligence (AI) based inference techniques. The interface-based PM extends the existing CT and CA work. The strategy (i.e. interface-based PM) makes available a new tutoring approach that aimed fine-grain (or step-wise) feedbacks, unlike the goal-oriented feedbacks of model-tracing. The impact of PMâas a preventive strategy (or intervention) and to aid diagnosis of learnersâ cognitive processâwas investigated in relation to other constructs from the literature (such as detection of misconception, feedback generation and perceived learning effectiveness). Thus, the conceptualisation and implementation of PM via an interface also contributes to knowledge and practice.
The evaluation of the ACCAM-based design approach and investigation of the above mentioned constructs were undertaken through usersâ reaction/perception to ILABS and ILAT. This involved, principally, quantitative approach. However, a qualitative approach was also utilised to gain deeper insight. Findings from the evaluation supports the formal (theory based) design approachâthe design of ILABS through interaction with ACCAM. Empirical data revealed the presence of conversation and cognitive visibility constructs in ILATs, which were determined through its behaviour during the learning process. This research identified some other theoretical elements (e.g. motivation, reflection, remediation, evaluation, etc.) that possibly play out in a learning process. This clarifies key conceptual variables that should be considered when constructing tutoring systems for applied numerical disciplines (e.g. accounting, engineering). Also, the research revealed that PM enhances the detection of a learnerâs misconception and feedback generation. Nevertheless, qualitative data revealed that frequent feedbacks due to the implementation of PM could be obstructive to thought process at advance stage of learning. Thus, PM implementations should also include delayed diagnosis, especially for advance learners who prefer to have it on request. Despite that, current implementation allows users to turn PM off, thereby using alternative learning route. Overall, the research revealed that the implementation of interface-based PM (i.e. conversation and cognitive visibility) improved the visibility of learnerâs cognitive process, and this in turn enhanced learningâas perceived
A Metamodel for Designing an Intelligent Tutoring Systems Authoring Tool
Previous intelligent tutoring systems (ITS) and ITS authoring studies predominantly simulated and evaluated artificial intelligence (AI) techniques and cognitive architectures/notions in educational domains. Current research focuses on software design that is priori driven by educational theories; it concerns the conception of
Augmented Conversation and Cognitive Apprenticeship Metamodel (ACCAM). The pedagogy driven metamodelâACCAMâforms the basis for a formal (theory based) approach to designing ITS authoring tools for numerical aspect of numerical disciplines. This research, therefore, showcases the convergence of two
theoretical perspectivesâthe Conversation Theory (CT) and Cognitive Apprenticeship (CA)âwhich were never considered together before now. The novel conceptual platformâthe ACCAMâflows and benefited from the synergistic effect of the stated theories through the introduction of the concept of âaugmented conversationâ
within the resulting integrated framework. Thus, current work draws on the pedagogical import of the mentioned educational theories, elicits new meanings, and lays the foundation as well as opens future evaluation of a pedagogical engineering methodology that flows therefrom
Traditional classroom versus distance learning approaches in providing eduactaion for students at the College of Applied Science and Technology at RIT
This thesis discusses the current controversial issue of traditional classroom vs. distance learning approaches in higher education institutions using a case study in the College of Applied Science and Technology at RIT. The most important question addressed in the thesis is, Are distance learning methods effective for addressing university-level learning goals? (Kathleen Davey, 1999, p. 45). There are currently many disputes between educational researchers on this issue. The first four chapters cover details of the proposal stage as previously approved by the Thesis Committee. Chapter One briefly introduces this issue and several important terms used throughout the thesis (e.g., distance learning, traditional classroom, and self-directing learning). Chapter Two presents an in-depth review and analysis of educational and psychological theories and research literature. Chapters Three and Four present principal research questions explored in addressing this issue, as well as ways that relevant data was obtained and analyzed using an action research methodology. The next three chapters discuss the data collection and analysis stage. Chapter Five presents data secured from surveyed RIT administrators\u27 interviews and questionnaire responses. Chapter Six describes data collected and analyzed based on observations in both the traditional classroom and distance learning sections of the surveyed course. Chapters Seven and Eight provide the results of data collection and analysis activities completed for instructors and students in the same two sections. These chapters include operational definitions, visual graphs, tables, and analytical interpretations of the data collected. The last three chapters present conclusions based on the data and analyses previously documented. Chapter Nine discusses gaps between instructors\u27 teaching styles and students\u27 learning styles for the surveyed course. Chapter Ten compares RIT\u27s university learning goals with the viewpoints and performance of instructors and students in both the traditional classroom and distance learning sections, and recommends ways to alleviate the performance discrepancies detected. Chapter Eleven presents serendipitous findings and limitations of the study. The general answer to the most important question addressed in the thesis is that current RIT distance learning methods are not as effective as needed to fully comply with university-level learning goals. However, Chapter Ten concludes that both traditional classroom and distance learning methods can be much more successful in meeting these goals if RIT implements the recommendations presented in this chapter and explores other ways to enhance both environments of the education system
Introductory programming: a systematic literature review
As computing becomes a mainstream discipline embedded in the school curriculum and acts as an enabler for an increasing range of academic disciplines in higher education, the literature on introductory programming is growing. Although there have been several reviews that focus on specific aspects of introductory programming, there has been no broad overview of the literature exploring recent trends across the breadth of introductory programming.
This paper is the report of an ITiCSE working group that conducted a systematic review in order to gain an overview of the introductory programming literature. Partitioning the literature into papers addressing the student, teaching, the curriculum, and assessment, we explore trends, highlight advances in knowledge over the past 15 years, and indicate possible directions for future research
Recommended from our members
Rethinking teaching strategies : a framework and demonstration through augmenting Maple
In this work, an interdisciplinary approach has been adopted for the study of
âą teaching strategies of an Intelligent Tutoring System, in the paradigm of multiple teaching strategies, and
âą the use of Computer Algebra Systems (CAS) in teaching problem solving in university mathematics.
As a result, the SIMTA (Styles Implemented by Methods Tactics Actions) theoretical framework has been developed to support and sustain teaching strategies in the paradigm of multiple teaching strategies. TeLoDe (TEaching Linear Ordinary Differential Equations), is a prototype Intelligent Tutoring System, teaching the ,solution of linear second order differential equations with constant coefficients in a novel way. This novel way, which has been empirically tested, has been achieved by augmenting Maple and represents an alternative use of CASs where the human lecturer and Maple are interlocked in a symbiotic and interdependent manner.
In SIMTA, the contemporary concept of teaching strategy is rethought and proposed to be viewed at two fundamental levels:
âą the organisational level
âą and the operational level.
The organisational level deals with the structure of the teaching strategy whereas the operational level deals with the manifestation of that structure.
In SIMTA the organisational level is represented by a triple generic structure, method, tactic(s), action(s). A method is a mechanism for structuring the subject matter (e.g. analogy, examples, generalisation, specialisation). Likewise, a tactic is a mechanism for facilitating the interaction (e.g. explicit interaction, implicit interaction). An action is a low level activity such as display this message, ask this question.
In SIMTA, the exact manifestation of the above generic structures (analogies, examples, implicit interaction, explicit interaction) depends on the concept of style: different styles result in different manifestations of the same generic structures. Thus, in SIMTA the concept of multiple teaching strategies is seen as merely a collection of teaching strategies manifested under the same style. These strategies operate with the aim of offering alternative representations of the same task at hand and ensuring that the lea~er is active by activating, directing and maintaining exploration.
To help demonstrate the feasibility of SIMTA, two styles, the expository style and the , guided discovery style have been formed. The expository style draws on Ausubel's theory of meaningful learning, whereas, the guided discovery style draws on Bruner's work. These styles have been implemented in TeLoDe.
TeLoDe, incorporates a teaching strategy module, based on a style, and declarative knowledge. Its purpose is threefold:
(i) to serve as a research tool for the SIMTA framework,
(ii) to serve as a prototype, demonstrating clearly how a 'second generation' CAS which undertakes the procedural aspect of mathematics allowing the human tutor to concentrate on its conceptual aspect, could be developed,
(iii) to demonstrate how Maple and human lecturers are given clear roles which are, nevertheless, interdependent in carrying out the teaching of university mathematics.
Two small-scale empirical studies were carried out in order to test SIMTA and TeLoDe respectively. The first study involved lecturers whereas the second study was carried out in a classroom environment. The results found from these studies demonstrate that TeLoDe has a potential as a teaching tool for problem solving in university mathematics in a novel way
A methodology for evaluating intelligent tutoring systems
DissertationThis dissertation proposes a generic methodology for evaluating intelligent tutoring systems (ITSs),
and applies it to the evaluation of the SQL-Tutor, an ITS for the database language SQL.
An examination of the historical development, theory and architecture of intelligent tutoring
systems, as well as the theory, architecture and behaviour of the SQL-Tutor sets the context for this
study. The characteristics and criteria for evaluating computer-aided instruction (CAl) systems are
considered as a background to an in-depth investigation of the characteristics and criteria
appropriate for evaluating ITSs. These criteria are categorised along internal and external
dimensions with the internal dimension focusing on the intrinsic features and behavioural aspects
of ITSs, and the external dimension focusing on its educational impact. Several issues surrounding
the evaluation of ITSs namely, approaches, methods, techniques and principles are examined, and
integrated within a framework for assessing the added value of ITS technology for instructional
purposes.Educational StudiesM. Sc. (Information Systems
A generic architecture for interactive intelligent tutoring systems
This thesis was submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy and awarded by Brunel University, 07/06/2001.This research is focused on developing a generic intelligent architecture for an interactive tutoring system. A review of the literature in the areas of instructional theories, cognitive and social views of learning, intelligent tutoring systems development methodologies, and knowledge representation methods was conducted. As a result, a generic ITS development architecture (GeNisa) has been proposed, which combines the features of knowledge base systems (KBS) with object-oriented methodology. The GeNisa architecture consists of the following components: a tutorial events communication module, which encapsulates the interactive processes and other independent computations between different components; a software design toolkit; and an autonomous knowledge acquisition from a probabilistic knowledge base. A graphical application development environment includes tools to support application development, and learning environments and which use a case scenario as a basis for instruction. The generic architecture is designed to support client-side execution in a Web browser environment, and further testing will show that it can disseminate applications over the World Wide Web. Such an architecture can be adapted to different teaching styles and domains, and reusing instructional materials automatically can reduce the effort of the courseware developer (hence cost and time) in authoring new materials. GeNisa was implemented using Java scripts, and subsequently evaluated at various commercial and academic organisations. Parameters chosen for the evaluation include quality of courseware, relevancy of case scenarios, portability to other platforms, ease of use, content, user-friendliness, screen display, clarity, topic interest, and overall satisfaction with GeNisa. In general, the evaluation focused on the novel characteristics and performances of the GeNisa architecture in comparison with other ITS and the results obtained are discussed and analysed.
On the basis of the experience gained during the literature research and GeNisa development and evaluation. a generic methodology for ITS development is proposed as well as the requirements for the further development of ITS tools. Finally, conclusions are drawn and areas for further research are identified
The student-produced electronic portfolio in craft education
The authors studied primary school studentsâ experiences of using an electronic portfolio in their craft education over four years. A stimulated recall interview was applied to collect user experiences and qualitative content analysis to analyse the collected data. The results indicate that the electronic portfolio was experienced as a multipurpose tool to support learning. It makes the learning process visible and in that way helps focus on and improves the quality of learning. © ISLS.Peer reviewe
Community ServiceLearning and the Vocational Teacher
While many have tried to understand the notion of service-learning, no one seems to agree on one definition or description. A Wingspread conference in 1990 defined service-learning as both a philosophy and a program (Giles, Honnet, & Migliore, 1991). The National and Community I Service Act (1990) contained a four part definition which described characteristics and processes of service-learning, including reflective components which tie service experiences to a curriculum
- âŠ