MacNeille completion and profinite completion can coincide on finitely generated modal algebras

Following Bezhanishvili & Vosmaer, we confirm a conjecture of Yde Venema by piecing together results from various authors. Specifically, we show that if $\mathbb{A}$ is a residually finite, finitely generated modal algebra such that $\operatorname{HSP}(\mathbb{A})$ has equationally definable principal congruences, then the profinite completion of $\mathbb{A}$ is isomorphic to its MacNeille completion, and $\Diamond$ is smooth. Specific examples of such modal algebras are the free $\mathbf{K4}$-algebra and the free $\mathbf{PDL}$-algebra.Comment: 5 page

Preservation theorems for algebraic and relational models of logic

A thesis submitted to the School of Computer Science, Faculty of Science, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Johannesburg, 15 May 2013In this thesis a number of different constructions on ordered algebraic structures are studied. In particular, two types of constructions are considered: completions and finite embeddability property constructions. A main theme of this thesis is to determine, for each construction under consideration, whether or not a class of ordered algebraic structures is closed under the construction. Another main focus of this thesis is, for a particular construction, to give a syntactical description of properties preserved by the construction. A property is said to be preserved by a construction if, whenever an ordered algebraic structure satisfies it, then the structure obtained through the construction also satisfies the property. The first four constructions investigated in this thesis are types of completions. A completion of an ordered algebraic structure consists of a completely lattice ordered algebraic structure and an embedding that embeds the former into the latter. Firstly, different types of filters (dually, ideals) of partially ordered sets are investigated. These are then used to form the filter (dually, ideal) completions of partially ordered sets. The other completions of ordered algebraic structures studied here include the MacNeille completion, the canonical extension (also called the completion with respect to a polarization) and finally a prime filter completion. A class of algebras has the finite embeddability property if every finite partial subalgebra of some algebra in the class can be embedded into some finite algebra in the class. Firstly, two constructions that establish the finite embeddability property for residuated ordered structures are investigated. Both of these constructions are based on completion constructions: the first on the Mac- Neille completion and the second on the canonical extension. Finally, algebraic filtrations on modal algebras are considered and a duality between algebraic and relational versions of filtrations is established

Comparison of Macneille, canonical, and profinite completions

Using duality theory, we give necessary and sufficient conditions for the MacNeille, canonical, and profinite completions of distributive lattices, Heyting algebras, and Boolean algebras to be isomorphic