Turning the Spotlight on Apathy:Identification and Treatment in Schizophrenia Spectrum Disorders

Among negative symptoms, apathy is central to the impairments in real-life functioning in schizophrenia spectrum disorders (SSD). Thus, optimizing treatment for apathy appears key to improve outcomes. In treatment research, however, negative symptoms are typically studied as a unifactorial construct. We, therefore, aim to shed necessary light on the status of apathy identification and treatment in SSD.</p

A transdiagnostic approach to negative symptoms: exploring factor structure and negative symptoms in bipolar disorders

BackgroundNegative symptoms are increasingly recognized as transdiagnostic phenomena, linked to reduced quality of life and functioning, and often caused or worsened by amendable external factors such as depression, social deprivation, side-effects of antipsychotics or substance use. The structure of negative symptoms fits into two dimensions: diminished expression and apathy. These may differ in association with external factors that influence their severity and may thus require different treatment approaches. The dimensions are comprehensively established in non-affective psychotic disorders but are understudied in bipolar disorders.MethodsWe conducted exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses in a sample of 584 individuals with bipolar disorder to assess the latent factor structure of negative symptoms as measured by the Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS), and performed correlational analyses and multiple hierarchical regression analyses to investigate links between the two dimensions of negative symptoms and clinical and sociodemographic correlates.ResultsThe latent factor structure of negative symptoms fits into two dimensions, i.e., diminished expression and apathy. A diagnosis of bipolar type I or a history of psychotic episodes predicted more severe levels of diminished expression. Depressive symptoms were associated with more severe negative symptoms across dimensions, yet 26.3% of euthymic individuals still displayed at least one mild or more severe negative symptom (PANSS score ≥ 3).DiscussionThe two-dimensional structure of negative symptoms seen in non-affective psychotic disorders reproduces in bipolar disorders indicating similarities in their phenomenology. Diminished expression was associated with a history of psychotic episodes and a diagnosis of BD-I, which may infer closer connections to psychosis liability. We found significantly less severe negative symptoms in euthymic than depressed participants. Nevertheless, more than a quarter of the euthymic individuals had at least one mild negative symptom, demonstrating some degree of persistence beyond depressed states

A good life with psychosis: rate of positive outcomes in first-episode psychosis at 10-year follow-up

BackgroundMore knowledge about positive outcomes for people with first-episode psychosis (FEP) is needed. An FEP 10-year follow-up study investigated the rate of personal recovery, emotional wellbeing, and clinical recovery in the total sample and between psychotic bipolar spectrum disorders (BD) and schizophrenia spectrum disorders (SZ); and how these positive outcomes overlap.MethodsFEP participants (n = 128) were re-assessed with structured clinical interviews at 10-year follow-up. Personal recovery was self-rated with the Questionnaire about the Process of Recovery-15-item scale (total score ⩾45). Emotional wellbeing was self-rated with the Life Satisfaction Scale (score ⩾5) and the Temporal Experience of Pleasure Scale (total score ⩾72). Clinical recovery was clinician-rated symptom-remission and adequate functioning (duration minimum 1 year).ResultsIn FEP, rates of personal recovery (50.8%), life satisfaction (60.9%), and pleasure (57.5%) were higher than clinical recovery (33.6%). Despite lower rates of clinical recovery in SZ compared to BD, they had equal rates of personal recovery and emotional wellbeing. Personal recovery overlapped more with emotional wellbeing than with clinical recovery (χ2). Each participant was assigned to one of eight possible outcome groups depending on the combination of positive outcomes fulfilled. The eight groups collapsed into three equal-sized main outcome groups: 33.6% clinical recovery with personal recovery and/or emotional wellbeing; 34.4% personal recovery and/or emotional wellbeing only; and 32.0% none.ConclusionsIn FEP, 68% had minimum one positive outcome after 10 years, suggesting a good life with psychosis. This knowledge must be shared to instill hope and underlines that subjective and objective positive outcomes must be assessed and targeted in treatment

A 10-year perspective on apathy development in psychotic disorders: Genetic risk and early predictors, associations with depression, and functional outcome

The thesis aims were to explore 1) genetic underpinnings of apathy in schizophrenia spectrum disorders (SZ) and healthy controls (HC), 2) prevalence of persistent apathy (PA), persistent depression (PD) and associations with functioning in a 1-year follow-up study of first-episode psychosis (FEP), 3) predictors and development of apathy, and associations with functioning in a 10-year follow-up study of FEP and HC. In HC, apathy was stable and low during the 10-year follow-up. In FEP, apathy decreased the first year and then remained stable. The duration of untreated psychosis (DUP), baseline apathy and depression scores were positively associated with apathy development. The effects of DUP and baseline apathy were enduring, but the effect of depression abated. Almost 40% had PA and/or PD the first year. A significant overlap of PA and PD was found in 11%. Having PA, PD or both was associated with severely impaired functioning, compared to having no persistent symptoms. Apathy showed negative cross-sectional associations with functioning during the 10-year follow-up. In SZ and HC, apathy showed non-significant associations with a schizophrenia polygenic risk score (SZ PRS). SZ PRS did not contribute to the explained variance in apathy in SZ. The consistent, negative associations with functioning affirm the enduring impact of apathy in FEP. The first year may be a critical period. Here, apathy is less cemented and maybe more responsive to treatment. Predictors of an unfavorable apathy course present early and may help clinicians identify a vulnerable subgroup in FEP. After one year, individuals with PA, PD, or both, have severe functional impairments. Thus, one should explore depressive symptoms in those with apathy and vice versa, use rating scales that reliably discriminate these similar phenotypes, and treat depression if present. Apathy may not be linked to the common genetic architecture of SZ. Research into environmental factors underlying apathy is warranted

Exploring the relationship between recency and frequency of cannabis use and diminished expression and apathy as two dimensions of negative symptoms in first episode psychosis. A one-year follow-up study

The association between cannabis use and negative symptoms remains unclear because of inconsistent results in existing studies. In this study we aimed to investigate the association between different aspects of cannabis use and 1) diminished expression and 2) apathy as a two-dimensional model of negative symptoms in a sample of 460 participants with first-episode psychosis. Data were collected on relevant clinical and demographic factors including diagnostics and habits of drug use at baseline, with a follow-up assessment after 12-months. We found an association between the frequency of cannabis use two years prior to baseline and the severity of diminished expression and apathy at baseline, while only the association to diminished expression held after controlling for potential clinical and demographic confounders. Frequency of cannabis use at baseline also had a significant effect on the development of diminished expression over the 12-month follow-up period. In conclusion, this study suggests that the frequency of cannabis use contributes to the severity of diminished expression at baseline, and to the progression of diminished expression after 12-months follow-up. Our findings also imply a dose-response relationship between frequency of use and severity of symptoms and add evidence to an association between cannabis use and negative symptoms

Associations between schizophrenia polygenic risk and apathy in schizophrenia spectrum disorders and healthy controls

Objective Apathy is a central predictor of a poor functional outcome in schizophrenia. Schizophrenia polygenic risk scores (PRSs) are used to detect genetic associations to key clinical phenotypes in schizophrenia. We explored the associations between schizophrenia PRS and apathy levels in schizophrenia spectrum disorders (n = 281) and matched healthy controls (n = 298), and further how schizophrenia PRS contributed in predicting apathy when added to premorbid and clinical factors in the patient sample. Method Schizophrenia PRSs were computed for each participant. Apathy was assessed with the Apathy Evaluation Scale. Bivariate correlation analyses were used to investigate associations between schizophrenia PRS and apathy, and between apathy and premorbid and clinical factors. Multiple hierarchical regression analyses were employed to evaluate the contributions of clinical variables and schizophrenia PRS to apathy levels. Results We found no significant associations between schizophrenia PRS and apathy in patients and healthy controls. Several premorbid and clinical characteristics significantly predicted apathy in patients, but schizophrenia PRS did not. Conclusion Since the PRSs are based on common genetic variants, our results do not preclude associations to other types of genetic factors. The results could also indicate that environmentally based biological or psychological factors contribute to apathy levels in schizophrenia

Divergent relationship between brain structure and cognitive functioning in patients with prominent negative symptomatology

Investigating commonalities in underlying pathology of cognitive dysfunction and negative symptoms in schizophrenia is important, as both are core features of the disorder and linked to brain structure abnormalities. We aimed to explore the relationship between cognition, negative symptoms and brain structure in schizophrenia. A total of 225 patients with Schizophrenia spectrum disorder and 283 healthy controls from the Norwegian Thematically Organized Psychosis (TOP) cohort were included in this study. Patients were categorized into four patient subgroups based on severity of negative symptoms: no-negative- (NNS), threshold-negative- (TNS), moderate-negative- (MNS), and prominent-negative (PNS) subgroups. MRI measures of brain volume, mean cortical thickness and surface area from pre-selected brain regions were tested for relationships with general cognitive ability and negative symptom subgroups. Positive associations were found between brain volume, thickness, surface area and cognition in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC), orbitofrontal cortex (OFC), fusiform gyrus (FG) and the left anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), but with no differences between subgroups. In the PNS subgroup, cognition was conversely negatively associated with brain volume in the left ACC. These results indicate that patients with prominent negative symptoms have different associations between cognition and brain structure in the left ACC, which may point to abnormal neurodevelopment

Turning the spotlight on apathy: identification and treatment in schizophrenia spectrum disorders

Among negative symptoms, apathy is central to the impairments in real-life functioning in schizophrenia spectrum disorders (SSD). Thus, optimizing treatment for apathy appears key to improve outcomes. In treatment research, however, negative symptoms are typically studied as a unifactorial construct. We, therefore, aim to shed necessary light on the status of apathy identification and treatment in SSD. </p

Turning the spotlight on apathy: identification and treatment in schizophrenia spectrum disorders

Among negative symptoms, apathy is central to the impairments in real-life functioning in schizophrenia spectrum disorders (SSD). Thus, optimizing treatment for apathy appears key to improve outcomes. In treatment research, however, negative symptoms are typically studied as a unifactorial construct. We, therefore, aim to shed necessary light on the status of apathy identification and treatment in SSD. </p