168 research outputs found
Development of a Logic Layer in the Semantic Web: Research Issues
The ontology layer of the semantic web is now mature enough (i.e. standards like RDF, RDFs, OWL, OWL 2) and the next step is to work on a logic layer for the development of advanced reasoning capabilities for knowledge extraction and efficient decision making. Adding logic to the web means using rules to make inferences. Rules are a means of expressing business processes, policies, contracts etc but most of the studies have focused on the use of monotonic logics in layered development of the semantic web which provides no mechanism for representing or handling incomplete or contradictory information respectively. This paper discusses argumentation, semantic web and defeasible logic programming with their distinct features and identifies the different research issues that need to be addressed in order to realize defeasible argumentative reasoning in the semantic web applications
A Paradox of Inferentialism
John McDowell articulated a radical criticism of normative inferentialism against Robert Brandom’s expressivist account of conceptual contents. One of his main concerns consists in vindicating a notion of intentionality that could not be reduced to the deontic relations that are established by discursive practitioners. Noticeably, large part of this discussion is focused on empirical knowledge and observational judgments. McDowell
argues that there is no role for inference in the application of observational concepts, except the paradoxical one of justifying the content of an observational judgment in terms of itself. This paper examines the semantical consequences of the analysis of the content of empirical judgments in terms of their inferential role. These, it is suggested, are distinct from the epistemological paradoxes that McDowell charges the inferentialist approach with
Defeasible RDFS via Rational Closure
In the field of non-monotonic logics, the notion of Rational Closure (RC) is
acknowledged as a prominent approach. In recent years, RC has gained even more
popularity in the context of Description Logics (DLs), the logic underpinning
the semantic web standard ontology language OWL 2, whose main ingredients are
classes and roles. In this work, we show how to integrate RC within the triple
language RDFS, which together with OWL2 are the two major standard semantic web
ontology languages. To do so, we start from , which is the logic
behind RDFS, and then extend it to , allowing to state that two
entities are incompatible. Eventually, we propose defeasible via
a typical RC construction. The main features of our approach are: (i) unlike
most other approaches that add an extra non-monotone rule layer on top of
monotone RDFS, defeasible remains syntactically a triple
language and is a simple extension of by introducing some new
predicate symbols with specific semantics. In particular, any RDFS
reasoner/store may handle them as ordinary terms if it does not want to take
account for the extra semantics of the new predicate symbols; (ii) the
defeasible entailment decision procedure is build on top of the
entailment decision procedure, which in turn is an extension of
the one for via some additional inference rules favouring an
potential implementation; and (iii) defeasible entailment can be
decided in polynomial time.Comment: 47 pages. Preprint versio
Logic-based Technologies for Intelligent Systems: State of the Art and Perspectives
Together with the disruptive development of modern sub-symbolic approaches to artificial intelligence (AI), symbolic approaches to classical AI are re-gaining momentum, as more and more researchers exploit their potential to make AI more comprehensible, explainable, and therefore trustworthy. Since logic-based approaches lay at the core of symbolic AI, summarizing their state of the art is of paramount importance now more than ever, in order to identify trends, benefits, key features, gaps, and limitations of the techniques proposed so far, as well as to identify promising research perspectives. Along this line, this paper provides an overview of logic-based approaches and technologies by sketching their evolution and pointing out their main application areas. Future perspectives for exploitation of logic-based technologies are discussed as well, in order to identify those research fields that deserve more attention, considering the areas that already exploit logic-based approaches as well as those that are more likely to adopt logic-based approaches in the future
Argumentation for machine learning: a survey
Existing approaches using argumentation to aid or improve machine learning differ in the type of machine learning technique they consider, in their use of argumentation and in their choice of argumentation framework and semantics. This paper presents a survey of this relatively young field highlighting, in particular, its achievements to date, the applications it has been used for as well as the benefits brought about by the use of argumentation, with an eye towards its future
Logic-based Technologies for Multi-agent Systems: A Systematic Literature Review
Precisely when the success of artificial intelligence (AI) sub-symbolic techniques makes them be identified with the whole AI by many non-computerscientists and non-technical media, symbolic approaches are getting more and more attention as those that could make AI amenable to human understanding. Given the recurring cycles in the AI history, we expect that a revamp of technologies often tagged as “classical AI” – in particular, logic-based ones will take place in the next few years.
On the other hand, agents and multi-agent systems (MAS) have been at the core of the design of intelligent systems since their very beginning, and their long-term connection with logic-based technologies, which characterised their early days, might open new ways to engineer explainable intelligent systems. This is why understanding the current status of logic-based technologies for MAS is nowadays of paramount importance.
Accordingly, this paper aims at providing a comprehensive view of those technologies by making them the subject of a systematic literature review (SLR). The resulting technologies are discussed and evaluated from two different perspectives: the MAS and the logic-based ones
A General Markup Framework for Integrity and Derivation Rules
We propose a general markup framework for integrity and derivation rules (R2ML).
Rule concepts are defined with the help of MOF/UML, a subset of the UML class
modeling language proposed by the Object Management Group (OMG)
for the purpose of \u27meta-modeling\u27, i.e. for defining languages conceptually on
the level of an abstract (semi-visual) syntax.
From these MOF/UML language models we can obtain concrete markup syntax
by applying a mapping procedure for generating corresponding languages
from parameterized DTDs
Pseudo-contractions as Gentle Repairs
Updating a knowledge base to remove an unwanted consequence is a challenging task. Some of the original sentences must be either deleted or weakened in such a way that the sentence to be removed is no longer entailed by the resulting set. On the other hand, it is desirable that the existing knowledge be preserved as much as possible, minimising the loss of information. Several approaches to this problem can be found in the literature. In particular, when the knowledge is represented by an ontology, two different families of frameworks have been developed in the literature in the past decades with numerous ideas in common but with little interaction between the communities: applications of AGM-like Belief Change and justification-based Ontology Repair. In this paper, we investigate the relationship between pseudo-contraction operations and gentle repairs. Both aim to avoid the complete deletion of sentences when replacing them with weaker versions is enough to prevent the entailment of the unwanted formula. We show the correspondence between concepts on both sides and investigate under which conditions they are equivalent. Furthermore, we propose a unified notation for the two approaches, which might contribute to the integration of the two areas
- …