Low Power Processor Architectures and Contemporary Techniques for Power Optimization – A Review

The technological evolution has increased the number of transistors for a given die area significantly and increased the switching speed from few MHz to GHz range. Such inversely proportional decline in size and boost in performance consequently demands shrinking of supply voltage and effective power dissipation in chips with millions of transistors. This has triggered substantial amount of research in power reduction techniques into almost every aspect of the chip and particularly the processor cores contained in the chip. This paper presents an overview of techniques for achieving the power efficiency mainly at the processor core level but also visits related domains such as buses and memories. There are various processor parameters and features such as supply voltage, clock frequency, cache and pipelining which can be optimized to reduce the power consumption of the processor. This paper discusses various ways in which these parameters can be optimized. Also, emerging power efficient processor architectures are overviewed and research activities are discussed which should help reader identify how these factors in a processor contribute to power consumption. Some of these concepts have been already established whereas others are still active research areas. © 2009 ACADEMY PUBLISHER

Null convention logic circuits for asynchronous computer architecture

For most of its history, computer architecture has been able to benefit from a rapid scaling in semiconductor technology, resulting in continuous improvements to CPU design. During that period, synchronous logic has dominated because of its inherent ease of design and abundant tools. However, with the scaling of semiconductor processes into deep sub-micron and then to nano-scale dimensions, computer architecture is hitting a number of roadblocks such as high power and increased process variability. Asynchronous techniques can potentially offer many advantages compared to conventional synchronous design, including average case vs. worse case performance, robustness in the face of process and operating point variability and the ready availability of high performance, fine grained pipeline architectures. Of the many alternative approaches to asynchronous design, Null Convention Logic (NCL) has the advantage that its quasi delay-insensitive behavior makes it relatively easy to set up complex circuits without the need for exhaustive timing analysis. This thesis examines the characteristics of an NCL based asynchronous RISC-V CPU and analyses the problems with applying NCL to CPU design. While a number of university and industry groups have previously developed small 8-bit microprocessor architectures using NCL techniques, it is still unclear whether these offer any real advantages over conventional synchronous design. A key objective of this work has been to analyse the impact of larger word widths and more complex architectures on NCL CPU implementations. The research commenced by re-evaluating existing techniques for implementing NCL on programmable devices such as FPGAs. The little work that has been undertaken previously on FPGA implementations of asynchronous logic has been inconclusive and seems to indicate that asynchronous systems cannot be easily implemented in these devices. However, most of this work related to an alternative technique called bundled data, which is not well suited to FPGA implementation because of the difficulty in controlling and matching delays in a 'bundle' of signals. On the other hand, this thesis clearly shows that such applications are not only possible with NCL, but there are some distinct advantages in being able to prototype complex asynchronous systems in a field-programmable technology such as the FPGA. A large part of the value of NCL derives from its architectural level behavior, inherent pipelining, and optimization opportunities such as the merging of register and combina- tional logic functions. In this work, a number of NCL multiplier architectures have been analyzed to reveal the performance trade-offs between various non-pipelined, 1D and 2D organizations. Two-dimensional pipelining can easily be applied to regular architectures such as array multipliers in a way that is both high performance and area-efficient. It was found that the performance of 2D pipelining for small networks such as multipliers is around 260% faster than the equivalent non-pipelined design. However, the design uses 265% more transistors so the methodology is mainly of benefit where performance is strongly favored over area. A pipelined 32bit x 32bit signed Baugh-Wooley multiplier with Wallace-Tree Carry Save Adders (CSA), which is representative of a real design used for CPUs and DSPs, was used to further explore this concept as it is faster and has fewer pipeline stages compared to the normal array multiplier using Ripple-Carry adders (RCA). It was found that 1D pipelining with ripple-carry chains is an efficient implementation option but becomes less so for larger multipliers, due to the completion logic for which the delay time depends largely on the number of bits involved in the completion network. The average-case performance of ripple-carry adders was explored using random input vectors and it was observed that it offers little advantage on the smaller multiplier blocks, but this particular timing characteristic of asynchronous design styles be- comes increasingly more important as word size grows. Finally, this research has resulted in the development of the first 32-Bit asynchronous RISC-V CPU core. Called the Redback RISC, the architecture is a structure of pipeline rings composed of computational oscillations linked with flow completeness relationships. It has been written using NELL, a commercial description/synthesis tool that outputs standard Verilog. The Redback has been analysed and compared to two approximately equivalent industry standard 32-Bit synchronous RISC-V cores (PicoRV32 and Rocket) that are already fabricated and used in industry. While the NCL implementation is larger than both commercial cores it has similar performance and lower power compared to the PicoRV32. The implementation results were also compared against an existing NCL design tool flow (UNCLE), which showed how much the results of these implementation strategies differ. The Redback RISC has achieved similar level of throughput and 43% better power and 34% better energy compared to one of the synchronous cores with the same benchmark test and test condition such as input sup- ply voltage. However, it was shown that area is the biggest drawback for NCL CPU design. The core is roughly 2.5× larger than synchronous designs. On the other hand its area is still 2.9× smaller than previous designs using UNCLE tools. The area penalty is largely due to the unavoidable translation into a dual-rail topology when using the standard NCL cell library

Design And Synthesis Of Clockless Pipelines Based On Self-resetting Stage Logic

For decades, digital design has been primarily dominated by clocked circuits. With larger scales of integration made possible by improved semiconductor manufacturing techniques, relying on a clock signal to orchestrate logic operations across an entire chip became increasingly difficult. Motivated by this problem, designers are currently considering circuits which can operate without a clock. However, the wide acceptance of these circuits by the digital design community requires two ingredients: (i) a unified design methodology supported by widely available CAD tools, and (ii) a granularity of design techniques suitable for synthesizing large designs. Currently, there is no unified established design methodology to support the design and verification of these circuits. Moreover, the majority of clockless design techniques is conceived at circuit level, and is subsequently so fine-grain, that their application to large designs can have unacceptable area costs. Given these considerations, this dissertation presents a new clockless technique, called self-resetting stage logic (SRSL), in which the computation of a block is reset periodically from within the block itself. SRSL is used as a building block for three coarse-grain pipelining techniques: (i) Stage-controlled self-resetting stage logic (S-SRSL) Pipelines: In these pipelines, the control of the communication between stages is performed locally between each pair of stages. This communication is performed in a uni-directional manner in order to simplify its implementation. (ii) Pipeline-controlled self-resetting stage logic (P-SRSL) Pipelines: In these pipelines, the communication between each pair of stages in the pipeline is driven by the oscillation of the last pipeline stage. Their communication scheme is identical to the one used in S-SRSL pipelines. (iii) Delay-tolerant self-resetting stage logic (D-SRSL) Pipelines: While communication in these pipelines is local in nature in a manner similar to the one used in S-SRL pipelines, this communication is nevertheless extended in both directions. The result of this bi-directional approach is an increase in the capability of the pipeline to handle stages with random delay. Based on these pipelining techniques, a new design methodology is proposed to synthesize clockless designs. The synthesis problem consists of synthesizing an SRSL pipeline from a gate netlist with a minimum area overhead given a specified data rate. A two-phase heuristic algorithm is proposed to solve this problem. The goal of the algorithm is to pipeline a given datapath by minimizing the area occupied by inter-stage latches without violating any timing constraints. Experiments with this synthesis algorithm show that while P-SRSL pipelines can reach high throughputs in shallow pipelines, D-SRSL pipelines can achieve comparable throughputs in deeper pipelines

Fast Heuristic and Exact Algorithms for Two-Level Hazard-Free Logic Minimization

None of the available minimizers for 2-level hazard-free logic minimization can synthesize very large circuits. This limitation has forced researchers to resort to manual and automated circuit partitioning techniques. This paper introduces two new 2-level logic minimizers:ESPRESSO-HF, a heuristic method which is loosely based on ESPRESSO-II, and IMPYMIN, an exact method based on implicit data structures. Both minimizers can solve all currently available examples, which range up to 32 inputs and 33 outputs.These include examples that have never been solved before.For examples that can be solved by other minimizers our methods are several orders of magnitude faster. As by-products of these algorithms, we also present two additional results. First, we introduce a fast new algorithm to check if a hazard-free covering problem can feasibly be solved. Second, we introduce a novel formulation of the 2-level hazard-free logic minimization problem by capturing hazard-freedom constraints within a synchronous function by adding new variables

Fast Heuristic and Exact Algorithms for Two-Level Hazard-Free Logic Minimization

None of the available minimizers for 2-level hazard-free logic minimization can synthesize very large circuits. This limitation has forced researchers to resort to manual and automated circuit partitioning techniques. This paper introduces two new 2-level logic minimizers:ESPRESSO-HF, a heuristic method which is loosely based on ESPRESSO-II, and IMPYMIN, an exact method based on implicit data structures. Both minimizers can solve all currently available examples, which range up to 32 inputs and 33 outputs.These include examples that have never been solved before.For examples that can be solved by other minimizers our methods are several orders of magnitude faster. As by-products of these algorithms, we also present two additional results. First, we introduce a fast new algorithm to check if a hazard-free covering problem can feasibly be solved. Second, we introduce a novel formulation of the 2-level hazard-free logic minimization problem by capturing hazard-freedom constraints within a synchronous function by adding new variables

High-Performance Placement and Routing for the Nanometer Scale.

Modern semiconductor manufacturing facilitates single-chip electronic systems that only five years ago required ten to twenty chips. Naturally, design complexity has grown within this period. In contrast to this growth, it is becoming common in the industry to limit design team size which places a heavier burden on design automation tools. Our work identifies new objectives, constraints and concerns in the physical design of systems-on-chip, and develops new computational techniques to address them. In addition to faster and more relevant design optimizations, we demonstrate that traditional design flows based on ``separation of concerns'' produce unnecessarily suboptimal layouts. We develop new integrated optimizations that streamline traditional chains of loosely-linked design tools. In particular, we bridge the gap between mixed-size placement and routing by updating the objective of global and detail placement to a more accurate estimate of routed wirelength. To this we add sophisticated whitespace allocation, and the combination provides increased routability, faster routing, shorter routed wirelength, and the best via counts of published techniques. To further improve post-routing design metrics, we present new global routing techniques based on Discrete Lagrange Multipliers (DLM) which produce the best routed wirelength results on recent benchmarks. Our work culminates in the integration of our routing techniques within an incremental placement flow to improve detailed routing solutions, shrink die sizes and reduce total chip cost. Not only do our techniques improve the quality and cost of designs, but also simplify design automation software implementation in many cases. Ultimately, we reduce the time needed for design closure through improved tool fidelity and the use of our incremental techniques for placement and routing.Ph.D.Computer Science & EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/64639/1/royj_1.pd

Ensuring Service Level Agreements for Composite Services by Means of Request Scheduling

Building distributed systems according to the Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA) allows simplifying the integration process, reducing development costs and increasing scalability, interoperability and openness. SOA endorses the reusability of existing services and aggregating them into new service layers for future recycling. At the same time, the complexity of large service-oriented systems negatively reflects on their behavior in terms of the exhibited Quality of Service. To address this problem this thesis focuses on using request scheduling for meeting Service Level Agreements (SLAs). The special focus is given to composite services specified by means of workflow languages. The proposed solution suggests using two level scheduling: global and local. The global policies assign the response time requirements for component service invocations. The local scheduling policies are responsible for performing request scheduling in order to meet these requirements. The proposed scheduling approach can be deployed without altering the code of the scheduled services, does not require a central point of control and is platform independent. The experiments, conducted using a simulation, were used to study the effectiveness and the feasibility of the proposed scheduling schemes in respect to various deployment requirements. The validity of the simulation was confirmed by comparing its results to the results obtained in experiments with a real-world service. The proposed approach was shown to work well under different traffic conditions and with different types of SLAs