Individualisation of transcranial electric stimulation to improve motor function after stroke:Current challenges and future perspective

Transcranial electric stimulation (tES) is a non-invasive brain stimulation technique that could potentially improve motor rehabilitation after stroke. However, the effects of tES are in general stronger in healthy individuals compared to people with stroke. Interindividual variability in brain structure and function due to stroke potentially explain this difference in effects. This thesis describes the development of methods to facilitate the individualisation of tES in people with stroke and identifies objective neurophysiological correlates of motor learning that could potentially help to monitor the response to tES.In chapter 2, EEG correlates of explicit motor task learning were derived in healthy, young participants. Chapter 3 investigated the effects of 3 different tDCS configurations (sham, targeting contralateral M1 and targeting the full resting motor network) on corticospinal excitability. Both conventional and motor network tDCS did not increase corticospinal excitability relative to sham stimulation. Chapter 4 describes methods to create head models of people with stroke and assesses the effects of stroke lesions on the electric fields within stimulation targets. Chapter 5 describes a method to experimentally determine the electric conductivity of the stroke lesion. Finally, Chapter 6 analyses the electric fields generated by conventional tDCS in people with stroke and age-matched controls. It is shown that the one-size-fits-all approach results in more variable electric fields in people with stroke compared to controls. Optimisation of the electrode positions to maximise the electric field in stimulation targets increases the electric fields in people with stroke to the same level as found in healthy controls.This thesis shows anatomical and motor function variability exists between people with stroke due to differences in lesion characteristics. While there are several opportunities to individualise tES, more research is needed to investigate if this improves the effects of tES. As such, clinical implementation of tES seems unrealistic in the foreseeable future.<br/

Individualisation of transcranial electric stimulation to improve motor function after stroke:Current challenges and future perspective

Transcranial electric stimulation (tES) is a non-invasive brain stimulation technique that could potentially improve motor rehabilitation after stroke. However, the effects of tES are in general stronger in healthy individuals compared to people with stroke. Interindividual variability in brain structure and function due to stroke potentially explain this difference in effects. This thesis describes the development of methods to facilitate the individualisation of tES in people with stroke and identifies objective neurophysiological correlates of motor learning that could potentially help to monitor the response to tES.In chapter 2, EEG correlates of explicit motor task learning were derived in healthy, young participants. Chapter 3 investigated the effects of 3 different tDCS configurations (sham, targeting contralateral M1 and targeting the full resting motor network) on corticospinal excitability. Both conventional and motor network tDCS did not increase corticospinal excitability relative to sham stimulation. Chapter 4 describes methods to create head models of people with stroke and assesses the effects of stroke lesions on the electric fields within stimulation targets. Chapter 5 describes a method to experimentally determine the electric conductivity of the stroke lesion. Finally, Chapter 6 analyses the electric fields generated by conventional tDCS in people with stroke and age-matched controls. It is shown that the one-size-fits-all approach results in more variable electric fields in people with stroke compared to controls. Optimisation of the electrode positions to maximise the electric field in stimulation targets increases the electric fields in people with stroke to the same level as found in healthy controls.This thesis shows anatomical and motor function variability exists between people with stroke due to differences in lesion characteristics. While there are several opportunities to individualise tES, more research is needed to investigate if this improves the effects of tES. As such, clinical implementation of tES seems unrealistic in the foreseeable future.<br/

Individual differences in error-related frontal midline theta activity during visuomotor adaptation

Post-feedback frontal midline EEG activity has been found to correlate with error magnitude during motor adaptation. However, the role of this neuronal activity remains to be elucidated. It has been hypothesized that post-feedback frontal midline activity may represent a prediction error, which in turn may be directly related to the adaptation process or to an unspecific orienting response. To address these hypotheses, we replicated a previous visuomotor adaptation experiment with very small perturbations, likely to invoke implicit adaptation, in a new group of 60 participants and combined it with EEG recordings. We found error-related peaks in the frontal midline electrodes in the time domain. However, these were best understood as modulations of frontal midline theta activity (FMT, 4–8 Hz). Trial-level differences in FMT correlated with error magnitude. This correlation was robust even for very small errors as well as in the absence of imposed perturbations, indicating that FMT does not depend on explicit or strategic re-aiming. Within participants, trial-level differences in FMT were not related to between-trial error corrections. Between participants, individual differences in FMT-error-sensitivity did not predict differences in adaptation rate. Taken together, these results imply that FMT does not drive implicit motor adaptation. Finally, individual differences in FMT-error-sensitivity negatively correlate to motor execution noise. This suggests that FMT reflects saliency: larger execution noise means a larger standard deviation of errors so that a fixed error magnitude is less salient. In conclusion, this study suggests that frontal midline theta activity represents a saliency signal and does not directly drive motor adaptation

Cortical dynamics during preparation and execution of reactive balance responses with distinct postural demands

The contributions of the cerebral cortex to human balance control are clearly demonstrated by the profound impact of cortical lesions on the ability to maintain standing balance. The cerebral cortex is thought to regulate subcortical postural centers to maintain upright balance and posture under varying environmental conditions and task demands. However, the cortical mechanisms that support standing balance remain elusive. Here, we present an EEG-based analysis of cortical oscillatory dynamics during the preparation and execution of balance responses with distinct postural demands. In our experiment, participants responded to backward movements of the support surface either with one forward step or by keeping their feet in place. To challenge the postural control system, we applied participant-specific high accelerations of the support surface such that the postural demand was low for stepping responses and high for feet-in-place responses. We expected that postural demand modulated the power of intrinsic cortical oscillations. Independent component analysis and time-frequency domain statistics revealed stronger suppression of alpha (9–13 Hz) and low-gamma (31–34 Hz) rhythms in the supplementary motor area (SMA) when preparing for feet-in-place responses (i.e., high postural demand). Irrespective of the response condition, support-surface movements elicited broadband (3–17 Hz) power increase in the SMA and enhancement of the theta (3–7 Hz) rhythm in the anterior prefrontal cortex (PFC), anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), and bilateral sensorimotor cortices (M1/S1). Although the execution of reactive responses resulted in largely similar cortical dynamics, comparison between the bilateral M1/S1 showed that stepping responses corresponded with stronger suppression of the beta (13–17 Hz) rhythm in the M1/S1 contralateral to the support leg. Comparison between response conditions showed that feet-in-place responses corresponded with stronger enhancement of the theta (3–7 Hz) rhythm in the PFC. Our results provide novel insights into the cortical dynamics of SMA, PFC, and M1/S1 during the control of human balance.Biomechatronics & Human-Machine Contro

Addressing the inconsistent electric fields of tDCS by using patient-tailored configurations in chronic stroke: Implications for treatment

Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) is a promising tool to improve and speed up motor rehabilitation after stroke, but inconsistent clinical effects refrain tDCS from clinical implementation. Therefore, this study aimed to assess the need for individualized tDCS configurations in stroke, considering interindividual variability in brain anatomy and motor function representation. We simulated tDCS in individualized MRI-based finite element head models of 21 chronic stroke subjects and 10 healthy age-matched controls. An anatomy-based stimulation target, i.e. the motor hand knob, was identified with MRI, whereas a motor function-based stimulation target was identified with EEG. For each subject, we simulated conventional anodal tDCS electrode configurations and optimized electrode configurations to maximize stimulation strength within the anatomical and functional target. The normal component of the electric field was extracted and compared between subjects with stroke and healthy, age-matched controls, for both targets, during conventional and optimized tDCS. Electrical field strength was significantly lower, more variable and more frequently in opposite polarity for subjects with stroke compared to healthy age-matched subjects, both for the anatomical and functional target with conventional, i.e. non-individualized, electrode configurations. Optimized, i.e. individualized, electrode configurations increased the electrical field strength in the anatomical and functional target for subjects with stroke but did not reach the same levels as in healthy subjects. Considering individual brain structure and motor function is crucial for applying tDCS in subjects with stroke. Lack of individualized tDCS configurations in subjects with stroke results in lower electric fields in stimulation targets, which may partially explain the inconsistent clinical effects of tDCS in stroke trials

Theta but not beta power is positively associated with better explicit motor task learning

Neurophysiologic correlates of motor learning that can be monitored during neurorehabilitation interventions can facilitate the develop

Theta but not beta power is positively associated with better explicit motor task learning

Neurophysiologic correlates of motor learning that can be monitored during neurorehabilitation interventions can facilitate the development of more effective learning methods. Previous studies have focused on the role of the beta band (14–30 Hz) because of its clear response during motor activity. However, it is difficult to discriminate between beta activity related to learning a movement and performing the movement. In this study, we analysed differences in the electroencephalography (EEG) power spectra of complex and simple explicit sequential motor tasks in healthy young subjects. The complex motor task (CMT) allowed EEG measurement related to motor learning. In contrast, the simple motor task (SMT) made it possible to control for EEG activity associated with performing the movement without significant motor learning. Source reconstruction of the EEG revealed task-related activity from 5 clusters covering both primary motor cortices (M1) and 3 clusters localised to different parts of the cingulate cortex (CC). We found no association between M1 beta power and learning, but the CMT produced stronger bilateral beta suppression compared to the SMT. However, there was a positive association between contralateral M1 theta (5–8 Hz) and alpha (8–12 Hz) power and motor learning, and theta and alpha power in the posterior mid-CC and posterior CC were positively associated with greater motor learning. These findings suggest that the theta and alpha bands are more related to motor learning than the beta band, which might merely relate to the level of perceived difficulty during learning

Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation Targeting the Entire Motor Network Does Not Increase Corticospinal Excitability

Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) over the contralateral primary motor cortex of the target muscle (conventional tDCS) has been described to enhance corticospinal excitability, as measured with transcranial magnetic stimulation. Recently, tDCS targeting the brain regions functionally connected to the contralateral primary motor cortex (motor network tDCS) was reported to enhance corticospinal excitability more than conventional tDCS. We compared the effects of motor network tDCS, 2 mA conventional tDCS, and sham tDCS on corticospinal excitability in 21 healthy participants in a randomized, single-blind within-subject study design. We applied tDCS for 12 min and measured corticospinal excitability with TMS before tDCS and at 0, 15, 30, 45, and 60 min after tDCS. Statistical analysis showed that neither motor network tDCS nor conventional tDCS significantly increased corticospinal excitability relative to sham stimulation. Furthermore, the results did not provide evidence for superiority of motor network tDCS over conventional tDCS. Motor network tDCS seems equally susceptible to the sources of intersubject and intrasubject variability previously observed in response to conventional tDCS