Selected Topics in Cryptanalysis of Symmetric Ciphers

It is well established that a symmetric cipher may be described as a system of Boolean polynomials, and that the security of the cipher cannot be better than the difficulty of solving said system. Compressed Right-Hand Side (CRHS) Equations is but one way of describing a symmetric cipher in terms of Boolean polynomials. The first paper of this thesis provides a comprehensive treatment firstly of the relationship between Boolean functions in algebraic normal form, Binary Decision Diagrams and CRHS equations. Secondly, of how CRHS equations may be used to describe certain kinds of symmetric ciphers and how this model may be used to attempt a key-recovery attack. This technique is not left as a theoretical exercise, as the process have been implemented as an open-source project named CryptaPath. To ensure accessibility for researchers unfamiliar with algebraic cryptanalysis, CryptaPath can convert a reference implementation of the target cipher, as specified by a Rust trait, into the CRHS equations model automatically. CRHS equations are not limited to key-recovery attacks, and Paper II explores one such avenue of CRHS equations flexibility. Linear and differential cryptanalysis have long since established their position as two of the most important cryptanalytical attacks, and every new design since must show resistance to both. For some ciphers, like the AES, this resistance can be mathematically proven, but many others are left to heuristic arguments and computer aided proofs. This work is tedious, and most of the tools require good background knowledge of a tool/technique to transform a design to the right input format, with a notable exception in CryptaGraph. CryptaGraph is written in Rust and transforms a reference implementation into CryptaGraphs underlying data structure automatically. Paper II introduces a new way to use CRHS equations to model a symmetric cipher, this time in such a way that linear and differential trail searches are possible. In addition, a new set of operations allowing us to count the number of active S-boxes in a path is presented. Due to CRHS equations effective initial data compression, all possible trails are captured in the initial system description. As is the case with CRHS equations, the crux is the memory consumption. However, this approach also enables the graph of a CRHS equation to be pruned, allowing the memory consumption to be kept at manageable levels. Unfortunately, pruning nodes also means that we will lose valid, incomplete paths, meaning that the hulls found are probably incomplete. On the flip side, all paths, and their corresponding probabilities, found by the tool are guaranteed to be valid trails for the cipher. This theory is also implemented in an extension of CryptaPath, and the name is PathFinder. PathFinder is also able to automatically turn a reference implementation of a cipher into its CRHS equations-based model. As an additional bonus, PathFinder supports the reference implementation specifications specified by CryptaGraph, meaning that the same reference implementation can be used for both CryptaGraph and PathFinder. Paper III shifts focus onto symmetric ciphers designed to be used in conjunction with FHE schemes. Symmetric ciphers designed for this purpose are relatively new and have naturally had a strong focus on reducing the number of multiplications performed. A multiplication is considered expensive on the noise budget of the FHE scheme, while linear operations are viewed as cheap. These ciphers are all assuming that it is possible to find parameters in the various FHE schemes which allow these ciphers to work well in symbiosis with the FHE scheme. Unfortunately, this is not always possible, with the consequence that the decryption process becomes more costly than necessary. Paper III therefore proposes Fasta, a stream cipher which has its parameters and linear layer especially chosen to allow efficient implementation over the BGV scheme, particularly as implemented in the HElib library. The linear layers are drawn from a family of rotation-based linear transformations, as cyclic rotations are cheap to do in FHE schemes that allow packing of multiple plaintext elements in one FHE ciphertext. Fasta follows the same design philosophy as Rasta, and will never use the same linear layer twice under the same key. The result is a stream cipher tailor-made for fast evaluation in HElib. Fasta shows an improvement in throughput of a factor more than 7 when compared to the most efficient implementation of Rasta.Doktorgradsavhandlin

Direct Construction of Recursive MDS Diffusion Layers using Shortened BCH Codes

MDS matrices allow to build optimal linear diffusion layers in block ciphers. However, MDS matrices cannot be sparse and usually have a large description, inducing costly software/hardware implementations. Recursive MDS matrices allow to solve this problem by focusing on MDS matrices that can be computed as a power of a simple companion matrix, thus having a compact description suitable even for constrained environ- ments. However, up to now, finding recursive MDS matrices required to perform an exhaustive search on families of companion matrices, thus limiting the size of MDS matrices one could look for. In this article we propose a new direct construction based on shortened BCH codes, al- lowing to efficiently construct such matrices for whatever parameters. Unfortunately, not all recursive MDS matrices can be obtained from BCH codes, and our algorithm is not always guaranteed to find the best matrices for a given set of parameters.Comment: Best paper award; Carlos Cid and Christian Rechberger. 21st International Workshop on Fast Software Encryption, FSE 2014, Mar 2014, London, United Kingdom. springe

Security analysis of NIST-LWC contest finalists

Dissertação de mestrado integrado em Informatics EngineeringTraditional cryptographic standards are designed with a desktop and server environment in mind, so, with the relatively recent proliferation of small, resource constrained devices in the Internet of Things, sensor networks, embedded systems, and more, there has been a call for lightweight cryptographic standards with security, performance and resource requirements tailored for the highly-constrained environments these devices find themselves in. In 2015 the National Institute of Standards and Technology began a Standardization Process in order to select one or more Lightweight Cryptographic algorithms. Out of the original 57 submissions ten finalists remain, with ASCON and Romulus being among the most scrutinized out of them. In this dissertation I will introduce some concepts required for easy understanding of the body of work, do an up-to-date revision on the current situation on the standardization process from a security and performance standpoint, a description of ASCON and Romulus, and new best known analysis, and a comparison of the two, with their advantages, drawbacks, and unique traits.Os padrões criptográficos tradicionais foram elaborados com um ambiente de computador e servidor em mente. Com a proliferação de dispositivos de pequenas dimensões tanto na Internet of Things, redes de sensores e sistemas embutidos, apareceu uma necessidade para se definir padrões para algoritmos de criptografia leve, com prioridades de segurança, performance e gasto de recursos equilibrados para os ambientes altamente limitados em que estes dispositivos operam. Em 2015 o National Institute of Standards and Technology lançou um processo de estandardização com o objectivo de escolher um ou mais algoritmos de criptografia leve. Das cinquenta e sete candidaturas originais sobram apenas dez finalistas, sendo ASCON e Romulus dois desses finalistas mais examinados. Nesta dissertação irei introduzir alguns conceitos necessários para uma fácil compreensão do corpo deste trabalho, assim como uma revisão atualizada da situação atual do processo de estandardização de um ponto de vista tanto de segurança como de performance, uma descrição do ASCON e do Romulus assim como as suas melhores análises recentes e uma comparação entre os dois, frisando as suas vantagens, desvantagens e aspectos únicos

CLAASP: a Cryptographic Library for the Automated Analysis of Symmetric Primitives

This paper introduces CLAASP, a Cryptographic Library for the Automated Analysis of Symmetric Primitives. The library is designed to be modular, extendable, easy to use, generic, efficient and fully automated. It is an extensive toolbox gathering state-of-the-art techniques aimed at simplifying the manual tasks of symmetric primitive designers and analysts. CLAASP is built on top of Sagemath and is open-source under the GPLv3 license. The central input of CLAASP is the description of a cryptographic primitive as a list of connected components in the form of a directed acyclic graph. From this representation, the library can automatically: (1) generate the Python or C code of the primitive evaluation function, (2) execute a wide range of statistical and avalanche tests on the primitive, (3) generate SAT, SMT, CP and MILP models to search, for example, differential and linear trails, (4) measure algebraic properties of the primitive, (5) test neural-based distinguishers. In this work, we also present a comprehensive survey and comparison of other software libraries aiming at similar goals as CLAASP

SoK: Security Evaluation of SBox-Based Block Ciphers

Cryptanalysis of block ciphers is an active and important research area with an extensive volume of literature. For this work, we focus on SBox-based ciphers, as they are widely used and cover a large class of block ciphers. While there have been prior works that have consolidated attacks on block ciphers, they usually focus on describing and listing the attacks. Moreover, the methods for evaluating a cipher\u27s security are often ad hoc, differing from cipher to cipher, as attacks and evaluation techniques are developed along the way. As such, we aim to organise the attack literature, as well as the work on security evaluation. In this work, we present a systematization of cryptanalysis of SBox-based block ciphers focusing on three main areas: (1) Evaluation of block ciphers against standard cryptanalytic attacks; (2) Organisation and relationships between various attacks; (3) Comparison of the evaluation and attacks on existing ciphers

LHash: A Lightweight Hash Function (Full Version)

In this paper, we propose a new lightweight hash function supporting three different digest sizes: 80, 96 and 128 bits, providing preimage security from 64 to 120 bits, second preimage and collision security from 40 to 60 bits. LHash requires about 817 GE and 1028 GE with a serialized implementation. In faster implementations based on function $T$, LHash requires 989 GE and 1200 GE with 54 and 72 cycles per block, respectively. Furthermore, its energy consumption evaluated by energy per bit is also remarkable. LHash allows to make trade-offs among security, speed, energy consumption and implementation costs by adjusting parameters. The design of LHash employs a kind of Feistel-PG structure in the internal permutation, and this structure can utilize permutation layers on nibbles to improve the diffusion speed. The adaptability of LHash in different environments is good, since different versions of LHash share the same basic computing module. The low-area implementation comes from the hardware-friendly S-box and linear diffusion layer. We evaluate the resistance of LHash against known attacks and confirm that LHash provides a good security margin

Lightweight Design Choices for LED-like Block Ciphers

Serial matrices are a preferred choice for building diffusion layers of lightweight block ciphers as one just needs to implement the last row of such a matrix. In this work we analyze a new class of serial matrices which are the lightest possible $4 \times 4$ serial matrix that can be used to build diffusion layers. With this new matrix we show that block ciphers like LED can be implemented with a reduced area in hardware designs, though it has to be cycled for more iterations. Further, we suggest the usage of an alternative S-box to the standard S-box used in LED with similar cryptographic robustness, albeit having lesser area footprint. Finally, we combine these ideas in an end-end FPGA based prototype of LED. We show that with these optimizations, there is a reduction of $16$ in area footprint of one round implementation of LED

MILP Method of Searching Integral Distinguishers Based on Division Property Using Three Subsets

Division property is a generalized integral property proposed by Todo at EUROCRYPT 2015, and then conventional bit-based division property (CBDP) and bit-based division property using three subsets (BDPT) were proposed by Todo and Morii at FSE 2016. The huge time and memory complexity that once restricted the applications of CBDP have been solved by Xiang et al. at ASIACRYPT 2016. They extended Mixed Integer Linear Programming (MILP) method to search integral distinguishers based on CBDP. BDPT can find more accurate integral distinguishers than CBDP, but it can not be modeled efficiently. Thus it cannot be applied to block ciphers with block size larger than 32 bits. In this paper, we focus on the feasibility of applying MILP-aided method to search integral distinguishers based on BDPT. We firstly study how to get the BDPT propagation rules of an S-box. Based on that we can efficiently describe the BDPT propagation of cipher which has S-box. Moreover, we propose a technique called ``fast propagation , which can translate BDPT into CBDP, then the balanced bits based on BDPT can be presented. Together with the propagation properties of BDPT, we can use MILP method based on CBDP to search integral distinguishers based on BDPT. In order to prove the efficiency of our method, we search integral distinguishers on SIMON, SIMECK, PRESENT, RECTANGLE, LBlock, and TWINE. For SIMON64, PRESENT, and RECTANGLE, we find more balanced bits than the previous longest distinguishers. For LBlock, we find a 17-round integral distinguisher which is one more round than the previous longest integral distinguisher, and a better 16-round integral distinguisher with less active bits can be obtain. For other ciphers, our results are in accordance with the previous longest distinguishers

Finding Bit-Based Division Property for Ciphers with Complex Linear Layers

The bit-based division property (BDP) is the most effective technique for finding integral characteristics of symmetric ciphers. Recently, automatic search tools have become one of the most popular approaches to evaluating the security of designs against many attacks. Constraint-aided automatic tools for the BDP have been applied to many ciphers with simple linear layers like bit-permutation. Constructing models of complex linear layers accurately and efficiently remains hard. A straightforward method proposed by Sun et al. (called the S method), decomposes a complex linear layer into basic operations like COPY and XOR, then models them one by one. However, this method can easily insert invalid division trails into the solution pool, which results in a quicker loss of the balanced property than the cipher itself would. In order to solve this problem, Zhang and Rijmen propose the ZR method to link every valid trail with an invertible sub-matrix of the matrix corresponding to the linear layer, and then generate linear inequalities to represent all the invertible sub-matrices. Unfortunately, the ZR method is only applicable to invertible binary matrices (defined in Definition 3).To avoid generating a huge number of inequalities for all the sub-matrices, we build a new model that only includes that the sub-matrix corresponding to a valid trail should be invertible. The computing scale of our model can be tackled by most of SMT/SAT solvers, which makes our method practical. For applications, we improve the previous BDP for LED and MISTY1. We also give the 7-round BDP results for Camellia with FL/FL−1, which is the longest to date.Furthermore, we remove the restriction of the ZR method that the matrix has to be invertible, which provides more choices for future designs. Thanks to this, we also reproduce 5-round key-dependent integral distinguishers proposed at Crypto 2016 which cannot be obtained by either the S or ZR methods