Analysis of the impact of wireless mobile devices in critical industrial applications

The main objective of the thesis is to study the impact of mobile nodes in industrial applications with strict reliability and time constraints in both centralized and decentralized topologies. Considering the harsh wireless channel conditions of industrial environments, that goal implies a considerable challenge. In order not to compromise the performance of the system, a deterministic Real-Time (RT) communication protocol is needed, along with a mechanism to deal with changes in the topology due to the movements of the wireless devices. The existing wireless standard technologies do not satisfy the requirements demanded by the most critical industrial applications such as Distributed Control Systems (DCS) and, thus, wired communication cannot be directly replaced by wireless solutions. Nevertheless, the adoption of wireless communications can be seen as an extension to the existing wired networks to create hybrid networks with mobility requirements. The design of a proper communication solution depends mainly on the choice of the Medium Access Control (MAC) protocol, which is responsible for controlling access to the medium and thereby plays a vital role in decreasing latency and packet errors. Furthermore, the changes in the topology due to the movement of the wireless devices must be managed correctly in order not to affect the performance of the entire network. In this doctoral thesis, a hybrid centralized architecture designed for industrial applications with strict requirements in terms of robustness, determinism and RT is proposed and evaluated. For that, a wireless RT MAC scheme based on the IEEE 802.11 physical layer is proposed along with a Real-Time Ethernet (RTE) MAC scheme. This hybrid system ensures seamless communication between both media. With the aim of including mobile devices in the proposed architecture, a soft-handover algorithm is designed and evaluated. This algorithm guarantees an uninterrupted communication during the handover process without the need for a second radio interface and with a reduced growth in network overhead. Finally, the impact of mobile nodes in a decentralized wireless topology is analysed. For that, the Self-Organizing Time Division Multiple Access (STDMA) protocol is evaluated to analyse its viability as an alternative to carrying out a handover in industrial applications without centralized systems.El objetivo principal de la tesis es estudiar el impacto de los nodos móviles en las aplicaciones inalámbricas industriales con requisitos estrictos de tiempo y robustez tanto para topologías centralizadas como descentralizadas. Este objetivo supone un gran desafío dadas las adversas condiciones del canal inalámbrico en los entornos industriales. Para no comprometer el rendimiento del sistema, es necesario un protocolo de comunicación determinista y con garantías de tiempo real, junto con un mecanismo para hacer frente a los cambios en la topología debido al movimiento de los dispositivos inalámbricos. Las tecnologías estándar inalámbricas existentes no satisfacen los requisitos exigidos por las aplicaciones industriales más críticas, como los Sistemas de Control Distribuido (DCS - Distributed Control Systems) y, por lo tanto, las comunicaciones cableadas no pueden ser reemplazadas directamente por soluciones inalámbricas. Sin embargo, la adopción de las comunicaciones inalámbricas puede verse como una extensión de las redes cableadas existentes con el objetivo de crear redes híbridas con requisitos de movilidad. El diseño de una solución de comunicación adecuada depende principalmente de la elección del protocolo de control de acceso al medio (MAC - Medium Access Control), el cual, desempeña un papel vital en la disminución de la latencia y del número de paquetes erróneos. Además, los cambios en la topología debidos al movimiento de los dispositivos inalámbricos deben gestionarse correctamente para que el rendimiento de toda la red no se vea afectado. En esta tesis doctoral se propone y se evalúa una arquitectura híbrida centralizada diseñada para aplicaciones industriales con requisitos estrictos de robustez, determinismo y tiempo real. Para ello, se propone un esquema MAC inalámbrico con garantías de tiempo real basado en la capa física IEEE 802.11 junto con un esquema MAC basado en Ethernet en tiempo real (RTE - Real-Time Ethernet). Este esquema híbrido garantiza una comunicación continua entre ambos medios de comunicación. Con el objetivo de incluir dispositivos móviles en la arquitectura propuesta, se propone y evalúa un algoritmo de soft-handover. Este algoritmo garantiza una comunicación ininterrumpida durante el proceso de handover sin la necesidad de una segunda interfaz de radio y con un aumento reducido de la sobrecarga de la red. Finalmente, se analiza el impacto de los nodos móviles en una topología inalámbrica descentralizada. Para ello, se evalúa el protocolo del estado del arte Self-Organizing Time Division Multiple Access (STDMA) con el objetivo de analizar su viabilidad como alternativa para realizar un handover en las aplicaciones industriales sin sistemas centralizados.Tesi honen helburu nagusia, nodo mugikorrek fidagarritasun eta denboraren aldetik baldintza ugari eskatzen duten aplikazio industrial zentralizatu eta deszentralizatuetan duten eragina aztertzea da. Eremu industrialetako haririk gabeko kanaletan ematen diren komunikazioetarako baldintza bereziki aurkakoak direla medio, helburu honek erronka handia sortzen du. Sarearen errendimendua arriskuan ez jartzeko, determinista eta denbora errealeko komunikazio protokolo bat beharrezkoa da, haririk gabeko nodoen mugimenduaren ondorioz topologiaren aldaketei aurre egiteko mekanismo batekin batera. Haririk gabeko teknologia estandarrek ez dute aplikazio industrial kritikoenek dituzten baldintzak betetzen eta, beraz, kable bidezko komunikazioak ezin dira haririk gabeko sistemekin ordezkatu. Hala ere, haririk gabeko komunikazioen erabilpena jadanik existitzen diren kable bidezko komunikazioen hedadura bezala kontsidera daiteke, mobilitate baldintzak dituzten sare hibridoak sortuz. Komunikazio sistemaren diseinu egokia Medium Access Control (MAC) protokoloaren hautaketa zuzenean oinarritzen da gehien bat, sarbidea kontrolatzeaz arduratzen baita, honela ezinbesteko papera izanik latentzian eta pakete erroreen murrizketan. Horretaz aparte, bai sare zentralizatu eta deszentralizatuen kasuan, haririk gabeko nodoen mugimenduek sortutako tipologia aldaketak azkar eta zuzen kudeatu behar dira sare osoko errendimenduak kalterik ez jasateko. Doktore tesi honetan, fidagarritasun zorrotz, determinismo eta denbora-errealeko baldintzak dituzten industria aplikazioetarako arkitektura hibrido zentralizatu bat proposatu eta ebaluatu da. Horretarako, IEEE 802.11 maila fisikoan oinarritutako haririk gabeko MAC eskema bat proposatu da, Real-Time Ethernet-en (RTE) oinarritutako MAC eskema batekin batera. Eskema hibrido honek bi komunikabideen artean etengabeko komunikazioa bermatzen du. Proposatutako arkitekturan nodo mugikorrak kontuan hartu ahal izateko, soft-handover algoritmo bat proposatu eta ebaluatu da. Algoritmo honek etenik gabeko komunikazioa bermatzen du handover prozesuan zehar bigarren irrati interfaze baten beharrik gabe eta sareko gainkarga oso gutxi handituz. Azkenik, nodo mugikorrek duten eragina haririk gabeko topologia deszentralizatuetan aztertu da. Horretako, bibliografiako Self-Organizing Time Division Multiple Access (STDMA) protokoloa ebaluatu da industrial aplikazioetako sistema zentralizatuen handover mekanismoaren alternatiba gisa

Reducing Communication Delay Variability for a Group of Robots

A novel architecture is presented for reducing communication delay variability for a group of robots. This architecture relies on using three components: a microprocessor architecture that allows deterministic real-time tasks; an event-based communication protocol in which nodes transmit in a TDMA fashion, without the need of global clock synchronization techniques; and a novel communication scheme that enables deterministic communications by allowing senders to transmit without regard for the state of the medium or coordination with other senders, and receivers can tease apart messages sent simultaneously with a high probability of success. This approach compared to others, allows simultaneous communications without regard for the state of the transmission medium, it allows deterministic communications, and it enables ordered communications that can be a applied in a team of robots. Simulations and experimental results are also included

Evaluating the suitability of IEEE 802.11ah for low-latency time-critical control loops

A number of industrial wireless technologies have emerged over the last decade, promising to replace the need for wires in a variety of use cases. Except for customized time division multiple access (TDMA)-based wireless technologies that can achieve ultralow latency over a very limited area, wireless communication generally has reliability and latency issues when it comes to industrial applications. Closed loop communication requires high reliability (over 99%), limited jitter and latency, which poses a challenge especially over a wide area measuring in hundreds of meters. Extended coverage is promised with the advent of sub-GHz technologies, one of them being IEEE 802.11ah which is the only one that offers sufficient data rate for frequent bidirectional communication. Thus, we evaluated IEEE 802.11ah for low-latency time-critical control loops. We propose the network setup for adjusting the network dynamics to that of control loops, enabling limited jitter and high reliability. We explore the scalability of IEEE 802.11ah network hosting both control loops and monitoring sensors that periodically transmit measurements. Assigning the control loop end-nodes to dedicated restricted access window (RAW) slot results in over 99.99% successful deliveries. Furthermore, interpacket delay is concentrated around the cycle-time in the following or preceding beacon interval in case the beacon interval is at least half the value of the shortest cycle-time. Adjusting the beacon interval to the fastest control loop in the network ensures latency requirements at the cost of maximum achievable throughput and energy consumption

AirTight: A Resilient Wireless Communication Protocol for Mixed-Criticality Systems

This paper describes the motivation, design, analysis and implementation of a new protocol for critical wireless communication called AirTight. Wireless communication has become a crucial part of the infrastructure of many cyber-physical applications. Many of these applications are real-time and also mixed-criticality, in that they have components/subsystems with different consequences of failure. Wireless communication is inevitably subject to levels of external interference. In this paper we represent this interference using a criticality-aware fault model; for each level of interference in the fault model we guarantee the timing behaviour of the protocol (i.e.~we guarantee that packet deadlines are satisfied for certainly levels of criticality). Although a new protocol, AirTight is built upon existing standards such as IEEE 802.15.4. A prototype implementation and protocol-accurate simulator, which are also built upon existing technologies, demonstrate the effectiveness and functionality of the protocol

BATSEN: Modifying the BATMAN Routing Protocol for Wireless Sensor Networks

The proliferation of autonomous Wireless Sensor Networks (WSN) has spawned research seeking power efficient communications to improve the lifetime of sensor motes. WSNs are characterized by their power limitations, wireless transceivers, and the converge-cast communications techniques. WSN motes use low-power, lossy radio systems deployed in dense, random topologies, working sympathetically to sense and notify a sink node of the detectable information. In an effort to extend the life of battery powered motes, and hence the life of the network, various routing protocols have been suggested in an effort to optimize converge-cast delivery of sensor data. It is well known that reducing the overhead required to perform converge-cast routing and communications reduces the effects of the primary power drain in the mote, the transceiver. Furthermore, WSNs are not well protected; network security costs energy both in computation and in RF transmission. This paper investigates the use of a Mobile Ad-hoc Networking (MANET) routing protocol known as B.A.T.M.A.N. in WSN. This thesis proposes that the features of B.A.T.M.A.N. in the MANET realm may prove beneficial to the WSN routing domain; and that slight modifications to the routing technique may prove beneficial beyond current protocol technologies. The B.A.T.M.A.N. variant will be compared against the contemporary LEACH WSN routing protocol to discern any potential energy savings

Real-time communication platfrom for wireless cyber-physical applications

A Cyber-Physical System (CPS) is a physical system whose operations are monitored, coordinated, and controlled by computation and communication processes. Applying wireless technologies to cyber-physical systems can significantly enhance the system mobility and reduce the deployment and maintenance cost. Existing wireless technologies, however either cannot provide real-time or probabilistic guarantee on packet delivery or are not fast enough to support desired application requirements. Nondeterministic packet transmission and insufficiently high sampling rate will severely hurt application performance. To address this problem, we propose a real-time wireless communication platform called RT-WiFi. In this dissertation, we present our design and implementation of the data link layer and network management framework of RT-WiFi platform that provides predictable packet delivery and high sampling rate. The RT-WiFi communication platform is designed to support configurable components for adjusting design trade-offs including sampling rate, latency variance, reliability and thus can serve as a suitable communication platform for supporting a wide range of wireless CPS applications. Based on the RT-WiFi management platform, we further propose advanced network management techniques to provide jitter-free scheduling algorithm for improving system performance and to support reliable data transmission in noisy environments. To evaluate the effectiveness of our proposed algorithms and to verify the efficiency of our network management platform, we conduct a series of experiments and a case study that integrate the RT-WiFi communication platform with a health care CPS application to investigate the application performance in the real world.Computer Science

A Priority-based Fair Queuing (PFQ) Model for Wireless Healthcare System

Healthcare is a very active research area, primarily due to the increase in the elderly population that leads to increasing number of emergency situations that require urgent actions. In recent years some of wireless networked medical devices were equipped with different sensors to measure and report on vital signs of patient remotely. The most important sensors are Heart Beat Rate (ECG), Pressure and Glucose sensors. However, the strict requirements and real-time nature of medical applications dictate the extreme importance and need for appropriate Quality of Service (QoS), fast and accurate delivery of a patient’s measurements in reliable e-Health ecosystem. As the elderly age and older adult population is increasing (65 years and above) due to the advancement in medicine and medical care in the last two decades; high QoS and reliable e-health ecosystem has become a major challenge in Healthcare especially for patients who require continuous monitoring and attention. Nevertheless, predictions have indicated that elderly population will be approximately 2 billion in developing countries by 2050 where availability of medical staff shall be unable to cope with this growth and emergency cases that need immediate intervention. On the other side, limitations in communication networks capacity, congestions and the humongous increase of devices, applications and IOT using the available communication networks add extra layer of challenges on E-health ecosystem such as time constraints, quality of measurements and signals reaching healthcare centres. Hence this research has tackled the delay and jitter parameters in E-health M2M wireless communication and succeeded in reducing them in comparison to current available models. The novelty of this research has succeeded in developing a new Priority Queuing model ‘’Priority Based-Fair Queuing’’ (PFQ) where a new priority level and concept of ‘’Patient’s Health Record’’ (PHR) has been developed and integrated with the Priority Parameters (PP) values of each sensor to add a second level of priority. The results and data analysis performed on the PFQ model under different scenarios simulating real M2M E-health environment have revealed that the PFQ has outperformed the results obtained from simulating the widely used current models such as First in First Out (FIFO) and Weight Fair Queuing (WFQ). PFQ model has improved transmission of ECG sensor data by decreasing delay and jitter in emergency cases by 83.32% and 75.88% respectively in comparison to FIFO and 46.65% and 60.13% with respect to WFQ model. Similarly, in pressure sensor the improvements were 82.41% and 71.5% and 68.43% and 73.36% in comparison to FIFO and WFQ respectively. Data transmission were also improved in the Glucose sensor by 80.85% and 64.7% and 92.1% and 83.17% in comparison to FIFO and WFQ respectively. However, non-emergency cases data transmission using PFQ model was negatively impacted and scored higher rates than FIFO and WFQ since PFQ tends to give higher priority to emergency cases. Thus, a derivative from the PFQ model has been developed to create a new version namely “Priority Based-Fair Queuing-Tolerated Delay” (PFQ-TD) to balance the data transmission between emergency and non-emergency cases where tolerated delay in emergency cases has been considered. PFQ-TD has succeeded in balancing fairly this issue and reducing the total average delay and jitter of emergency and non-emergency cases in all sensors and keep them within the acceptable allowable standards. PFQ-TD has improved the overall average delay and jitter in emergency and non-emergency cases among all sensors by 41% and 84% respectively in comparison to PFQ model