Efficiency in colonoscopy

Global trends, including demographic changes, are significantly increasing the demand and cost of healthcare. Endoscopy services are no exception and, even before the Covid-19 pandemic, significant pressure resulted in many units failing to meet cancer wait targets. The need to improve efficiency has never been greater and particularly so for colonoscopy which significantly reduces morbidity and mortality from colorectal cancer. Today, advances in colonoscope technologies and emergence of artificial intelligence offer the potential for improved colonoscopy practice. The aim of this thesis is to explore how efficiency in colonoscopy can be enhanced throughout the patient pathway. Five major studies were performed evaluating bowel preparation (CLEANSE), polyp detection (AI-DETECT), optical diagnosis (DISCARD3), insertion technique (WAVE) and post-colonoscopy colorectal cancer (AI-DETECT). CLEANSE is an evaluation of a novel low-volume same-day bowel preparation regime (Plenvu) and showed this offers a more efficient bowel cleansing option than standard regimens. AI-DETECT is a randomised study evaluating a computer-aided detection (CADe) system (GI Genius) and showed a borderline significant improvement in polyp detection is achieved amongst high performing endoscopists. DISCARD3 is a major evaluation of optical diagnosis with a “resect and discard” strategy exploring the learning curve, quality assurance process, causes of error and economic impact. This study shows such a strategy is feasible and safe and could potentially be implemented with a quality assurance process in place within the English Bowel Cancer Screening Progamme (BCSP). WAVE is a randomised study evaluating colonoscopy insertion technique. This showed a ‘hybrid’ insertion technique is more efficient than a water-exchange colonoscopy technique. REFLECT is a retrospective evaluation of post-colonoscopy colorectal cancer cases identified at national level and showed after local root cause analysis a significant proportion were in fact detected cancers. These studies provide valuable insights that we hope will ultimately lead to more efficient colonoscopy whilst maintaining quality and enhancing patient care.Open Acces

Remote access computed tomography colonography

This thesis presents a novel framework for remote access Computed Tomography Colonography (CTC). The proposed framework consists of several integrated components: medical image data delivery, 2D image processing, 3D visualisation, and feedback provision. Medical image data sets are notoriously large and preserving the integrity of the patient data is essential. This makes real-time delivery and visualisation a key challenge. The main contribution of this work is the development of an efficient, lossless compression scheme to minimise the size of the data to be transmitted, thereby alleviating transmission time delays. The scheme utilises prior knowledge of anatomical information to divide the data into specific regions. An optimised compression method for each anatomical region is then applied. An evaluation of this compression technique shows that the proposed ‘divide and conquer’ approach significantly improves upon the level of compression achieved using more traditional global compression schemes. Another contribution of this work resides in the development of an improved volume rendering technique that provides real-time 3D visualisations of regions within CTC data sets. Unlike previous hardware acceleration methods which rely on dedicated devices, this approach employs a series of software acceleration techniques based on the characteristic properties of CTC data. A quantitative and qualitative evaluation indicates that the proposed method achieves real-time performance on a low-cost PC platform without sacrificing any image quality. Fast data delivery and real-time volume rendering represent the key features that are required for remote access CTC. These features are ultimately combined with other relevant CTC functionality to create a comprehensive, high-performance CTC framework, which makes remote access CTC feasible, even in the case of standard Web clients with low-speed data connections

Eye-tracking the moving medical image: Development and investigation of a novel investigational tool for CT Colonography

Colorectal cancer remains the third most common cancer in the UK but the second leading cause of cancer death with >16,000 dying per year. Many advances have been made in recent years in all areas of investigation for colorectal cancer, one of the more notable being the widespread introduction of CT Colonography (CTC). CTC has rapidly established itself as a cornerstone of diagnosis for colonic neoplasia and much work has been done to standardise and assure quality in practice in both the acquisition and interpretation of the technique. A novel feature of CTC is the presentation of imaging in both traditional 2D and the ‘virtual’ 3D endoluminal formats. This thesis looks at expanding our understanding of and improving our performance in utilizing the endoluminal 3D view. We present and develop novel metrics applicable to eye-tracking the moving image, so that the complex dynamic nature of 3D endoluminal fly-through interpretation can be captured. These metrics are then applied to assess the effect of important elements of image interpretation, namely, reader experience, the effect of the use Computer Aided Detection (CAD) and the influence of the expected prevalence of abnormality. We review our findings with reference to the literature of eye tracking within medical imaging. In the co-registration section we apply our validated computer-assisted registration algorithm to the matching of 3D endoluminal colonic locations between temporally separate datasets, assessing its accuracy as an aid to colonic polyp surveillance with CTC

A roadmap for the clinical implementation of optical-imaging biomarkers

Clinical workflows for the non-invasive detection and characterization of disease states could benefit from optical-imaging biomarkers. In this Perspective, we discuss opportunities and challenges towards the clinical implementation of optical-imaging biomarkers for the early detection of cancer by analysing two case studies: the assessment of skin lesions in primary care, and the surveillance of patients with Barrett’s oesophagus in specialist care. We stress the importance of technical and biological validations and clinical-utility assessments, and the need to address implementation bottlenecks. In addition, we define a translational roadmap for the widespread clinical implementation of optical imaging-technologies

New Techniques in Gastrointestinal Endoscopy

As result of progress, endoscopy has became more complex, using more sophisticated devices and has claimed a special form. In this moment, the gastroenterologist performing endoscopy has to be an expert in macroscopic view of the lesions in the gut, with good skills for using standard endoscopes, with good experience in ultrasound (for performing endoscopic ultrasound), with pathology experience for confocal examination. It is compulsory to get experience and to have patience and attention for the follow-up of thousands of images transmitted during capsule endoscopy or to have knowledge in physics necessary for autofluorescence imaging endoscopy. Therefore, the idea of an endoscopist has changed. Examinations mentioned need a special formation, a superior level of instruction, accessible to those who have already gained enough experience in basic diagnostic endoscopy. This is the reason for what these new issues of endoscopy are presented in this book of New techniques in Gastrointestinal Endoscopy

Visualisation of curved tubular structures in medical databases: An application to virtual colonoscopy

Medical conditions affecting the colon are problematic to diagnose due to the difficulty in examining this particular internal organ. To date, the most widely used approach is to perform a colonoscopy; a procedure in which a small camera is inserted into the colon to examine its surface. This procedure is unpleasant and potentially dangerous for the patient, and is expensive and time consuming for the hospital. As a result, patients at risk of developing the conditions are not always screened as often as would be desirable. Over the last few years a new approach known as virtual colonoscopy has been gaining popularity. The method uses information from a CT scan to reconstruct a 3D model of the colon which can then be examined without the patient needing to undergo a colonoscopy. This approach is now commonly used when screening for polyps (an indication of colon cancer) but can not be so easily used on conditions such as Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD) where information beyond the shape of the surface is required. This thesis forms part of a larger project which aims to diagnose conditions such as IBD by using image processing algorithms on CT data and presenting the results to the user in an easy to interpret way. Specifically we are concerned with this visualisation stage of the system and so have developed a new visualisation approach which we call Volumetric CPR. This can be used to supplement the more traditional virtual flythrough visualisation and is applicable to IBD detection as well as screening for polyps. Our technique builds on the concept of Curved Planar Reformation (CPR), which has proved to be a practical and widely used tool for the visualisation of curved tubular structures within the human body. It has been useful in medical procedures involving the examination of blood vessels and the spine. However, it is more difficult to use it for structures such as the colon because abnormalities are smaller relative to the size of the structure and may not have such distinct density and shape characteristics. Our new approach improves on this situation by using volume rendering for hollow regions of the structure and standard CPR, for the surrounding tissue. This effectively combines grey scale contextual information with detailed colour information from the area of interest. The approach is successfully used with each of the standard CPR types and the resulting images are promising as an alternative for virtual colonoscopy. We also demonstrate how systems can effectively utilize this new visualisation in order to convey maximum information to the user. We show how overlays can be used to present surface coverage data and how sophisticated lighting models can improve the users understanding of the 3D structure. We also present details of how to integrate our visualisation into existing systems and work flows

Developing and evaluating expertise in colonoscopy

The quality and safety of colonoscopy have become of paramount importance with the worldwide expansion in the utilisation of this procedure, especially with the introduction of colorectal cancer screening in many countries. It is well known that colonoscopic performance varies significantly between practitioners. This thesis explores the effects of assessment in colonoscopy and polypectomy on performance and practice as well as trying to define the factors which differentiate the very best practitioners from the clinically competent. Until 2011, there was no formalised way of certifying polypectomy competence. We looked at the effects of the introduction of mandatory polypectomy assessment on trainee endoscopists applying for certification of competency in the United Kingdom. This work showed that documentation of polypectomy competence significantly improved after these changes were introduced. A global survey of polypectomy practice was undertaken to evaluate international guidance on polypectomy skills training and how trainers deliver teaching on polypectomy around the world, as well as trainees’ experience of gaining polypectomy skills. Significant variability in endoscopists’ experience of polypectomy training was found with few formal national guidelines published. This led to an evaluation of expert endoscopists who underwent an accreditation process with some similarities before commencing Bowel Cancer Screening (BCS). We examined whether it was possible to predict future performance from a single assessment and found that criteria used to assess whether candidates were competent could not predict the best performers from those who passed. Several hundred expert BCS colonoscopists were then monitored over a three year period to determine changes in performance over time and whether long-term performance could be predicted. The best predictors of performance over time for all metrics were initial performance. In order to identify key features of expertise in endoscopy, experienced colonoscopists were interviewed to distinguish characteristics of true endoscopic experts. These interviews revealed the importance of both technical and non-technical skills in defining expertise.Open Acces

Appearance Modelling and Reconstruction for Navigation in Minimally Invasive Surgery

Minimally invasive surgery is playing an increasingly important role for patient care. Whilst its direct patient benefit in terms of reduced trauma, improved recovery and shortened hospitalisation has been well established, there is a sustained need for improved training of the existing procedures and the development of new smart instruments to tackle the issue of visualisation, ergonomic control, haptic and tactile feedback. For endoscopic intervention, the small field of view in the presence of a complex anatomy can easily introduce disorientation to the operator as the tortuous access pathway is not always easy to predict and control with standard endoscopes. Effective training through simulation devices, based on either virtual reality or mixed-reality simulators, can help to improve the spatial awareness, consistency and safety of these procedures. This thesis examines the use of endoscopic videos for both simulation and navigation purposes. More specifically, it addresses the challenging problem of how to build high-fidelity subject-specific simulation environments for improved training and skills assessment. Issues related to mesh parameterisation and texture blending are investigated. With the maturity of computer vision in terms of both 3D shape reconstruction and localisation and mapping, vision-based techniques have enjoyed significant interest in recent years for surgical navigation. The thesis also tackles the problem of how to use vision-based techniques for providing a detailed 3D map and dynamically expanded field of view to improve spatial awareness and avoid operator disorientation. The key advantage of this approach is that it does not require additional hardware, and thus introduces minimal interference to the existing surgical workflow. The derived 3D map can be effectively integrated with pre-operative data, allowing both global and local 3D navigation by taking into account tissue structural and appearance changes. Both simulation and laboratory-based experiments are conducted throughout this research to assess the practical value of the method proposed

Optimizing endoscopic strategies for colorectal cancer screening : improving colonoscopy effectiveness by optical, non-optical, and computer-based models

Introduction: Le cancer colorectal demeure un grave problème de santé publique au Canada. Les programmes de dépistage pourraient réduire l'incidence du cancer colorectal et la mortalité qui lui est associée. Une coloscopie de haute qualité est considérée comme un moyen rentable de prévenir le cancer en identifiant et en éliminant les lésions précurseurs du cancer. Bien que la coloscopie puisse servir de mesure préventive contre le cancer, la procédure peut imposer un fardeau supplémentaire à la santé publique par l'enlèvement et l'évaluation histologique de polypes colorectaux diminutifs et insignifiants, qui présentent un risque minime d'histologie avancée ou de cancer. La technologie de l'amélioration de l'image permettrait aux médecins de réséquer et de rejeter les polypes diminutifs ou de diagnostiquer et de laisser les polypes rectosigmoïdiens diminutifs sans examen histopathologique. Malgré la disponibilité de systèmes informatiques de caractérisation des polypes, la pratique du diagnostic optique reste limitée en raison de la crainte d'un mauvais diagnostic de cancer, d'une mauvaise surveillance des patients et des problèmes médico-légaux correspondants. Il est donc indispensable d'élaborer des stratégies alternatives de résection et d'élimination non optiques pour améliorer la précision et la sécurité du diagnostic optique et l'adapter à la pratique clinique. Ces stratégies doivent répondre à des critères cliniques simples et ne nécessitent pas de formation supplémentaire ni de dispositifs d'amélioration de l'image. De plus, la pratique sûre du diagnostic optique, la prise de décision appropriée concernant la technique de polypectomie ou l'intervalle de surveillance dépendent de l'estimation précise de la taille des polypes. La variabilité inter-endoscopistes dans la mesure de la taille des polypes exige le développement de méthodes fiables et validées pour augmenter la précision de la mesure de la taille. Une balance virtuelle intégrée à un endoscope haute définition est actuellement disponible pour le calcul automatique de la taille des polypes, mais sa faisabilité clinique n'a pas encore été établie. En dehors des points susmentionnés, une coloscopie de haute qualité nécessite l'examen complet de la muqueuse colique, ainsi que la visualisation de la valve iléocæcale et de l'orifice appendiculaire. À ce jour, aucune solution informatique n'a été capable d'assister les endoscopistes pendant les coloscopies en temps réel en détectant et en différenciant les points de repère cæcaux de façon automatique. Objectifs: Les objectifs de cette thèse sont : 1) d'étudier l'effet de la limitation du diagnostic optique aux polypes de 1 à 3 mm sur la sécurité du diagnostic optique pour le traitement des polypes diminutifs et l'acceptation par les endoscopistes de son utilisation dans les pratiques en temps réel tout en préservant ses potentiels de temps et de rentabilité ; 2) élaborer et examiner des stratégies non optiques de résection et d'élimination qui peuvent remplacer le diagnostic optique tout en offrant les mêmes possibilités d'économie de temps et d'argent ; 3) examiner la précision relative d'un endoscope à échelle virtuelle pour mesurer la taille des polypes ; 4) former, valider et tester un modèle d'intelligence artificielle qui peut prédire la complétude d'une procédure de coloscopie en identifiant les points de repère anatomiques du cæcum (c'est-à-dire la valve iléo-cæcale et l'orifice appendiculaire) et en les différenciant les uns des autres, des polypes et de la muqueuse normale. Méthodes: Pour atteindre le premier objectif de cette thèse, une analyse post-hoc de trois études prospectives a été réalisée pour évaluer la proportion de patients chez lesquels des adénomes avancés ont été découverts et le diagnostic optique a entraîné une surveillance retardée dans trois groupes de taille de polypes : 1–3, 1–5, et 1–10 mm. Pour atteindre le second objectif de cette thèse, deux stratégies non optiques ont été développées et testées dans deux études prospectives: une stratégie de résection et d'élimination basée sur la localisation qui utilise la localisation anatomique des polypes pour classer les polypes du côlon en non-néoplasiques ou néoplasiques à faible risque et une stratégie de résection et d'élimination basée sur les polypes qui attribue des intervalles de surveillance en fonction du nombre et de la taille des polypes. Dans les trois études, la concordance de l'attribution d'intervalles de surveillance basée sur un diagnostic optique à haute confiance ou sur des stratégies non optiques avec les recommandations basées sur la pathologie, ainsi que la proportion d'examens pathologiques évités et la proportion de communications immédiates d'intervalles de surveillance, ont été évaluées. Le troisième objectif de cette thèse a été abordé par le biais d'une étude de faisabilité pilote prospective qui a utilisé la mesure de spécimens de polypes immédiatement après leur prélèvement, suite à une polypectomie par un pied à coulisse Vernier comme référence pour comparer la précision relative des mesures de la taille des polypes entre les endoscopistes et un endoscope à échelle virtuelle. Enfin, le quatrième objectif de cette thèse a été évalué par l'enregistrement et l'annotation prospective de vidéos de coloscopie. Des images non modifiées de polype, de valve iléo-caecale, d'orifice appendiculaire et de muqueuse normale ont été extraites et utilisées pour développer et tester un modèle de réseau neuronal convolutionnel profond pour classer les images pour les points de repère qu'elles contiennent. Résultats: La réduction du seuil du diagnostic optique favoriserait la sécurité du diagnostic optique en diminuant de manière significative le risque d'écarter un polype avec une histologie avancée ou la mauvaise surveillance d'un patient avec de tels polypes. En outre, les stratégies non optiques de résection et d'élimination pourraient dépasser le critère de référence d'au moins 90% de concordance dans l'attribution des intervalles de surveillance post-polypectomie par rapport aux décisions basées sur l'évaluation pathologique. De plus, il a été démontré que l'endoscope à échelle virtuelle est plus précis que l'estimation visuelle de la taille des polypes en temps réel. Enfin, un modèle d'apprentissage profond s'est révélé très efficace pour détecter les repères cæcaux, les polypes et la muqueuse normale, à la fois individuellement et en combinaison. Discussion: La prédiction histologique optique des polypes de 1 à 3 mm est une approche efficace pour améliorer la sécurité et la faisabilité de la stratégie de résection et d'écartement dans la pratique. Les approches non optiques de résection et d'élimination offrent également des alternatives viables au diagnostic optique lorsque les endoscopistes ne sont pas en mesure de répondre aux conditions de mise en œuvre systématique du diagnostic optique, ou lorsque la technologie d'amélioration de l'image n'est pas accessible. Les stratégies de résection et de rejet, qu'elles soient optiques ou non, pourraient réduire les coûts supplémentaires liés aux examens histopathologiques et faciliter la communication du prochain intervalle de surveillance le même jour que la coloscopie de référence. Un endoscope virtuel à échelle réduite faciliterait l'utilisation du diagnostic optique pour la détection des polypes diminutifs et permet une prise de décision appropriée pendant et après la coloscopie. Enfin, le modèle d'apprentissage profond peut être utile pour promouvoir et contrôler la qualité des coloscopies par la prédiction d'une coloscopie complète. Cette technologie peut être intégrée dans le cadre d'une plateforme de vérification et de génération de rapports qui élimine le besoin d'intervention humaine. Conclusion: Les résultats présentés dans cette thèse contribueront à l'état actuel des connaissances dans la pratique de la coloscopie concernant les stratégies pour améliorer l'efficacité de la coloscopie dans la prévention du cancer colorectal. Cette étude fournira des indications précieuses pour les futurs chercheurs intéressés par le développement de méthodes efficaces de traitement des polypes colorectaux diminutifs. Le diagnostic optique nécessite une formation complémentaire et une mise en œuvre à l'aide de modules de caractérisation informatisés. En outre, malgré la lenteur de l'adoption des solutions informatiques dans la pratique clinique, la coloscopie assistée par l'IA ouvrira la voie à la détection automatique, à la caractérisation et à la rédaction semi-automatique des rapports de procédure.Introduction: Colorectal cancer remains a critical public health concern in Canada. Screening programs could reduce the incidence of colorectal cancer and its associated mortality. A high-quality colonoscopy is appraised to be a cost-effective means of cancer prevention through identifying and removing cancer precursor lesions. Although colonoscopy can serve as a preventative measure against cancer, the procedure can impose an additional burden on the public health by removing and histologically evaluating insignificant diminutive colorectal polyps, which pose a minimal risk of advanced histology or cancer. The image-enhance technology would enable physicians to resect and discard diminutive polyps or diagnose and leave diminutive rectosigmoid polyps without histopathology examination. Despite the availability of computer-based polyp characterization systems, the practice of optical diagnosis remains limited due to the fear of cancer misdiagnosis, patient mismanagement, and the related medicolegal issues. Thus, alternative non-optical resection and discard strategies are imperative for improving the accuracy and safety of optical diagnosis for adaptation to clinical practice. These strategies should follow simple clinical criteria and do not require additional education or image enhanced devices. Furthermore, the safe practice of optical diagnosis, adequate decision-making regarding polypectomy technique, or surveillance interval depends on accurate polyp size estimation. The inter-endoscopist variability in polyp sizing necessitates the development of reliable and validated methods to enhance the accuracy of size measurement. A virtual scale integrated into a high-definition endoscope is currently available for automated polyp sizing, but its clinical feasibility has not yet been demonstrated. In addition to the points mentioned above, a high-quality colonoscopy requires the complete examination of the entire colonic mucosa, as well as the visualization of the ileocecal valve and appendiceal orifice. To date, no computer-based solution has been able to support endoscopists during live colonoscopies by automatically detecting and differentiating cecal landmarks. Aims: The aims of this thesis are: 1) to investigate the effect of limiting optical diagnosis to polyps 1–3mm on the safety of optical diagnosis for the management of diminutive polyps and the acceptance of endoscopists for its use in real-time practices while preserving its time- and cost-effectiveness potentials; 2) to develop and examine non-optical resect and discard strategies that can replace optical diagnosis while offering the same time- and cost-saving potentials; 3) to examine the relative accuracy of a virtual scale endoscope for measuring polyp size; 4) to train, validate, and test an artificial intelligence-empower model that can predict the completeness of a colonoscopy procedure by identifying cecal anatomical landmarks (i.e., ileocecal valve and appendiceal orifice) and differentiating them from one another, polyps, and normal mucosa. Methods: To achieve the first aim of this thesis, a post-hoc analysis of three prospective studies was performed to evaluate the proportion of patients in which advanced adenomas were found and optical diagnosis resulted in delayed surveillance in three polyp size groups: 1‒3, 1‒5, and 1‒10 mm. To achieve the second aim of this thesis, two non-optical strategies were developed and tested in two prospective studies: a location-based resect and discard strategy that uses anatomical polyp location to classify colon polyps into non-neoplastic or low-risk neoplastic and a polyp-based resect and discard strategy that assigns surveillance intervals based on polyp number and size. In all three studies, the agreement of assigning surveillance intervals based on high-confidence optical diagnosis or non-optical strategies with pathology-based recommendations, as well as the proportion of avoided pathology examinations and the proportion of immediate surveillance interval communications, was evaluated. The third aim of this thesis was addressed through a prospective pilot feasibility study that used the measurement of polyp specimens immediately after retrieving, following a polypectomy by a Vernier caliper as a reference to compare the relative accuracy of polyp size measurements between endoscopists and a virtual scale endoscope. Finally, the fourth aim of this thesis was assessed through prospective recording and annotation of colonoscopy videos. Unaltered images of polyp, ileocecal valve, appendiceal orifice and normal mucosa were extracted and used to develop and test a deep convolutional neural network model for classifying images for the containing landmarks. Results: Reducing the threshold of optical diagnosis would promote the safety of optical diagnosis by significantly decreasing the risk of discarding a polyp with advanced histology or the mismanagement of a patient with such polyps. Additionally, the non-optical resect and discard strategies could surpass the benchmark of at least 90% agreement in the assignment of post-polypectomy surveillance intervals compared with decisions based on pathologic assessment. Moreover, the virtual scale endoscope was demonstrated to be more accurate than visual estimation of polyp size in real-time. Finally, a deep learning model proved to be highly effective in detecting cecal landmarks, polyps, and normal mucosa, both individually and in combination. Discussion: Optical histology prediction of polyps 1‒3 mm in size is an effective approach to enhance the safety and feasibility of resect and discard strategy in practice. Non-optical resect and discard approaches also offer feasible alternatives to optical diagnosis when endoscopists are unable to meet the conditions for routine implementation of optical diagnosis, or when image-enhanced technology is not accessible. Both optical and non-optical resect and discard strategies could reduce additional costs related to histopathology examinations and facilitate the communication of the next surveillance interval in the same day as the index colonoscopy. A virtual scale endoscope would facilitate the use of optical diagnosis for the detection of diminutive polyps and allows for appropriate decision-making during and after colonoscopy. Additionally, the deep learning model may be useful in promoting and monitoring the quality of colonoscopies through the prediction of a complete colonoscopy. This technology may be incorporated as part of a platform for auditing and report generation that eliminates the need for human intervention. Conclusion: The results presented in this thesis will contribute to the current state of knowledge in colonoscopy practice regarding strategies for improving the efficacy of colonoscopy in the prevention of colorectal cancer. This study will provide valuable insights for future researchers interested in developing effective methods for treating diminutive colorectal polyps. Optical diagnosis requires further training and implementation using computer-based characterization modules. Furthermore, despite the slow adoption of computer-based solutions in clinical practice, AI-empowered colonoscopy will eventually pave the way for automatic detection, characterization, and semi-automated completion of procedure reports in the future