Comments on "what the back of the object looks like: 3D reconstruction from line drawings without hidden lines"

I comment on a paper describing a method for deducing the hidden topology of an object portrayed in a 2D natural line drawing. The principal problem with this paper is that it cannot be considered an advance on (or even an equal of) the state of the art as the approach it describes makes the same limiting assumptions as approaches proposed 10 years ago. There are also important omissions in the review of related wor

3D reconstruction of curved objects from single 2D line drawings.

Wang, Yingze.Thesis (M.Phil.)--Chinese University of Hong Kong, 2009.Includes bibliographical references (leaves 42-47).Abstract also in Chinese.Chapter 1 --- Introduction --- p.1Chapter 2 --- Related Work --- p.5Chapter 2.1 --- Line labeling and realization problem --- p.5Chapter 2.2 --- 3D reconstruction from multiple views --- p.6Chapter 2.3 --- 3D reconstruction from single line drawings --- p.7Chapter 2.3.1 --- Face identification from the line drawings --- p.7Chapter 2.3.2 --- 3D geometry reconstruction --- p.9Chapter 2.4 --- Our research topic and contributions --- p.13Chapter 3 --- Reconstruction of Curved Manifold Objects --- p.14Chapter 3.1 --- Assumptions and terminology --- p.14Chapter 3.2 --- Reconstruction of curved manifold objects --- p.17Chapter 3.2.1 --- Distinguishing between curved and planar faces --- p.17Chapter 3.2.2 --- Transformation of Line Drawings --- p.20Chapter 3.2.3 --- Regularities --- p.23Chapter 3.2.4 --- 3D Wireframe Reconstruction --- p.26Chapter 3.2.5 --- Generating Curved Faces --- p.28Chapter 3.2.6 --- The Complete 3D Reconstruction Algorithm --- p.33Chapter 4 --- Experiments --- p.35Chapter 5 --- Conclusions and Future Work --- p.40Chapter 5.1 --- Conclusions --- p.40Chapter 5.2 --- Future work --- p.40Bibliography --- p.4

3D object reconstruction from 2D and 3D line drawings.

Chen, Yu.Thesis (M.Phil.)--Chinese University of Hong Kong, 2008.Includes bibliographical references (leaves 78-85).Abstracts in English and Chinese.Chapter 1 --- Introduction and Related Work --- p.1Chapter 1.1 --- Reconstruction from 2D Line Drawings and the Applications --- p.2Chapter 1.2 --- Previous Work on 3D Reconstruction from Single 2D Line Drawings --- p.4Chapter 1.3 --- Other Related Work on Interpretation of 2D Line Drawings --- p.5Chapter 1.3.1 --- Line Labeling and Superstrictness Problem --- p.6Chapter 1.3.2 --- CAD Reconstruction --- p.6Chapter 1.3.3 --- Modeling from Images --- p.6Chapter 1.3.4 --- Identifying Faces in the Line Drawings --- p.7Chapter 1.4 --- 3D Modeling Systems --- p.8Chapter 1.5 --- Research Problems and Our Contributions --- p.10Chapter 1.5.1 --- Recovering Complex Manifold Objects from Line Drawings --- p.10Chapter 1.5.2 --- The Vision-based Sketching System --- p.11Chapter 2 --- Reconstruction from Complex Line Drawings --- p.13Chapter 2.1 --- Introduction --- p.13Chapter 2.2 --- Assumptions and Terminology --- p.15Chapter 2.3 --- Separation of a Line Drawing --- p.17Chapter 2.3.1 --- Classification of Internal Faces --- p.18Chapter 2.3.2 --- Separating a Line Drawing along Internal Faces of Type 1 --- p.19Chapter 2.3.3 --- Detecting Internal Faces of Type 2 --- p.20Chapter 2.3.4 --- Separating a Line Drawing along Internal Faces of Type 2 --- p.28Chapter 2.4 --- 3D Reconstruction --- p.44Chapter 2.4.1 --- 3D Reconstruction from a Line Drawing --- p.44Chapter 2.4.2 --- Merging 3D Manifolds --- p.45Chapter 2.4.3 --- The Complete 3D Reconstruction Algorithm --- p.47Chapter 2.5 --- Experimental Results --- p.47Chapter 2.6 --- Summary --- p.52Chapter 3 --- A Vision-Based Sketching System for 3D Object Design --- p.54Chapter 3.1 --- Introduction --- p.54Chapter 3.2 --- The Sketching System --- p.55Chapter 3.3 --- 3D Geometry of the System --- p.56Chapter 3.3.1 --- Locating the Wand --- p.57Chapter 3.3.2 --- Calibration --- p.59Chapter 3.3.3 --- Working Space --- p.60Chapter 3.4 --- Wireframe Input and Object Editing --- p.62Chapter 3.5 --- Surface Generation --- p.63Chapter 3.5.1 --- Face Identification --- p.64Chapter 3.5.2 --- Planar Surface Generation --- p.65Chapter 3.5.3 --- Smooth Curved Surface Generation --- p.67Chapter 3.6 --- Experiments --- p.70Chapter 3.7 --- Summary --- p.72Chapter 4 --- Conclusion and Future Work --- p.74Chapter 4.1 --- Conclusion --- p.74Chapter 4.2 --- Future Work --- p.75Chapter 4.2.1 --- Learning-Based Line Drawing Reconstruction --- p.75Chapter 4.2.2 --- New Query Interface for 3D Object Retrieval --- p.75Chapter 4.2.3 --- Curved Object Reconstruction --- p.76Chapter 4.2.4 --- Improving the 3D Sketch System --- p.77Chapter 4.2.5 --- Other Directions --- p.77Bibliography --- p.7