Practical residue curve map analysis applied to solvent recovery in non-ideal binary mixtures by batch distillation processes

Batch distillation inherent advantages has initiated recent search for process feasibility rules enabling the separation of azeotropic or difficult zeotropic binary mixtures thanks to the addition of an entrainer. A systematic procedure enabling to find suitable process and eventually suitable entrainer for the separation of zeotropic or azeotropic binary mixture is described. It brings together into practical use batch distillation process feasibility rules, chemical affinity insight and thermodynamic data analysis available in the literature. The procedure has been implemented in a wizard computer tool and is illustrated on the separation of the water – acetonitrile binary homoazeotrope. Through this tool, all possible 224 feasibility rules and 326 batch distillation sequence processes are checked systematically for each entrainer

Extractive distillation: recent advances in operation strategies

Extractive distillation is one of the efficient techniques for separating azeotropic and low-relativevolatility mixtures in various chemical industries. This paper first provides an overview of thermodynamic insight covering residue curve map analysis, the application of univolatility and unidistribution curves, and thermodynamic feasibility study. The pinch-point analysis method combining bifurcation shortcut presents another branch of study, and several achievements have been realized by the identification of possible product cut under the following key parameters: reflux ratio, reboil ratio, and entrainer-feed flow rate ratio. Process operation policies and strategy concerning batch extractive distillation processes are summarized in four operation steps. Several configurations and technological alternatives can be used when extractive distillation processes take place in a continuous or batch column, depending on the strategy selected for the recycle streams and for the main azeotropic feeds

Application of process synthesis for the recovery of valuable chemicals from an industrial waste stream

MSc ThesisA dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree Master of Science in Engineering to the Faculty of Engineering and the Built Environment, School of Chemical and Metallurgical Engineering, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2018This work aims at designing and simulating on Aspen Plus process simulator a process that can recover valuable chemicals from a High Organic Waste (HOW) stream produced at Sasol Secunda plant, South Africa. The waste is made up of low boiling point organic components such as pyridine, acetonitrile and Methyl Ethyl Ketone and water. Currently, the waste is incinerated without energy recovery. This practice serves to exacerbate the already high greenhouse gases emissions from the plant, but more importantly, it results in the missed opportunity to maximize revenues through resale of recycled valuable chemicals. The recovery of valuable chemicals from the HOW is made difficult by the formations of azeotrope between organic components and water; at least 6 azeotropes exist in the HOW stream. In this work the emphasis is on pyridine because of its established market value and demand. Pyridine market size is about 400 million USD in 2017 and is expected to increase to over 600 million USD by 2021 mainly due to increased usage in the agrochemical industry. Water integration strategy was also assessed demand because of the reported need to improve water utilization efficiency at Sasol Secunda plant. The recovery was achieved in 2 separate steps: 1) water-pyridine mixture was separated from the rest of the HOW stream using fractional distillation and 2) pyridine enrichment section which was designed using thermodynamic tools such as residue curve maps and isovolatility curves. The rest of the HOW stream (light fractions) was sent to the currently used incinerator. Liquid-liquid extraction and azeotropic distillation were considered for the pyridine enrichment step. Results showed that the combination of liquid-liquid extraction and distillation offered the benefit of a lower entrainer to azeotropic mixture ratio (EA) compared to azeotropic distillation. This gave the lowest recorded EA at 0.320:1. The comparison between the proposed process and the incineration of the whole HOW stream showed that the implementation of the process proposed reduced the incineration load by 60wt% and CO and CO2 emissions by 50%. Dividing Wall column process integration technique was implemented to reduce the number of distillation columns in the proposed process and 10% reduction in the reboiler and condenser duties was observed. Implementation of DWC further improved the purity of the recovered pyridine from 96mol% to over 99.9mol%. Preliminary economic evaluation carried out on Aspen Plus showed that the proposed recovery process was profitable with an Internal Rate of Return (IRR) of 20% and a payback period of 4.5 years.MT 201

Особенности ректификационного разделения многокомпонентных смесей

Objectives. To improve the process of developing energy-efficient flowsheets for the distillation separation of multicomponent aqueous and organic mixtures based on a comprehensive study of the phase diagram structures, including those in the presence of additional selective substances.Methods. Thermodynamic-topological analysis of phase diagrams; modeling of phase equilibria in the AspenTech software package using the equations of local compositions: Non-Random Two Liquid and Wilson; computational experiment to determine the column parameters for separation flowsheets of model and real mixtures of various nature.Results. The fractionation conditions of the origin multicomponent mixture due to the use of sharp distillation, pre-splitting process, extractive distillation with individual and binary separating agents were revealed. The columns operation parameters and the energy consumption of the separation flowsheets ensuring the achievement of the required product quality with minimal energy consumption were determined.Conclusions. Using the original methods developed by the authors earlier and based on the generalization of the results obtained, new approaches to the synthesis of energy-efficient multicomponent mixtures separation flowsheets were proposed. The provisions that form the methodological basis for the development of flowsheets for the separation of multicomponent mixtures and supplement the standard flowsheet synthesis plan with new procedures were formulated.Цели. Совершенствование процесса разработки энергоэффективных схем ректификационного разделения многокомпонентных водных и органических смесей на основе комплексного исследования структуры фазовой диаграммы, в том числе в присутствии селективных дополнительных веществ.Методы. Термодинамико-топологический анализ фазовых диаграмм; моделирование фазовых равновесий в программном комплексе AspenTech с использованием уравнений локальных составов Non-Random Two Liquid, Вильсона; вычислительный эксперимент по определению параметров работы колонн схем разделения модельных и реальных смесей разной природы.Результаты. Выявлены условия фракционирования исходной многокомпонентной смеси за счет использования промежуточного заданного разделения, предварительного расслаивания, экстрактивной ректификации с индивидуальными и бинарными разделяющими агентами. Определены параметры работы колонн и энергозатраты схем разделения, обеспечивающие достижение требуемого качества продуктов при минимальных энергозатратах.Выводы. С использованием разработанных ранее авторами оригинальных методик и на основе обобщения полученных результатов предложены новые подходы к синтезу энергоэффективных схем разделения многокомпонентных смесей. Сформулированы положения, которые составляют методологическую основу разработки принципиальных схем разделения многокомпонентных смесей и дополняют типовой план синтеза схем новыми процедурами

Сравнение схем экстрактивной ректификации смесей метанол–тетрагидрофуран–вода

Objectives. Synthesis and comparative analysis of the extractive distillation flowsheets for aqueous mixtures of solvents utilized in pharmaceutical industries using the example of a methanol−tetrahydrofuran−water system with various compositions. The ternary system contains two minimally boiling azeotropes that exist in a vapor–liquid phase equilibrium. To evaluate the selective effect of glycerol, the phase equilibria of the methanol–tetrahydrofuran–water and methanol–tetrahydrofuran–water–glycerol systems at 101.32 kPa were studied.Methods. The calculations were carried out in the Aspen Plus V.9.0 software package. The vapor–liquid equilibria were simulated using the non-random two-liquid (NRTL) equation with the binary interaction parameters of the software package database. To account for the non-ideal behavior of the vapor phase, the Redlich–Kwong equation of state was used. The calculations of the extractive distillation schemes were carried out at 101.32 kPa.Results. The conceptual flowsheets of extractive distillation are proposed. The flowsheets consist of three (schemes I–III) or four (scheme IV) distillation columns operating at atmospheric pressure. In schemes I and II, the extractive distillation of the mixtures is carried out with tetrahydrofuran isolation occurring in the distillate stream. Further separation in the schemes differs in the order of glycerol isolation: in the third column for scheme I (traditional extractive distillation complex) or in the second column for scheme II (two-column extractive distillation complex + methanol/water separation column). Sсheme III caters to the complete dehydration of the basic ternary mixtures, followed by the extractive distillation of the azeotropic methanol–tetrahydrofuran system, also with glycerol. Sсheme IV includes a preconcentration column (for the partial removal of water) and a traditional extractive distillation complex.Conclusions. According to the criterion of least energy consumption for separation (the total load of the reboilers of distillation columns), sсheme I (a traditional complex of extractive distillation) is recommended. Additionally, the energy expended for the separation of the basic equimolar mixture using glycerol as the extractive agent was compared with that expended using another selective agent: 1,2-ethanediol. Glycerol is an effective extractive agent because it reduces energy consumption, in comparison with 1,2-ethanediol, by more than 5%.Цели. Синтез и сравнительный анализ схем экстрактивной ректификации водных смесей растворителей фармацевтических производств на примере системы метанол–тетрагидрофуран–вода различного состава. Трехкомпонентная система содержит два минимально кипящих азеотропа, которые присутствуют в диапазоне существования парожидкостного равновесия. Для оценки селективного действия глицерина исследованы фазовые равновесия систем метанол–тетрагидрофуран–вода и метанол–тетрагидрофуран–вода–глицерин при 101.32 кПа.Методы. Вычислительный эксперимент выполнен на платформе Aspen Plus V.9.0. Проведены расчеты фазовых равновесий по уравнению NRTL (Non-Random Two-Liquid) с параметрами бинарного взаимодействия базы данных программного комплекса. Для учета неидеального поведения паровой фазы использовали уравнение состояния Редлиха–Квонга. Расчеты схем экстрактивной ректификации проведены при 101.32 кПа.Результаты. Предложены принципиальные технологические схемы разделения (I–IV), состоящие из трех (I–III) или четырех (IV) ректификационных колонн, работающих при атмосферном давлении. В схемах I, II проводилась экстрактивная ректификация базовых смесей с различным содержанием воды для выделения в дистиллатном потоке тетрагидрофурана. Дальнейшее разделение в схемах различалось очередностью выделения глицерина: в третьей колонне схемы I (традиционный трехколонный комплекс экстрактивной ректификации) или во второй колонне схемы II (двухколонный комплекс экстрактивной ректификации + колонна разделения метанола и воды). В схеме III предусмотрено полное обезвоживание базовых трехкомпонентных смесей с последующей экстрактивной ректификацией азеотропной системы метанол–тетрагидрофуран также с глицерином. Схема IV состоит из колонны концентрирования (частичного удаления воды) и традиционного комплекса экстрактивной ректификации.Выводы. По критерию наименьших энергозатрат на разделение (суммарная нагрузка кипятильников ректификационных колонн) рекомендована схема I (традиционный комплекс экстрактивной ректификации). Дополнительно проведено сравнение энергозатрат схемы I при разделении смеси эквимолярного состава с другим селективным веществом – этиленгликолем, предложенным ранее в качестве агента. Глицерин является эффективным экстрактивным агентом, поскольку обеспечивает снижение энергозатрат более чем на 5%

Improvement of Batch Distillation Separation of Azeotropic Mixtures

La distillation est le procédé de séparation le plus répandu dans l'industrie chimique. Pour la séparation des mélanges azéotropiques, une méthode spéciale de distillation doit être appliquée. Le but de mon travail était d'améliorer la séparation des mélanges azéotropiques par distillation discontinue (DD). Un nouvel algorithme a été présenté pour la détermination de la séquence des produits de DD pour des mélanges multicomposants azéotropiques. Contrairement aux méthodes publiées précédemment, cet algorithme n'a pas besoin des paramètres d'équilibre. Configurations non-conventionnelles de DD ont été étudiées par simulation rigoureuse avec un accent sur l'opération fermée. Nombreux modes d'opération fermés étaient proposés, lesquelles diffèrent en l'opération de réservoir supérieur. Les effets du recyclage des fractions sur un procédé de séparation existant de 6 lots d'un mélange déchet azéotropique ont été étudiés. Les études ont été étendues pour un procédé de distillation extractive discontinue (DED). Un volume minimal de pré-fraction doit être incinéré. Le cas optimal de DED a donné un profit plus grand que celui de DD. DED a été étudié pour la séparation des deux mélanges azéotropiques. La séparation a été infaisable ou le rendement a été bas par DD, mais DED et le procédé hybride ont donné des rendements élevés. Une nouvelle politique de DED a été aussi proposée. Un modèle généralisé de la distillation hétéroazéotropique discontinue avec une rétention variable de décanteur a été développé. Dans une analyse de faisabilité, toutes les politiques opérationnelles possibles ont été identifiées. Ce modèle a été étendu pour la distillation extractive hétérogène discontinue. ABSTRACT : Distillation is the most widespread method for separating liquid mixtures. The separation of azeotropic mixtures requires a special distillation method. My aim was to improve the batch distillation separation of azeotropic mixtures. A new algorithm was presented for the determination of product sequences of batch distillation of multicomponent azeotropic mixtures. Non-conventional configurations were studied by simulation with emphasis on closed operation. The effects of off-cut recycle on a six-batch separation process of a waste solvent mixture were also investigated. Batch extractive distillation was studied for the separation of two azeotropic mixtures. A new extractive policy was also proposed. A generalised model of batch heteroazeotropic distillation with variable decanter hold-up was developed. This model was extended for batch heterogeneous extractive distillation

Extension of thermodynamic insights on batch extractive distillation to continuous operation

Nous étudions la faisabilité du procédé de distillation extractive continue pour séparer des mélanges azéotropiques A-B à température de bulle minimale ou maximale, avec un tiers corps E lourd ou léger. Les mélanges ternaires A-B-E appartiennent aux classes 1.0-1-a et 1.0-2 qui se subdivisent chacune en deux souscas selon la position de la courbe d'univolatilité. La colonne de distillation a trois sections, rectification, extractive, épuisement. Nous établissons les équations décrivant les profiles de composition liquide dans chaque section en fonction des paramètres opératoires: pureté et taux de récupération du distillat, taux de reflux ratio R et rapport des débits d'alimentation FE/F dans le cas d'un tiers corps lourd ; pureté et taux de récupération du produit de pied, taux de rebouillage S et rapport des débits d'alimentation FE/F dans le cas d'un tiers corps léger. Avec un tiers corps lourd alimenté comme liquide bouillant au dessus de l'étage d'alimentation du mélange A-B, nous identifions le distillat atteignable et les plages de valeurs faisables des paramètres R et FE/F à partir du critère général de faisabilité énoncé par Rodriguez-Donis et al. (Ind. Eng. Chem. Res, 2009, 48(7), 3544–3559). Pour la classe 1.0-1a, il existe des rapport FE/F et reflux ratio minimum. Le rapport FE/F est plus important pour le procédé continu que pour le procédé discontinu parce que la faisabilité du procédé continu nécessite que les profils d'épuisement et extractifs s'intersectent. Pour la classe 1.0-2, les deux constituants A et B sont des distillats potentiels, l'un sous réserve que le rapport FE/F reste inférieur à une valeur limite maximale. Le procédé continu exhibe également une valeur minimale de FE/F à un taux de reflux ratio donné, contrairement au procédé discontinu. Avec un tiers corps léger alimenté comme vapeur saturante sous l'étage d'alimentation du mélange A-B, nous identifions le produit de pied atteignable et les plages de valeurs faisables des paramètres S et FE/F à partir du critère général de faisabilité énoncé par Rodriguez-Donis et al. (Ind. Eng. Chem. Res, 2012, 51, 4643–4660). Comparé au cas des tiers corps lourds, le produit principal est obtenu en pied. Autrement, les comportements des classes 1.0-1a et 1.0-2 sont analogues entre les tiers corps léger et lourd. Avec un tiers corps léger, le procédé continu ajoute la contrainte que les profils de rectification et extractifs s'intersectent. La contrainte d'intersection des profils d'épuisement et extractif est partagée par les deux modes opératoires continu et discontinu. Ce travail valide la méthodologie proposée pour évaluer la faisabilité du procédé de distillation extractive continue et permet de comparer les tiers entre eux en termes de taux de reflux ratio minimum et de rapport de débit d'alimentation minimal. ABSTRACT : We study the continuous extractive distillation of minimum and maximum boiling azeotropic mixtures A-B with a heavy or a light entrainer E, intending to assess its feasibility based on thermodynamic insights. The ternary mixtures belong to the common 1.0-1a and 1.0-2 class ternary diagrams, each with two sub-cases depending on the univolatility line location. The column has three sections, rectifying, extractive and stripping. Differential equations are derived for each section composition, depending on operating parameters: distillate product purity and recovery, reflux ratio R and entrainer – feed flow rate ratio FE/F for the heavy case; bottom product purity and recovery, reboil ratio and entrainer – feed flow rate ratio for the light entrainer case. For the case with a heavy entrainer fed as a boiling liquid above the main feed, the feasible product and operating parameters R and FE/F ranges are assessed under infinite reflux ratio conditions by using the general feasibility criterion enounced by Rodriguez-Donis et al. (Ind. Eng. Chem. Res, 2009, 48(7), 3544–3559). For the 1.0-1a class, there exists a minimum entrainer - feed flow rate ratio to recover the product, and also a minimum reflux ratio. The minimum entrainer - feed flow rate ratio is higher for the continuous process than for the batch because of the additional requirement in continuous mode that the stripping profile intersects with the extractive profile. For the 1.0-2 class both A and B can be distillated. For one of them there exists a maximum entrainer - feed flow rate ratio. The continuous process also has a minimum entrainer - feed flow rate ratio limit for a given feasible reflux ratio. For the case with a light entrainer fed as saturated vapor below the main feed, the feasible product and operating parameters S and FE/F ranges are assessed under infinite reflux ratio conditions by using the general feasibility criterion enounced by Rodriguez-Donis et al. (Ind. Eng. Chem. Res, 2012, 51, 4643–4660), Compared to the heavy entrainer case, the main product is removed from the column bottom. Similar results are obtained for the 1.0-1a and 1.0-2 class mixtures whether the entrainer is light or heavy. With a light entrainer, the batch insight about the process feasibility holds for the stripping and extractive sections. Now, an additional constraint in continuous mode comes from the necessary intersection between the rectifying and the extractive sections. This work validates the proposed methodology for assessing the feasibility of continuous extractive distillation processes and enables to compare entrainers in terms of minimum reflux ratio and minimum entrainer feed flow rate ratio

Conception des procédés de distillation extractive continue basée sur des critères de faisabilité thermodynamique de la distillation extractive discontinue

Nous étudions la faisabilité du procédé de distillation extractive continue pour séparer des mélanges azéotropiques A-B à température de bulle minimale ou maximale, avec un tiers corps E lourd ou léger. Les mélanges ternaires A-B-E appartiennent aux classes 1.0-1-a et 1.0-2 qui se subdivisent chacune en deux souscas selon la position de la courbe d'univolatilité. La colonne de distillation a trois sections, rectification, extractive, épuisement. Nous établissons les équations décrivant les profiles de composition liquide dans chaque section en fonction des paramètres opératoires: pureté et taux de récupération du distillat, taux de reflux ratio R et rapport des débits d'alimentation FE/F dans le cas d'un tiers corps lourd ; pureté et taux de récupération du produit de pied, taux de rebouillage S et rapport des débits d'alimentation FE/F dans le cas d'un tiers corps léger. Avec un tiers corps lourd alimenté comme liquide bouillant au dessus de l'étage d'alimentation du mélange A-B, nous identifions le distillat atteignable et les plages de valeurs faisables des paramètres R et FE/F à partir du critère général de faisabilité énoncé par Rodriguez-Donis et al. (Ind. Eng. Chem. Res, 2009, 48(7), 3544 3559). Pour la classe 1.0-1a, il existe des rapport FE/F et reflux ratio minimum. Le rapport FE/F est plus important pour le procédé continu que pour le procédé discontinu parce que la faisabilité du procédé continu nécessite que les profils d'épuisement et extractifs s'intersectent. Pour la classe 1.0-2, les deux constituants A et B sont des distillats potentiels, l'un sous réserve que le rapport FE/F reste inférieur à une valeur limite maximale. Le procédé continu exhibe également une valeur minimale de FE/F à un taux de reflux ratio donné, contrairement au procédé discontinu. Avec un tiers corps léger alimenté comme vapeur saturante sous l'étage d'alimentation du mélange A-B, nous identifions le produit de pied atteignable et les plages de valeurs faisables des paramètres S et FE/F à partir du critère général de faisabilité énoncé par Rodriguez-Donis et al. (Ind. Eng. Chem. Res, 2012, 51, 4643 4660). Comparé au cas des tiers corps lourds, le produit principal est obtenu en pied. Autrement, les comportements des classes 1.0-1a et 1.0-2 sont analogues entre les tiers corps léger et lourd. Avec un tiers corps léger, le procédé continu ajoute la contrainte que les profils de rectification et extractifs s'intersectent. La contrainte d'intersection des profils d'épuisement et extractif est partagée par les deux modes opératoires continu et discontinu. Ce travail valide la méthodologie proposée pour évaluer la faisabilité du procédé de distillation extractive continue et permet de comparer les tiers entre eux en termes de taux de reflux ratio minimum et de rapport de débit d'alimentation minimalWe study the continuous extractive distillation of minimum and maximum boiling azeotropic mixtures A-B with a heavy or a light entrainer E, intending to assess its feasibility based on thermodynamic insights. The ternary mixtures belong to the common 1.0-1a and 1.0-2 class ternary diagrams, each with two sub-cases depending on the univolatility line location. The column has three sections, rectifying, extractive and stripping. Differential equations are derived for each section composition, depending on operating parameters: distillate product purity and recovery, reflux ratio R and entrainer feed flow rate ratio FE/F for the heavy case; bottom product purity and recovery, reboil ratio and entrainer feed flow rate ratio for the light entrainer case. For the case with a heavy entrainer fed as a boiling liquid above the main feed, the feasible product and operating parameters R and FE/F ranges are assessed under infinite reflux ratio conditions by using the general feasibility criterion enounced by Rodriguez-Donis et al. (Ind. Eng. Chem. Res, 2009, 48(7), 3544 3559). For the 1.0-1a class, there exists a minimum entrainer - feed flow rate ratio to recover the product, and also a minimum reflux ratio. The minimum entrainer - feed flow rate ratio is higher for the continuous process than for the batch because of the additional requirement in continuous mode that the stripping profile intersects with the extractive profile. For the 1.0-2 class both A and B can be distillated. For one of them there exists a maximum entrainer - feed flow rate ratio. The continuous process also has a minimum entrainer - feed flow rate ratio limit for a given feasible reflux ratio. For the case with a light entrainer fed as saturated vapor below the main feed, the feasible product and operating parameters S and FE/F ranges are assessed under infinite reflux ratio conditions by using the general feasibility criterion enounced by Rodriguez-Donis et al. (Ind. Eng. Chem. Res, 2012, 51, 4643 4660), Compared to the heavy entrainer case, the main product is removed from the column bottom. Similar results are obtained for the 1.0-1a and 1.0-2 class mixtures whether the entrainer is light or heavy. With a light entrainer, the batch insight about the process feasibility holds for the stripping and extractive sections. Now, an additional constraint in continuous mode comes from the necessary intersection between the rectifying and the extractive sections. This work validates the proposed methodology for assessing the feasibility of continuous extractive distillation processes and enables to compare entrainers in terms of minimum reflux ratio and minimum entrainer feed flow rate ratioTOULOUSE-INP (315552154) / SudocSudocFranceF