Security Code Smells in Android ICC

Android Inter-Component Communication (ICC) is complex, largely unconstrained, and hard for developers to understand. As a consequence, ICC is a common source of security vulnerability in Android apps. To promote secure programming practices, we have reviewed related research, and identified avoidable ICC vulnerabilities in Android-run devices and the security code smells that indicate their presence. We explain the vulnerabilities and their corresponding smells, and we discuss how they can be eliminated or mitigated during development. We present a lightweight static analysis tool on top of Android Lint that analyzes the code under development and provides just-in-time feedback within the IDE about the presence of such smells in the code. Moreover, with the help of this tool we study the prevalence of security code smells in more than 700 open-source apps, and manually inspect around 15% of the apps to assess the extent to which identifying such smells uncovers ICC security vulnerabilities.Comment: Accepted on 28 Nov 2018, Empirical Software Engineering Journal (EMSE), 201

The Dilemma of Security Smells and How to Escape It

A single mobile app can now be more complex than entire operating systems ten years ago, thus security becomes a major concern for mobile apps. Unfortunately, previous studies focused rather on particular aspects of mobile application security and did not provide a holistic overview of security issues. Therefore, they could not accurately understand the fundamental flaws to propose effective solutions to common security problems. In order to understand these fundamental flaws, we followed a hybrid strategy, i.e., we collected reported issues from existing work, and we actively identified security-related code patterns that violate best practices in software development. We further introduced the term ``security smell,'' i.e., a security issue that could potentially lead to a vulnerability. As a result, we were able to establish comprehensive security smell catalogues for Android apps and related components, i.e., inter-component communication, web communication, app servers, and HTTP clients. Furthermore, we could identify a dilemma of security smells, because most security smells require unique fixes that increase the code complexity, which in return increases the risk of introducing more security smells. With this knowledge, we investigate the interaction of our security smells with the 192 Mitre CAPEC attack mechanism categories of which the majority could be mitigated with just a few additional security measures. These measures, a String class with behavior and the more thorough use of secure default values and paradigms, would simplify the application logic and at the same time largely increase security if implemented appropriately. We conclude that application security has to focus on the String class, which has not largely changed over the last years, and secure default values and paradigms since they are the smallest common denominator for a strong foundation to build resilient applications. Moreover, we provide an initial implementation for a String class with behavior, however the further exploration remains future work. Finally, the term ``security smell'' is now widely used in academia and eases the communication among security researchers

The Dilemma of Security Smells and How to Escape It

A single mobile app can now be more complex than entire operating systems ten years ago, thus security becomes a major concern for mobile apps. Unfortunately, previous studies focused rather on particular aspects of mobile application security and did not provide a holistic overview of security issues. Therefore, they could not accurately understand the fundamental flaws to propose effective solutions to common security problems. In order to understand these fundamental flaws, we followed a hybrid strategy, i.e., we collected reported issues from existing work, and we actively identified security-related code patterns that violate best-practices in software development. Based on these findings, we compiled a list of security smells, i.e., security issues that could potentially lead to a vulnerability. As a result, we were able to establish comprehensive security smell catalogues for Android apps and related components, i.e., inter-component communication, web communication, app servers, and HTTP clients. Furthermore, we could identify a dilemma of security smells, because most security smells require unique fixes that increase the code complexity, which in return increases the risk of introducing more security smells. With this knowledge, we investigate the interaction of our security smells with the 192 Mitre CAPEC attack mechanism categories of which the majority could be mitigated with just a few additional security measures. These measures, a String class with behavior and the more thorough use of secure default values and paradigms, would simplify the application logic and at the same time largely increase security if implemented appropriately. We conclude that application security has to focus on the String class, which has not largely changed over the last years, and secure default values and paradigms since they are the smallest common denominator for a strong foundation to build resilient applications. Moreover, we provide an initial implementation for a String class with behavior, however the further exploration remains future work. Finally, the term "security smell" is now widely used in academia and eases the communication among security researchers

A Survey and Evaluation of Android-Based Malware Evasion Techniques and Detection Frameworks

Android platform security is an active area of research where malware detection techniques continuously evolve to identify novel malware and improve the timely and accurate detection of existing malware. Adversaries are constantly in charge of employing innovative techniques to avoid or prolong malware detection effectively. Past studies have shown that malware detection systems are susceptible to evasion attacks where adversaries can successfully bypass the existing security defenses and deliver the malware to the target system without being detected. The evolution of escape-resistant systems is an open research problem. This paper presents a detailed taxonomy and evaluation of Android-based malware evasion techniques deployed to circumvent malware detection. The study characterizes such evasion techniques into two broad categories, polymorphism and metamorphism, and analyses techniques used for stealth malware detection based on the malware’s unique characteristics. Furthermore, the article also presents a qualitative and systematic comparison of evasion detection frameworks and their detection methodologies for Android-based malware. Finally, the survey discusses open-ended questions and potential future directions for continued research in mobile malware detection

Analyzing the Unanalyzable: an Application to Android Apps

In general, software is unreliable. Its behavior can deviate from users’ expectations because of bugs, vulnerabilities, or even malicious code. Manually vetting software is a challenging, tedious, and highly-costly task that does not scale. To alleviate excessive costs and analysts’ burdens, automated static analysis techniques have been proposed by both the research and practitioner communities making static analysis a central topic in software engineering. In the meantime, mobile apps have considerably grown in importance. Today, most humans carry software in their pockets, with the Android operating system leading the market. Millions of apps have been proposed to the public so far, targeting a wide range of activities such as games, health, banking, GPS, etc. Hence, Android apps collect and manipulate a considerable amount of sensitive information, which puts users’ security and privacy at risk. Consequently, it is paramount to ensure that apps distributed through public channels (e.g., the Google Play) are free from malicious code. Hence, the research and practitioner communities have put much effort into devising new automated techniques to vet Android apps against malicious activities over the last decade. Analyzing Android apps is, however, challenging. On the one hand, the Android framework proposes constructs that can be used to evade dynamic analysis by triggering the malicious code only under certain circumstances, e.g., if the device is not an emulator and is currently connected to power. Hence, dynamic analyses can -easily- be fooled by malicious developers by making some code fragments difficult to reach. On the other hand, static analyses are challenged by Android-specific constructs that limit the coverage of off-the-shell static analyzers. The research community has already addressed some of these constructs, including inter-component communication or lifecycle methods. However, other constructs, such as implicit calls (i.e., when the Android framework asynchronously triggers a method in the app code), make some app code fragments unreachable to the static analyzers, while these fragments are executed when the app is run. Altogether, many apps’ code parts are unanalyzable: they are either not reachable by dynamic analyses or not covered by static analyzers. In this manuscript, we describe our contributions to the research effort from two angles: ① statically detecting malicious code that is difficult to access to dynamic analyzers because they are triggered under specific circumstances; and ② statically analyzing code not accessible to existing static analyzers to improve the comprehensiveness of app analyses. More precisely, in Part I, we first present a replication study of a state-of-the-art static logic bomb detector to better show its limitations. We then introduce a novel hybrid approach for detecting suspicious hidden sensitive operations towards triaging logic bombs. We finally detail the construction of a dataset of Android apps automatically infected with logic bombs. In Part II, we present our work to improve the comprehensiveness of Android apps’ static analysis. More specifically, we first show how we contributed to account for atypical inter-component communication in Android apps. Then, we present a novel approach to unify both the bytecode and native in Android apps to account for the multi-language trend in app development. Finally, we present our work to resolve conditional implicit calls in Android apps to improve static and dynamic analyzers

Novel Attacks and Defenses in the Userland of Android

In the last decade, mobile devices have spread rapidly, becoming more and more part of our everyday lives; this is due to their feature-richness, mobility, and affordable price. At the time of writing, Android is the leader of the market among operating systems, with a share of 76% and two and a half billion active Android devices around the world. Given that such small devices contain a massive amount of our private and sensitive information, the economic interests in the mobile ecosystem skyrocketed. For this reason, not only legitimate apps running on mobile environments have increased dramatically, but also malicious apps have also been on a steady rise. On the one hand, developers of mobile operating systems learned from security mistakes of the past, and they made significant strides in blocking those threats right from the start. On the other hand, these high-security levels did not deter attackers. In this thesis, I present my research contribution about the most meaningful attack and defense scenarios in the userland of the modern Android operating system. I have emphasized "userland'' because attack and defense solutions presented in this thesis are executing in the userspace of the operating system, due to the fact that Android is slightly different from traditional operating systems. After the necessary technical background, I show my solution, RmPerm, in order to enable Android users to better protect their privacy by selectively removing permissions from any app on any Android version. This operation does not require any modification to the underlying operating system because we repack the original application. Then, using again repackaging, I have developed Obfuscapk; it is a black-box obfuscation tool that can work with every Android app and offers a free solution with advanced state of the art obfuscation techniques -- especially the ones used by malware authors. Subsequently, I present a machine learning-based technique that focuses on the identification of malware in resource-constrained devices such as Android smartphones. This technique has a very low resource footprint and does not rely on resources outside the protected device. Afterward, I show how it is possible to mount a phishing attack -- the historically preferred attack vector -- by exploiting two recent Android features, initially introduced in the name of convenience. Although a technical solution to this problem certainly exists, it is not solvable from a single entity, and there is the need for a push from the entire community. But sometimes, even though there exists a solution to a well-known vulnerability, developers do not take proper precautions. In the end, I discuss the Frame Confusion vulnerability; it is often present in hybrid apps, and it was discovered some years ago, but I show how it is still widespread. I proposed a methodology, implemented in the FCDroid tool, for systematically detecting the Frame Confusion vulnerability in hybrid Android apps. The results of an extensive analysis carried out through FCDroid on a set of the most downloaded apps from the Google Play Store prove that 6.63% (i.e., 1637/24675) of hybrid apps are potentially vulnerable to Frame Confusion. The impact of such results on the Android users' community is estimated in 250.000.000 installations of vulnerable apps

Towards a Network-based Approach for Smartphone Security

Smartphones have become an important utility that affects many aspects of our daily life. Due to their large dissemination and the tasks that are performed with them, they have also become a valuable target for criminals. Their specific capabilities and the way they are used introduce new threats in terms of information security. The research field of smartphone security has gained a lot of momentum in the past eight years. Approaches that have been presented so far focus on investigating design flaws of smartphone operating systems as well as their potential misuse by an adversary. Countermeasures are often realized based upon extensions made to the operating system itself, following a host-based design approach. However, there is a lack of network-based mechanisms that allow a secure integration of smartphones into existing IT infrastructures. This topic is especially relevant for companies whose employees use smartphones for business tasks. This thesis presents a novel, network-based approach for smartphone security called CADS: Context-related Signature and Anomaly Detection for Smartphones. It allows to determine the security status of smartphones by analyzing three aspects: (1) their current configuration in terms of installed software and available hardware, (2) their behavior and (3) the context they are currently used in. Depending on the determined security status, enforcement actions can be defined in order to allow or to deny access to services provided by the respective IT infrastructure. The approach is based upon the distributed collection and central analysis of data about smartphones. In contrast to other approaches, it explicitly supports to leverage existing security services both for analysis and enforcement purposes. A proof of concept is implemented based upon the IF-MAP protocol for network security and the Google Android platform. An evaluation verifies (1) that the CADS approach is able to detect so-called sensor sniffing attacks and (2) that reactions can be triggered based on detection results to counter ongoing attacks. Furthermore, it is demonstrated that the functionality of an existing, host-based approach that relies on modifications of the Android smartphone platform can be mimicked by the CADS approach. The advantage of CADS is that it does not need any modifications of the Android platform itself

Analysis of Mobile Malware: A Systematic Review of Evolution and Infection Strategies

The open-source and popularity of Android attracts hackers and has multiplied security concerns targeting devices. As such, malware attacks on Android are one of the security challenges facing society. This paper presents an analysis of mobile malware evolution between 2000-2020. The paper presents mobile malware types and in-depth infection strategies malware deploys to infect mobile devices. Accordingly, factors that restricted the fast spread of early malware and those that enhance the fast propagation of recent malware are identified. Moreover, the paper discusses and classifies mobile malware based on privilege escalation and attack goals. Based on the reviewed survey papers, our research presents recommendations in the form of measures to cope with emerging security threats posed by malware and thus decrease threats and malware infection rates. Finally, we identify the need for a critical analysis of mobile malware frameworks to identify their weaknesses and strengths to develop a more robust, accurate, and scalable tool from an Android detection standpoint. The survey results facilitate the understanding of mobile malware evolution and the infection trend. They also help mobile malware analysts to understand the current evasion techniques mobile malware deploys

Security Issues of Mobile and Smart Wearable Devices

Mobile and smart devices (ranging from popular smartphones and tablets to wearable fitness trackers equipped with sensing, computing and networking capabilities) have proliferated lately and redefined the way users carry out their day-to-day activities. These devices bring immense benefits to society and boast improved quality of life for users. As mobile and smart technologies become increasingly ubiquitous, the security of these devices becomes more urgent, and users should take precautions to keep their personal information secure. Privacy has also been called into question as so many of mobile and smart devices collect, process huge quantities of data, and store them on the cloud as a matter of fact. Ensuring confidentiality, integrity, and authenticity of the information is a cybersecurity challenge with no easy solution. Unfortunately, current security controls have not kept pace with the risks posed by mobile and smart devices, and have proven patently insufficient so far. Thwarting attacks is also a thriving research area with a substantial amount of still unsolved problems. The pervasiveness of smart devices, the growing attack vectors, and the current lack of security call for an effective and efficient way of protecting mobile and smart devices. This thesis deals with the security problems of mobile and smart devices, providing specific methods for improving current security solutions. Our contributions are grouped into two related areas which present natural intersections and corresponds to the two central parts of this document: (1) Tackling Mobile Malware, and (2) Security Analysis on Wearable and Smart Devices. In the first part of this thesis, we study methods and techniques to assist security analysts to tackle mobile malware and automate the identification of malicious applications. We provide threefold contributions in tackling mobile malware: First, we introduce a Secure Message Delivery (SMD) protocol for Device-to-Device (D2D) networks, with primary objective of choosing the most secure path to deliver a message from a sender to a destination in a multi-hop D2D network. Second, we illustrate a survey to investigate concrete and relevant questions concerning Android code obfuscation and protection techniques, where the purpose is to review code obfuscation and code protection practices. We evaluate efficacy of existing code de-obfuscation tools to tackle obfuscated Android malware (which provide attackers with the ability to evade detection mechanisms). Finally, we propose a Machine Learning-based detection framework to hunt malicious Android apps by introducing a system to detect and classify newly-discovered malware through analyzing applications. The proposed system classifies different types of malware from each other and helps to better understanding how malware can infect devices, the threat level they pose and how to protect against them. Our designed system leverages more complete coverage of apps’ behavioral characteristics than the state-of-the-art, integrates the most performant classifier, and utilizes the robustness of extracted features. The second part of this dissertation conducts an in-depth security analysis of the most popular wearable fitness trackers on the market. Our contributions are grouped into four central parts in this domain: First, we analyze the primitives governing the communication between fitness tracker and cloud-based services. In addition, we investigate communication requirements in this setting such as: (i) Data Confidentiality, (ii) Data Integrity, and (iii) Data Authenticity. Second, we show real-world demos on how modern wearable devices are vulnerable to false data injection attacks. Also, we document successful injection of falsified data to cloud-based services that appears legitimate to the cloud to obtain personal benefits. Third, we circumvent End-to-End protocol encryption implemented in the most advanced and secure fitness trackers (e.g., Fitbit, as the market leader) through Hardware-based reverse engineering. Last but not least, we provide guidelines for avoiding similar vulnerabilities in future system designs