Synthetic and Evolutionary Construction of a Chlorate-Reducing Shewanella oneidensis MR-1.

UnlabelledDespite evidence for the prevalence of horizontal gene transfer of respiratory genes, little is known about how pathways functionally integrate within new hosts. One example of a mobile respiratory metabolism is bacterial chlorate reduction, which is frequently encoded on composite transposons. This implies that the essential components of the metabolism are encoded on these mobile elements. To test this, we heterologously expressed genes for chlorate reduction from Shewanella algae ACDC in the non-chlorate-reducing Shewanella oneidensis MR-1. The construct that ultimately endowed robust growth on chlorate included cld, a cytochrome c gene, clrABDC, and two genes of unknown function. Although strain MR-1 was unable to grow on chlorate after initial insertion of these genes into the chromosome, 11 derived strains capable of chlorate respiration were obtained through adaptive evolution. Genome resequencing indicated that all of the evolved chlorate-reducing strains replicated a large genomic region containing chlorate reduction genes. Contraction in copy number and loss of the ability to reduce chlorate were also observed, indicating that this phenomenon was extremely dynamic. Although most strains contained more than six copies of the replicated region, a single strain with less duplication also grew rapidly. This strain contained three additional mutations that we hypothesized compensated for the low copy number. We remade the mutations combinatorially in the unevolved strain and determined that a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) upstream of cld enabled growth on chlorate and was epistatic to a second base pair change in the NarP binding sequence between narQP and nrfA that enhanced growth.ImportanceThe ability of chlorate reduction composite transposons to form functional metabolisms after transfer to a new host is an important part of their propagation. To study this phenomenon, we engineered Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 into a chlorate reducer. We defined a set of genes sufficient to endow growth on chlorate from a plasmid, but found that chromosomal insertion of these genes was nonfunctional. Evolution of this inoperative strain into a chlorate reducer showed that tandem duplication was a dominant mechanism of activation. While copy number changes are a relatively rapid way of increasing gene dosage, replicating almost 1 megabase of extra DNA is costly. Mutations that alleviate the need for high copy number are expected to arise and eventually predominate, and we identified a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) that relieved the copy number requirement. This study uses both rational and evolutionary approaches to gain insight into the evolution of a fascinating respiratory metabolism

Synthetic and Evolutionary Construction of a Chlorate-Reducing Shewanella oneidensis MR-1

Despite evidence for the prevalence of horizontal gene transfer of respiratory genes, little is known about how pathways functionally integrate within new hosts. One example of a mobile respiratory metabolism is bacterial chlorate reduction, which is frequently encoded on composite transposons. This implies that the essential components of the metabolism are encoded on these mobile elements. To test this, we heterologously expressed genes for chlorate reduction from Shewanella algae ACDC in the non-chlorate-reducing Shewanella oneidensis MR-1. The construct that ultimately endowed robust growth on chlorate included cld, a cytochrome c gene, clrABDC, and two genes of unknown function. Although strain MR-1 was unable to grow on chlorate after initial insertion of these genes into the chromosome, 11 derived strains capable of chlorate respiration were obtained through adaptive evolution. Genome resequencing indicated that all of the evolved chlorate-reducing strains replicated a large genomic region containing chlorate reduction genes. Contraction in copy number and loss of the ability to reduce chlorate were also observed, indicating that this phenomenon was extremely dynamic. Although most strains contained more than six copies of the replicated region, a single strain with less duplication also grew rapidly. This strain contained three additional mutations that we hypothesized compensated for the low copy number. We remade the mutations combinatorially in the unevolved strain and determined that a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) upstream of cld enabled growth on chlorate and was epistatic to a second base pair change in the NarP binding sequence between narQP and nrfA that enhanced growth

Functional Redundancy in Perchlorate and Nitrate Electron Transport Chains and Rewiring Respiratory Pathways to Alter Terminal Electron Acceptor Preference

Most dissimilatory perchlorate reducing bacteria (DPRB) are also capable of respiratory nitrate reduction, and preferentially utilize nitrate over perchlorate as a terminal electron acceptor. The similar domain architectures and phylogenetic relatedness of the nitrate and perchlorate respiratory complexes suggests a common evolutionary history and a potential for functionally redundant electron carriers. In this study, we identify key genetic redundancies in the electron transfer pathways from the quinone pool(s) to the terminal nitrate and perchlorate reductases in Azospira suillum PS (hereafter referred to as PS). We show that the putative quinol dehydrogenases, (PcrQ and NapC) and the soluble cytochrome electron carriers (PcrO and NapO) are functionally redundant under anaerobic growth conditions. We demonstrate that, when grown diauxically with both nitrate and perchlorate, the endogenous expression of NapC and NapO during the nitrate reduction phase was sufficient to completely erase any growth defect in the perchlorate reduction phase caused by deletion of pcrQ and/or pcrO. We leveraged our understanding of these genetic redundancies to make PS mutants with altered electron acceptor preferences. Deletion of the periplasmic nitrate reductase catalytic subunit, napA, led to preferential utilization of perchlorate even in the presence of equimolar nitrate, and deletion of the electron carrier proteins napQ and napO, resulted in concurrent reduction of nitrate and perchlorate. Our results demonstrate that nitrate and perchlorate respiratory pathways in PS share key functionally redundant electron transfer proteins and that mutagenesis of these proteins can be utilized as a strategy to alter the preferential usage of nitrate over perchlorate

Mechanism of H2S Oxidation by the Dissimilatory Perchlorate-Reducing Microorganism Azospira suillum PS.

The genetic and biochemical basis of perchlorate-dependent H2S oxidation (PSOX) was investigated in the dissimilatory perchlorate-reducing microorganism (DPRM) Azospira suillum PS (PS). Previously, it was shown that all known DPRMs innately oxidize H2S, producing elemental sulfur (So). Although the process involving PSOX is thermodynamically favorable (ΔG°' = -206 kJ ⋅ mol-1 H2S), the underlying biochemical and genetic mechanisms are currently unknown. Interestingly, H2S is preferentially utilized over physiological electron donors such as lactate or acetate although no growth benefit is obtained from the metabolism. Here, we determined that PSOX is due to a combination of enzymatic and abiotic interactions involving reactive intermediates of perchlorate respiration. Using various approaches, including barcode analysis by sequencing (Bar-seq), transcriptome sequencing (RNA-seq), and proteomics, along with targeted mutagenesis and biochemical characterization, we identified all facets of PSOX in PS. In support of our proposed model, deletion of identified upregulated PS genes traditionally known to be involved in sulfur redox cycling (e.g., Sox, sulfide:quinone reductase [SQR]) showed no defect in PSOX activity. Proteomic analysis revealed differential abundances of a variety of stress response metal efflux pumps and divalent heavy-metal transporter proteins, suggesting a general toxicity response. Furthermore, in vitro biochemical studies demonstrated direct PSOX mediated by purified perchlorate reductase (PcrAB) in the absence of other electron transfer proteins. The results of these studies support a model in which H2S oxidation is mediated by electron transport chain short-circuiting in the periplasmic space where the PcrAB directly oxidizes H2S to So The biogenically formed reactive intermediates (ClO2- and O2) subsequently react with additional H2S, producing polysulfide and So as end products.IMPORTANCE Inorganic sulfur compounds are widespread in nature, and microorganisms are central to their transformation, thereby playing a key role in the global sulfur cycle. Sulfur oxidation is mediated by a broad phylogenetic diversity of microorganisms, including anoxygenic phototrophs and either aerobic or anaerobic chemotrophs coupled to oxygen or nitrate respiration, respectively. Recently, perchlorate-respiring microorganisms were demonstrated to be innately capable of sulfur oxidation regardless of their phylogenetic affiliation. As recognition of the prevalence of these organisms intensifies, their role in global geochemical cycles is being queried. This is further highlighted by the recently recognized environmental pervasiveness of perchlorate not only across Earth but also throughout our solar system. The inferred importance of this metabolism not only is that it is a novel and previously unrecognized component of the global sulfur redox cycle but also is because of the recently demonstrated applicability of perchlorate respiration in the control of biogenic sulfide production in engineered environments such as oil reservoirs and wastewater treatment facilities, where excess H2S represents a significant environmental, process, and health risk, with associated costs approximating $90 billion annually

Table5.XLSX

<p>Most dissimilatory perchlorate reducing bacteria (DPRB) are also capable of respiratory nitrate reduction, and preferentially utilize nitrate over perchlorate as a terminal electron acceptor. The similar domain architectures and phylogenetic relatedness of the nitrate and perchlorate respiratory complexes suggests a common evolutionary history and a potential for functionally redundant electron carriers. In this study, we identify key genetic redundancies in the electron transfer pathways from the quinone pool(s) to the terminal nitrate and perchlorate reductases in Azospira suillum PS (hereafter referred to as PS). We show that the putative quinol dehydrogenases, (PcrQ and NapC) and the soluble cytochrome electron carriers (PcrO and NapO) are functionally redundant under anaerobic growth conditions. We demonstrate that, when grown diauxically with both nitrate and perchlorate, the endogenous expression of NapC and NapO during the nitrate reduction phase was sufficient to completely erase any growth defect in the perchlorate reduction phase caused by deletion of pcrQ and/or pcrO. We leveraged our understanding of these genetic redundancies to make PS mutants with altered electron acceptor preferences. Deletion of the periplasmic nitrate reductase catalytic subunit, napA, led to preferential utilization of perchlorate even in the presence of equimolar nitrate, and deletion of the electron carrier proteins napQ and napO, resulted in concurrent reduction of nitrate and perchlorate. Our results demonstrate that nitrate and perchlorate respiratory pathways in PS share key functionally redundant electron transfer proteins and that mutagenesis of these proteins can be utilized as a strategy to alter the preferential usage of nitrate over perchlorate.</p

Image1.PDF

<p>Most dissimilatory perchlorate reducing bacteria (DPRB) are also capable of respiratory nitrate reduction, and preferentially utilize nitrate over perchlorate as a terminal electron acceptor. The similar domain architectures and phylogenetic relatedness of the nitrate and perchlorate respiratory complexes suggests a common evolutionary history and a potential for functionally redundant electron carriers. In this study, we identify key genetic redundancies in the electron transfer pathways from the quinone pool(s) to the terminal nitrate and perchlorate reductases in Azospira suillum PS (hereafter referred to as PS). We show that the putative quinol dehydrogenases, (PcrQ and NapC) and the soluble cytochrome electron carriers (PcrO and NapO) are functionally redundant under anaerobic growth conditions. We demonstrate that, when grown diauxically with both nitrate and perchlorate, the endogenous expression of NapC and NapO during the nitrate reduction phase was sufficient to completely erase any growth defect in the perchlorate reduction phase caused by deletion of pcrQ and/or pcrO. We leveraged our understanding of these genetic redundancies to make PS mutants with altered electron acceptor preferences. Deletion of the periplasmic nitrate reductase catalytic subunit, napA, led to preferential utilization of perchlorate even in the presence of equimolar nitrate, and deletion of the electron carrier proteins napQ and napO, resulted in concurrent reduction of nitrate and perchlorate. Our results demonstrate that nitrate and perchlorate respiratory pathways in PS share key functionally redundant electron transfer proteins and that mutagenesis of these proteins can be utilized as a strategy to alter the preferential usage of nitrate over perchlorate.</p

Mechanism of H2S Oxidation by the Dissimilatory Perchlorate-Reducing Microorganism Azospira suillum PS.

The genetic and biochemical basis of perchlorate-dependent H2S oxidation (PSOX) was investigated in the dissimilatory perchlorate-reducing microorganism (DPRM) Azospira suillum PS (PS). Previously, it was shown that all known DPRMs innately oxidize H2S, producing elemental sulfur (So). Although the process involving PSOX is thermodynamically favorable (ΔG°' = -206 kJ ⋅ mol-1 H2S), the underlying biochemical and genetic mechanisms are currently unknown. Interestingly, H2S is preferentially utilized over physiological electron donors such as lactate or acetate although no growth benefit is obtained from the metabolism. Here, we determined that PSOX is due to a combination of enzymatic and abiotic interactions involving reactive intermediates of perchlorate respiration. Using various approaches, including barcode analysis by sequencing (Bar-seq), transcriptome sequencing (RNA-seq), and proteomics, along with targeted mutagenesis and biochemical characterization, we identified all facets of PSOX in PS. In support of our proposed model, deletion of identified upregulated PS genes traditionally known to be involved in sulfur redox cycling (e.g., Sox, sulfide:quinone reductase [SQR]) showed no defect in PSOX activity. Proteomic analysis revealed differential abundances of a variety of stress response metal efflux pumps and divalent heavy-metal transporter proteins, suggesting a general toxicity response. Furthermore, in vitro biochemical studies demonstrated direct PSOX mediated by purified perchlorate reductase (PcrAB) in the absence of other electron transfer proteins. The results of these studies support a model in which H2S oxidation is mediated by electron transport chain short-circuiting in the periplasmic space where the PcrAB directly oxidizes H2S to So The biogenically formed reactive intermediates (ClO2- and O2) subsequently react with additional H2S, producing polysulfide and So as end products.IMPORTANCE Inorganic sulfur compounds are widespread in nature, and microorganisms are central to their transformation, thereby playing a key role in the global sulfur cycle. Sulfur oxidation is mediated by a broad phylogenetic diversity of microorganisms, including anoxygenic phototrophs and either aerobic or anaerobic chemotrophs coupled to oxygen or nitrate respiration, respectively. Recently, perchlorate-respiring microorganisms were demonstrated to be innately capable of sulfur oxidation regardless of their phylogenetic affiliation. As recognition of the prevalence of these organisms intensifies, their role in global geochemical cycles is being queried. This is further highlighted by the recently recognized environmental pervasiveness of perchlorate not only across Earth but also throughout our solar system. The inferred importance of this metabolism not only is that it is a novel and previously unrecognized component of the global sulfur redox cycle but also is because of the recently demonstrated applicability of perchlorate respiration in the control of biogenic sulfide production in engineered environments such as oil reservoirs and wastewater treatment facilities, where excess H2S represents a significant environmental, process, and health risk, with associated costs approximating $90 billion annually

Table1.XLSX

<p>Most dissimilatory perchlorate reducing bacteria (DPRB) are also capable of respiratory nitrate reduction, and preferentially utilize nitrate over perchlorate as a terminal electron acceptor. The similar domain architectures and phylogenetic relatedness of the nitrate and perchlorate respiratory complexes suggests a common evolutionary history and a potential for functionally redundant electron carriers. In this study, we identify key genetic redundancies in the electron transfer pathways from the quinone pool(s) to the terminal nitrate and perchlorate reductases in Azospira suillum PS (hereafter referred to as PS). We show that the putative quinol dehydrogenases, (PcrQ and NapC) and the soluble cytochrome electron carriers (PcrO and NapO) are functionally redundant under anaerobic growth conditions. We demonstrate that, when grown diauxically with both nitrate and perchlorate, the endogenous expression of NapC and NapO during the nitrate reduction phase was sufficient to completely erase any growth defect in the perchlorate reduction phase caused by deletion of pcrQ and/or pcrO. We leveraged our understanding of these genetic redundancies to make PS mutants with altered electron acceptor preferences. Deletion of the periplasmic nitrate reductase catalytic subunit, napA, led to preferential utilization of perchlorate even in the presence of equimolar nitrate, and deletion of the electron carrier proteins napQ and napO, resulted in concurrent reduction of nitrate and perchlorate. Our results demonstrate that nitrate and perchlorate respiratory pathways in PS share key functionally redundant electron transfer proteins and that mutagenesis of these proteins can be utilized as a strategy to alter the preferential usage of nitrate over perchlorate.</p

Table4.XLSX

<p>Most dissimilatory perchlorate reducing bacteria (DPRB) are also capable of respiratory nitrate reduction, and preferentially utilize nitrate over perchlorate as a terminal electron acceptor. The similar domain architectures and phylogenetic relatedness of the nitrate and perchlorate respiratory complexes suggests a common evolutionary history and a potential for functionally redundant electron carriers. In this study, we identify key genetic redundancies in the electron transfer pathways from the quinone pool(s) to the terminal nitrate and perchlorate reductases in Azospira suillum PS (hereafter referred to as PS). We show that the putative quinol dehydrogenases, (PcrQ and NapC) and the soluble cytochrome electron carriers (PcrO and NapO) are functionally redundant under anaerobic growth conditions. We demonstrate that, when grown diauxically with both nitrate and perchlorate, the endogenous expression of NapC and NapO during the nitrate reduction phase was sufficient to completely erase any growth defect in the perchlorate reduction phase caused by deletion of pcrQ and/or pcrO. We leveraged our understanding of these genetic redundancies to make PS mutants with altered electron acceptor preferences. Deletion of the periplasmic nitrate reductase catalytic subunit, napA, led to preferential utilization of perchlorate even in the presence of equimolar nitrate, and deletion of the electron carrier proteins napQ and napO, resulted in concurrent reduction of nitrate and perchlorate. Our results demonstrate that nitrate and perchlorate respiratory pathways in PS share key functionally redundant electron transfer proteins and that mutagenesis of these proteins can be utilized as a strategy to alter the preferential usage of nitrate over perchlorate.</p