A Comparative Study of Efficient Initialization Methods for the K-Means Clustering Algorithm

K-means is undoubtedly the most widely used partitional clustering algorithm. Unfortunately, due to its gradient descent nature, this algorithm is highly sensitive to the initial placement of the cluster centers. Numerous initialization methods have been proposed to address this problem. In this paper, we first present an overview of these methods with an emphasis on their computational efficiency. We then compare eight commonly used linear time complexity initialization methods on a large and diverse collection of data sets using various performance criteria. Finally, we analyze the experimental results using non-parametric statistical tests and provide recommendations for practitioners. We demonstrate that popular initialization methods often perform poorly and that there are in fact strong alternatives to these methods.Comment: 17 pages, 1 figure, 7 table

An Enhanced Initialization Method to Find an Initial Center for K-modes Clustering

Data mining is a technique which extracts the information from the large amount of data. To group the objects having similar characteristics, clustering method is used. K-means clustering algorithm is very efficient for large data sets deals with numerical quantities however it not works well for real world data sets which contain categorical values for most of the attributes. K-modes algorithm is used in the place of K-means algorithm. In the existing system, the initialization of K- modes clustering from the view of outlier detection is considered. It avoids that various initial cluster centers come from the same cluster. To overcome the above said limitation, it uses Initial_Distance and Initial_Entropy algorithms which use a new weightage formula to calculate the degree of outlierness of each object. K-modes algorithm can guarantee that the chosen initial cluster centers are not outliers. To improve the performance further, a new modified distance metric -weighted matching distance is used to calculate the distance between two objects during the process of initialization. As well as, one of the data pre-processing methods is used to improve the quality of data. Experiments are carried out on several data sets from UCI repository and the results demonstrated the effectiveness of the initialization method in the proposed algorithm

Linear, Deterministic, and Order-Invariant Initialization Methods for the K-Means Clustering Algorithm

Over the past five decades, k-means has become the clustering algorithm of choice in many application domains primarily due to its simplicity, time/space efficiency, and invariance to the ordering of the data points. Unfortunately, the algorithm's sensitivity to the initial selection of the cluster centers remains to be its most serious drawback. Numerous initialization methods have been proposed to address this drawback. Many of these methods, however, have time complexity superlinear in the number of data points, which makes them impractical for large data sets. On the other hand, linear methods are often random and/or sensitive to the ordering of the data points. These methods are generally unreliable in that the quality of their results is unpredictable. Therefore, it is common practice to perform multiple runs of such methods and take the output of the run that produces the best results. Such a practice, however, greatly increases the computational requirements of the otherwise highly efficient k-means algorithm. In this chapter, we investigate the empirical performance of six linear, deterministic (non-random), and order-invariant k-means initialization methods on a large and diverse collection of data sets from the UCI Machine Learning Repository. The results demonstrate that two relatively unknown hierarchical initialization methods due to Su and Dy outperform the remaining four methods with respect to two objective effectiveness criteria. In addition, a recent method due to Erisoglu et al. performs surprisingly poorly.Comment: 21 pages, 2 figures, 5 tables, Partitional Clustering Algorithms (Springer, 2014). arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1304.7465, arXiv:1209.196

Improved K-means clustering algorithms : a thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Computer Science, Massey University, New Zealand

K-means clustering algorithm is designed to divide the samples into subsets with the goal that maximizes the intra-subset similarity and inter-subset dissimilarity where the similarity measures the relationship between two samples. As an unsupervised learning technique, K-means clustering algorithm is considered one of the most used clustering algorithms and has been applied in a variety of areas such as artificial intelligence, data mining, biology, psychology, marketing, medicine, etc. K-means clustering algorithm is not robust and its clustering result depends on the initialization, the similarity measure, and the predefined cluster number. Previous research focused on solving a part of these issues but has not focused on solving them in a unified framework. However, fixing one of these issues does not guarantee the best performance. To improve K-means clustering algorithm, one of the most famous and widely used clustering algorithms, by solving its issues simultaneously is challenging and significant. This thesis conducts an extensive research on K-means clustering algorithm aiming to improve it. First, we propose the Initialization-Similarity (IS) clustering algorithm to solve the issues of the initialization and the similarity measure of K-means clustering algorithm in a unified way. Specifically, we propose to fix the initialization of the clustering by using sum-of-norms (SON) which outputs the new representation of the original samples and to learn the similarity matrix based on the data distribution. Furthermore, the derived new representation is used to conduct K-means clustering. Second, we propose a Joint Feature Selection with Dynamic Spectral (FSDS) clustering algorithm to solve the issues of the cluster number determination, the similarity measure, and the robustness of the clustering by selecting effective features and reducing the influence of outliers simultaneously. Specifically, we propose to learn the similarity matrix based on the data distribution as well as adding the ranked constraint on the Laplacian matrix of the learned similarity matrix to automatically output the cluster number. Furthermore, the proposed algorithm employs the L2,1-norm as the sparse constraints on the regularization term and the loss function to remove the redundant features and reduce the influence of outliers respectively. Third, we propose a Joint Robust Multi-view (JRM) spectral clustering algorithm that conducts clustering for multi-view data while solving the initialization issue, the cluster number determination, the similarity measure learning, the removal of the redundant features, and the reduction of outlier influence in a unified way. Finally, the proposed algorithms outperformed the state-of-the-art clustering algorithms on real data sets. Moreover, we theoretically prove the convergences of the proposed optimization methods for the proposed objective functions