Scheduling policies and system software architectures for mixed-criticality computing

Mixed-criticality model of computation is being increasingly adopted in timing-sensitive systems. The model not only ensures that the most critical tasks in a system never fails, but also aims for better systems resource utilization in normal condition. In this report, we describe the widely used mixed-criticality task model and fixed-priority scheduling algorithms for the model in uniprocessors. Because of the necessity by the mixed-criticality task model and scheduling policies, isolation, both temporal and spatial, among tasks is one of the main requirements from the system design point of view. Different virtualization techniques have been used to design system software architecture with the goal of isolation. We discuss such a few system software architectures which are being and can be used for mixed-criticality model of computation

Distributed real-time fault tolerance in a virtualized separation kernel

Computers are increasingly being placed in scenarios where a computer error could result in the loss of human life or significant financial loss. Fault tolerant techniques must be employed to prevent an error from resulting in a fault causing such losses. Two types of errors that are common in real-time and embedded system are soft errors, i.e. data bit corruption, and timing errors, such as missed deadlines. Purely software based techniques to address these types of errors have the advantage of not requiring specialized hardware and are able to use more readily available commercial off-the-shelf hardware. Timing errors are addressed using Adaptive Mixed-Criticality, a scheduling technique where higher criticality tasks are given precedence over those of lower criticality when it is impossible to guarantee the schedulability of all tasks. While mixed-criticality scheduling has gained attention in recent years, most approaches assume a periodic task model and that the system has a single criticality level which dictates the available budget to all tasks. In practice these assumptions do not hold: different types of tasks are better served by different scheduling approaches and only a subset of high critical tasks might require additional capacity to meet deadlines. In the latter case, this occurs when a process has experienced a fault and requires additional capacity to perform the recovery. In this thesis, soft errors are addressed using a novel real-time fault tolerance method based on a virtualized separation kernel. Instead of executing redundant copies of an application on separate machines, the applications are consolidated onto one multi-core processor and use hardware virtualization extensions to partition the applications. This allows new recovery schemes to be explored. In addition, the maximum recovery time is sufficiently bounded to ensure recovery occurs in a timely manner without affecting the normal execution of the application. A virtualized separation kernel in combination with Adaptive Mixed-Criticality techniques creates a fault tolerant system that predictably detects and recovers from timing and soft errors

Leveraging virtualization technologies for resource partitioning in mixed criticality systems

Multi- and many-core processors are becoming increasingly popular in embedded systems. Many of these processors now feature hardware virtualization capabilities, such as the ARM Cortex A15, and x86 processors with Intel VT-x or AMD-V support. Hardware virtualization offers opportunities to partition physical resources, including processor cores, memory and I/O devices amongst guest virtual machines. Mixed criticality systems and services can then co-exist on the same platform in separate virtual machines. However, traditional virtual machine systems are too expensive because of the costs of trapping into hypervisors to multiplex and manage machine physical resources on behalf of separate guests. For example, hypervisors are needed to schedule separate VMs on physical processor cores. Additionally, traditional hypervisors have memory footprints that are often too large for many embedded computing systems. This dissertation presents the design of the Quest-V separation kernel, which partitions services of different criticality levels across separate virtual machines, or sandboxes. Each sandbox encapsulates a subset of machine physical resources that it manages without requiring intervention of a hypervisor. In Quest-V, a hypervisor is not needed for normal operation, except to bootstrap the system and establish communication channels between sandboxes. This approach not only reduces the memory footprint of the most privileged protection domain, it removes it from the control path during normal system operation, thereby heightening security

MCS-IOV : Real-time I/o virtualization for mixed-criticality systems

In mixed-criticality systems, timely handling of I/O is a key for the system being successfully implemented and functioning appropriately. The criticality levels of functions and sometimes the whole system are often dependent on the state of the I/O. An I/O system for a MCS must provide simultaneously isolation/separation, performance/efficiency and timing-predictability, as well as being able to manage I/O resource in an adaptive manner to facilitate efficient yet safe resource sharing among components of different criticality levels. Existing approaches cannot achieve all of these requirements simultaneously. This paper presents a MCS I/O management framework, termed MCS-IOV. MCS-IOV is based on hardware assisted virtualisation, which provides temporal and spatial isolation and prohibits fault propagation with small extra overhead in performance. MCS-IOV extends a real-time I/O virtualisation system, by supporting the concept of mixed criticalities and customised interfaces for schedulers, which offers good timing-preditability. MCS-IOV supports I/O driven criticality mode switch (the mode switch can be triggered by detection of unexpected I/O behaviors, e.g., a higher I/O utilization than expected) and timely I/O resource reconfiguration up on that. Finally, We evaluated and demonstrate MCS-IOV in different aspects

MultiPARTES: Multicore Virtualization for Mixed-Criticality Systems

Modern embedded applications typically integrate a multitude of functionalities with potentially different criticality levels into a single system. Without appropriate preconditions, the integration of mixed-criticality subsystems can lead to a significant and potentially unacceptable increase of engineering and certification costs. A promising solution is to incorporate mechanisms that establish multiple partitions with strict temporal and spatial separation between the individual partitions. In this approach, subsystems with different levels of criticality can be placed in different partitions and can be verified and validated in isolation. The MultiPARTES FP7 project aims at supporting mixed- criticality integration for embedded systems based on virtualization techniques for heterogeneous multicore processors. A major outcome of the project is the MultiPARTES XtratuM, an open source hypervisor designed as a generic virtualization layer for heterogeneous multicore. MultiPARTES evaluates the developed technology through selected use cases from the offshore wind power, space, visual surveillance, and automotive domains. The impact of MultiPARTES on the targeted domains will be also discussed. In a number of ongoing research initiatives (e.g., RECOMP, ARAMIS, MultiPARTES, CERTAINTY) mixed-criticality integration is considered in multicore processors. Key challenges are the combination of software virtualization and hardware segregation and the extension of partitioning mechanisms to jointly address significant non-functional requirements (e.g., time, energy and power budgets, adaptivity, reliability, safety, security, volume, weight, etc.) along with development and certification methodology

Achieving Performance Balance for Dual-Criticality System Based on ARM TrustZone

Many mixed-criticality systems are composed of a RTOS (Real-Time Operating System) and a GPOS (General Purpose Operating System), and we define this as a mixed-timesensitive system. Complexity, isolation, real-time latency, and overhead are the main metrics to design such a mixed-timesensitive system. These metrics may conflict with each other, so it is difficult for them to be consistently optimized. Most existing implementations only optimize with part of the above metrics but not all. As the first contribution, this paper provides a detailed analysis of performance influencing factors which are exerted by various runtime mechanisms of existing mixed-time-sensitive systems. We figure out the difference in performance across system designs such as task switching, memory management, interrupt handling, and resource isolation. We propose the philosophy of utilizing TrustZone characteristics to optimize various mechanisms in mixed-time-sensitive systems. The second contribution of the paper is to propose a Trustzonebased solution - termed TZDKS - for mixed-time sensitive system. Appropriate utilization of TrustZone extensions helps TZDKS to implements (i) virtualization environment for GPOS and RTOS, (ii) high efficiency task switching, memory accessing, interrupt handling and device accessing which are verified by experiments. Therefore, TZDKS can achieve a full-scale balance amongst aforementioned metrics