Tissue mimicking materials for imaging and therapy phantoms: a review

Tissue mimicking materials (TMMs), typically contained within phantoms, have been used for many decades in both imaging and therapeutic applications. This review investigates the specifications that are typically being used in development of the latest TMMs. The imaging modalities that have been investigated focus around CT, mammography, SPECT, PET, MRI and ultrasound. Therapeutic applications discussed within the review include radiotherapy, thermal therapy and surgical applications. A number of modalities were not reviewed including optical spectroscopy, optical imaging and planar x-rays. The emergence of image guided interventions and multimodality imaging have placed an increasing demand on the number of specifications on the latest TMMs. Material specification standards are available in some imaging areas such as ultrasound. It is recommended that this should be replicated for other imaging and therapeutic modalities. Materials used within phantoms have been reviewed for a series of imaging and therapeutic applications with the potential to become a testbed for cross-fertilization of materials across modalities. Deformation, texture, multimodality imaging and perfusion are common themes that are currently under development

L'élastographie ultrasonore dynamique vasculaire : une nouvelle modalité d'imagerie non-invasive pour la caractérisation mécanique de la thrombose veineuse

L’accident thromboembolique veineux, tel que la thrombose veineuse profonde (TVP) ou thrombophlébite des membres inférieurs, est une pathologie vasculaire caractérisée par la formation d’un caillot sanguin causant une obstruction partielle ou totale de la lumière sanguine. Les embolies pulmonaires sont une complication mortelle des TVP qui surviennent lorsque le caillot se détache, circule dans le sang et produit une obstruction de la ramification artérielle irriguant les poumons. La combinaison d’outils et de techniques d’imagerie cliniques tels que les règles de prédiction cliniques (signes et symptômes) et les tests sanguins (D-dimères) complémentés par un examen ultrasonographique veineux (test de compression, écho-Doppler), permet de diagnostiquer les premiers épisodes de TVP. Cependant, la performance de ces outils diagnostiques reste très faible pour la détection de TVP récurrentes. Afin de diriger le patient vers une thérapie optimale, la problématique n’est plus basée sur la détection de la thrombose mais plutôt sur l’évaluation de la maturité et de l’âge du thrombus, paramètres qui sont directement corrélées à ses propriétés mécaniques (e.g. élasticité, viscosité). L’élastographie dynamique (ED) a récemment été proposée comme une nouvelle modalité d’imagerie non-invasive capable de caractériser quantitativement les propriétés mécaniques de tissus. L’ED est basée sur l’analyse des paramètres acoustiques (i.e. vitesse, atténuation, pattern de distribution) d’ondes de cisaillement basses fréquences (10-7000 Hz) se propageant dans le milieu sondé. Ces ondes de cisaillement générées par vibration externe, ou par source interne à l’aide de la focalisation de faisceaux ultrasonores (force de radiation), sont mesurées par imagerie ultrasonore ultra-rapide ou par résonance magnétique. Une méthode basée sur l’ED adaptée à la caractérisation mécanique de thromboses veineuses permettrait de quantifier la sévérité de cette pathologie à des fins d’amélioration diagnostique. Cette thèse présente un ensemble de travaux reliés au développement et à la validation complète et rigoureuse d’une nouvelle technique d’imagerie non-invasive élastographique pour la mesure quantitative des propriétés mécaniques de thromboses veineuses. L’atteinte de cet objectif principal nécessite une première étape visant à améliorer les connaissances sur le comportement mécanique du caillot sanguin (sang coagulé) soumis à une sollicitation dynamique telle qu’en ED. Les modules de conservation (comportement élastique, G’) et de perte (comportement visqueux, G’’) en cisaillement de caillots sanguins porcins sont mesurés par ED lors de la cascade de coagulation (à 70 Hz), et après coagulation complète (entre 50 Hz et 160 Hz). Ces résultats constituent les toutes premières mesures du comportement dynamique de caillots sanguins dans une gamme fréquentielle aussi étendue. L’étape subséquente consiste à mettre en place un instrument innovant de référence (« gold standard »), appelé RheoSpectris, dédié à la mesure de la viscoélasticité hyper-fréquence (entre 10 Hz et 1000 Hz) des matériaux et biomatériaux. Cet outil est indispensable pour valider et calibrer toute nouvelle technique d’élastographie dynamique. Une étude comparative entre RheoSpectris et la rhéométrie classique est réalisée afin de valider des mesures faites sur différents matériaux (silicone, thermoplastique, biomatériaux, gel). L’excellente concordance entre les deux technologies permet de conclure que RheoSpectris est un instrument fiable pour la mesure mécanique à des fréquences difficilement accessibles par les outils actuels. Les bases théoriques d’une nouvelle modalité d’imagerie élastographique, nommée SWIRE (« shear wave induced resonance dynamic elastography »), sont présentées et validées sur des fantômes vasculaires. Cette approche permet de caractériser les propriétés mécaniques d’une inclusion confinée (e.g. caillot sanguin) à partir de sa résonance (amplification du déplacement) produite par la propagation d’ondes de cisaillement judicieusement orientées. SWIRE a également l’avantage d’amplifier l’amplitude de vibration à l’intérieur de l’hétérogénéité afin de faciliter sa détection et sa segmentation. Finalement, la méthode DVT-SWIRE (« Deep venous thrombosis – SWIRE ») est adaptée à la caractérisation de l’élasticité quantitative de thromboses veineuses pour une utilisation en clinique. Cette méthode exploite la première fréquence de résonance mesurée dans la thrombose lors de la propagation d’ondes de cisaillement planes (vibration d’une plaque externe) ou cylindriques (simulation de la force de radiation par génération supersonique). DVT-SWIRE est appliquée sur des fantômes simulant une TVP et les résultats sont comparés à ceux donnés par l’instrument de référence RheoSpectris. Cette méthode est également utilisée avec succès dans une étude ex vivo pour l’évaluation de l’élasticité de thromboses porcines explantées après avoir été induites in vivo par chirurgie.The venous thromboembolism such as the lower limb deep venous thrombosis (DVT) is a vascular pathology characterized by a blood clot formation that induces partial or total vessel lumen occlusion. Pulmonary embolism is a fatal complication of DVT where the clot detaches from the wall, circulates in the blood flow, and produces an obstruction of pulmonary arterial branches. The combination of clinical prediction rules (signs or symptoms) and blood tests (D-dimer testing) coupled to venous ultrasonography (i.e. compression ultrasonography, color Doppler) allows an accurate diagnosis of first DVT. Nevertheless, such clinical tools present poor results to detect recurrent thrombotic events. Then, in order to guide patients towards optimal therapy, the problem is no more to detect the presence of thrombus, but to evaluate its maturity and its age, which are correlated to their mechanical properties (e.g. elasticity, viscosity). The dynamic elastography (DE) has been recently proposed as a novel non-invasive imaging modality capable to characterize the quantitative mechanical properties of tissues. The DE is based on the analysis of acoustical parameters (i.e. velocity, attenuation, wave pattern) of low frequency (10-7000 Hz) shear waves propagating within the probed medium. Such shear waves generated by external vibration, or remotely using ultrasound beam focalisation (radiation force), were tracked using ultra-fast ultrasound or magnetic resonance imaging. A method based on DE and adapted to mechanical characterization of venous thrombosis may allow the quantification of diseases severity in order to improve the final diagnosis. This thesis presents the works related to the development and complete validation of a novel non-invasive elastography imaging method for the quantitative and reliable estimation of mechanical properties of venous thrombosis. In order to fulfil the main objective, it is first necessary to improve knowledge about mechanical behaviours of blood clot (coagulated blood) subjected to a dynamic solicitation similar to DE. The shear storage (elastic behaviour, G’) and loss (viscous behavior, G’’) moduli of porcine blood clots are measured by DE during the blood coagulation kinetics (at 70 Hz) and after completely coagulation (between 50 Hz and 160 Hz). These results are the first dynamic behaviour measurements of blood clots in such wide frequency range. The subsequent step consists in introducing an innovative reference instrument (« gold standard »), called RheoSpectris, dedicated to measure the hyper-frequency viscoelasticity (between 10 Hz and 1000 Hz) of materials and biomaterials. This tool is indispensable to validate new dynamic elastography techniques. A comparative study between RheoSpectris and classical rheometry is performed to validate the measurements on different materials (silicon, thermoplastic, biomaterials, gel). The excellent agreement between both technologies allows to conclude that RheoSpectris is a reliable instrument for mechanical measurements at high frequencies, which is not always possible with current tools. The theoretical basis of a novel elastographic imaging modality, labelled SWIRE (« shear wave induced resonance dynamic elastography ») is presented and validated on vascular phantoms. Such approach allows the characterization of mechanical properties of a confined inclusion (e.g. blood clot) from its resonance (displacement amplification) due to the propagation of judiciously oriented shear waves. SWIRE has also the advantage to amplify the vibration amplitude within the heterogeneity to help for its detection and segmentation. Finally, the method DVT-SWIRE ((« Deep venous thrombosis – SWIRE ») is adapted to the quantitative elasticity estimation of venous thrombosis in the context of clinical use. DVT-SWIRE exploits the first resonance frequency measured within the thrombosis during the plane (vibration of rigid plate) or cylindrical (simulating supersonic radiation force generation) shear waves propagation. The technique is applied on DVT phantoms and the results are compared to those given by the RheoSpectris reference instrument. This method is also used successfully in an ex vivo study for the elasticity assessment of explanted porcine thrombosis surgically induced in vivo

A Microsoft HoloLens Mixed Reality Surgical Simulator for Patient-Specific Hip Arthroplasty Training

Surgical simulation can offer novice surgeons an opportunity to practice skills outside the operating theatre in a safe controlled environment. According to literature evidence, nowadays there are very few training simulators available for Hip Arthroplasty (HA). In a previous study we have presented a physical simulator based on a lower torso phantom including a patient-specific hemi-pelvis replica embedded in a soft synthetic foam. This work explores the use of Microsoft HoloLens technology to enrich the physical patient-specific simulation with the implementation of wearable mixed reality functionalities. Our HA multimodal simulator based on mixed reality using the HoloLens is described by illustrating the overall system, and by summarizing the main phases of the design and development. Finally, we present a preliminary qualitative study with seven subjects (5 medical students, and 2 orthopedic surgeons) showing encouraging results that suggest the suitability of the HoloLens for the proposed application. However, further studies need to be conducted to perform a quantitative test of the registration accuracy of the virtual content, and to confirm qualitative results in a larger cohort of subjects

Soft liver phantom with a hollow biliary system

Einleitung: Die flexible Endoskopie bietet eine ständig wachsende Zahl innovativer diagnostischer und therapeutischer Möglichkeiten bei hepatobiliären Erkrankungen. Diese fortschrittlichen Verfahren, die mitunter komplex und gar nicht so selten mit relevanten Komplikationen verbunden sind, erfordern spezielle technische Fertigkeiten, ein profundes anatomisches Wissen und eine lange Lernkurve, die praktisch trainiert werden muss. Für ein patientenunabhängiges Training endoskopischer und endosonographischer Eingriffe sollte ein weiches, naturgetreues und langlebiges Leberorganmodell mit detaillierter Morphologie zur Verfügung stehen. In dieser Arbeit wird ein praktikables und kostengünstiges selbst hergestelltes weiches Lebermodell mit anatomisch korrektem Gallensystem vorgestellt. Methode: Mit Hilfe von 3D-Druck- und Weichstoffformungstechnologien wurde ein nahezu realistisches Lebermodell mit einem komplexen, hohlen Gallensystem hergestellt. Die Anatomie des Lebermodells wurde mittels Computertomographie (CT), Ultraschall und Endoskopie validiert. Nach Aufbereitung und Auswertung der Bildgebung wurden interventionelle transhepatische Eingriffe eingeleitet. Zur Validierung der Trainingseffekte und der individuellen Kompetenz wurde ein genaues Bewertungssystem für den transhepatischen Zugang etabliert. Ergebnisse: Ein realistisches Lebermodell wurde erfolgreich entwickelt und hergestellt. Die CT-Ergebnisse zeigen, dass das Lebermodell die detaillierte Anatomie wiedergibt, mit einem räumlichen Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) von 0,9 ± 0,2 mm und 1,7 ± 0,7 mm für die äußere Form bzw. den Gallengang. Das endosonographische Bild des Modells ist realistisch und die Dimension der Gallengänge ist konsistent. Die transhepatische Punktion der Gallengänge war durchführbar und ein elektronisches Abtastsystem zur quantitativen Lokalisierung der transhepatischen Nadel in Echtzeit war erfolgreich möglich. Schlussfolgerung: Das vorgestellte künstliche Lebermodell für das endoskopische und endosonografische Training kommt der Realität einer normalen Leber sehr nahe, ist kostengünstig, einfach zu reproduzieren und für die Serienproduktion geeignet. Mit dem elektronischen Sensormodul lässt sich der Trainingserfolg objektiv kontrollieren. Neben der transhepatischen Punktion könnten an diesem Modell weitere Eingriffe trainiert werden, wie z. B. endoskpischen retrograden Cholangiopankreatographie (ERCP), perkutane transhepatische Cholangiographie oder choliangiographische Drainage (PTC/PTCD), perkutane holedochofiberoskopie (POC), endoskopische ultraschallgeführte biliäre Drainage (EUS-BD)

Patient-Specific Polyvinyl Alcohol Phantoms for Applications in Minimally Invasive Surgery

In biomedical engineering, phantoms are physical models of known geometric and material composition that are used to replicate biological tissues. Phantoms are vital tools in the testing and development of novel minimally invasive devices, as they can simulate the conditions in which devices will be used. Clinically, phantoms are also highly useful as training tools for minimally invasive procedures, such as those performed in regional anaesthesia, and for patient-specific surgical planning. Despite their widespread utility, there are many limitations with current phantoms and their fabrication methods. Commercial phantoms are often prohibitively expensive and may not be compatible with certain imaging modalities, such as ultrasound. Much of the phantom literature is complicated or hard to follow, making it difficult for researchers to produce their own models and it is highly challenging to create anatomically realistic phantoms that replicate real patient pathologies. Therefore, the aim of this work is to address some of the challenges with current phantoms. Novel fabrication methods and frameworks are presented to enable the creation of phantoms that are suitable for use in both the development of novel devices and as clinical training tools, for applications in minimally invasive surgery. This includes regional anaesthesia, brain tumour resection, and percutaneous coronary interventions. In such procedures, imaging is of key importance, and the phantoms developed are demonstrated to be compatible across a range of modalities, including ultrasound, computed tomography, MRI, and photoacoustic imaging

Multimodal phantoms for clinical PET/MRI

Phantoms are commonly used throughout medical imaging and medical physics for a multitude of applications, the designs of which vary between modalities and clinical or research requirements. Within positron emission tomography (PET) and nuclear medicine, phantoms have a well-established role in the validation of imaging protocols so as to reduce the administration of radioisotope to volunteers. Similarly, phantoms are used within magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to perform quality assurance on clinical scanners, and gel-based phantoms have a longstanding use within the MRI research community as tissue equivalent phantoms. In recent years, combined PET/MRI scanners for simultaneous acquisition have entered both research and clinical use. This review explores the designs and applications of phantom work within the field of simultaneous acquisition PET/MRI as published over the period of a decade. Common themes in the design, manufacture and materials used within phantoms are identified and the solutions they provided to research in PET/MRI are summarised. Finally, the challenges remaining in creating multimodal phantoms for use with simultaneous acquisition PET/MRI are discussed. No phantoms currently exist commercially that have been designed and optimised for simultaneous PET/MRI acquisition. Subsequently, commercially available PET and nuclear medicine phantoms are often utilised, with CT-based attenuation maps substituted for MR-based attenuation maps due to the lack of MR visibility in phantom housing. Tissue equivalent and anthropomorphic phantoms are often developed by research groups in-house and provide customisable alternatives to overcome barriers such as MR-based attenuation correction, or to address specific areas of study such as motion correction. Further work to characterise materials and manufacture methods used in phantom design would facilitate the ability to reproduce phantoms across sites