2,694 research outputs found
Shining Light On Shadow Stacks
Control-Flow Hijacking attacks are the dominant attack vector against C/C++
programs. Control-Flow Integrity (CFI) solutions mitigate these attacks on the
forward edge,i.e., indirect calls through function pointers and virtual calls.
Protecting the backward edge is left to stack canaries, which are easily
bypassed through information leaks. Shadow Stacks are a fully precise mechanism
for protecting backwards edges, and should be deployed with CFI mitigations. We
present a comprehensive analysis of all possible shadow stack mechanisms along
three axes: performance, compatibility, and security. For performance
comparisons we use SPEC CPU2006, while security and compatibility are
qualitatively analyzed. Based on our study, we renew calls for a shadow stack
design that leverages a dedicated register, resulting in low performance
overhead, and minimal memory overhead, but sacrifices compatibility. We present
case studies of our implementation of such a design, Shadesmar, on Phoronix and
Apache to demonstrate the feasibility of dedicating a general purpose register
to a security monitor on modern architectures, and the deployability of
Shadesmar. Our comprehensive analysis, including detailed case studies for our
novel design, allows compiler designers and practitioners to select the correct
shadow stack design for different usage scenarios.Comment: To Appear in IEEE Security and Privacy 201
C-FLAT: Control-FLow ATtestation for Embedded Systems Software
Remote attestation is a crucial security service particularly relevant to
increasingly popular IoT (and other embedded) devices. It allows a trusted
party (verifier) to learn the state of a remote, and potentially
malware-infected, device (prover). Most existing approaches are static in
nature and only check whether benign software is initially loaded on the
prover. However, they are vulnerable to run-time attacks that hijack the
application's control or data flow, e.g., via return-oriented programming or
data-oriented exploits. As a concrete step towards more comprehensive run-time
remote attestation, we present the design and implementation of Control- FLow
ATtestation (C-FLAT) that enables remote attestation of an application's
control-flow path, without requiring the source code. We describe a full
prototype implementation of C-FLAT on Raspberry Pi using its ARM TrustZone
hardware security extensions. We evaluate C-FLAT's performance using a
real-world embedded (cyber-physical) application, and demonstrate its efficacy
against control-flow hijacking attacks.Comment: Extended version of article to appear in CCS '16 Proceedings of the
23rd ACM Conference on Computer and Communications Securit
Signature-Based Protection from Code Reuse Attacks
Abstract—Code Reuse Attacks (CRAs) recently emerged as a new class of security exploits. CRAs construct malicious programs out of small fragments (gadgets) of existing code, thus eliminating the need for code injection. Existing defenses against CRAs often incur large performance overheads or require extensive binary rewriting and other changes to the system software. In this paper, we examine a signature-based detection of CRAs, where the attack is detected by observing the behavior of programs and detecting the gadget execution patterns. We first demonstrate that naive signature-based defenses can be defeated by introducing special “delay gadgets ” as part of the attack. We then show how a software-configurable signature-based approach can be designed to defend against such stealth CRAs, including the attacks that manage to use longer-length gadgets. The proposed defense (called SCRAP) can be implemented entirely in hardware using simple logic at the commit stage of the pipeline. SCRAP is realized with minimal performance cost, no changes to the software layers and no implications on binary compatibility. Finally, we show that SCRAP generates no false alarms on a wide range of applications.
Recommended from our members
Repurposing Software Defenses with Specialized Hardware
Computer security has largely been the domain of software for the last few decades. Although this approach has been moderately successful during this period, its problems have started becoming more apparent recently because of one primary reason — performance. Software solutions typically exact a significant toll in terms of program slowdown, especially when applied to large, complex software. In the past, when chips became exponentially faster, this growing burden could be accommodated almost for free. But as Moore’s law winds down, security-related slowdowns become more apparent, increasingly intolerable, and subsequently abandoned. As a result, the community has started looking elsewhere for continued protection, as attacks continue to become progressively more sophisticated.
One way to mitigate this problem is to complement these defenses in hardware. Despite lacking the semantic perspective of high-level software, specialized hardware typically is not only faster, but also more energy-efficient. However, hardware vendors also have to factor in the cost of integrating security solutions from the perspective of effectiveness, longevity, and cost of development, while allaying the customer’s concerns of performance. As a result, although numerous hardware solutions have been proposed in the past, the fact that so few of them have actually transitioned into practice implies that they were unable to strike an optimal balance of the above qualities.
This dissertation proposes the thesis that it is possible to add hardware features that complement and improve program security, traditionally provided by software, without requiring extensive modifications to existing hardware microarchitecture. As such, it marries the collective concerns of not only users and software developers, who demand performant but secure products, but also that of hardware vendors, since implementation simplicity directly relates to reduction in time and cost of development and deployment. To support this thesis, this dissertation discusses two hardware security features aimed at securing program code and data separately and details their full system implementations, and a study of a negative result where the design was deemed practically infeasible, given its high implementation complexity.
Firstly, the dissertation discusses code protection by reviving instruction set randomization (ISR), an idea originally proposed for countering code injection and considered impractical in the face of modern attack vectors that employ reuse of existing program code (also known as code reuse attacks). With Polyglot, we introduce ISR with strong AES encryption along with basic code randomization that disallows code decryption at runtime, thus countering most forms of state-of-the-art dynamic code reuse attacks, that read the code at runtime prior to building the code reuse payload. Through various optimizations and corner case workarounds, we show how Polyglot enables code execution with minimal hardware changes while maintaining a small attack surface and incurring nominal overheads even when the code is strongly encrypted in the binary and memory.
Next, the dissertation presents REST, a hardware primitive that allows programs to mark memory regions invalid for regular memory accesses. This is achieved simply by storing a large, pre-determined random value at those locations with a special store instruction and then, detecting incoming values at the data cache for matches to the predetermined value. Subsequently, we show how this primitive can be used to protect data from common forms of spatial and temporal memory safety attacks. Notably, because of the simplicity of the primitive, REST requires trivial microarchitectural modifications and hence, is easy to implement, and exhibits negligible performance overheads. Additionally, we demonstrate how it is able to provide practical heap safety even for legacy binaries.
For the above proposals, we also detail their hardware implementations on FPGAs, and discuss how each fits within a complete multiprocess system. This serves to give the reader an idea of usage and deployment challenges on a broader scale that goes beyond just the technique’s effectiveness within the context of a single program.
Lastly, the dissertation discusses an alternative to the virtual address space, that randomizes the sequence of addresses in a manner invisible to even the program, thus achieving transparent randomization of the entire address space at a very fine granularity. The biggest challenge is to achieve this with minimal microarchitectural changes while accommodating linear data structures in the program (e.g., arrays, structs), both of which are fundamentally based on a linear address space. As a result, this modified address space subsumes the benefits of most other spatial randomization schemes, with the additional benefit of ideally making traversal from one data structure to another impossible. Our study of this idea concludes that although valuable, current memory safety techniques are cheaper to implement and secure enough, so that there are no perceivable use cases for this model of address space safety
Binary Exploitation in Industrial Control Systems: Past, Present and Future
Despite being a decades-old problem, binary exploitation still remains a serious issue in computer security. It is mainly due to the prevalence of memory corruption errors in programs written with notoriously unsafe but yet indispensable programming languages like C and C++. For the past 30 years, the nip-and-tuck battle in memory between attackers and defenders has been getting more technical, versatile, and automated. With raised bar for exploitation in common information technology (IT) systems owing to hardened mitigation techniques, and with unintentionally opened doors into industrial control systems (ICS) due to the proliferation of industrial internet of things (IIoT), we argue that we will see an increased number of cyber attacks leveraging binary exploitation on ICS in the near future. However, while this topic generates a very rich and abundant body of research in common IT systems, there is a lack of systematic study targeting this topic in ICS. The present work aims at filling this gap and serves as a comprehensive walkthrough of binary exploitation in ICS. Apart from providing an analysis of the past cyber attacks leveraging binary exploitation on ICS and the ongoing attack surface transition, we give a review of the attack techniques and mitigation techniques on both general-purpose computers and embedded devices. At the end, we conclude this work by stressing the importance of network-based intrusion detection, considering the dominance of resource-constrained real-time embedded devices, low-end embedded devices in ICS, and the limited ability to deploy arbitrary defense mechanism directly on these devices
Adaptive just-in-time code diversification
We present a method to regenerate diversified code dynamically in a Java bytecode JIT compiler, and to update the diversification frequently during the execution of the program. This way, we can significantly reduce the time frame in which attackers can let a program leak useful address space information and subsequently use the leaked information in memory exploits. A proof of concept implementation is evaluated, showing that even though code is recompiled frequently, we can achieved smaller overheads than the previous state of the art, which generated diversity only once during the whole execution of a program
Unsupervised Anomaly-based Malware Detection using Hardware Features
Recent works have shown promise in using microarchitectural execution
patterns to detect malware programs. These detectors belong to a class of
detectors known as signature-based detectors as they catch malware by comparing
a program's execution pattern (signature) to execution patterns of known
malware programs. In this work, we propose a new class of detectors -
anomaly-based hardware malware detectors - that do not require signatures for
malware detection, and thus can catch a wider range of malware including
potentially novel ones. We use unsupervised machine learning to build profiles
of normal program execution based on data from performance counters, and use
these profiles to detect significant deviations in program behavior that occur
as a result of malware exploitation. We show that real-world exploitation of
popular programs such as IE and Adobe PDF Reader on a Windows/x86 platform can
be detected with nearly perfect certainty. We also examine the limits and
challenges in implementing this approach in face of a sophisticated adversary
attempting to evade anomaly-based detection. The proposed detector is
complementary to previously proposed signature-based detectors and can be used
together to improve security.Comment: 1 page, Latex; added description for feature selection in Section 4,
results unchange
- …