Chapter 4: New Assessment Methods

The OTiS (Online Teaching in Scotland) programme, run by the now defunct Scotcit programme, ran an International e-Workshop on Developing Online Tutoring Skills which was held between 8–12 May 2000. It was organised by Heriot–Watt University, Edinburgh and The Robert Gordon University, Aberdeen, UK. Out of this workshop came the seminal Online Tutoring E-Book, a generic primer on e-learning pedagogy and methodology, full of practical implementation guidelines. Although the Scotcit programme ended some years ago, the E-Book has been copied to the SONET site as a series of PDF files, which are now available via the ALT Open Access Repository. The editor, Carol Higgison, is currently working in e-learning at the University of Bradford (see her staff profile) and is the Chair of the Association for Learning Technology (ALT)

The Tutor's Role

This chapter addresses three questions about being an effective online tutor: 1. Why do we still think that online tutoring can principally draw its basis from face-to-face group processes and dynamics or traditional pedagogy? 2. Does the literature tell us anything more than we would make as an intelligent guess? 3. Do we really know what an ‘effective’ online tutor would be doing? The OTiS participants have gone some way to answering these questions, through the presentation and discussion of their own online tutoring experiences. Literature in this area is still limited, and suffers from the need for timeliness of publication to be useful. Intelligent guesses are all very well, but much better as a source of information for online tutors are the reflections and documented experiences of practitioners. These experiences reveal that face-to-face pedagogy has some elements to offer the online tutor, but that there are key differences and there is a need to examine the processes and dynamics of online learning to inform online tutoring

Collaborative practice in enhancing the first year student experience in higher education

Transition into higher education presents challenges for students, whatever their age or previous educational history. An emerging issue on an undergraduate programme in England was how to support students who self reported educational histories of continual formative feedback, model answers, revision guides and limited use of the library. This article reports findings from an action research project which considered whether there was a mismatch between students’ previous educational histories and the academic expectations of the university. Findings indicated that academic expectations did not fully take account of previous student experiences. Student responses also indicated little previous guidance around effective internet searching and libraries were rarely used prior to starting university. Transitional scaffolding was positively evaluated, students reporting greater confidence levels in accessing appropriate resources, high levels of student completion, retention and satisfactio

Community-oriented Service-Learning: A university experience for preventing cannabis abuse in vulnerable adolescents and young people

Learning integrated into community action promotes a more active citizenry. More specifically, service-learning (S-L) embedded into higher education can represent a big challenge yet also an opportunity to involve the whole university community in social and community development. This paper addresses this teaching method by identifiying and reviewing the different components that define S-L, that is: civic engagement, social responsibility, civic education, partnership, and reflection. The ways in which S-L can be introduced into the curriculum are explained, through detailing experiences already carried out in the teaching of psychology. Current available data on its efficacy in university education are analyzed. The focus now turns to a university experience involving Community Psychology students across Bachelor’s and Master’s degrees. During this experience, students on both programmes make their final-year projects to develop a prevention resource aimed at young people at high risk of problematic cannabis use. Ultimately, this program not only teaches students the principles of Community Psychology but also give them an opportunity to put them into practice

Inquiry-based learning in the arts: a meta-analytical study

This report summarises learning about inquiry-based learning (IBL) in the arts and humanities disciplines at the University of Sheffield during the period in which the Centre for Inquiry-based Learning in the Arts and Social Sciences (CILASS) has been in operation. It draws upon impact evaluation data from curriculum development projects that have been funded by CILASS in departments in the Faculty of Arts and Humanities

MAKING SENSE OF ‘CLASSICAL’ MUSICAL PERFORMANCE AT UNIVERSITY: AN ETHNOGRAPHICALLY-INFORMED CASE STUDY OF A COMMUNITY OF PRACTICE

This thesis investigates how ‘classical’ musical performance (performance of Western art music) is understood in a university context from the perspective of the members of a performance community to which the researcher also belonged. Previous research on musical performance in higher education (HE) has tended to focus on the exploration and/or evaluation of aspects of the educational process of musical performance without necessarily investigating the value systems implicit in these aspects. Using the conceptual lens of ‘communities of practice’, this thesis goes beyond a focus on the educational process and teases out the values and beliefs surrounding musical performance at a UK university. Furthermore, it explores how these values and beliefs are constructed and/or enacted by students and tutors through participation in the practices of a performance community. A rationale is provided for the adoption of a qualitative, single-case study approach within a social constructionist theoretical framework. The data construction methods used in this study – participant-observation, interviews, focus groups and document analysis – are discussed. The researcher’s role as an ‘insider’ to the community investigated in this study is also considered. Thematic Analysis of the data brings into focus three different emic understandings of performance: (1) ‘Classical’ musical performance as display of abilities and/or knowledge; (2) ‘Classical’ musical performance as source of insider’s knowledge; and (3) ‘Classical’ musical performance as a shared musical experience. The analysis indicates that these three understandings are unequally distributed, with ‘performance as display’ being dominant, followed by ‘performance as source of insider’s knowledge’. ‘Performance as a shared musical experience’ is the least common understanding among community members. Understanding the values and beliefs constructed and/or enacted through the community practices identified here sheds new light onto how and what musicians teach and learn at university and how this might be changed for the better

Carers as partners in social work education

This report explores the extent and nature of participation by caregivers in the education of social work students in England. A national survey gave rise to a series of telephone interviews with education providers; regional workshops then brought together for discussion representives of carers' organisations, individual caregivers and educators. The study identified the ways in which caregivers are involved in educating social work students, the challenges experienced, the factors that facilitate positive involvement, and the outcomes experienced by those involved. The report makes a series of recommendations designed to facilitate good practice in caregiver participation in social work education